Order Coney Waffle Takeout or Delivery
Coney Waffle Photos
You might also consider
More like Coney Waffle
Recommended Reviews - Coney Waffle
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
- Lots of flavor options - [[HIGHLIGHT]]Clean and spacious inside; no interior seating[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] - Friendly, young staff - Ice cream was decent; creamy, but didn't feel "cold" cold--began to melt/drip even before we stepped back outside - [[HIGHLIGHT]]Picnic tables seating outside[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] - [[HIGHLIGHT]]Be careful of melted ice cream on table tops, benches and floor![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]
Food (5/5): Very tasty ice cream and they had fudge samples that tasted amazing. Service (5/5): They were very friendly and helpful even when I was taking forever to decide. Ambiance (5/5): [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a cute ice cream shop.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]
[[HIGHLIGHT]]This place is super spotless.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]It smells delicious.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The people are super nice. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a very chill vibe[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] and the flavors are ridiculously amazing strawberry Nutella, cannoli, birthday cake, cranberry chocolate chunk looks like it's almost sold out dolce la Leche raspberry chocolate chunk, rainbow, cookie, pistachio, Jersey Devil, Rocky Road and banana split and then there's a crumb cake ice cream that is called crumb, baby and of course the Jersey Devil they do have gluten-free ice cream cones and something for everybody and they also have the cookie chip witches many floats and shakes lots and lots of toppings they have Chocolate marshmallow caramel peanut butter, Nutella and whipped cream shell. They have coconut based vegan ice cream non-dairy and they also have Italian ice and ice cream, cones and Coney waffle ice cream cake or eat small batch ice cream and they make their own ice cream flavors that rotate that's amazing. Oh, and let me just tell you, the sizes of the scoops are huge. The ice cream is so delicious and light. It's amazing and delicious. I also cannot wait to come back lol I'm like a little kid jumping up and down right now inside This is right around the corner from where I had the amazing and ridiculous Greek salad
The service was very kind and I felt bad that there was only one girl working when there were a lot of costumers. We got the rainbow sprinkles and soft serve twist on a cone and it satisfied my cravings for a sweet treat. They had a lot of different hard serve flavors as well.
Cute little ice cream shop in the circle by the beach. It is a little pricey. My husband and I both got the smallest cup of ice cream and it still came out to around $14. Service was quick and we barely had to wait in line. We really loved the cinnamon bun flavor!
Very yummy! Pricey but it's near the beach so it's expected. Big portions, [[HIGHLIGHT]]across from the beach, seating outside, very convenient.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]
Tons of flavors to choose from! The staff was super friendly and even told us the top 3 flavors. Extremely colorful and bright within the store. I wish there was a table or two inside the store. There are a lot of tables outside though. I love that they offer a wide variety of toppings. It was so good that we went back for seconds the next day! My friend purchased two kinds of fudge. It didn't taste as fresh and rich as she would have liked.
Coney Waffle Cakery was awesome! I called and needed cake for the same day. Maria was able to accommodate me and complete it just one hour after opening! Their cakes are awesome creations and our kids love them! They've always provided great service and happy faces on our family! This time we got the Kit Kat Cake with Oreo ice cream topped with chipwich, Oreo sandwiches and mini m&m chocolate covered pretzels. It was delicious!!
I love the quality of the ice cream here. It always tastes so good. You wont be disappointed. They have some seating outside. Definintely come here if you love ice cream as much as i do!
Tried the mango and strawberry cheesecake, amazing on a hot summer day! (Cash only, has an ATM inside)
This is your typical Instagramy ice-cream shop, it's convenient being next the the beach. If you're craving ice-cream and walk past it you might go in and buy something. I wouldn't go everytime I crave icecream since it could be expensive, I rather go somewhere else.
Just enjoyed an ice Cream at this new location. Ice Cream itself is really good and creamy. The only down side is the waffle is not made to order. The waffle is hard and I just wished it was made fresh. I would come back but ask for a fresh waffle.
