TL;DR - if you want the closest thing to NY pizza in OC, this is it. Best bang for buck ez. I've been looking for some really good NY style pizza in the OC area and most of the times have been relatively disappointed as no place seems to be able to get it quite right. I saw that they only open 2 days a week but that also made me think this guy has to know what he's doing if he's willing to only do 2 days. Well, lemme just say this.... Mike's gets it right. Flavor, texture, thinness and dough are all on point. Simplicity is key here, you choose cheese or pep. Both are absolutely delicious. Lots of places make pep taste too salty, but balance is really good here. If there is any thing I could suggest it would be wanting just a tiny bit more tomato sauce, but it's so minor compared to the major pitfalls of many other pizza joints. They have a 2 pie max for quality control for takeout as it seems like he hand-makes each pizza to order, and although might be unfortunate for large parties for smaller gatherings should be enough! For context, 2 large pizzas was about $45 and could easily feed like 5-6 people (I was able to feed 8). So honestly very budget friendly compared to some other ones I've tried that were $30+ for a single pizza (and didn't even taste as good). Definitely a spot I need to come back to and try in-person. Although I'm sad I can only do Fridays or Saturdays, I'd prefer consistency and quality over quality especially as a pizza lover. So.... Here's to my go-to pizza spot on Fri/Sat! read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - 18" Large Pepperoni Pizza and Large Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

Our favorite pizza in Fullerton! We were looking for pizza before MMA fights and used Yelp to search. 18" Half cheese, half pep hit the spot and for only $20?!?! Cooked just the way we like and the gentlemen working the counter were amazing. read more

Mike is still killing it here in DTF, at the old Mings restaurant. Open 2 days a week, they usually run out of dough Saturday unless you're lucky. Amazing pizza...cheese and pepperoni only. read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Perfectly cooked, not burnt. - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

Mike's Firestone Pizza is.... Pizza in Fullerton, California. The owner is super unique and I finally got to greet him. He has this genuine vibe about his work ethic and almost seems like he is trying to learn more about himself through the repeated process of his hand produced art of pizza. I can tell he studies or he himself is a big fan or Pizza or the art of pizza. What is the art of pizza? Simple but not simple. Stupid simple but crazy not simple. If you really get into it, you can almost communicate with the dough and see how every hour the chemistry between the yeast and flour creates different tone and frequency. Almost like a music. Hows the Pizza here? You have to come and experince it. Wait about hour and half, and keep suffering as others around you get the pie first and enjoy the pieces as your stomach growls. Do I recommend it? Haha No comment! Its all energy and if you appreciate the obssesive passion for this craft from Mike, maybe you will! Maybe not? :)) read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza but a Pepperoni Pizza but a Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

Hands down one of my favorite pizza spots. Mike's Firestone Pizza absolutely delivers. The crust is thin but has no flop at all, which is exactly how it should be. Perfect structure, easy to eat, and incredibly satisfying. The char on the undercarriage is spot on--beautifully cooked with just the right amount of crisp and flavor. You can tell they really know what they're doing with their oven and dough. On top of that, the service is great--friendly, welcoming, and efficient, which makes the whole experience even better. Simple, well-executed pizza done right. If you care about crust, texture, proper char, and good service, this place is a must. read more

Probably have to start this by saying I just got back from a pizza tour in New Haven, CT and NYC. So my pallet had high expectations. I gave this pizza a 7.1 on my scale. Pretty solid. Definitely a NY style, and I appreciated the CT cut. It was a little too floppy in my opinion. And I think the sauce was not my favorite. I will say I appreciate Mikes small business and how serious he is about it. I talked with an employee and could tell they really care about what they do. He compared their pizza to Two Saucy Broads just down the street, which I've had before. And I would totally agree. Just about the same. Not spectacular but very solid pies. If local, this pie is worth a try for sure. read more

See all

This is the best pizza I've ever had. Never been to NY, but imagine it would taste like this. read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

I have finally found a perfect pizza and I'm so excited!! Mike's Firestone Pizza is perfectly thin and bubbly with chewy crust, great sauce and perfectly placed toppings!! The 2 gentleman working this evening were so friendly, courteous and really fun to talk with. Look no further, this is the place for the bomb pizza!! Thanks guys!! read more

