Loving us some mellow mushroom! The crust is just right and the flavors are out of site! They have a cool hippie vibe to their properties that speaks to my younger self. This is a newer location and smaller than some I have been to but it was nice! Of course the food was top notch! Just wish they would add green olives to the topping list! There is actually quite a selection of food options if you not looking for pizza but I really suggest the pizza! Already making plans to come back here with a group! read more

See all

We originally ordered pizza salad and wings through Uber Eats and it was missing sauces and a salad. As well as the food was cold. I called and they made it right! The second time it was warm and delicious as well as I got everything I ordered read more

A hidden pizza gem. Love the owner chef who actually is a pizza expert who just happens to be at a chain restaurant. Odd location and they deserve more customers! read more

This is the worst Mellow Mushroom in my area, so much so I am willing to drive an extra 15-20 minutes to go to the further away location. Half the time they close the store outside of their posted hours. They always mess up my to go orders. Which is amazing because I ordered a plan cheese pizza and they somehow manage it o mess it up. They close half the restaurant or patio because they "don't want to clean it again". I am truly amazed this location manages to stay open and I am always disappointed in myself whenever I think they might have changed and I should give them another try. I will not make that mistake again read more

To management: The newer servers hired this month for lunch service should not be working here. We were ignored for over 20 minutes in a restaurant that was not busy -- no greeting, no drinks, no service of any kind. After multiple attempts to get someone's attention, it became clear we were being deliberately ignored. Several other tables also waited excessively long for basic service. This was not a one-off mistake; it felt intentional and completely unacceptable. Whatever the underlying issue is, this kind of behavior will ruin your business. In the past, we've been satisfied with the service, even during busy times. read more

don't ever come here if you're any kind of Rush because you have a bunch of people working here but nobody's working if you know what I mean we came in here ordered Subs cuz we thought that was going to be quicker took him forever just to bring the Greek salads so I'm never coming back here read more

Food is still excellent. The crew does a great job. Went during a busy time for dinner and it was great!

We were a party of 6 coming in at 8:15 before a comedy show a few doors down, the way were greeted was disappointing. They didn't say welcome in but instead said " um you are cutting it close the kitchen is closing in 30 min" with a snarky tone. I get it was 30 min before close but why would want the one last sale. On top of that when we were being sat I apologized for the inconvenience and the reply I received was "no comment " That just set the tone for the dinner. read more

whoever is making pizza these days is not living up to the Mellow experience. I would tell him to look at pizza pictures on the website and see how his pizzas do not look like that. this isn't papa John's, mellow is supposed to be better. read more

I have only ordered and eaten the Holy Shiitake pizza w/garlic & truffle drizzle ... dozens of times! And it has been consistently great from Mello Mushroom restaurants in Atlanta and now I go to the Mello Mushroom in downtown Auburn. Other folks with me have ordered everything else and I've never heard a complaint. read more

Pizza wasn't as good as other locations. Looked more thrown together and for as much as it costs, was definitely lacking something. Our server was nice. Water tasted funny. read more

So my very first time at this location. Wasn't very busy at all. Ordered "the works" pizza. Not bad but compared to other Mellow Mushroom's. It just didn't seem to taste the same. Dining in the restaurant you expected to be fresh right out of the oven but honestly it's felt like it sat under a heat lamp or something. Took about 23 minutes for the pizza, medium pizza to reach the table. Although the server was very nice, definitely lack of service no sense of urgency. I sat down and ordered my soda, The young lady went behind the bar and started working and cleaning, I waited about 12 minutes for my drink and I actually had to get up and ask her for my drink. And she said 'oh I'll be there in a minute 'pretty casually. read more

