So we love, five stars every single time which is usually Friday night. We always go to the Galloway location but yelp can't identify that as separate. We've enjoyed dozens of times, the sauce is delicious, the pizza is perfect. We get plain, sometimes toppings or white with broccoli. We love the cheesesteaks, Stromboli, chicken parm and zeppoles. I recently tried the chicken nachos, they're different topped with chopped up chicken but really tasty. My picky family from grandpa to three year old and I mean picky, all can find something on McHughs menu because they're always consistently very good! And I should mention the folks answering the phone are always helpful & welcoming people! They do have a couple tables for a quick bite but we always take home. Mangia!! read more

I visit my family up in Brigantine, NJ about once a month. And usually every Friday night, it's pizza night for them. When they rented a house, it was between Andrea's (really good pizza too) and McHugh's usually switching once a week. They've since moved to a house they bought real close to McHugh's. Since then, it's been nothing but McHugh's pizza for them. Every time we get pizza from them it's always consistent. We always get a Pepperoni Double Cut (for the kids) and that's always really good. We've since tried their Sicilian Sausage and that's really good too. When I come we get 2 pizza's haha. I also get their Mozzarella Sticks which are awesome! I wouldn't change anything about them. Always done right every time. Well maybe one thing, the small is a 6 count so I always get a Large order. Their onion rings are really good too. I def want to try some of the other things on their menu, but those are the thing's we always get and are always GREAT! read more

Order several pies on Friday night of Labor Day Weekend. Not too many pizza places to choose from in town and this might have been just about the only place to pop up besides some Mexican/Pizza place. Order take out and several pies were ready within 30 minutes of calling. It was a bit of a zoo inside with the phone ringing off the hook but the cashiers were attentive enough to get me checked out within a couple mins. Order was correct. Cash Only! Scarce parking on a holiday weekend. Not an empty seat in the joint. Next door was crowded too. Pie wasn't bad and the price was right. Somehow the pepperoni was better than the cheese probably because of a little extra grease and slightly more well done. Saw another review mentioned that they answer the phone "pick up or delivery" which is correct. If they answered with a little chit chat they would never be able to field all the phone orders on a busy holiday weekend. read more

McHugh's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brigantine, New Jersey

See all

Not good. Ordered a turkey hoagie and received turkey on a roll. Picture on left. Ordered a chicken cheesesteak and sad how little it is. Picture on right. read more

McHugh's Pizza - a half eaten sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Brigantine, New Jersey

Thank you Everyone for such a great experience! My 2 year old daughter is very picky lil one! She loved how everything!

McHugh's is one of the first places I visited when I decided to visit as many pizza places as possible (but before I decided to focus on plain pizza). Staying in Brigantine on vacation, I got a personal pizza with chicken on top. I chose the thick variety over thin - the cheese and sauce were thick as well as the sauce, and all tasting pretty good. Overall, solid pizza choice if you're in the area. read more

just ordered 2 large pies, cooked lite almost raw, & got 2 pies almost well done. When I called & complained, they did offer to make 2 new pies, but we were told it would be an additional 40 minute wait, so we just ate it, but did not enjoy it at all. How you can over-cook pizza, when a customer orders lightly cooked, almost raw, is beyond me, plus they put the receipt right in the middle of our food!!! Can you imagine if it was a complicated order??? We will never order again!!! read more

McHugh's Pizza - two pizzas in boxes - Pizza Near Me - Brigantine, New Jersey

Would you pay 9 bucks for a BLT sub that looked like this? I don't even know if it was bacon? read more

McHugh's Pizza - A really gross BLT sub - Pizza Near Me - Brigantine, New Jersey

Overall, only average as we ordered pizza, burger, fries and a salad. While friendly and somewhat challenged when ordering, the order was wrong upon pickup. Many of the comments on other reviews were accurate, so the owner may benefit from reading and possibly addressing customer's concerns. Not the best, although certainly not the worst as food options are somewhat limited in Brigantine. Thanks for providing a later night food option! read more

This place is great - no clue what these other negative reviews are talking about. Friendly and timely service, though it is cash only. Unlike other pizza places that don't answer the phone, take forever, and can be very rude, McHughs is the opposite. It's great shore pizza and we will absolutely be back for an easy and reliable dinner! read more