@bigdudesbigfoods stopped at #coneywaffleasburypark for a 2 foot tall #SideshowShake Its a #BigGulp-sized drink, covered with all kinds of desserts: an ice cream cone, ice cream waffle sandwiches, chocolate-covered pretzels, Ring Pops, candy bracelets, gummies of all shapes and sizes, a #Chipwich, mounds of cotton candy, and a #KitKatBar. #BigDudesBigFoods #foodie #foodies #foodpics #dessert #globaleats #shenanigans #BDBFCertified
Review Insights
2 months ago
Pleasant experience! Has a dine in tables. Accepts debit/credit. Has a high chair. No restroom. Has outdoor table seating. Street parking. See images for reference read more
2 months ago
[[HIGHLIGHT]]This place was super cute! The ambiance was great and super fun well done[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. The service was good. My husband got the Reese's waffle Sunday and it looked amazing, but he said it was chocolate soft serve, with Reese's prices, and some kind peanut butter powder. The waffle was unexpectedly very hard. Super crunchy, and he thought a little difficult to eat with a plastic spoon. We got there very close to closing, so, it's possible the waffles might be a different texture when they are fresher. He enjoyed the sundae anyway, and we got some chocolates to take home and tried the next day. The almond bark was good, and the peanut butter non perils he said tasted a little burnt. Everything in the case looked amazing tho, especially the huge cookies! read more
THE GOOD ---------------- + Lots of flavors to choose from + They let you taste test the flavors! + [[HIGHLIGHT]]Plenty of outdoor seating available, including the tables outside of J's Pizza and 7 Eleven[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] THE NOT SO GOOD ---------------------------- + Ice cream melted within a minute once we went outside, despite it not being crazy hot. Unfortunately, it diminished our feelings about the ice cream. MIXED THOUGHTS --------------------------- = Ice cream flavors were OK. Nothing that was amazing. Ordered the Jersey Devil + Pistachio Almonine in 1 small cone and a few other flavors in another small cone. read more
- Lots of flavor options - [[HIGHLIGHT]]Clean and spacious inside; no interior seating[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] - Friendly, young staff - Ice cream was decent; creamy, but didn't feel "cold" cold--began to melt/drip even before we stepped back outside - [[HIGHLIGHT]]Picnic tables seating outside[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] - [[HIGHLIGHT]]Be careful of melted ice cream on table tops, benches and floor![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more
1 month ago
Food (5/5): Very tasty ice cream and they had fudge samples that tasted amazing. Service (5/5): They were very friendly and helpful even when I was taking forever to decide. Ambiance (5/5): [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a cute ice cream shop.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more
[[HIGHLIGHT]]This place is super spotless.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]It smells delicious.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The people are super nice. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a very chill vibe[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] and the flavors are ridiculously amazing strawberry Nutella, cannoli, birthday cake, cranberry chocolate chunk looks like it's almost sold out dolce la Leche raspberry chocolate chunk, rainbow, cookie, pistachio, Jersey Devil, Rocky Road and banana split and then there's a crumb cake ice cream that is called crumb, baby and of course the Jersey Devil they do have gluten-free ice cream cones and something for everybody and they also have the cookie chip witches many floats and shakes lots and lots of toppings they have Chocolate marshmallow caramel peanut butter, Nutella and whipped cream shell. They have coconut based vegan ice cream non-dairy and they also have Italian ice and ice cream, cones and Coney waffle ice cream cake or eat small batch ice cream and they make their own ice cream flavors that rotate that's amazing. Oh, and let me just tell you, the sizes of the scoops are huge. The ice cream is so delicious and light. It's amazing and delicious. I also cannot wait to come back lol I'm like a little kid jumping up and down right now inside This is right around the corner from where I had the amazing and ridiculous Greek salad read more
The service was very kind and I felt bad that there was only one girl working when there were a lot of costumers. We got the rainbow sprinkles and soft serve twist on a cone and it satisfied my cravings for a sweet treat. They had a lot of different hard serve flavors as well. read more
