Good: - marg pizza - trenette bolognese - ravioli (wouldn't get it again cuz not my palate) - strachiatella Meh: - root vegetables Black cod was weird, like it seemed nice but we all thought the fish was too slimy, too...alive? Too recently slaughtered? But I mean, maybe we're just not cool enough to appreciate it lol. read more

See all

Food was great, drinks were great. The fancy pizza oven! Best gnocchi ever. Like biting into a cloud. Mushroom sauce was tasty Surprised they only 2 options for meat & seafood entrée read more

See all

I hate to write such a bad review for a local spot but we have given Mentone multiple shots and last night was the final straw. The portion sizes are crazy small for a non-coursed meal. My daughters each had the ravioli and it looked like a toddler portion-literally 7 very small raviolis. My lamb was tough and exactly three bites with lentils that were terribly salty. The menu options are pretty limited-only a lamb and a fish (overpriced cod) for entrees other than pasta or a pizza-no beef or chicken. The chef's curated salame appetizer most definitely came out of packages from the grocery store and slapped onto a wooden serving tray. It's like they're not even trying. I'm super bummed because even after our appetizers, salad, and "entrees" we were still hungry and literally ordered food from another restaurant to be delivered to our house so we had a meal when we got there. $340 bucks to order another meal is insane. One star for the very nice hostess. read more

4% surcharge. 4/5: The Genovese pizza $26 was a daily special, with pesto, pistachio, ricotta, moz, basil. the flavors were great. But their Neapolitan pizza has a very soft crust; it's very pillowy, with very little char on the bottom. There is not enough contrast between the crust and the toppings; you can't tell where the crust ends and where the toppings begin. I prefer Neapolitan pizza with more chew on the crust and char on the bottom, like at Pizzeria Delfina, Che Fico, and Doppio Zero. 5/5: Eggplant appetizer $20. Perfectly seared/caramelized eggplant, with just enough chili to give it a boost. 2/5: Lemon curd dessert $12, with fior di latte gelato and pistachio praline. This dessert doesn't work. The super intense lemon curd obliterates the subtle flavors of the fior di latte gelato; they should never be served together. Don't get this dessert; instead, just get a single scoop of the fior di latte gelato, which is 5/5 excellent $9 Random points: - My table was wobbling like a tilt-a-whirl because the weld connecting the base to the post failed. - When they deliver the bill, they stick it to a small metal tray using a magnet. That risks de-magnetizing the stripe on my credit card. read more

See all

Delicious food (see photo captions), great service, and a comfortable, cozy atmosphere! Highly recommend! read more

See all

Condensed menu but still very hard to choose an item. The Focaccia is the best on planet Earth. Everything is prepared with fresh ingredients and amazing care. We have traveled Extensively to Europe and the one common thread with most European cuisine is fresh, lively, and memorable. Mentone creates that same sensation. read more

Lovely restaurant with fabulous service. Homey and comfortable yet still a little fancy. Open kitchen, high ceilings and an Italy-meets-France vibe. I loved it. Offerings were diverse and plentiful. Once again, I was struck with wanting all of the things. My server was accommodating with my request to taste two different white wines and two different reds throughout my meal. I opted for the Chardonnay to go with the special halibut crudo, which was outstandingly prepared. The fish itself was a bit on the fishy side (especially for halibut) but I don't fault the restaurant. The treatment of the fish was perfection. I'm a bit of a Caesar salad aficionado and considered skipping Mentone's mostly because I'd just enjoyed one the night before. But I just had to try it and I'm glad I did. It was certainly not traditional but it was very well made, even better with the added anchovies ~ although I did suffer some sticker shock when I got the bill and found that those little fish were $2 each. Ooof. Switched gears to some Pinot Noir and went for the ricotta sage browned butter ravioli, which were fabulous. I probably should have stopped there but ordered the tiramisu and it was a miss for me. Just way (way) too boozy and totally lacked balance, although it was pretty. All in all, a very nice experience ~ although very pricey for a single diner. Appetizer, salad (with the pricey little fishies), entree, dessert and two 5-ounce pours of wine left my wallet $185 lighter (with tax, tip and 4% kitchen wages surcharge). I know everything is very expensive these days, but whoa. Definitely a special occasion kind of place! read more

