Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    McCarthy Tire Service

    1.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Services - McCarthy Tire Service

    Auto wheel and tire repair

    Tire balancing

    Tire installation

    4 More Services

    Tire repair

    Tire retreading

    Tire rotation

    Wheel alignment

    McCarthy Tire Service Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - McCarthy Tire Service

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Brought my truck in for a couple of tires. When I picked it up 3 studs had stripped threads and couldn't put the nuts on.

    Business owner information

    Photo of Colleen C.

    Colleen C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - McCarthy Tire Service

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Tires 1,772 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Joe Basil Chevrolet

    Joe Basil Chevrolet

    (118 reviews)

    I took my car in for the scheduled maintenance and started talking to my salesman I worked with…read morebefore on options for when my lease was coming up. I had no intention of getting into something new now but after test driving and making sure it worked within my budget, that's what happened. I ended up in a new lease for only a couple dollars more a month in something that was a little bit bigger for the family but also more efficient. I am looking at my past review from here and I am writing this one week short of two years since my last review, which makes sense! After excellent service here for my last two cars, I will be going back to the same salesman at Joe Basil for my next car too.

    My daughter was looking to buy a new vehicle and went shopping around on a Sunday so she can view…read morethem in private 1st then checked online a little further before I went with her to test drive a couple Chevy Trax's we had a nice person named Tyler help us since my daughter came prepared with questions Tyler gave her good answers and if he didn't know he looked it up for her. She came back with her father to help her make the deal on the one she wanted and I was with her while they helped her get the the plates do an oil change all the details it takes to purchase a new vehicle. She was being helped by Tyler all day and finally at 6 o clock she drove away with her 2024 Trax had great service and a great salesman thank you Tyler for all the help and spending the whole day helping my daughter get on the way with a new vehicle! Everyone at Basil are friendly helpful and are there to see you have a great experience!

    Dunn Tire - Waiting room

    Dunn Tire

    (27 reviews)

    Purchased another set of tires last year and just got a screw in one. Was able to take advantage…read moreof their free repair service! I figured I'd update my review because the purchase of the newest tires and this service visit were both good. It's invaluable to have free repairs and the other perks of buying from Dunn. Unless I find a killer deal elsewhere this will continue to be my go to tire shop.

    Back at the beginning of December I went in to get a seasonal tire changeover. My appointment was…read moreat 4pm and I didn't get out until 6:15pm or so. Annoying but I understand they're busy at the end of the day when folks get out of work to take their car there. After leaving and driving all of 5 miles (and picking up my mom to go to a concert), my rear driver tire was flat. Pulled over and changed the tire. Already I planned on returning the next morning for a refund or some sort of compensation. At this point it was too late to go to the concert (also due to the fact that the appointment took over 2hrs) so we decide to go get dinner in east aurora. Hesitantly, I get on the 400 and after about 30 seconds of driving on the thruway, second flat tire, this time it was my rear passenger tire. Called roadside assistance and waited 2hrs on the side of the 400 at night in December. When roadside arrived, I realized my front passenger tire was also flat. Roadside took us back to the Union rd Dunn Tire location. Thank god the first tire went on a 30mph road and the second and third tires went while speeding up, not when I was at full speed. If I had been well on the thruway doing 70 and both tires went at once? Myself and my mother could have been seriously hurt or worse. The tires, upon closer inspection, were not attached to the wheels properly so when I turned my vehicle they started to slip off. Unbelievable negligence. I went in there the next morning and had the manager look at my car. He took it in and redid all of the tires as well as replaced the two rear tires. His explanation was that the valve stems were not replaced properly, which frankly I think is bullshit and I guess a better sounding excuse than "yeah my employee didn't properly install tires at a shop called dunn TIRE". He was apologetic and offered a full refund. I don't remember his name but he was good. Whoever worked on my vehicle should never touch one again, and after escalating this with a DM via email, I eventually stopped hearing back. I can't stress enough how much worse this could have been. Maybe this place shouldn't hire a bunch of 20 something year olds that skipped steps in their job bc they wanted to leave on time on a Friday night. Do not go to this location. It was my first time after only going to the McKinley pkwy location prior. Absolutely do not let those people do anything to your car.

    McCarthy Tire Service - tires - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...