Cute little ice cream shop in the circle by the beach. It is a little pricey. My husband and I both got the smallest cup of ice cream and it still came out to around $14. Service was quick and we barely had to wait in line. We really loved the cinnamon bun flavor! read more
1 year ago
Very yummy! Pricey but it's near the beach so it's expected. Big portions, [[HIGHLIGHT]]across from the beach, seating outside, very convenient.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more
Tons of flavors to choose from! The staff was super friendly and even told us the top 3 flavors. Extremely colorful and bright within the store. I wish there was a table or two inside the store. There are a lot of tables outside though. I love that they offer a wide variety of toppings. It was so good that we went back for seconds the next day! My friend purchased two kinds of fudge. It didn't taste as fresh and rich as she would have liked. read more
3 years ago
Coney Waffle Cakery was awesome! I called and needed cake for the same day. Maria was able to accommodate me and complete it just one hour after opening! Their cakes are awesome creations and our kids love them! They've always provided great service and happy faces on our family! This time we got the Kit Kat Cake with Oreo ice cream topped with chipwich, Oreo sandwiches and mini m&m chocolate covered pretzels. It was delicious!! read more
3 years ago
This is your typical Instagramy ice-cream shop, it's convenient being next the the beach. If you're craving ice-cream and walk past it you might go in and buy something. I wouldn't go everytime I crave icecream since it could be expensive, I rather go somewhere else. read more
Just enjoyed an ice Cream at this new location. Ice Cream itself is really good and creamy. The only down side is the waffle is not made to order. The waffle is hard and I just wished it was made fresh. I would come back but ask for a fresh waffle. read more
5 years ago
@bigdudesbigfoods stopped at #coneywaffleasburypark for a 2 foot tall #SideshowShake Its a #BigGulp-sized drink, covered with all kinds of desserts: an ice cream cone, ice cream waffle sandwiches, chocolate-covered pretzels, Ring Pops, candy bracelets, gummies of all shapes and sizes, a #Chipwich, mounds of cotton candy, and a #KitKatBar. #BigDudesBigFoods #foodie #foodies #foodpics #dessert #globaleats #shenanigans #BDBFCertified read more
8 years ago
Fast, friendly service and delicious ice cream on one of NJs coolest boardwalks. This may not be the original location but this one is by far my favorite. There are no crazy lines here and plenty of seating inside and out. read more
This was on the bucket list after seeing their "SideShow Shake" on a tv show "Food Paradise". It just looked so amazing and crazy that my grandmother and I decided we needed to make the trek to try it at least once. Parking was crazy, since it is summer (street parking, since the surrounding lots were full), but we were lucky enough to not wait in line since we got there in the first hour they were open. We ordered our Cyclone (mint chocolate chip) "SideShow" Shake and were told to grab a table outside and they would bring it out. We paid $21 for this monstrous creation and its cash only. Employees were super nice as well. Our Milkshake was topped with cotton candy, cookie ice cream sandwich, upside down ice cream cone, waffle ice cream sandwich, chocolate pretzel and numerous candy (candy bracelet, ring pop, and gummies). This treat needs to be split amongst multiple people because it needs to be disassembled and the heat ruins the ice cream (I.e. Melts) and cotton candy pretty quickly. There were 2 of us and we basically only ate the ice cream and part of the milkshake; we were given "to-go" bags/box for the cotton candy and other treats but the cotton candy hardened on the way to the car due to the heat. I wasn't super impressed with the milkshake though; it tasted pretty watered down in my opinion. It was fun to try once, but I think once was enough! Definitely worth a visit if you haven't been though! read more
5 years ago
You are getting what you expect. The ice cream is just average and an gimmick. However you will definitely have all the bragging rights on the beach. You're cavity milkshake will also make for a good instagram photo! I went to the Belmar location and it was cash only..... who is cash only in 2021 on a beach come on. read more
