We couldn't resist returning to the lovely landscape of McCall Vineyard for their final Burger night of the season. The crisp autumn air on a gorgeous sunny day did not disappoint. Our delicious grass fed burgers from their farm were perfect. Our glasses of Reserve Chardonnay were a lovely accompaniment, we took a bottle home, and also bottles of their Reserve Merlot and Pinot Noir. A Day to remember. See you next year. Thank you! read more

See all

Burger night is a must at this winery. We went the first Friday of October and it was perfect and pretty popular! No problem getting a table. We had a glass of Ben's Blend and a glass of the Reserve Pinot Noir to pair with our burgers- both were delicious! The Pinot was maybe more cherry. Sadly they ran out of chocolate chip cookies the night we were there read more

We arrived an hour before closing last Saturday and were greeted by both servers with grumpy faces and poor attitudes...almost felt like they didn't want us there. We were able to get a glass of wine and were very respectful of their closing time. I have been here multiple times and even made a trip out there from Connecticut three weeks earlier for a case of wine which I really like. If you don't want customers then let people know that directly rather than through grumpy faces! read more

Other wineries recommend McCall for Pinot Noir, and rightly so. Nicola took such good care of us. We'll we back. read more

See all

I was in Long Island. Weather was not particularly nice. Figured it would be a good day for the wineries. When i got there. The weather broke and it turned out to be a nice day. Went to McCall several years ago. I liked it. Nice place. Super chill. Got a prosciutto platter and some artisan bread. A flight of white wines. Ended up loving one and bought a few bottles. Service was super friendly. Prices were fair. Good experience read more

McCall Wines - Prosciutto platter - Wineries Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

We've been to McCall's dozens of times. Most recently we did Thursday burger night. It was completely awesome. We've been coming to the North Fork wineries for 25 years. McCalls has the best reds, One Woman has the best whites. Period! Also, they have the best tasting rooms. read more

This is a review for McCall's burger night! They offer burger night through Columbus Day weekend each year on Thursday & Fridays 4-8pm. The beef for the burgers is from their own cows, paired with amazing French fries and you can add chocolate chip cookies. All of it comes from a little food truck on the property and is absolutely amazing! Reservations are highly recommended, and definitely bring bug spray because seating is outside! This was our 3rd year doing burger night at McCall's and we will definitely be back again in the future! read more

See all

This is definitely in my top 3 wineries out in Long Island. Such a gem with so many positive things to say! Came here on a whim on the 4th of July after we visited a winery directly across the way. This winery is a sustainably farmed vineyard and cattle ranch. They have beautiful indoor and outdoor seating. Rocking chairs and picnic tables on the outside along with old stables fashioned into seating areas. It's so cute! Although it can get stuffy in warmer weather. They have a little trailer outside that makes burgers, erc. some nights. Definitely make a reservation for that. Otherwise, one really isn't necessary for a small group. The owners and staff are all so pleasant and sweet! Especially the one male owner from Spain. Wish I remembered his name. He was so kind, informative, and friendly. I had the summer flight for I believe $25. 4 of the best wines I had that day. Crisp and refreshing. They came in 4 mini carafes. Also had the ciabatta with oil for dipping and the prosciutto with breadsticks. The prosciutto was melt in your mouth delicious. Bread was warm and tender. Upon entry inside to pay, they have a bar, indoor booths, a tasting room, and a store where you can buy their butchered products! They also make and sell their own Bourbon. I bought a 4 pack of their burgers, and he gave me a pack of their bone marrow for free! So generous. They were probably some of the best burgers I've ever had. The bone marrow was out of this world, too! Had a great experience coming here. Can't wait to return! read more

See all

Cozy spot with lots of picnic tables to chill at. The tasting room is an old barn. Very cool. There are even stalls to sit in if you have a group! The staff was super friendly! It was great chatting with the father and daughter. I grabbed the Pinot flight. Really good. I liked all 3. Deb had the summer flight. This was good as well. I really liked the rose. We also had a warm baguette. Really good bread. Perfect with the wine. Overall a really great spot to relax and enjoy some good wine. read more

See all

Decided to give this place another try 3 years after our first disappointment. Same exact thing happened. We were asked to sit outside and wait for a server. 30 minutes later, ignored we walked out. Never again. read more

My new favorite vineyard. The grounds are beautiful. The stable where they have seating is historic. The wines are great. The staff is amazing. The cheese boards are phenomenal. Love when they have burgers after 5 PM in the summers. read more

During our winery tour of the North Fork we happened upon McCall and it was a terrific call! Everything here was just perfect and right up our alley. We took a stall spot in the open air tasting room which looks like like converted barn. Loved the rustic look and vibe of this place. Picnic table seating outside across the vinyards and around the barn. Nice setting to enjoy some wine tasting. Our server was awesome. He made us feel so welcomed, and spoke with us like we were old friends. He was very knowledgeable about the wines here, the history of the place, and also gave suggestions on the wines. He steered us right! This place has won many awards for their wines and we could tell why. The reds, whites, and roses were delicious. Nice generous amounts with the flights too. Along with a terrific charcuterie board and items to nosh on this was a wonderful experience. They also have a private cattle ranch and sell premium cuts of beef here along with other food and souvenir items. It's a family owned and operated business, and they make it's patrons feel like part of the family. Can't wait to come back here for more wine as the bottles we bought home are empty! read more