We always order from here on our first night when we come down the shore. The pizza is really good, with sausage being one of our favorites. The vegetable stromboli is one of my favorites, full of gooey cheese, broccoli, onions, peppers and spinach in a soft crispy dough. Be forewarned - the large can feed like 4 people if not more! My kids love the mozzarella sticks and curly fires, which even during pickup and the drive home, don't come soggy. Cheesesteaks are also really yummy, but the salads are mostly full of lettuce, so I would't recommend ordering those if you're looking for a hearty salad. Even during the hectic summer season and Saturday check-ins, their wait times are reasonable and the orders have always come out right. Definitely one of our favorites on the island! read more

love their pizza. Got a large half pepperoni half plain yesterday. I'm sorry I didn't take a picture as it was picture perfect. we loved having it delivered during football and didn't miss a down. they have the best pizza on the island, it arrived hot quickly. We highly recommend their pizza along with the cheesestea. my favorite is with fried green peppers and wiz. read more

My wife and I live in South Carolina and spent the week in Brigantine. We were catching up with family because I was born and raised in south Jersey. My wife loves real Italian and Sicilian pizza from the north.So, one of the first things we did upon arrival is order Jersey Sicilian pizza. Quality was there, taste was not. Pizza, unfortunately, tasted like frozen food grocery pan pizza. We were sadly disappointed. We live in Columbia, SC and have only one place in the whole city that makes from scratch Sicilian pizza. Naturally, they are transplants from Brooklyn and have everything shipped down south, but their pizza is hands above what I had in my home state of Jersey. McHugh's is using quality ingredients but they might need to revisit recipe or the ovens they are using. I will be back but for the traditional Italian pie. read more

Primo is usually the family go-to in Brigantine especially for the pizza. Not a bad price for a pie at a shore location and it's always made just right. Sandwiches and salads are really good too. Service can take a bit long during the weekend so prepare for that and this place is old school and only takes cash. Remember to bring your cash before you arrive. IMO best place for a pie & sides on the island read more

McHugh's Pizza - Perfect pie. A bit crispy & a ton of flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Brigantine, New Jersey

Not sure if this place is under new ownership but the pizza is better. Stopped for a few slices for me and my kids as a snack...the plain slices were yummy and we gobbled them up. Crust was thin and mine tore apart when I tried taking a bite but overall a solid option on the island. read more

Great pizza great prices. When you ask for well done it's well done. When you ask for extra sauce you get it. And the pizza is always hot! Quickest delivery on the island! read more

I hate to say this....but not only one of the worst Shore pizzas I've ever had, but the WORST pizza I've had. The fries and mozzarella sticks were decent but we rented this place for week and please tell me Brigantine has better. read more

McHugh's Pizza served us delicious pizzas on Brigantine Island NJ. The casual beach ambience was perfect for us.

Omg worst pizza ever. I would never dare order again. The pizza was soggy and tasted sour. I think the cheese was rotting. The antipasto salad tasted like dirty lettuce. I just can't even. The food was a disaster read more

Thank you Brig Team! Awesome food, acceptable delivery time and fabulous delivery staff! Thank you Primo!! read more

Definitely not the definition of a good jersey pizza, however, it was decent. There aren't many pizza places on the island of Brigantine. It is on the pricier side and it is CASH ONLY. We call on a Saturday night for pickup, they said 30 minutes, it was a little faster than 30 minutes which was great. All the staff inside were very friendly. We ordered 2 pizzas, mozzarella sticks, and wings. Their wings were really good & the mozzarella sticks were decent. I would go back again for the convenience. They deliver as well! read more

PRIMO= Perfectly Regular Italian Meal Obviously The plain pie was perfectly regular and absolutely nothing to write home about. Thankfully it was just mediocre and not bad. Thankfully my husband read the menu, saw the spicy chicken pizza and got the idea to ask for a side of hot sauce. Thankfully we also asked for crushed red pepper and had garlic & oregano at home. There's definitely better pizza on the island and across the bridge in AC. This will do if needed though. read more

McHugh's Pizza - Large plain pie - Pizza Near Me - Brigantine, New Jersey

Service: I am not one to give neutral / bad reviews however the counter person (middle aged woman with black hair) was flat out nasty! Her attitude and mannerisms to the staff and customers is uncalled for. I hope for the sake of your staff that this is a family run business otherwise the turn over rate must be rather high. Food: While the plain pizza was good the Buffalo chicken pie was not. Each slice had less than 4 small pieces of chicken and a small drizzle of sauce. Pass read more