New ice cream shop on the block alert! This shop sits on one end of the Asbury boardwalk, and I'm pretty sure it took over another ice cream shop from last season. I came in looking for their crazy sideshow shake, but was told it was a 30 oz milkshake anddd it was $18. Realistically if I hadn't already spent all day at the beach dropping cash on food anddd because I didn't want to give myself another 25 lbs to lug around, I decided to just get a cone. I have to say that the young lady behind the counter (she's actually pictured behind a sideshow shake pic) was SUPER awesome and nice. She asked great questions about what I wanted and gave extra large tasting spoons of ice cream (I could've filled up on those)! I opted for a salted chocolate pretzel ice cream on a chocolate dipped cone....and it was amazing. The pretzel pieces were all crunchy and perfectly sized (I hate when they are too small), and there was great tasting caramel in it, without being overpowering so you couldn't taste the rest of the flavors. The waffle cone was also delicious and fresh. Hubby and I split the cone as it was pretty large ($8 total btw), and he actually contemplated going back for another one when we finished. I highly recommend stopping, the shop is really clean and has plenty of outside seating to enjoy the ocean view as well. read more
Love this place! How can you go wrong with ice cream on a sweltering hot day?! You can't. Many flavors to choose from in a variety of cones or cups. Outdoor seating- if you're lucky to grab a table. I seen one table get a humongous Instagram type ice cream that had cotton candy, milkshake, and candy all packed into one. Boardwalk ritual, every year is a must! read more
6 years ago
4 years ago
7 years ago
Wow this ice cream is so good! To be honest, my husband and I didn't know that this place was famous and had some buzzfeed and TV features on it for some of their over the top milkshakes and cones. We were at the beach for the day, wanted ice cream and found this place and were so happy we did. Immediately I noticed all the amazing flavors they had. It was so hard to choose what two flavors to get. I eventually settled on M&m explosion and rich and famous (cookie dough PLUS brownie bits with a cookie swirl!) we also decided to try their dipped waffle cones which made the whole cone that much better! The portion was huge, the ice cream was DELICIOUS and the price wasn't horrible considering you are at the shore on a boardwalk. We would both totally go back! read more
3 years ago
5 years ago
Satisfied with the Java chip ice cream in a sugar cone. The prices were reasonable and they had a wide selection of stuff it was so hard to choose. Loved the location - right in front of the beach, on the boardwalk. Makes the whole experience much more fun. read more
3 years ago
5 years ago
I had a great experience here. My friend and I each got the side shows. It was a hot day so umbrellas would've been nice outside at the benches. The girls were excited to create the side shows and were very nice to us and accommodating. They came out and brought us the side shows, with napkins, trays and bags. read more
Where to even begin? It was a hot summer day, and while half the party had a swollen and sprained ankle, we made sure to visit the world famous Coney waffle. Immediately we were greeted by a lovely ATM who informed us that this was cash only! Didn't even matter! The smell of sweetness was enough to overcome any inconvenience of having to withdraw some ca$h Legit, this ice cream was the most magnificent thing since spread. I understood why the Ship's company newsletter called it "the only thing tastier than the beef ravioli MRE." I had the amazing unicorn flavor, and literally, it tasted like someone took rainbows and converted it into food. Just pure JOY. And don't even get me started on the cake batter flavor. The flavor "Cake batter with Salty caramel pretzel and I think like peanut butter s'mores" was honestly revolutionary. An icon above its time, I felt the same amount of joy eating this as when I first bought my Rolling Stone concert tickets. Absurd joy. A little butterfly, floating in the wind. read more
2 years ago
7 years ago
Fast service and fun flavors, the perfect treat during a summer beach day! This place is known for their crazy milkshakes and ice cream, which you can get in a cup, regular cone, or tie-dye waffle cone. We opted for waffle cones with two scoops each. I was really excited to try their "monster cookie" flavor, which is bright blue with chocolate and cookie bits swirled into it. Be careful though, it'll dye your teeth/tongue blue! Overall a nice place on the boardwalk to stop by for some sweets. read more
Delicious ice cream and plenty of unique flavors. There are also waffles and such for people who might want something different. This is largely an Instagram spot, though. This ice cream cone was $15, and it's not what I ordered. I just asked for a cone with some candies stuck in, but they tried to give me the whole shebang. I did like the ice cream flavors I got--lemon bar and unicorn power. The rainbow cookies and gummies were yummy as well. Customer service wasn't great. One girl was trying to help me I felt like, but the cashier seemed moody or annoyed by something. Don't feel a need to rush back. However, if I'd ever return, I'd want to try a cone with a cannoli, a brownie waffle, and the Batman Fudge and/or Boston Cream Pie ice cream flavors. read more
