Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mill Creek Cheese

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    InexpensiveCheese Shops

    Mill Creek Cheese Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Mill Creek Cheese

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 months ago

    Very relaxing, very beautiful and well maintained property. Good price Very clean communication very good.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Lost Soul Z.
    573
    255
    364

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Carr Valley Cheese - Off of Hwy 14

    Carr Valley Cheese

    4.6(16 reviews)
    8.6 mi
    $$

    We bought gifts for friends and cheese for us. Everything is amazing. Friendly and helpful staff…read more Definitely worth the stop.

    I love coming to Carr Valley Cheese - not only for the top notch products, but because shopping…read morehere is an experience. I will spend like 20 minutes in this little shop looking at every single product they sell. All local, which I appreciate. I come here looking to buy a pound of cheddar, and leave with about 10 other products I didn't plan to buy. I always end up making a charcuterie after for all my unexpected purchases. They have so many varieties of cheddar - I ended up getting half a pound of their 2 year aged white cheddar and half a pound of soft Gouda to make the perfect mac & cheese. I also got some seasonal wildflower cheddar that I'm excited to try. This small shop is well organized and very cute, with a variety of products not limited to cheese, such as soup kits, bread kits, locally produced honey, all types of fresh butter (including goat butter), wine, and kitchen goods. And of course all your cheese fixings, such as crackers, meat sticks, several types of jams, and charcuterie boards and knives. I didn't interact with the employee working except when she greeted me when I walked in (which is always nice) and when she checked me out. She was friendly and approachable, so if I did have any questions I wouldn't feel like I was bothering her by asking (which I feel at some businesses I've been to in the past). Carr Valley Cheese is my go-to local quality cheese place for all my special cheesy meals.

    Photos
    Carr Valley Cheese - Gonna put this on a burger!

    Gonna put this on a burger!

    Carr Valley Cheese - Orphan cheese - sampled cheeses get repackaged for a cheaper price!!

    Orphan cheese - sampled cheeses get repackaged for a cheaper price!!

    Carr Valley Cheese

    See all

    Uplands Cheese Company - Their signature cheese, 8 oz for $17 circa May 2026.

    Uplands Cheese Company

    5.0(5 reviews)
    10.2 mi
    $$$

    I just tried some of their signature Pleasant Ridge Reserve cheese, which currently runs $17 for an…read more8 oz package. I must say premium Wisconsin cheeses are like hazy IPA's to me. There are a ton of tastes (and textures) and they're all a little different, and I like them all! Maybe one day I'll develop enough of a palate to have a favorite, but for now, they're all good!!

    Pleasant Ridge Reserve, the signature cheese of the Uplands Cheese Company, may be one of the…read moresingle most perfect hard cows milk cheese made in the US. A traditionally made cheese in the style of alpine cheeses from southwestern France, Pleasant Ridge Reserve is made only during the months when cows graze on grasses, sweet clover, and wild herbs, giving their milk a depth of flavor not usually found in most cheeses from year-round milkers grazing on silage and grain. This award winning cheese (just go to their website to see how many accolades they've earned...it is simply awesome) is a favorite both here in the Midwest and all over the country. For those of us lucky to live in Chicago, it is on the menu of many local restaurants, who use it both on cheese plates and in more complex dishes. During a recent visit to Hot Chocolate on Damen, for example, I had a Pleasant Ridge Reserve-filled brioche. I think this cheese is better to eat out of hand than to incorporate in a recipe - with heating, many of the subtleties of texture and flavor are lost. Seek it out. And if you do find it in a cheese shop, make sure the piece you get does not touch plastic. Because plastic is the enemy of all cheese. If it must touch plastic, make sure you get it out as soon as possible and put in proper cheese paper or wax paper and foil. And eat it right away - it isn't going to get any better in your fridge. Uplands isn't open to the public, but if you call ahead they may just accomodate you. The trip through the lush, rolling hills of southern Wisconsin is an agrarian's dream.