We were spending the day on Brigantine when hunger struck!!! Quick! What? Pizzzzzzzaaaaaaa!!!!! We ordered on the phone from this place not even knowing where they were and how their food would be. We were like.... surprise us.... it's just pizza. Well upon finding the place we noticed it looked pretty normal. Inside was a little surprise. Cash only. Whaaat? It's the 21st Century! ATM Available. Ohhhhhhh. Rip off! Note to self.... must remember to call IRS and alert them that there could potentially be hundreds of thousands of dollars in unreported income... except those that match the ATM log of course. Out of principle I rummaged through my glove compartment to find a few dollars. Pepperoni pizza is what we ordered and it was delicious!!! Way better than we get in Pennsylvania. I know... what do you expect. Would we go back? YES! But first the call to the IRS. read more

After having to ditch our first option for dinner for two families with five older teens combined, we selected McHugh's Primo. They should have been our first choice. Saturday night before 4th Of July so we know places will be crazy. They were very accommodating! Ordered two large pepperonis along with three hoagies and multiple salads. Plenty of food to satisfy two traveling families. Food and service was excellent! Will definitely go back or order take out!!! read more

Paying 8 dollars for a half assed cheesesteak. This is the worst cheesesteak on the island by far. read more

McHugh's Pizza - Paying 8 dollars for a half assed cheesesteak. This is the worst cheesesteak on the island by far. - Pizza Near Me - Brigantine, New Jersey

Disgusting place!!!!! A fat man what appears to be the owner, was coughing horribly!!!! People all around him were eating and he didn't apologize!!!! I had to get up with my family and leave. Also, noticed The cook used his bare hands to pick the onion rings and fry them!! Please don't eat here!!! Horrible !!!! read more

This place looks pretty basic but it's food will not disappoint! My family had a fully array off the menu-- salad for me... was fresh and delicious! Pizza for my little Bree was thin, crispy and had awesome sauce.. and the chicken and fries were on point. It was a great place for takeout on the way home from the beach! Enjoy friends! read more

Really good Sicilian pizza as well as old bay fries! However the mozzarella sticks and regular fries are ok. Will definitely order from here again next time I return! read more

Overpriced. Way way way overpriced for very generic pizza. The pizza was okay at best. The fries were soggy. Even doing a "special" we paid a lot of money. Not worth it. read more

We were staying in the area and stop by and picked up a pie. The pizza was good and they were nice enough to provided paper plates and toppings since we didn't have any of those in our room. It wasn't the best pizza ever but if you are in the area and want something quick and cheap this is a good place. read more

First off they answer their phone - PICK UP OR DELIVERY. Not hello, not Primo Pizza- just abrasively pick up or delivery. Very rude imo. The woman on the phone was rude and said the total and hung up. No good bye. They are cash only but don't tell you that over the phone - they have an ATM that only charges you .25. That's a plus so they earned a star back for that. I held the door for the woman who worked there and she stood in the door way yelling at her daughter while I held the door for her for an awkwardly long time (while I was holding my pizza) didn't say thank you. Again rude. The chicken parm hero was edible but nothing special but the pizza was burnt badly. I called and asked to speak to a manager and was put on hold and ultimately hung up on. Very poor customer service with okay food. I won't go back. read more

Excellent staff/service and great food, My favorite things I normally order are, a chicken cheesesteak and the Sicilian pizza. So good every time I order! read more

Made to order pizza fresh and hot! Great value too! Service is also great while we waited for our order, we saw the employees working very diligently and quickly. There seemed to an order to the dinner madness and it clearly shows how mgmt know how to run a perfect smooth business. Always happy to see an well-oiled machine run. read more

Ordered thick crust plain, completely tasteless. Even the dough had flavor at all. Won't go back

Excellent pie, extremely nice staff. My wife and I enjoyed the atmosphere and food. We were in town for the week and unfortunately found McHughs on our last night. Will definitely come back if we're in the area again. read more

ordered delivery on a saturday night and it was pretty decent. didn't take long but only takes cash. plain pizza was good but the mushrooms used on the pizza were kind of gross. all in all, not many good pickins during the off season for delivery and this was a decent option! read more

Love coming here after the beach, pizza is great. Super thin crunchy crust and perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Comes out super fast and the service is nice. Great prices too for being on an island. read more

Pizza was nothing to write home about. Fries were cold. We asked for cheese fries but got sweet potatoe fries. Cheesesteak seemed ok. Asked for fried onions on the side because I was sharing with my daughter who doesn't eat them. They gave me maybe 6 small strands. They need a better pizza place on this island read more

Ordered sausage pepper n onion pizza. Delivery was fast but If you want peppers and onions cooked on pizza with everything else I guess you have to tell them that. Dough was not what it used to be either. This is one of last places that always survived in Brigantine, but seems recipes have changed and pizza with all toppings cooked in it with everything else isn't the norm anymore either. read more

McHugh's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brigantine, New Jersey