The first times I was a customer of Michaelangelo's was from 1988 through 1992. This was Monterey Park and my introduction to fast food/restaurant pizza since I was 9 to 10 years old. I remember the Addams Family pinball table, the original Turtles arcade, King of the Monsters, Baseball Stars, the octagonal shape bar counter adjacent to the open pizza kitchen, the wall mirror tiles with yellow veins over the red leather booths and the RGB TV projector showing Raiders games on the walls. I remember the slices, pepperoni when I was that kid, the tomato sauce was thicker, chunkier. After Mikey's closed and moved I figured it was over, the end of an era forever. I learned of a Michaelangelo's in San Dimas through casual research in 2019, there is a Michael Angelo's somewhere in California but it wasn't until after the pandemic that I learned through more research the San Dimas and Monterey Park locations were/are the same place. I returned for the first time in 34 years May of '26. I ordered a medium meat lovers pizza to see what would happen. The dark red walls, the multiple flat screens and the modern arcade decor are a far cry from the 80's and early 90's. Still, they provide a welcome atmosphere of familiarity. The nostalgia builds all over again. The recipe felt so familiar and delicious to me but more than that. Michaelangelo's pizza tasted like memories. I tried the Michaelangelo's special in June. The Supreme pizza that you don't appreciate as a kid but only as an adult. The almost sourdough taste to the crust, the olive oil or canola oil flavor to the vegetables and cheese. I requested and got an extra layer of marinara sauce at no extra charge. It was sweet, tangy, I do miss the thick, chunky texture the sauce used to be on those slices but, as most of us old timers say, that was a long time ago. Based upon my three recent visits to Mikey's, because I am not in their 5 mile radius and I can only visit once a month, Michaelangelo's Pizza 1985 gets a solid from me. Do not order ahead of time except for catering. Walk in to order and visit as late as 7 to 7:30pm as they'll still keep those ovens on. Forget Domino's, bland. Forget Pizza Hut, it's spicy sponge. Forget Little Caesars, the cheese is Chef Boyardee. Chuck E. Cheese, WTF is that?! Forget Round Table, Shakeys and Straw Hat, their pizzas are the typical pay grade above DiGiornos but Michaelangelo's pizza tastes like memories, absolute bloody good memories. And nothing, I mean nothing has literally replaced the empty space that Michaelangelo's left behind in Monterey Park near East Los Angeles College longer than a few months. All those businesses failed and continue to fail. When I go there, it's not just the great pizza but the 80's and early 90's trip through time in TV and video games. That's what Michaelangelo's means to me. read more

Went around 4pm yesterday (Tuesday) it was empty which was understandable because of this heat. The cashier was a bit rude and seemed to be rushing us to order. After she took our order she was off the clock, I see why. The 2 young. cashiers who replaced her were friendly. We got the meat lovers and dry wings. The pizza was a 6.7/10. The wings were big and juicy, they get a solid 7.4/10 It seems like a perfect spot for game nights or huge sporting events. I would definitely come back. read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza - Michaelangelo's Meat Lovers - Pizza Near Me - San Dimas, California

There needed to be a photo of this salad, it is amazing and plentyful!!! It will alst me for 2 or 3 meals for sure. The rest of the family is enjoy the Antapasto salad and a couple of calzones. They are always beyond delicious! read more

Pizza they're good here at Michelangelo's! You should add in your order the chicken wings- they're delicious as well! Food % Service 100% Ambiance 100% They have moved to a new location but still in San Dimas. read more

We get pizza and salad from Michelangelo's almost every week. The value is phenomenal. The new location on the north side of Arrow Highway is very nice. Service is great and we love the Michaelangelo's Special. read more

Been coming to this restaurant since 20+ years ago. Food is still the best around and the service is great. Even tho now I moved to different city but I still bring friends from other city to visit. Love the BBQ chicken and their wings. read more

The pizza is good, I am a fan of bread-y thicker crust, which was yummy! It could use a bit more sauce but overall the pizza was good! Zucchini fries were good too, normal frozen Zucchini fries. Unfortunately each time that we have stopped in to the restaurant or called its been disappointing as far as service. I wouldn't say they are rude, but not friendly, not welcoming, very dry and almost like you're bothering the staff being thereand asking a question. We came in one night maybe 20 minutes before closing time, just to ask a question and we were told before and after the question that they're closing up very soon. I would definitely work on customer service. read more