FIRST, when you get there, ask to sit in Victoria's section. Next, order whatever floats your boat because the kitchen SLAYS! Next, pick your favorite draft beer, wine, or cocktail because their selection is wonderful. Now, order your second drink and look forward to an amazing pie! We enjoyed a beer while we waited for our Buffalo chicken pizza. It was DELICIOUS! We don't usually order whole wheat dough, but this was amazing. The texture and flavor were perfect. It was raining and ugly the night we were there so there were only a couple open tables, but despite a nearly full restaurant, the service remained excellent. It was quiet enough for us to chat whi,e we waited and ate, but also enjoyed watching the UGA gymnastics team win their match on tv while we ate. Don't overlook this place. They do it RIGHT. read more

Mellow Mushroom - Buffalo chicken pizza with bleu cheese sauce! AMAZING! - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

SAturday night was the worst experience I've ever had with a pizza delivery. I clearly ordered online as left side black olives and mushrooms and all over the pizza both sides Italian sausage. Got a completely wrong pizza. Called the store and they said they would comp my pizza and to just order the pizza over again. I did the same thing with black olives and mushrooms on the left and Italian sausage all over. New pizza came and it was still wrong with only black olives on the left, the rest cheese. This is ridiculous and I had to pay for Door Dash twice. The store would only comp the pizza amounts. Do not use these people. read more

The food was good but the service was terrible. One waitress had the whole dining room while the manager just stood around gossiping to the other waitresses. I felt sorry for our server, but it was still very frustrating having to wait so long and to get no drink refills. read more

Food and service is good. However, whoever has access to to the bar is watering everything down. They're gonna lose a lot of bar revenue if they don't get on top of it. This is the second time it's happened. Today it was Dewars about 10 months ago it was the Jameson. Whiskeys looks almost clear when looking at it through the glass. read more

They have a bar but don't have experienced bartenders. I ordered a drink that the young lady didn't know how to make. So I tried to go with a shot but they don't carry cognac. So lastly I ordered a beer and I was told I couldn't have it because they "didn't have the button in the system to ring it in". I almost canceled my 2 pizzas because that is probably the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. But we won't be back none the less. While I appreciate both young ladies being honest about their lack of bartending skills, it's unfortunate that they didn't have one person in the building who could figure it out. I'm not sure if they bothered to ask a manager or supervisor. Hopefully my pizza is good, otherwise I'm walking out. And yes I've had plenty of time to sit and write this review while THIRSTY because I haven't been offered water either. #FAIL read more

Mellow Mushroom - The bar - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

They will get a 2/5 from me. We ordered a house special pizza tonight and it was the worst pizza we have had in a long time. Until now we have never been disappointed by Mellow Mushroom. We have been eating there for ten years at this location. The manager just apologized and that was all. We were not looking for anything free but the manager did not anything to make the situation better. If this is going to be their standard, frozen pizzas are not bad and 1/3 the price. read more

Awesome staff. Loved our bartender. We went for a casual beer and ended up chilling at the mushroom. Service was great food was great. Beer came to order. Its a small bar probably fits 6~7 people comfortably but it was a fun night for me. Our bartender even gave us samples of what was on draft for us to try. That was service. There pretzel bites were the bomb. Great match with beer. Good environment with good people! Will definitely come back soon read more

Mellow Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Been to the one in Alpharetta, plenty of parking in this complex. I visited on a tuesday for a pickup and it was super crowded!! They ended up taking longer (45mins) for the order than what they initially said (25mins). They have game/live music going on tuesday nights! The pizza was good, no complaints! Wish the prices were little cheaper. You pay for each topping, the more toppings makes it more expensive. Overall good pizza place if you dont want the fast food chains! read more

Just had a good meal here. Good pizza, good wings, and a good salad. Ethan, our server was very attentive. Nice relaxed meal.