Mentone - Italian Near Me - Aptos, California

See all

Overall positive experience at Mentone! The stracciatella was fantastic, with very high quality olive oil on it. Loved the focaccia that came with it, too. The pizza was really decent for the area, too. The only thing I wished was that it had more marbling. The sauce and crust were both excellent though, definitely some of the better pizza in the area! The ox tail was decent, though not mindblowing. Similar to the desserts, all decent but not amazing. Similar to other reviews the only thing I would say is that everything felt ~20% more expensive than it should have been. The food was quite good, but at the pricepoint I'm not sure I'd return. read more

See all

This review is much over due. While the visit was a bit ago... the memory is like yesterday. It was that satisfying. Elegant, classy and romantic. Full bar, casual atmosphere with exceptional food. Brought to you by Michelin Chef David Kinch and Santa Cruz local. Mentone is located in the newer Aptos Village area. A sweet addition to the Santa Cruz region dining scene. My food was delicious. An elevated and untraditional caesar salad started off the meal. I loved it! Radicchio... yum. Then the star of the show. A wood-fired, delectable Margherita pizza. Crust soooo fantastic. Memorable to the last bite. And of course an unforgettable, lovely Italian red with which to savor it all. Service was impeccable. Professional and our waitperson was knowledgeable about everything Mentone. Checking in just at the right times. She definitely added to the pleasing rhythm of the meal. The ambiance is stunning. Low lights and exquisite art work. Nice spacing between seating. My fondest memory... being able to meet David Kinch and share a photo at his very cool bar! Such a nice and approachable person. I want to go back soon! 2026 here I come:). You will want to also. read more

See all

Took my mother here years ago; the restaurant has been consistently on-point (i.e. great food, customer service, etc.) Always a must if you seldom visit Aptos Village. read more

Amazing food we loved it! Their pizzas and pasta are fire! Me and partner would go back.

Came here for my graduation dinner expecting a great experience. A family member previously managed this location, so I came in with high expectations. After staring at the lackluster menu for fifteen minutes and having my request to substitute the lentils that come with the rack of lamb denied, I eventually settled on the black cod, the only other protein option on the menu. The waitress mentioned she had never tried it herself due to a food allergy. Unfortunately, the dish was one of the worst restaurant meals I have ever been served. In front of me was what appeared to be a roughly 2 ounce piece of cod that seemed undercooked, sitting in a sauce that reminded me of SpaghettiOs or Chef Boyardee, accompanied by just three green beans. The price? $45. I immediately sent it back and ordered the ravioli instead. That was not much better. The portion consisted of only seven tiny ravioli, each about an inch square. By the end of the meal, I left feeling disappointed, unsatisfied, and still hungry. The one redeeming aspect of the experience was the service. Our waitress and the staff taking care of my family's table were friendly, attentive, and professional throughout the evening. Unfortunately, great service alone could not make up for the quality and value of the food. read more

Food was delish and service was really good. I loved the fact that the pasta dishes were not only sublime but they were a reasonable size. You felt like you were eating a special dish. read more

What a great place in Aptos Village. When you walk in the restaurant is nice and bright and welcoming. My boyfriend and I visited on a Friday evening. We luckily found a spot at the bar and ordered drinks and the stracciatella with local olive oil and focaccia. OMG this was delicious! I would come back here just for this! We also had the margherita pizza with mozzarella di bufala and parmigiano reggiano. This was rather tasty too! The staff was very attentive and friendly throughout our visit. Overall a great spot and I highly recommend it if you're in the area! read more

Mentone - Italian Near Me - Aptos, California

This place blew me away. I was on a local girls trip in Santa Cruz and my friend made us a reservation here for dinner. Everyone from the hostess to our waitress was super friendly and the food was phenomenal. I had the mentone martini which I highly recommend. For food we ordered the Margherita pizza, sardenaira pizza, arugula salad, eggplant starter (my fav!), stracciatella (yum!) and broccolini. While everything was delicious I absolutely loved the eggplant. Overall, it was the perfect setting for me and my high school besties to catch up and have a wonderful night. Thank you Mentone! I hope to be back soon! read more