    Photos
    Uplands Cheese Company

    See all

    Carr Valley Cheese - Great gift box idea

    Carr Valley Cheese

    4.4(18 reviews)
    15.1 mi
    $$

    You come to Wisconsin for the cheese! And do they got it!…read more They have a great variety of cheese and meats! They have aged cheese and bacon bread cheese. Also pumpkin spice cheese. And some local wines, honey, bbq sauce and such. Great place to check out in you're passing through or looking to make a charcuterie board!

    Love love love. I miss cheese curds, and this place offers…read morefine, fresh and squeaky curds. So many choices in the cheese varieties, both in different types of cheese as well as the milk used-- cow, goat, and sheep. I prefer the stronger, longer-aged cheeses, and wasn't disappointed. Lots of sizes available as well. The staff is super helpful- was looking for something comparable to a Manchego, and was steered toward the aged Marisa, which was delightful. They make a cave-aged Marisa as well, but they were out. I also accidentally purchased the regular Marisa, and two hours later took it back, and they were happy to refund so I could purchase the correct variety. The 6 year cheddar is phenomenal. They have cheddars from the curd stage (divinely squeaky!) to a 12 year aged. The black goat truffle is very, very good, and one of my favorite items is the goat butter. Very, very creamy and mild, with just a nice goaty finish. Perfect on a lightly toasted sourdough. Definitely a must try if you're a fan of the goat cheeses. I'll be back in February for another visit, and plan to bring a bigger suitcase!

    Photos
    Carr Valley Cheese - Lots of good choices

    Lots of good choices

    Carr Valley Cheese - Gift ideas

    Gift ideas

    Carr Valley Cheese - Maple syrup

    See all

    Maple syrup

    Cedar Grove Cheese

    Cedar Grove Cheese

    4.3(7 reviews)
    11.5 mi
    $$

    We loved visiting this little place. It was wonderfully stocked with a great variety…read more I picked up multiple trimmings for some quiche and mac and cheese. Perfect sizes and a great price. I'm giving a 5 rating but am putting a disclaimer. This is for the cheese and wonderful support staff that answered questions and helped us out. Not for any tours as it was Saturday and no cheese making was going on. This was a great little stop and really is some wonderful cheese. We plan on ordering some for Christmas gifts this year. My family made sure to mention you need to get some pictures next to the holding tanks. The cow pattern is too cute!

    When you think "Wisconsin" you automagically think "Cheese!" and this factory store says it loudly…read moreand clearly! I first learned of this award-winning cheesemaker when it was featured on an episode of Wisconsin Public Television's series, "Wisconsin Foodie". I decided then and there I had to find this factory. It's about a 2-1/2 hour drive from my house, straight across the state on Wisconsin Highway 60. (West of Sauk City, follow Cty B to Mill Road to the store. It's signed.) My first attempt got me here about 15 minutes after the store closed. :( My second attempt got me here in plenty of time! The variety of cheeses available here makes it difficult to choose. Regular dairy cheese, along with sheep and goat milk cheeses are here. (There are some specialty cheeses available from other makers, such as bleu cheese.) I opted for my favorites, Colby and Swiss, an took a chance on a block of garlic cheddar. You'll also find a wide selection of accessories. I purchased a wire cheese slicer with dual widths, thick and thin. There are refrigerator magnets, t-shirts and logo ball caps. Large windows allow you to watch cheese making in progress, as long as you're there early in the day. When you arrive late in the afternoon, as I did, you'll see sparkling clean, stainless steel cheese making equipment. If you arrive after closing time, you can find their product in Plain at the Shell station and at Straka Meats in Plain. (You should visit Straka Meats, anyway, for another gastronomical adventure!) Oh, yes. The garlic cheddar was delicious!

    Photos
    Cedar Grove Cheese - Living Machine Water Treatment system.

    Living Machine Water Treatment system.

    Cedar Grove Cheese - Official Wisconsin Master Cheese Maker photo.

    Official Wisconsin Master Cheese Maker photo.

    Cedar Grove Cheese - Old school photographs!

    See all

    Old school photographs!

    Mill Creek Cheese - cheese - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...