Set at the bar, was the only patron at the bar, and still had terrible service. There is maybe 4 ppl total in the restaurant. Got a drink order, but no one has been back in 15 minutes to check on me. There are 3 lids sitting at a table doing nothing. read more

Mellow Mushroom - a menu on a table - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

See all

I eat here sporadically when I'm at my employers office in Alpharetta. On this visit my boss treated us to lunch. Parking is easy. The interior dining area and patio are consistently clean and well decorated. Service is consistently friendly. They have good vegetarian and vegan food options plus food that has meat for my carnivore coworkers. I ordered the tempeh teriyaki sandwich with chips and a drink. The rest of the group dined on assorted pizzas. Portion sizes and prices are reasonable and the food is consistently delicious. Bathrooms are consistently clean and tidy. I recommend this location!! read more

I would like to say that I haven't always loved their pizza BUT it has grown on me. I really like their beer cheese with the Parmesan pretzel bites! Nom nom! read more

Our server was super friendly and helpful, sad I forgot her name so I can't give her props here The guys in the kitchen were rad, helped me find a vegan dressing and made a wicked good vegan pizza. The Follow Your Heart cheese didn't melt as good as Daiya but it had a good flavor. Jalapeños were super hot and DELICIOUS! Definitely coming back soon! read more

Mellow Mushroom - Vegan pizza w artichoke hearts, portabella mushrooms, jalapeños and Follow Your Heart cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Free wifi, hipster rock music, delicious food. Yes, I'm definitely a fan of Mellow Mushroom Pizza. Especially since they offer gluten free pizza crust and take care to avoid cross-contamination. I normally order the Kosmic Karma, but decided to opt for the House Special, which basically piles on all the various GF veggie and meat toppings, then adds in some extra cheese to boot. Love it! I prefer table service at Mellow Mushroom, but the more efficient - and less costly - counter ordering system works just fine at this location. Soda, water, and tea refills are do-it-yourself, but leave a nice tip when you pay and the staff may just bring your plates and utensils directly to your table. Bottom line: these kids know how to make great pizza, salads, and hoagies, so order up your favorite items, then sit back and enjoy the feast. read more

Mellow Mushroom - Gluten free house special - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Go see Susie! She is the best! Hands down best service around, always friendly and welcomes you with a smile.

Nice place for pizza. Dough is great and baked to nice taste. We tried assortment of pizzas, all tested good. The restaurant was quick in service. Order was placed on phone and was ready on time. Will try again! read more

We love mellow mushroom pizza, especially the crust, and frequent the restaurant around the Atlanta area; however, this particular MM was not as consistent. We were very disappointed in the quality of the food. Ordered carry out for two large pizzas and a Greek salad. The pizza had too much oil sitting on top of the pepperoni and the pizza, itself- the box was saturated with oil. The pizza was stone cold and we only drove 3 miles from the restaurant. The salad was sub-par with huge chunks of the lettuce you typically throw away. It was clear the salad was the gross ice berg from a bag, not fresh romaine lettuce- the way it should have been! We ordered online and arrived 15 minutes early, the restaurant did have the pizza ready which we appreciated and the chopped ingredients on the salad were good but again, the lettuce (which is primarily what a salad is composed of, was inedible). This type of shortcut with the pizza and salad is unacceptable and deters me from returning. This area has tons of other pizza restaurants with higher quality product. read more

Disappointed with this mellow mushroom. My bf went to pick up our order today at this location. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, two chocolate chip cookies and a gallon of lemonade. The pizza was fine, but it was so oily! The oil was just pooling in the pepperoni slices and we had to use a paper towel to get the excess out. The cookies were both STALE. They only had one chocolate chip left so they gave us a sugar cookie to replace the other one. Both were literally hard as a brick. We couldn't even take a bite of it - it was that hard. Both went straight in the trash. read more

Went in and saw a sign on the door that said " Closed, Pick up welcome" so we decided to go in and ask if we can place an order togo at the counter and the man started explaining to us very rudely that he's turned all the ovens off and to read the sign. The sign was very misleading given we assumed we were able to get a pizza for carry out. Them not being able to seat us was not an issue, it was the nasty attitude he had as if we were supposed to know upon entering that they turned the ovens off. The man had an accent and was middle aged. read more