See all

Terrible service, the pizza we got was just uninspired and burnt. It's a bland excessively expensive menu, with small drink and food portions. Also a Hidden 4% kitchen service charge. We had to wave our waitress down for service, multiple time and even though it was on the reservation and I politely reminded the hostess, they did nothing for a birthday. We won't be back. You should go elsewhere too. read more

Excellent service but ...the food was less than exciting. Ordered chioppino and a pizza. That was not chioppino. Please try harder. read more

This was our second time dining at the restaurant. Our first visit was back in 2020 during Covid, when we sat outside. We'd been wanting to return to experience the indoor ambiance, so we decided to visit again for my birthday. Unfortunately, the restaurant did nothing to acknowledge the occasion, which was disappointing. The cocktails were excellent, and the pizza was delicious. However, the portion size of the gnocchi felt small for the price. Service was inconsistent. Our server disappeared for long stretches, and we noticed several staff members gathered behind the bar chatting. I asked a server to describe one of their sparking wines & she was unable to do so. She mumbling something, then walked away. Overall, the experience fell short of expectations. A simple gesture, like a candle on the dessert, would have gone a long way. Sadly, we won't be back. read more

Mentone - Italian Near Me - Aptos, California

Love love love Mentone! What a gem in the heart of Aptos Village. Chef Grubbs creates not only delectable Italian fare, but also beautiful plates as well. I've always appreciated plates that consider the visual of a contrasting colorful drizzle on a plate or the impressive towering shavings of cheese on a salad, for example. They're beautiful without trying to be. Right when you step inside, the restaurant transports you to Italy with its large room, filled with the sounds of happy people eating, and framed posters decorating the walls. Mentone is one of the only restaurants where everything I order is delicious, from salad to dessert. Everything. And the service is always excellent and authentically homey. Mentone is truly a special place. read more

See all

The service was amazing! From the moment you walk in, the wonderful people who work there are working to make the experience great! Love the inviting and Italian ambiance. I highly recommend ordering the Manresa bread and stracciatella! The Negroni is on point too! There was a great buttery fish we also ordered with our appetizers but I don't remember what it was called. read more

Mentone is our go-to spot for celebrating, every single time! The space is open and airy, the art is effortlessly cool, and the whole place hums with that perfect mix of energy and ease. We never skip the Caesar, and if the ravioli makes an appearance, it's non-negotiable. Yes, the portion is small, but each piece is a delicate, flavor-packed pillow that absolutely earns its place on the table. We've also enjoyed the oysters, pizza, and eggplant. Honestly, it's hard to go wrong here. Dessert is a ritual: the decaf affogato (bless them for the decaf espresso) is a must, and a recent lemon mousse with pistachios was bright, balanced, and memorable. The service seals the deal: warm, personable, and perfectly attentive without ever hovering. And here's a pro tip: no reservation? Show up a little early and you'll likely snag a bar seat. Once it fills, they switch to a waitlist system, so you can relax without anyone hovering over your shoulder. It's the kind of place that makes any night feel like an occasion, and we are thrilled to have it so close by! read more

5 stars just for the eggplant. All the food was good but as an eggplant hater, this restraints eggplant has single handedly changed my mind. It has a special place in my cherished food memories. read more

I've been here a few times now, including one instance at the bar for cocktails and light bites. The food here is consistently excellent, as you would expect from a place started by a 3* Michelin chef. The irony is, I have yet to have the pizza here. I will try on my 4th visit - I promise :). One of my favorites here is the polenta - such great flavors and texture. The cocktails here are also meticulously and deliciously prepared. Mentone will not disappoint! read more

See all

Mentone is always a 10/10. Staff, food, service is always excellent! The margarita pizza is a standout. read more

See all

Great service, very attentive and quick service. Right when we got there they asked what kind of water we wanted. Server explained specials to us and she recommended some starters as well and yummy drinks. Will be back soon! It's such a cute little fun place inside even though it's still fancy. read more