This pizza is very, very good. All the ingredients are top tier. The dough is excellent! I like the owner. He's a really nice guy and you always get a warm greeting from him. TIP: The ingredients are so good that it makes reheating this pizza taste fresh after refrigeration. So refrigerate your leftovers. And when you're ready to eat again preheat your oven up to a high temperature like 500 degrees. Throw it for 2-3 minutes and you're all set. read more

This killer pizza spot and bar are hidden in the restaurant formerly known as Ziings. Mike and his bartender give friendly and fun service at astoundingly affordable prices. The pizza is some of the closest to NY style we've found, and is the perfect mid-evening stop to pad your stomach for some late night festivities. It's a bit of a bummer that you can only get pizza during a small window (5-9 on Friday and Saturday), but that makes it a bit more special. As Mike is working solo with his Firestone oven, don't expect "hot n ready" pizzas--the wait is well worth it and the cheap drinks from the bar will hold you over just fine during the wait. If you are there at 9 and want to stay, the place turns over into a club. We haven't experienced the late night switch, but people are typically lined up well before 9. read more

Great new York style pizza. Tastes great. The quality is there. It's obvious that it's freshly made with quality ingredients. If your hesitating to order, don't this pizza is amazing and if you love peperoni or sausage you will love this pizza read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Peperoni large - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

Amazing NY style Pizza and friendly bartender. Highly recommend. Easy to miss if you are driving down Harbor. read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

I went in a a Saturday night to try the "best rated pizza". The place was empty, it was a hour wait and they only had pepperoni or cheese. Nothing else. Nope read more

Hi, hands down the best pizza place in Fullerton!! We get this almost every weekend!! Yes, it's that good!! We do wish it was open 7 days a week though ;) we'll get what we can get lol thank you Mike for the yummy pizzas our family loves them oh and great service too!! read more

Mike please please please please do this full-time..... I would pick up a pizza at least once a week if you were open more and I'm sure lots of other customers would also.... Best pie I have had probably ever, tied with a pizza I had in New York Way way back in the day. This is my first ever review on yelp ! That's how serious and confident I am in your product read more

Great pizza at a great price! I did have to wait a while for it (45 minutes or so), but that was mostly on me (walk in on a Friday night) and the staff warned me about the wait before I ordered. A.) it was worth the wait and B.) they have a full bar, so there are worse places to wait for a pie. I'm sure you can call in your order and avoid the wait. The toppings were limited to cheese and pepperoni, but that works when the ingredients are top quality, which these are. I'm sure the owner can get his hands on a bunch of mediocre toppings, I respect that he only serves items that are up to his standards. The dough is crispy and chewy, the sauce is fresh and bright, quality pepperoni and cheese, the pizza is very well cooked and has a great "undercarriage" I'll be back for sure. read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

See all

Food was great, the service was excellent a little bit too long, but worth it for the pizza. The ambience was also great, overall easy 10/10. read more

Just... wow. So many pizza places are just cookie cutter Sysco dough with zero flavor or texture. This stuff is the read deal. Mike's is truly an artisan pie - I just wish I could get it during the week! read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

See all

Must try! Amazing food, amazing service, and a friendly environment. You can tell the pizza is made with love. Everything is made to order. My grandparents came from Alhambra and despite not being a fan of pizza without veggies, they loved it. read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Large Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

Hole in the wall, made to order pizza kind of confusing dark in the back of a bar but very good overall

Hands down the closest New York Pie you can get in this area. If you had it "Mike's" way and enjoyed it ... try "Peter from New York" way. If you are from New York, I think you'll understand. read more

TLDR: Don't waste your time here, just go somewhere else. Unless you have an hour to burn for a single pizza. Walked in and it was pretty empty. I ended up ordering in the back and ordered a pepperoni pizza. They only had two toppings. Pepperoni and cheese. I ordered the 10 inch and thought I would get it soon since it's a smaller pizza and it's just pepperoni. Not only that but there was barely anyone there. I ordered before 4 other gentlemen and they got their order before me. After about 30 minutes of waiting I asked the same person who I ordered from, "how much longer until the pizza is done? It's been half an hour already?" And they responded with an attitude, "well can't you see there's other before you so about another 10 minutes" After that I decided to walk out and the thought it wasn't worth the wait. Overall it has an odd vibe being there, my time was wasted and so was my money. 1/10. Just go somewhere else honestly. read more

if you've been searching endlessly for TRUE Boston or NYC style pizza, you search is over, friend. this pizza is legit. great crust, tangy sauce, quality cheese and toppings, and cooked to PERFECTION. Mike's is located inside Ziing's in DTF. only open Fri and Sat 5-9pm. read more

10/10 pizza. It's everything you want, good peps/crust/flavor. It's only 1 dude making pies, so takes a while, but worth the wait. Be patient and enjoy the pizza. read more

Delicious pizza ! Fresh tasty authentic crust , quality pepperoni! Highly recommend!!

