Good pizza, second best in the area. Wings are pretty good. Nice selection of 2 go brewskis. Subs are good. Service is good. The slices are nice and big. Stromboli is tasty. Delivery times can be slow. They could do better on their health inspections. read more

We usually go to the Midtown Pizza on Main Street in Middletown, PA. We moved and ordered from the Eisenhower location because it was closer. Warning. . DO NOT ORDER FROM THEM AND USE DELIVERY! They messed up our order for $70 .. (4) times!!!!! Then REFUSED TO CORRECT IT.. they threatened US when we requested the refund. As we have the food and did not eat it! They are crooks! DO NOT ORDER WITH DELIVERY.. DO NOT COUNT ON ANY CUSTOMER SERVICE read more

Midtown Pizza - Terrible food and customer service. - Italian Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Ordered a cheeseburger stromboli and it was exactly what I hoped for. Very flavorful! The steak was seasoned well and the onions with the melted American cheese made it so delicious. The marinara sauce that came with it was also made very well. My family and I will definitely be going back! read more

Wing deal on Sundays is great! They have a good social each day as well. Carlos is a great bartender on the bar side and always very accommodating! Four stars only due to the fact that they recently changed to a smoking bar which is not my thing. We will definitely return (especially during football season!) read more

We were so fed up with Hershey Park and their limited offerings (1hr+ lines for food and limited offerings due to staffing) that we left the park early. We ordered $100+ worth of pizza as we were starving. The pizza was ready promptly and was amazing. Perfect crust! My favorites were the New Yorker cheese pizza and the White Pizza. My 10 month old loved the ricotta on it. The wings were okay (needed some butter mixed into the hot sauce) and the salad would've been good if we had remembered to check for the dressing. No worries, we just ripped the chicken of the wings and mixed it in the salad. All and all, the staff was friendly, the food was done faster than any line at Hershey Park, and it was delicious. We may have over ordered as we are still eating leftovers 2 days later. Still delicious! read more

The pizza is excellent, the service on the bar side, (Mugs), is horrible! We came in today after work and sat at the bar for at least five minutes. No bartender. None. Zero. I will continue to order their pizza, but we will not stop by for a beer after work again. EVER. read more

Great pizza I only got 2 slices felt like I was eating 4 the pizza slices was huge and the fries was great the place was nice it's connected to a bar with pool tables l. The employees was nice and friendly read more

Max started out with a goldmine but lost it.Warm beer that tastes flat and no rib special anymore. Bartender does five jobs for one pay and leaves to deliver food! The last time I went I had to ask for the keg to be changed.No thanks,I'll go elsewhere. read more

Love the pizza Selection of 40 oz. Not big fan of the bread type they use. Why do I feel like I always need to criticize oww. Yeh. But there is so many options and choices that are good. @ this joint. read more

Don't eat here.They don't use gloves. Two people handled money then proceeded to take my sandwich apart to ad mayonnaise. Didn't wash hands or use gloves. I asked to speak to manager or owner they said they don't have that information they don't know. Really. They were upset that I wanted my money back. They don't even care. The guy is still back there making subs with no gloves on. read more

The Food is very good but some of the people that come in there look like they are on Drugs

Bought a sub and thought it was really good. Second trip to same restaurant bought sub I could not eat because the whole one sub of sub roll was very stale and hard and when I went back and told the person who waited on me they could only say they were sorry. Third trip to same restaurant and ordered a sub again and there was less on this sub then you get on a Subway sub, and that is very sad. Will not return to this restaurant and would advise other people to steer clear and try other restaurants for better service and better food. read more

My friend and I stopped in for a drink. (Currently known as Mugs) she was hungry and decided to order the special "rib" dinner. It was horrible, a bunch of bones cartilage and fat. My friend used the term disgusting. To top it off we spent the following day making trips to the bathroom. The $5 pitcher of beer was ok but the food? Keep it! read more

We've stayed at the La Quinta on Eisenhower several times and have gotten into the habit of picking up a pizza at Midtown just across the road. Over several years we've tried most of the meat pies and today we tried the white tomato pizza. Although I prefer a thin crisp crust, the thick crust used by Midtown has nice texture and a pleasant yeasty flavor. Looks like ordering online is the way to go as they offer a10% discount and have removed the seating they used to have. On the plus side they now have a door directly Mugs bar and bbq next doer so the wait dissent have to be uncomfortable. read more

The steak and cheese with loaded fries was worth the walk across the street. Definitely lived up to the other reviews. I'll go back again the next night here. read more

For a pizza shop midtown pizza is very versatile I went in to pick up dinner for takeout but when I saw how nice and clean the dining area was my family and I simply had to sit down to eat there, the servers were very courteous and professional. In short I would recommend this place to anyone wanting a good dining experience with even better food read more

well after 4 phone calls and 3 hours i still do not nave the Stromboli i ordered. nor a time on when/ if i will get it. or any idea on how i will be refunded. read more