See all

This winery on the North Fork of Long Island was one of my parent's favorites. We were out there this past weekend for a family event and decided to stop in. I have had their wines in the past but never visited the winery even though we have been out this way frequently over the years. To start off, you need to pay close attention finding the entrance when coming out here. It's marked but, you can easily miss it. A turnaround opportunity is far down the road. Also, this is a rural road which winds and turns and traffic on a weekend can be heavy. The setting is really peaceful and rustic. We decided to sit outside and had a sampler of their Autumn and Red wines, which are also for sale by the bottle. You can get flight of three for between $20.00 - $25.00. It's pricey but the wines they make here are some of the best here on the North Fork. It was quiet on Saturday afternoon but there were customers coming in and out. There is ample parking on site. I remember sampling the Pinot Noir, Cabernet Franc and one of their Library wines. All were really good. My wife had the Autumn sampler which had a rose and two white wines (Marjorie's and ?). They all had a nice, light and earthy flavor to them. We also had a charcuterie cheese board to go with it. We had a really nice time. And forgive me, I forgot to take a picture of the wines we had. The wine prices range from $24 - $189 depending on the size, year and varietal. They also can ship to your state if your state allows that. There is a burger trailer on site that serves burgers after 4pm. A burger plate with fries runs about $15. Definitely check this winery out if you are visiting the North Fork of the island. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

So lovely, delicious, and very accommodating! You can easily make a reservation for an outdoor picnic table online, and even though we were running late and arrived at 5:30, they served us and let us hang out and finish eating/drinking past their 6pm close time. We got two flights and especially liked the Summer Flight, with the rosé and sav blanc as stand-outs. We noshed on a great cheese & charcuterie platter and really enjoyed the vineyard views and laid back vibes. I so appreciate the folks at McCall and highly recommend to anyone who will be in the area. If I didn't have to hop on a flight, I would've taken a bottle of rosé home to remind us of our GRAPE experience! read more

See all

What a great little Vinyard off of Main road. We are members of pelligrini across the street but decided to try this place first this past weekend. The grounds are set back off the road and has a very rustic barn vibe which is cool. The actual bar is set inside of a barn and has a few indoor tables between some old stalls. The wine is pretty good with my favorite being the Ben's blend, which they only bottle during premium summers. The merlot was nice as well and not to heavy. They also have their own cattle and meat for sale which is pretty cool. A little expensive but you can't get any fresher. Cheers. read more

McCall Wines - Wineries Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

What a beautiful space! My husband arrived, with a reservation, and we were so delighted to have the entire winery to ourselves for a while. How neat that it is an old barn! Our host was a lovely woman who eloquently explained each wine in our (2) flights. She was thorough, polite, and personable. The wines are good; we enjoyed them all, and they were generous pours for a flight. We also ordered a cheese plate, which was beautiful. A brie, a hard cheese with a lavender espresso edible rind (so good!), and a cheddar. They were served with light crackers and pepperoni. This was a beautiful way to start our day! Thank you, McCall! read more

See all

Oh McCall, you got the stuff but you just don't know how to deliver it. I was excited to come here because of the reviews and that my choice to come here was validated by another vineyard owner. The grounds was certainly nothing to write home about. There were wooden picnic table randomly on a field with no cover and a few that were. The reservation process was extremely easy and that was fortunate because I had to move it a few times. And the Cabrenet Franc was absolutely fantastic. But the good news stops there and I unfortunately have to agree with some of the yelper comments on the service. They were not friendly at all (three elderly women). I tried to engage in a conversation a few times, but only received one word answers and was snarky. They just seemed pissed off for some reason and I thought that a winery that lacks character (polo themed), or ambiance (picnic tables), they would have at least have great service to make up for it. But sadly no. I am a fan of the wine, and will become a customer, I just wouldn't go back to the vineyard again. It didn't affect me but if you do have a party of 7, it is mandated to pay at least $40 a person. A ridiculous price when a flight only costs $25 read more

Read one of the bad reviews and I have to totally disagree with them. I lovvvveeedddd McCall Wines. I brought my friend from the Isle of Man here and we were blown away by the beauty of the space as well as the quality of the wines. The server was prompt and very nice. This is my favorite winery on Long Island and I have been to most of them. The vibe: classy yet chill. I will definitely be back, and I will be telling everyone this is the best winery on Long Island. read more

Very nice spot w beautiful cows in the back. The wine was nice, especially the whites which are much better than the reds on Long Island. Cool little tasting room w very nice outside area. read more

McCall Wines - Wineries Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

Waited 20 minutes when there were maybe 5 tables filled. Asked kindly where to receive service and they rolled their eyes and said table service. We left. No chance I will spend my money with someone so entitled! read more

For my second birthday wine tasting adventure, we stopped at McCall and enjoyed a selection of wines in the rustic converted horse stall. Excellent wines and a great experience. My fave was the elegant Field Blend red, which I purchased a bottle of. read more