Really enjoyed our dinner at Mike's. Good beer, great pizza, friendly service, at a very reasonable price. Would absolutely come again. Be advised: you don't get a lot of options here. Pepperoni and several kinds of sausage. That's it. No veg, no fancy fig drizzle, nothing like that. Just good cheese and meat toppings on a delicious crust. I almost never eat mammals but made an exception by necessity and it did not disappoint. Will be back. read more

10 out of 10! The BOMB! Eat it while it's hot out of the oven or you are missing out! Will come back and bring all of our friends for a pizza party! read more

Crust was thin and crispy, cheese was melty, and the toppings were loaded. Nothing fancy, just real good pizza made right

Great service but importantly great tasting pizza!!! Ask for the hot honey on the side. read more

Mike takes great pride in making these pies. Has that "back east " hint to it, which is quite rare around here. The price is very fair. Add a little parm, some red pepper flakes, and a touch of oregano and you're almost there. It was first trip to Mikes last Sat 1-10-26 5pm. I am a "Pizza Snob" I will be back.. for sure... read more

I ordered through door dash, some bomb ass pizza , each bite gets more addicting, go check this place out if you haven't!!!! read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

See all

We got a pepperoni pizza to go from Mike's Firestone Pizza a couple of weeks ago. Although we are pizza snobs from New Yawk, we actually enjoyed it. The cheese, sauce and especially the dough were very reminiscent of pies back home. It was a good size and had plenty of pepperoni. We will definitely return. I hope they start being open every night not just on weekends. read more

I finally pulled the trigger and decided to call in and order take out. ORdered a large pepperoni with extra pepperoni. The pizza took exactly 35 minutes like he said and it was the best pizza I've had since move to Fullerton over a year ago. I just found my new spot. Will be ordering from here every time I want pizza read more

When i say this pizza slaps. It f-ing slaps. Mike made us two pizzas after he was coming off a busy rush and they were absolutely amazing. Clearly he cares so much about the product he is putting out. The slice has a great crunch, it folds, and the crust is super crunchy and chewy! Will definitely be coming here again!!! 10/10 read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

After leaving a spin class around the block, my girlfriend and I were both craving pizza. I know she likes Domino's, but I'm a little more classy and will only eat the finest of New York-style pizzas, lol. So I order the biggest size they have, throw some pepperoni, Cajun sausage, jalapeño, and some other sausage on that thing, and wait the 45 minutes it was going to take. I was the last customer, so it took a minute. Anyway, yes, I had a few beers while I waited, and yes, the pizza was effin AMAZING! I'll definitely be back for more. read more

Very good customer service. If you love New York style pizza this place will not disappoint.

Great pizza. Perfectly crunchy crust. OC needs more NY style so I'm grateful for this place. read more

Mike’s Firestone Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fullerton, California

This is hands down the best pizza in Fullerton, and likely the best pizza in SoCal. It's a must try, drive as far as you need to get this pie. Mike is so down to earth and loves his craft. You can taste the passion in every bite of the pizza. Every part is perfect, the crispy bottom, the simple yet elegant sauce and delicious greasy (not too greasy) cheese. For real no doubt 10/10, and with the hot honey and easy 11/10. I'm serious, come and get this pizza, what are doing still reading this, go now! read more

This is the best pizza in the oc. Every 2 weeks we order 2 large pizzas and grab 1/2 beers while we wait. Everyone that we have sent there has thanked us. So good! read more

This pizza, easy, 8.9. Service was great! Bartender and chef were very professional and nice! Ambiance was great! Clean and amazing location. Had entertainment while we wait and a waiting area for our family while we waited for our pizza. We will Definitely return for pizza in the future! 100 percent satisfied while waiting and enjoying the service! read more