I have been coming to this MM almost weekly for years. The pizza is great and the staff is friendly. The salad is always fresh. It tends to be crowded at lunch, especially with large groups from local offices, so you might want to time your visit so you don't arrive between 12-12:30. Or call ahead if you have a bunch of people. Outdoor seating is covered and generous. It's on the parking lot but not by the road so it's not noisy. read more

Buyer beware! We ordered our dinner from Mellow Mushroom yesterday. People were nice, and we left a good tip. Got home and my daughter's hoagie tasted spoiled... it was an avocado hoagie. We ordered a whole hoagie with tater tots as a side. When we arrived home it was a half, spoiled hoagie. Kindly, they offered to replace it and so today we went to pick up a new dinner for her. The hoagie was fresh and tasty and Hannah was so friendly and helpful. However the manager happened to come to the register and started berating me for coming to early to pick up the order and we should have given them more time to get it ready,,, ya da ya da.... It was so inappropriate... nothing about the half, spoiled hoagie. Good bye, Mellow... too many pizza places in Alpharetta for this! read more

This place is a joke ! Don't pay with cash or they will think it's fake money lmao after showing them more cash I had I left the pizza and anything from them there. Actually have a marker to confirm it's fake rather then having the eagle eye idiots. Will not recommend I felt a vibe as soon as I walked in I should've known lesson learned. read more

I will never come back here , the pizza guys are disgusting. They eat while making pizza using the same gloves to cook ... There is others who reach over the divider and grab whatever ingredients with their bare hands and eat. The place is messy , even out of lighting missing light bulbs . There is still Christmas decorations! Just embarrassing ! read more

Let me start by saying I love the taste and texture of their pizza. But the price for the add-ons is absolutely ridiculous and this goes for all locations. My last two visits at the Windward location resulted in my getting an eight piece pizza with 20 pieces of pepperoni for $2.99. Onions, peppers, banana peppers all $2.99 for about $.15 worth of food. All the sides are a rip off. I hate to have to find another pizza place but I refuse to be made a fool of. read more

Never disappoints. I love the mushroom soup, the meatball sub, creating my own calzone. Good local restaurant, good service, I recommend it. read more

Mellow Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Extremely disappointed in the service today. After working an exhausting shift as an RN, I called so I can place an order over the phone and pick it up without having to wait. Called, put on a NINE minute hold. I was still on hold when I entered the store only to find I was.... the ONLY customer in there. The lady apologized as a matter-of-fact. She said she "forgot the call was on hold". If I wasn't so exhausted from working a long shift, I would have stopped at one of the five pizza places I passed on my way home. So much for supporting a local business! Never again! I've lost faith in Mellow Mushroom! read more

I'd heard quite a bit about the Mellow Mushroom and so I was happy to see that it's right near the hotel where I'm staying. This was the first time, so I decided to play it safe and start with a normal cheese pizza and add a couple of toppings instead of going for one of their unique recipes. The pizza was good. It rarely happens, but in this case the crust was like way better than the pizza itself. It was nicely crispy and soft at the same time and was nicely seasoned as well. I ordered a small and it was more than enough pizza for me - actually I finished only half of it. While the pizza was decent, the garlic bread on the other hand, was pretty disappointing. No real garlic flavor. Not consistently crispy. It didn't seem fresh at all. Very meh... Also they don't deliver. I don't know why they list delivery on their yelp page if they don't really do it. That was a bit annoying to find out after calling them. Again, it was nearby so I went ahead with the order. I would try MM again - maybe that magical mystery pizza or something like that. read more

This is the best Mellow Mushroom I've ever been to! The service is excellent, the Restuarant is clean and the food is delicious even for a very busy Friday. I can't say enough good about our waitress Gabby... she took care of everything even when we spilled our Coke! This is our third visit here but we will definitely be back. read more

Mellow Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia