5/5 Stars -- Ohio's Ice Cream Legend…read more By far the best place in Ohio to get fresh, amazing ice cream. I mean, Toft's Dairy has like 50 flavors--seriously, there's something for everyone. You can grab a cone, a cup, or even buy ice cream to take home for the family. And it's not just ice cream--they have milk, specialty drinks, and even fun merch like t-shirts. My personal favorite? Peanut Butter Cup + Peanut Butter Pretzel--absolute perfection. Creamy, nutty, salty, sweet... all the things you want in a summer treat. Sizes? They've got three, but honestly, the small is perfect: enough to satisfy that ice cream craving without going overboard. Medium is basically a full meal, so pace yourself. What makes it extra special for me: we know someone who works there (we met her at Kalahari), and she loves giving suggestions on flavor combos. Her tips always take a cone from great to legendary. And of course, there's the Cedar Point connection--stopping at Toft's after a day on the rides or after a big sporting event is pure nostalgia. Sticky fingers, huge smiles, and ice cream that tastes like summer memories. Bottom line: Toft's Dairy isn't just ice cream--it's a tradition, a memory, and hands-down the best sweet spot in Sandusky. You go once, and you'll be back again and again.

After a great lunch at Jolly Roger I was headed back towards Cleveland and wanted to grab some ice…read morecream; Toft Dairy had popped up in my online feed recently so I figured I would give them a try. I have had Toft's ice cream a couple of times before, but the scoop shop experience can always be different. This location is actually there headquarters, factory and the scoop shop. The building has a covered patio out front, there are some cow statues and an original dairy cart out front. Inside they have a large service area with a huge amount of flavors, plus coolers with packed ice cream and ice cream pies. I ordered a medium sized cup with Banana Foster and Caveman Chocolate ice creams. The cup was $7.50 which seemed a bit expensive until I saw the portion size, this was really about 4 scoops of ice cream. The ice cream is nice and smooth with a nice texture and mouthfeel. The banana foster ice cream was slightly sweet and had a mild banana flavor I did not taste the advertised burnt sugar swirl. The Caveman Chocolate was very good with a rich dark chocolate ice cream and a nice amount of chocolate truffles, although again I did not taste the thick fudge swirls. Toft's has some very good ice cream, the scoop shop lacks some of the charm of other ice cream places, not too surprising since it is part of the factory. The ice cream is a bit expensive, but the portions are big. Probably the most flavor choices I have seen at an ice cream place.

Was taking parts to a customer and stopped here on a whim for lunch. Very good. Got a big hamburger…read morewith onion rings and a coke for $8. Hamburger had fresh tomatoes and onion. Had great service. Outdoor seating only with nice tables and fast service. Pleasantly surprised! Also have a nice playground out back for kids.

We enjoy going there on Rt 6 Huron as the treats are reasonably priced and good value. Wide variety…read moreof options ie soft serve, dole whip, frozen yogurt as base then a huge number of toppings. We like that they have a small size for those of us watching our diets too. Their sandwiches and soups are good. Weekly food specials. Also good memories as this place has a 50+ year local history. Support Local.

Pretty busy place in the summer to visit, but good ice cream. It's a great outdoor ice cream shack…read morewhere the staff is nice and fast. With no indoor seating, there is limited outdoor seating, but plenty of parking.

I drive an hour just for this ice cream. My family loves tofts. Usually were go to the Sandusky…read morelocation, but this one is tinier and usually not as crazy. The staff is always young, but at least nice. There are so many flavors to choose from.

We had the worst experience at this place because of a young brunette woman working the evening of…read more6/27. She was incredibly rude and would not look any of in the eye. An item in our order was made incorrectly and when it was pointed out, she reluctantly remade the item with the most unprofessional effort and made it even worse. Even when she was thanked for her "efforts" she had no response and not even the decency to acknowledge our thanks although she was well aware that her remake was ghastly. If the owner of this establishment is reading this, I highly suggest you reconsider your employment of this individual. It is evident that her attitude is affecting the rest of your staff, and it is far from the positive or at least neutral environment you'd expect from an ice cream shop.

The ice cream is soo good try the Bart Simpson flurry it's butter finger and chocolate syrupread more

I usually go to Twist and Shout in order to get an ice cream cone. However, today I went and got a…read moreburger. I was told that they were very good, but I never take anyone else's word for it. But I will tell you it was one of the best burgers that I've ever had. They did a great job. It was just right just the way I asked for it. I would highly recommend going to Twist and Shout in order to get not only an ice cream cone, but a burger.

We took a day trip over to Port Clinton to walk the shores of Lake Erie and enjoy the sun set…read more Along the way I searched for an ice cream shop and Scooter's Dairy Bar came up on Waze. We decided to give it a shot and were pleased with our choice. Scooter's offers a wide variety of ice cream in both dairy and non-dairy varieties (contrary to the dairy bar name) for incredibly reasonable prices. The serving sizes were generous and the staff was super friendly. The parking situation isn't the greatest; however, there is a large lot just across the street that you can stop in to run over and get your treats. Check it out if you're in the area and craving the nostalgia of a small town ice cream shop

It's not the best ice cream nearby, but it's good. This is your nostalgic dairy shack of quick…read morefried hot food, drink treats, and ice cream desserts. They do carry the non-dairy Dole whip in orange flavor. The young staff were friendly and quite quick. Judging by the location, they cater to mostly the local neighborhood and nearby school functions foot traffic. They support the military with a discount. Parking lot is small, but plenty of street parking. The patio has about 6 tables with umbrellas. Area was clean and free of trash. A nice stop if you don't want to go stand in the other tourist lines with prices. #UpCloseSavor XP

Great prices and great ice-cream! I've never had a bad experience here. The employees misunderstood…read moremy order once and fixed it without any hassle.

Cheap prices, no hassle ordering at the walk up window, & yummy ice cream. Hard to go wrong by…read morechoosing to grab a snack here during the heat of the day. I had the seasonal special with fresh strawberries & it really hit the spot.

Been going here since I was a child, its changed hands at least once or twice to my knowledge- and…read morethe quality has never changed. I do NOT like hot dogs- UNLESS, Im at the shake shak- I cannot resist getting a footlong (regular or chili). Im not sure what brand they use, or the amazing chili sauce they use, but its the only kind that doesn't upset my stomach, and it tastes so good. Its a summer staple for us- the ice cream is always great and given I am pickier than I should be- the folks that work there- always get my complicated order made right on. I travel 20 minutes now to go there, as I live over by Bascom, and its worth it, because I know it will be exactly as you want it.

II highly recommend Shake Shack of Tiffin. Stop by during road trip and we had a crew of 16 who…read moretried many different flavors of shakes and the banana split ice cream. Loved my pineapple shake. You will not be disappointed.

I don't know if this has always been the Purple Parrot, but I have been coming to this ice cream…read morestand for probably 30 years. This is an old-fashioned side of the road ice cream stand that has whatever you could dream of - hard ice cream and soft serve and so many food items from hotdogs to walking tacos to shredded chicken sandwiches to fried mushrooms and so much more. I personally am a soft serve girl and there are very few flavor combinations in this world that I love more than peanut butter and chocolate. On this my most recent trip this summer, I had the Nutter Butter sundae. The Nutter Butter sundae is Chocolate ice cream topped with peanut butter fluff, peanuts, whipped cream, a cherry and a Nutter Butter cookie. I'm sure you can tell by the description that this was a sugar overload, but delicious. I also got a pup cup for my pup, which is a small bit of vanilla ice cream with a dog treat on top. The ice cream was delicious and we had really good service my only gripe is the prices are a bit high. I paid $2.50 for a dog cup of ice cream - I just remember when that used to be like $.50 but I guess that's inflation for you. Overall, this is a great place with good ice cream and a nostalgic feel.

The food here is really good. I got their veggie wrap, fries, and dreamsicle shake. Best fries I…read morethink I've ever had. Only thing i didn't like was the clouds of mosquitoes outside but they do have a screened porch where you can wait for your order. Really friendly people, too. I'd go back.

I ordered a footlong, nachos, and a medium milk shake it was almost 15 bucks. I don't mind paying…read morefor stuff when it is good but my food was ice cold my 5.25 medium milk shake is not even blended. It is literally like putting a straw in a jar of peanut butter and drinking it. I couldn't even finish it. I wasted my 15 dollars by choosing to got here. Won't be making that mistake again. Definitely other places to go in Tiffin.

Someone recommended this wonderful place, so we had to stop in (from Virginia). The service was…read morefast! We had the Buckeye ice cream and it was delicious! We will visit again the next time we are in Ohio.