See all

Been wanting to try this place out for some time now, and finally got the chance. It was a bit of a colder night with drizzle, so it was indoor seating only. We arrived 15 minutes before our reservation, and were told we couldn't get seated until the time we reserved. It did look pretty busy, and seems like seating is somewhat limited. We were quickly greeted by our server, who walked us through the menu. We went with a Margherita pizza and a Caesar. I believe all food options are meant to share. The Margherita was delicious, I just wish it had a bit more cheese. They did offer to add some type of special cheese, but I decided to opt out of it. The Caesar was delicious. I loved the croutons. Parking is limited, but there is some street parking. Overall, I really enjoyed my dining experience here and am extremely happy with the food! read more

Mentone - Caesar - Italian Near Me - Aptos, California

See all

The young woman at the front desk was so kind and pleasant. But the food was not. I don't get the hype at all. I'm not sure if it's the vacation-effect, where people become attached to a restaurant when they visit for the weekend. Cute location, cute interior. Limited menu, and wildly overpriced. The pesto with green beans and potatoes, ENTREE, at $32.00 was barely the size of a side. The flavor of the pesto was delicious. The pizza was so thin and soggy that it could blow in the breeze when you held it up. The crust was puffy, so that was nice. I get it, this is a hipster restaurant, so no bread (no one wants to think that they're in Olive Garden, for heaven's sake!) Nor is there any dessert -- not a great special occasion place for that reason, but you could always dip out later to get ice cream at Marianne's. If you like the experience of being in an exclusive restaurant, then you'll enjoy it for the ambience, and the flavor, but the actual food itself is NBD. read more

For my husband's 49th, we had the ceaser salad, pasta bolognese, cheese ravioli, and the best dish I have had forever, the oxtail w/polenta Best service & meal we have had in 10 years since moving here from New York. A hundred stars if Icould read more

The eggplant appetizer was hands down the best eggplant I've ever eaten. We followed with an arugula salad, that was bright and crisp. The soppressata pizza was highly recommended and did not disappoint. Just the perfect amount of spice. Finished with the lemon curd which just writing about makes my mouth water. Can't wait to come back! read more

Mentone - Old Fashioned - Italian Near Me - Aptos, California

We had tried coming a few times but never had reservations and didn't want to wait. It's definitely worth the wait! Great cocktails, appetizers, and food! The building is beautiful and classy and the artwork is great. read more

Having tried Manresa a decade ago, I have been excited for Mentone for a few years. Finally able to pass through. My cocktail (Tokyo Drift) was nicely balanced and not too sweet, which is a rarity. Tripe and polenta was a pleasant surprise. Polenta was creamy. Tripe was tender and did not disguise what it was. Always good to see some offal on the menu. Anchovy pizza was great. Dough had right mix of chew and crunch. Tomato sauce cut through the oil of the fish and olives well. Seems like a lot of the reviews for this place are grading on a pretty harsh curve. Overall, easy to recommend for a classy happy hour stop. read more

Mentone - Tripe & Polenta - Italian Near Me - Aptos, California

See all

My husband and I came here on Labor Day without a reservation. We arrived before they opened at 5:00 and were able to get one of the few tables that weren't booked. And despite having read a recent negative review about service we found the service EXCELLENT!! Friendly and super fast! We had great cocktails, the special appetizer of tomatoe confit over stracciatella cheese with balsamic glaze (OUTSTANDING!!!) Calabrese pizza and octopus. We were in and out within 45 min. The fast and friendly service couldn't have been more excellent. So ignore the other negative review. Give this place a try. Cute Italian vibe, great food and cocktails. Just a limited menu. But you can do that when you execute everything well. My husband said the octopus with butter beans was so tender and wished he could lick the sauce off the plate! read more

Mentone - Pizza with salame and Calabrian chili - Italian Near Me - Aptos, California

See all

Been wanting to come here since they opened. Pizza was good and the Cesar salad was very cheesy/Parmesan Cheese. The Gazpacho soup was excellent. Drinks was good read more

