Holy crap! This ice cream is awesome! Had the apple crisp with caramel topping, insane!! We also got a banana bread sundae and it was so freaking good. Warm soft banana bread covered in ice cream. Amazing. As an ice cream snob this place is right up at the top of the list with Hoffman's in spring lake. Cash only so make sure you have cash. Line could be a bit long and slow but it's worth the wait. read more

Great little shop on the corner. Great choice in flavors. I get a medium and its the perfect amount on a Hot Summer day! read more

This ice cream shop is so kitschy and cute. It's a 1950's style ice cream parlor with seating both inside and out. We just didn't sit outside because of the country music they were playing. The owners are friendly and accommodating. I ordered the last of the Mallomar ice cream which had marshmallows, chocolate and cookie pieces (just like the cookies). It was a unique, delicious flavor which I always appreciate. For a small, you can choose 2 flavors/2 scoops, so I also asked for a mocha/coffee chip flavor which was good too. This is our go-to ice cream shop when we're in town with a good selection and fair prices. read more

See all

Hinlickity's is located in the Highlands next to one of my favorite local Italian restaurants. The shop normally closes at 9 on Saturday night but we lucked out as they had a crowd and were open past 10. The shop looks like it is only offering outdoor seating at this point, I saw through the window that the inside is well furnished like an ice cream shop from the 1950's would look. The selection of ice cream is solid and they offer some unusual flavors like creamed corn. I tasted their coffee and rocky road, both very good. The prices are reasonable and the portions are generous. If you are in the area I recommend them. I would advise that you call first to confirm that they are open, we have dropped by a few times during their business hours and they have been closed. Good luck and enjoy! read more

Hinlickity’s Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

See all

Nice selection of terrific ice creams-you taste the flavorings, it's not just a sugar bomb. Fairly priced, too-often you pay a 'shore tax' for being so close to the water. read more

This is such a lovely place. I appreciate the home baked goods that are warm and topped with fresh ice cream and hot fudge. Cannoli flavor is really made with heart! Their garden style seating is super cute too! read more

Yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy! read more

Hinlickity’s Ice Cream - Strawberry ice cream in a waffle cone! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

A beautiful 50's setting adorns this newly opened creamery right in downtown Highlands. Check it out. A variety of different flavors are available at reasonable prices. This ice cream has a full-bodied fat content, definitely not ice-milk. I delved into a vanilla cone and scarfed it down quickly. Excellent. There are counter seats and tables to eat inside and listen to "oldies" on their jukebox. It's very upbeat here. The owners are very cordial ( husband & wife). They even have a gift area to purchase Knick knacks, candy's al all in a 50's vein. They also have an ice cream truck which I have seen in town selling ice cream. There's a nice vibe here. read more

See all

Charming, special, sweet little place. With just one other review, I'm guessing they are a relatively new establishment, but they were packed the night of our trip. The owner made me a special request, a Raspberry "Freeze" and worked hard to get the right ratio of seltzer, milk, and sorbet to have it be delightful. She even said she'd name it after me! Excellent prices considering; a comparable place in our downtown would've had prices at least a third more. I had a few big bites of my husband's pistachio, and it was wonderful; creamy and not too sweet and clearly home-made. Wonderful little spot that represents the mood of the area really well. Can't wait to return! read more

Highlands clings to it's past and that's a good thing. Here wedged between the bluffs and the sea you'll find a town that hasn't sold it's soul to the north of the Driscoll bridge crowd. At least not yet. Real stores, bars and restaurants catering to real people. Al H. junior and I were looking to kill a few hours being beached out. The day was as hot and humid as a dog's breath. So the closer to the water the better. Walking Henry Hudson's trail north of town was great if still a bit hot at waters edge. After, we decided on ice cream. Hinlickity's is a bright cheerful gem on the main drag. We ordered outside not realizing there even was an inside and enjoyed our ice cream alfresco. Al H. Jr went for Cherry Vanilla and gave it high marks. I had a root beer float that was fantastic and they gave me the can of root beer to top it off. Nice touch. Service was super and prices seemed reasonable. So next time you're in Highlands save room for ice cream and make it Hinlickity's. I scream for Ice cream. Hinlickities....go! read more

See all

Great ice cream, great prices, nice sizes, beautiful store. Had the homemade brownie sundae. Delicious! Kudos to the owners.

It is a very cute place with outstanding service and the price is what is to be expected. My only issue is that their ice cream lacked definitive flavors. Of the five different ones we tried, all were very mildly tasting of the flavors they were named. They were , however, cold, refreshing, and welcoming on a hot day. read more

I just moved to Highlands NJ from New York about 3 months ago and I was looking for an ice cream shop to go to. I went to Hinlickity's Ice Cream because it was close and it looked good. Today was my first time going and trying it out and my experience was pretty lame. I ordered 2 chocolate egg creams and it didn't even come in a to go cup it came in a glass so I was forced to stay there and drink it. Not only that but I had to wait over 20 minutes just for a tiny drink. And it wasn't even that busy. Also, it's all good way over priced. Such a rip off too. Iwas so disappointed. Probably never going there again. read more

Thank you for making my cousin's birthday a great one. Today was one of his 'good days' so they decided to take a drive down from N. Arlington for his birthday. Dina made it special and everyone in the store sang happy birthday. Hinlickity's Ice Cream Parlor is not just ice cream, they bring back memories of childhood and make everyone feel like family. read more

A combination of chic and retro. The decor and the ambience alone make you feel good. The creative and wide selection of ice cream possibilities make for a superb outing with friends or a soothing retreat if you're on your own like me. Today I'm having cookies and cream in seltzer, as I battle the humidity and delude myself about cutting calories. Bottom line: refreshing and fun! read more

Such a cute ice cream shop!! The outdoor area is decorated so nicely and perfect for a summer night. I had warm banana bread with pecan ice cream that was so delicious and yummy. read more

Hinlickity’s Ice Cream - Banana bread with butter pecan ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

We were staying in town for my 35th high school reunion. This place was awesome. It was HOT--during the heat wave in July--and they made my wife a special cooling slushee. I had a wonderful double scoop of pistachio in a waffle cone. Great family business! read more

Nice throwback to an old school ice cream parlor. Plenty of seating and plenty of flavors to choose from. Ice cream was good. Prices were reasonable as well. The only negative is that it's cash only. read more

Excellent quality ice cream and big portions. Great family run local business. I've tried almost every favor and have never been disappointed. read more

Hired their ice cream truck for a private party and they were a no show. Had dozens of kids excited for them to come for a summer bbq and they were unresponsive when we called and did not show up at all. I would stay away from them from your parties and go to someone who actually shows up. read more

Very cute place with great ice cream. We got the brownie sundae which was delicious. Just wish they had a little more of a selection.

Cool retro ice cream parlor that has delicious home made ice cream! The ice cream is really good and the place is really cool for the photo ops! It feels a little crowed inside once the place is full but they have outdoor seating which makes it better! Great stop for anyone of any age read more

What a wonderful place to go back in time! Not only is the ice cream delicious and the ambiance perfectly appointed with "ole time" ice cream parlor decor, but the owners are friendly, eager to please, and wonderfully down to earth folks!! read more

A great surprise in The Highlands. Super premium quality without pretentiousness . Cool trucks too

Great ice cream - good service - retro atmosphere - will come again when we are in area.

This local Highlands Gem is special for many reasons the least of which being the delicious ice cream. It's full of flavor yet not overly sweet and made from high quality ingredients. The people are about as real as it gets and the atmosphere is 50 s all the way. Travel to this place it's well worth the effort! read more