Bought lunch for a customer after they recommended Michaelangelo's and liking their pizzas. I preordered the night before for it to be ready when they opened the following day, which it was and right on time, great service l, the lady behind the counter was nice and helpful. We got a Pepperoni, a vegetarian and Michaelangelo's Special, along with garlic bread and a large green salad with blue cheese. The pizzas were tasty, a lot of toppings and the edges were crispy, I would have preferred the overall crust to stand up better, floppy on the specialty pizzas, but I guess that may be expected with the amount of toppings, but still very enjoyable and I liked it. The garlic bread was good, perfectly toasted, buttered, but not a lot of garlic. Which that could be a good or bad thing depending on taste, I prefer a bit more garlic, but again, very tasty. Lastly the salad, greens, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, pepperoncinis and mozzarella cheese, with blue cheese dressing. The blue cheese is homemade, but misses the mark for me, I typically love homemade restaurant blue cheese, but this one not so much, something was just off with it and I could not use it and enjoy the salad. I am sounding picky, which I don't mean to be, and I am not, just giving my experience. I love a good pizza spot. The space itself is large, lots of tables, decor inside is nice and feels like a classic pizza spot the also have beers on tap and has a nice game area for the kids. Nice spot for groups, Families, etc. Enjoy! read more

See all

My husband and I have been coming to this restaurant for quite a few years but it seems that the last 2 years that service has gone down. tried ordering to go half an hour before closing at least which our order of a pizza and salad normally takes 10-15 mins. The phone was picked up told kitchen is closed and then was hung up on. This has happened too many times that we've brushed poor customer service off, looks like we'll find a new pizza place to go to sadly. read more

Good pizza with a good vibe. If I wanted to sit down at an old-school pizza place and drink a pitcher of beer, this is the place I would go. Ample seating, lots of TVs, and good pizza. read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza - The Matty - Pizza Near Me - San Dimas, California

Amazing food and good quality food, the staff was so kind to us as well. Perfect place for dinner or lunch, we got the chicken Alfredo pizza and wings. So delicious!! read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Dimas, California

What can I say , I've been a loyal customer for years, but lately the employees ! Are plain out assholes. So I'm not going back! I'll take my business somewhere else! and the food is ok. Somewhere through the years the food quality went downhill. read more

It's all about the pizza, folks! The main thing is to keep the main thing the main thing--and Michaelangelo's does just that with their delicious pizza. The dining area is ideal for parties and there are TVs for watching games. The service was good, and my wife and I enjoyed it and happily recommend it. read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza - A medium pepperoni and mushroom. The picture honestly doesn't do it justice but it was a fabulous pie! - Pizza Near Me - San Dimas, California

Raiders spot Delicious food pizza and wings are Fast service Good beer prices best bet is the tower read more

This place has great customer service, large dining area, arcade, TV's are placed to see no matter where you sit, 10 beer taps, food comes out fast and tastes amazing! You definitely can taste the quality in their ingredients. If you haven't gave this gem a try, do yourself a favor and stop in and try for yourself. You won't regret it! Keep up the great work, MichaelAngelo's Pizza read more

I love coming here, their wings, pasta, and pizza is good. The service here is typically good! There was only one time where the lady was rude but I never usually see her, I only ever see the younger employees which are polite! It gets quite busy at times but the portions are huge and worth it read more

Always a great time! We recently held a youth team fundraiser here. The staff was attentive, on point, easy to work with, great food, TVs/ sports, and cold beers on tap! We will definitely continue to come back! read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Dimas, California

I go here a few times and have steered customer to here as I go to Montanas night club often (same parking lot) and this not the first time I've been put on hold for 10+ minutes to order a pizza for pick up, end up walking over (while on hold) to find at least one person at the register not do anything. I addressed the person at the register about being on hold to receive a "oh. Sorry". Very disappointed and don't think I'll be taking my business or sending anyone there anymore. read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Dimas, California

I had this pizza once and it wasn't too bad. We normally go to Domino's, but I was at my buddies house and he bought this and now I wanna go back. I suggest trying their pizzas. read more

If I was Dave Portnoy I would give this pizza a solid score of 6.5! The hot wings are also great and the ranch is homemade which is the best kind! Service is very friendly and ambiance at the new location is the same as the old, flat screen TVs, long tables and a few arcade games as well. I usually order the pepperoni/mushroom or the pepperoni/sausage pizza. Sometimes it has a slight flop, but not too much to where you have to fold it. Crust is crispy, not hard, but not soft, just the right amount of crispy. Cheese is the perfect consistency and not super greasy. Like I said, solid 6.5 pie. If your ever in San Dimas, CA this place is great for a pizza night with the famliy or friends! read more

MichaelAngelo's food is a well established family restaurant. Have been going here for decades. The chicken are finger licking good and delicious. They have a variety flavors; sweet chili, mango habanero, garlic parmesan, and lemon pepper just to name a few. Their pizza is crisp and savory. We got pepperoni and sausage! You can't go wrong with MichaelAngelo's! read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza - Large pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Dimas, California