See all

Party of 4. We stopped in around 6pm with no reservations on a Friday night after a day of sailing (so fancy!). We were graciously accommodated with a high top. Started off with the fresh peach and prosciutto appetizer and a Caesar salad. The peaches were perfection and carried the dish. Normally I would t order a salad as it takes up valuable real estate in my stomach, however this was the best Caesar I've ever had; so fresh, crisp and light tasting. Moved on to the black cod which was divine. Two pizzas and two bottles of Barolo later we left with full tummies and happy hearts. Wine list is impressive and fairly priced. Service was warm and friendly and although the restaurant became extremely busy we never felt rushed. Definitely returning when we are in the area. read more

Mentone - Happy sailors. - Italian Near Me - Aptos, California

One of the best meals I've had. Each ingredient in every dish was excellent. From the appetizer to desserts, my wife and I could not believe how delicious the dishes were. We also had our two little ones: 3 and 2 year old kids. This was the only meal that week in which everyone ate all their food. That is saying something when it comes to our kids. We had the Stacciatella to start off. Wife had the Tagliatelle, I had Trenette and the kids split the kids cheese pizza. I had a slice of their pizza and it was the best slice of pizza I might ever have eaten. We finished the night with chocolate gelato and the lemon curd. Wow, wow, wow! I can't wait to come back. read more

The food can be good, but the service is the worst. There are way too many incompetent employees bumbling around. I used to recommend Mentone but I can't do that any longer. The last couple of times the food was a mess, soggy pizza, the crudo taste like bile and laughable portions. It feels like a joke when a spoonful of food arrives on a large plate. Several dirty areas in the kitchen made me think they're not as clean as you'd expect. Be careful. read more

Had an amazing dinner experience tonight. We arrived around 6 PM on a Friday night. The restaurant was obviously quite busy. They have a small smaller space that the ambience of the restaurant is very cozy and lively. We put our name down on a list to sit at the bar for two and we're able to be seated within 15 minutes. Started off with one of their guava Mezcal cocktails and a red wine both were delicious. I especially loved the cocktail. For our entrées, we had a Caesar salad salad and a Bolognese. They were very attentive at the bar and service was all around great. We then decided to get dessert and landed on they lemon curd with pistachios and got a wonderful recommendation for a charters pairing from our bartender. I think it was one of the most immaculate desserts I've ever had honestly so delicious. Overall, would definitely recommend for a nice date night if you did want to come with a larger party definitely would recommend making a reservation as their pre-limited on space. read more

Went to Mentone as a party of 6. Decided to order family-style and shared everything we ordered. This was fun because we got to try so many things. The slushy spritzes were a fabulous way to start! Not too sweet and really delicious! We got some appetizers: focaccia with burrata, pickled cauliflower, and eggplant. While I am not a huge eggplant fan, this was my favorite dish of the night! The focaccia and cauliflower were also excellent. We ordered three pastas: sage brown butter raviolis, pesto gnocchi, and the bolognese. All were great but I think the raviolis and gnocchi were the stand-outs. We also got two pizzas: Margherita, and one with salami and Calabrian chiles - my favorite of the pizzas. The food was excellent as was the service. Will go back for sure! I want to try their Caesar salad and I would definitely get the eggplant and focaccia again! read more

Amazing dinner again!!! Bartenders Jillian and Mathew gave us great suggestions and helped us navigate through the menu! Amazing cocktails and food but better yet service! Can't wait to come back. Until next time! read more

Came back post-covid to try the full menu and eat inside. The menu isn't big, but it has a good variety of choices. Also some specials which were great. My wife started with the special soup, a chilled spring pea soup, which was herbaceous, bright and floral, studded with crisp croutons. I started with the beef tartare, which had incredible mouth-feel. But was way over-seasoned. Both too salty and too much vinaigrette in particular the vinegar. It was quite bracing and a little hard to finish, which was unfortunate because it was beautiful meat. I then had the polenta with grits which was perfect. Very cozy dish, well seasoned and balanced tomato ragu with slivers of perfectly cooked tripe, with I think little chunks of pancetta as well. My wife had the gnocchi with peas and morels which was light and bright. Service was attentive. Nice they had sparkling water on tap and the frozen peach fizz cocktail was really well liked by my wife. read more

Mentone - Beef tartare - Italian Near Me - Aptos, California