8 years ago
Overall review: I really enjoy this place ! Very good ice cream and a great location right in front of the beach. They have specialty shakes which run about $20 dollars, but it is good to split with somebody. Atmosphere: A great location right in front of the beach. There is indoor and outdoor seating. Food: The ice cream is excellent. There are so many flavors and toppings to pick from. Note: It is cash only, but they do have an ATM inside and there also is a 711 next store with a fee slightly cheaper. (Or at least last time I went it was) Final Thoughts: I would suggest going towards sunset or night time and taking your ice cream on the beach while you walk or seating up a blanket by the water. The ice cream melts very quickly when going there in the day time. read more
Cute little place on the boardwalk! I had the coffee ice cream and it was one of the best. They have tons of options for waffle cones. Tons of flavors and they also have waffle choices. I would def go back, but do not forget it's cash only! read more
Page 1 of 5
More info about Coney Waffle
803 Ocean Ave
Belmar, NJ 07719
Directions
(732) 556-6951
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.coneywaffle.shop
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
Ask the Community - Coney Waffle
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
5 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
10 years ago
10 years ago
8 years ago
9 years ago
7 years ago
Coney Waffle - icecream - Updated August 2026
Best of Belmar
People found Coney Waffle by searching for…
Trending Searches in Belmar, NJ
Browse Articles
Browse Nearby
BEST of Belmar, New Jersey Restaurants near Coney Waffle
BEST of Belmar, New Jersey Coffee near Coney Waffle
BEST of Belmar, New Jersey Things to Do near Coney Waffle
BEST of Belmar, New Jersey Desserts near Coney Waffle
BEST of Belmar, New Jersey Breakfast near Coney Waffle
BEST of Belmar, New Jersey Parking near Coney Waffle
BEST of Belmar, New Jersey Gelato near Coney Waffle
BEST of Belmar, New Jersey Boba near Coney Waffle
Browse Brands
Related Searches in Belmar, NJ
Best Bagels Available in Belmar, New Jersey
Best Gluten Free Breakfast Places in Belmar, New Jersey
Best Rolled Ice Cream Shops Around Belmar, New Jersey
Best Shakes Available in Belmar, New Jersey
Best Smoothie Spots and Cafes in Belmar, New Jersey
Best Vegan Restaurants to Try in Belmar, New Jersey
Delicious Carrot Cake Bakeries Near Belmar, New Jersey
Delicious Ice Cream Sundae Options in Belmar, New Jersey
Delicious Ice Cream Treats in Belmar, New Jersey
Delicious Soup Spots to Try in Belmar, New Jersey
Discover Authentic Filipino Food in Belmar, New Jersey
Discover Coffee & Tea Options in Belmar, New Jersey
Discover Juice Bars & Smoothies in Belmar, New Jersey
Discover Soft Serve Ice Cream in Belmar, New Jersey
Discover Vegan Desserts Near Belmar, New Jersey
Discover the Best Macarons Available in Belmar, New Jersey
Enjoy Custard Ice Cream in Belmar, New Jersey
Enjoy Dairy Free Ice Cream Flavors in Belmar, New Jersey
Enjoy Delicious Hot Dogs in Belmar, New Jersey
Explore Custom Cakes Crafted in Belmar, New Jersey
Explore Delicious Vegetarian Food in Belmar, New Jersey
Explore Dessert Places Around Belmar, New Jersey
Explore Popular Foodie Restaurants in Belmar, New Jersey
Explore Popular Tea Rooms in Belmar, New Jersey
Fast Birthday Cake Delivery Services in Belmar, New Jersey
Find Chocolatiers & Shops Around Belmar, New Jersey
Find Delicious Chocolate Cake in Belmar, New Jersey
Find Refreshing Italian Ice Treats in Belmar, New Jersey
Find the Best Homemade Ice Cream in Belmar, New Jersey
Great Diners to Visit in Belmar, New Jersey
Order Cookie Delivery Services in Belmar, New Jersey
Order Delicious Ice Cream Cake Near Belmar, New Jersey
Order Fresh and Tasty Salad Options in Belmar, New Jersey
Popular Ice Cream Shop Near Belmar, New Jersey
Popular Ice Cream Truck Stops in Belmar, New Jersey
Refreshing Shaved Ice Treats in Belmar, New Jersey
Savor Vegan Ice Cream Flavors in Belmar, New Jersey
Shop at the Best Asian Bakery in Belmar, New Jersey
Taste Frozen Yogurt Favorites in Belmar, New Jersey
Taste the Best Brownies Available in Belmar, New Jersey
Taste the Best Sugar Free Desserts Around Belmar, New Jersey
Taste the Finest Gelato Available in Belmar, New Jersey
Top Candy Stores to Visit in Belmar, New Jersey
Top Frozen Custard Spots to Try in Belmar, New Jersey
Top-Rated Ice Cream Cakes Available in Belmar, New Jersey
Try Gelato Ice Cream Near You in Belmar, New Jersey
Try the Best Banh Mi Sandwiches in Belmar, New Jersey
Where to Get Fresh Malasadas in Belmar, New Jersey