See all

Stop by the here other day and really enjoyed the pizza and anti-pasta salad. My brother had a sandwich and it was good as well. The prices are decent and service was good read more

We always comes to watch the big soccer games here and the staff is always accommodating with our requests. The pizza is solid and has its own unique pizzeria taste. Great place to grab a beer and slice while watching any sporting event! read more

The Pizza is delicious here. I've been to this place twice already. Those two times that I've gone the service is exceptional. The ambience is great, they have TV's and arcade games to entertain the kiddos. This place is a good place to go relax and have a delicious pizza. read more

Excellent pastas and pizzas. Their wings are so bomb too. I loved that they had those video games for the little ones to entertain themselves with while us adults relaxed and had beers. My kid attended so many birthday parties here and the staff was always so patient with him and his little friends even when they would run around because they were so excited to be around each other outside of school. It broke my heart to see it empty during the pandemic but it makes me so happy to know that it survived. It's a gem of a restaurant and it is a permanent fixture in San Dimas. read more

I had to escape the 57 fwy and found this restaurant for a quiet late lunch escape. I was in the mood for a personal pizza and the lady recommended the pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, bell pepper and olive pizza special. I was sold. This small sized pizza was beyond a personal pizza size (six slices). It was very fresh, hot and tasty! I spent the next half hour debating myself to bring half of the pizza home, or have lunch and dinner in one sitting. Lunch/dinner won out and I was content for the rest of the day! I was hungry walking in and I left very content. I recommend this cheerful casual restaurant. As a traveling business person, I'll plan to be back! Arrow Highway exit, across the street and a right turn. Reasonably priced too! read more

Initially ordered pizza and wings for pickup and it was so good we decided to come back a week later and had the same thing at the 'new' location. read more

Their lasagna and cheese knot bread is to die for. Their lasagna is seasoned to perfection and their cheesy garlic knot bread is super good!!!! read more

Delicious personal pizza and great price. Ordered a drink and a custom personal pizza and it was only $16.

Would not take an order 30 mins before closing cause they were lazy. Why have a closing time. Guess making money is not important to the establishment. read more

I'm not one to leave reviews but I feel obligated for this one. Pizza was good, however the service was awful. Every single employee is on their phone, no hospitality what so ever, they seem bothered by people asking a question. The kid that brings the pizza out just sets it down and doesn't say a word, walks away, and we have no plates or napkins. We had to get up and go ask for plates. Biggest thing that bothers me is all the employees buried in their phones, highly disrespectful to your customers in my opinion. Expect decent pizza, but don't expect good service. read more

Horrific pizza!!!!!! Ordered meat lovers. No pizza sauce, only three pieces of each meat, accept Canadian bacon, there's none of that!!!!!! Never again! read more

Michaelangelos pizza has delicious food and great customer service. I myself enjoy the chicken pesto pasta, 10/10 highly recommend. Don and his staff are very accommodating when my family and I dine in. read more

Place is ran by kids, no Managment. Glad there offering opportunity, but the they can clearly lack customer service skills. This place was much better at their last location. Never had such poor service in a long time. If you're the owner, pay for real management and take care of your customers. We were a group of 8 that had to unfortunately to walk out. read more

They don't allow service dogs so we left the lady in the front could of been a little nicer about it but it's ok we took our business to Red Robin right on the corner and they welcomed us in :)) read more

The food is delicious! I got the pepperoni pizza, sausage pizza, and wings. I can't wait to try the other food on the menu. read more

This place is a hidden gem tucked in a shopping center. The food was delicious. The ranch is the nest and I see why they charge extra for it. I wish this place was local to where I live. I would say this is what a pizza should taste like. Big open space for large groups. Parking is plenty. Bathrooms clean. read more

Very good service , good delivery, very nice , profesional. The food is delicious, we went last time for my nephew birthday, he loved

After living in area for over 30 years, we finally ate at Michaelangelo's Pizza. It was pretty good. We ordered a Greek salad, fried zucchini sticks, a vegetarian pizza, and a build-your-own pizza. Price was reasonable. Food was tasty. Service was good. Ambiance was fine. Clearly, this is a family-friendly place with kids playing in an arcade area. We will be back. read more

Well, I am pretty disappointed with the cleanliness, or lack of here. The trash cans were overfilled, spilling over onto the floor, also, the floor has trash all over the place at the tables where people eat. As I'm eating my pizza, which I really like, and have always liked their pizza, so I have no complaints there, but I see 3 employees just standing around talking, when they should be taking the trash out and sweeping the floors. Poor management in my opinion. I'll probably just have my pizza delivered from now on, I just can't see myself eating at place that doesn't clean up where customers eat. read more

Michaelangelo's Pizza - Overfilled trash can - Pizza Near Me - San Dimas, California

See all