If you're looking for a decent steak in the Eaton area, this is about it. I asked for my 'McCartys steak' medium rare and it came out exactly as requested. Couldn't finish it all, had to take some home. Sides are good and their salad bar is a welcome plus. Soups are hearty with the ingredients-not thin gruel. Drinks are generous pours. The servers and bartenders are friendly and attentive. Crowd is a comfortable mix of golfers and non-golfers. Will return to try their prime rib, burgers, perhaps some fish as well. The one thing they might consider doing is expand their draft beer selection to include something dark and local. read more

I'm writing to follow up on a dining experience at McCarty's in Eaton on July 27, 2026, at 11:25 AM (Table 17). During my visit, I signed up for the rewards program. Since my server, Jennifer S., used a paper bill instead of a POS device, I provided my phone number on the receipt for her to enter manually. Unfortunately, these points have not been credited to my account. I reached out to the team via email at mccartys39ecc@gmail.com on July 30, but I have yet to receive a response. I would appreciate it if someone could look into this and help me get my rewards points updated. read more

Always enjoy the food at McCarty's. I have the cowboy burger in most cases. Best burger anywhere. Fish and chips are pretty good too. Would definitely recommend McCartney's. read more

Great service. Food is well prepared. Our server was attentive not intrusive and a lot of fun

Stopped in and had Apple Pie a la mode it was awesome never had one like that in my life. On top of that service was great really love that place read more

One of the "owners " so he said,was rude and very unprofessional . He talked down to a customer. The food wasn't as good as previous times I visited. read more

McCarty's was exactly what I would expect for a public country club in a rural area. Cute and quaint with friendly service and food that was good enough. The brussels sprouts were dry but had good flavor. The cheese curds were the typical cubed, baked cheese curds that you find at most restaurants with cheese curds on their menu in northern Colorado right now. If I'm in the area, I would go again to try more food. read more

I've been here several times and the food is typically very good. However, everything about their gyro special I had this week was disappointing. The meat, the tzatziki sauce, the overall flavor was a let down. I suggest not trying to improve it but simply replacing it. read more

Alissa C. was our server today, as usual friendly, professional and top shelf attentiveness and care. Food was great, always a good environment. Don't miss a chance to visit the first time or circle back. read more

Ordered the shrimp flatbread pizza. Pretty good. Service was good but a little slow to get our initial order. Nice ambiance, country music playing and people chatting for a late Wednesday lunch. read more

McCarty's - Blackened Shrimp Flatbread Pizza with side salad - Bars Near Me - Eaton, Colorado

See all

I use to be a regular here because the food was amazing. But the last 3 times I've been in for a steak it wasn't cooked right and they forgot part of my order. Really wish they would get back to how they use to be!!! read more

Very decent Eastern plains Restaurant with an amazing salad bar. Great homemade food. Super servers. read more

McCarty's - Yummy salad bar. - Bars Near Me - Eaton, Colorado

Good food great service. Nice menu. Reasonable prices. Worth the drive. The views of the golf course are good.

Always good food. Awesome soup and salad bar. Clean and welcoming! Wait staff is always friendly!

Great food and people Diverse menu options as well as specials Great views Don't pass it up. read more

This spot is a gem! Great food and fantastic service! Between the pot roast, french dip, burger and another sandwich, all were served hot and by great service. The salad bar, although basic, was fresh, clean and a fine addition to the meal! Well done! The manager was checking with everyone, helping clear tables, and it was nice to see quality service. We will be back, all the way from the Denver metro area, with more famiily next time! read more

Typically have had good experience. Had been a somewhat regular diner at this restaurant...but the last two occasions have been "spotty" with the last one just pathetic, my Southwest Chicken Wrap was so dry...the SW Ranch Dressing and guacamole were missing with nothing but the wrap cut in half on the plate! No garnish of any sort and no ramekins with the SW Ranch Dressing or Guacamole...just a bare plate. Fortunately my wife's Prime Rib was excellent and we ordered a Salad Bar and order of Fried Calamari which gave me enough good food. read more

Rylie was amazing! She took very good care of us, and paid attention to every detail! Prime rib was great! Brussels Sprouts fantastic What a gem to find !!!! I love the folks in this town of Eaton Colorado A wonderful break from portland read more

Linda C. Greeley we went for lunch on 12/26/2022 . prices were ok but wait staff was not properly trained. Also, in the 1 1/2 hours we were there not once was the salad bar attended and / or cleaned up. We had to ask for the dinner rolls to be restocked. The dinner rolls were not warmed and cold from the refrigerator. read more

We absolutely LOVE this place!!!! Daniel and his staff are always pleasant and on it. The food is amazing and the specials are on point for the time of year, cold or hot. They are so supportive of our community and always available for us to host fundraisers for any sport. We could not be more grateful to have them be a part of this community! read more

Good food, good service and excellent prices!! Can't do much better than that! Make sure to look at daily specials when you come in.

Best place in Eaton! Regular menu items are consistently good with specials adding delicious variety. Prices are refreshingly fair. Service is always attentive. read more

This place has a terrible women working for them. We came in for breakfast and drinks. Waited 20 minutes to even see her. She never greeted us. I got my own water for her to walk away without asking if we needed anything. Another guy at the bar told her to take care of us before him because he's been there and has his food and drink. For her to just make him another drink and ignore us again. A group of people had a room catered for them with no plates to eat from. She was annoyed when they asked for plates so they could eat. To then again walk away from us. This was a terrible experience and will never come back!! The guy at the bar even apologized to us as we left. read more

I have been coming to McCarty's for years and always have a great time! The prime rib and daily specials are not only delicious but also budget friendly! The salad bar is my favorite! The wait staff and management team work together to make every thing run efficiently, even when they are super busy! read more

Delicious! Affordable!!!! And incredible staff! Best restaurant in Eaton! I love this place and the staff!!!!

This was my first time eating here. I work up in the area a couple days a week and finally decided to try it on my way home. Food was excellent and beer was cold! Will definitely be going back and add it as a usual on my list. read more

We had dinner here last Friday and it was excellent! The wait staff is very good, the salad bar is one of the best around and our meals were served hot and timely. We all had steak and salad bar. All of our steaks were cooked exactly the way we ordered them. It's one of our favorite places now! It's on the golf coarse so its beautiful and has a beautiful view of the mountains. It has a great patio and the prices are so reasonable. I definately recommend! Check the menue as it changes from day to day. They have lunch and dinner specials. read more

This is my go-to place to eat .... I have never been disappointed with the food. The steak sandwich is delicious as well as the burgers, salads, fries ... I could go on. I love the specials they offer!!!! The place could use an update, especially the booths and tables :) but that doesn't stop me from enjoying a great meal!!! read more

They really need to update there website. I was really excited to try this place. However it was a huge let down No Sunday brunch buffet. However the website said they do one. Our server really needed some training. I ordered a breakfast sandwich and she said it came with toast and then came back and asked me if I still wanted it and it didn't come with my meal. The breakfast sandwich was very dry. This place was a huge letdown. read more