See all

Review pre covid: Bottom line: beautiful grounds. Flavorful wines. Gluten line: my wife thanks God daily that wine is gluten free. No available GF snacks though. Long line: stopped here shortly and enjoyed the suggested sampling. Normal price for the area. Wines were on par with region and well balanced. We enjoyed ourselves but didn't feel compelled to buy a bottle to go. To be fair, this was just the first stop in a tour. Would go back if in the area and recommend a stop. read more

See all

Very local small winery on the North Fork. Not really for the wine touring yahoos that hit up the North Fork with their bachelor and bachelorette parties. Indoor and outdoor tables. The outdoor picnic tables are set up under some old trees...good shade against the summer sun. The food is limited but pleasant enough. Service was quick and friendly. The Pinot Noir is the wine to order. Pretty good for a Long Island wine. read more

Beautiful place. Service was beautiful. Our server was very nice. Has well knowledge on different wines that they had. Would def be back again. read more

McCall Wines - Our wonderful hostess - Wineries Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

Nice Long Island winery. Not much of a structure but probably one of the best wines from Long Island

Great wine, great service, definitely will come back. Their wine is good, specially the reds if you are a red wine person. read more

McCall Wines - Wineries Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

The best wines on the east end. Russ and his family are producing beautiful wines and preserving countless acres that will never be developed. Their Thursday and Friday burger nights featuring their grass fed Charlois and Wagyu cattle are divine. Great staff! Big fan! read more

I'm so, so glad we decided to pop into McCall Wines on our brief trip out east- of all the vineyards we visited yesterday, this one was unanimously the favorite among a group of four of us. The short: this was the perfect vineyard for a fall day. Highly recommend. The longer: The property is beautiful. It's expansive, and there's an adorable, well decorated barn, tons of outdoor picnic tables, and tons of area for walking (we saw a guy & his dog taking a stroll). There's also a huge wine selection at a variety of price points. There's an awesome wine reserve list, and a selection of more affordable bottles. We opted for the Pinot Noir, as they explained they're one of the few vineyards in the area who make that grape. It was light & flavorful, and so good I took a bottle home for my parents. They gave us a taste of the merlot, too, and that was a great, fuller bodied wine. We also shared the cheese platter. It had cheddar, Brie, Gruyere and a ton of crackers. For $15 you get A LOT of cheese. I can't wait to come back in the winter and experience the cozy barn's fireplace! read more

McCall Wines - Cheese selection ($15) - Wineries Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

See all

Stopped by one afternoon to buy some meat from their grass fed Charolais cattle. It was a little awkward walking into the tasting room like a family meeting happening. They looked up from what they were doing and just stared at us. I asked if they were open and they said yes. I asked if they had any meat for sale and they said yes. A woman walked over to the wine tasting area and asked if we would like to do a wine tasting, I said no we want the meat. She then brought us to the back room where they freeze different cuts of meat. She was not too knowledgeable about the cuts of beef and in fact does not even eat there own beef. We picked a cut of meat and she asked us again if we wanted to do a wine tasting. Once again, no lady just the beef! I like the fact that they respect the land and worked with the Peconic land trust and preserved over 20 acres of land that would have been developed. It's also has a rustic feel to it a much different experience than other vineyards. They do have some very good wines that I tasted at area restaurants. Someday I'll go back and give it another chance. read more

See all

This is one of my favorite North Fork wineries. Four reasons why: 1. Funky and delicious pinot noir. As good as it gets around here. 2. They've got the friendliest of horses. Almost too friendly. In fact, they might try and make out with you...but don't be that guy (Drew*). They are horses, and they don't know any better. 3. Katie, the down-to-earth, fun and friendly host who pours tasty vino, tells you how it is, and shares fun facts about how barnacles are the most well-endowed animals out there (proportionally). 4. This winery is as fun in the winter as it is in the summer. Whether you're hanging out in the barn with a fireplace heater, or at the picnic tables outside with an occasional horse makeout session, it's all good. _______________ *Don't believe me? Here: https://vimeo.com/132388311 read more

McCall Wines - Wineries Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

This is wholly NOT big, corporate, shiny or loud. It's the ultimate opposite. From the unobtrusive barn, laid back setting, to the stables turned into intimate private tastings & shaking Frank McCall's hand & conversing w him over his wines....I loved everything about the whole experience. Nothing contrived about this winery which makes it all the more appealing. Awards: http://www.newyorkwines.org/NYGold Stand outs based on that day's tasting option: The 09 Merlo reserve & the 2013 Sauvignon Blanc were my favorites. Suggested: you & significant other or an intimate group of your most relaxed friends, grab a picnic table on the lawn w a view of the tasting room, little veggie & herb garden, vineyards, & horses and savor a bottle together under the trees. Small parking, no food. Didn't see a restroom either. read more

See all

I find there are few places you can go to both taste wines and feed cattle, all in one, fluid, sweeping motion. McCall is a must-stop when I find myself tasting in the area; my preference has shifted towards (and seemingly settled at) their (below-mentioned) Estate Pinot Noir. Not that their other reds aren't good, they are - but a glass of the Estate is all I need. I usually bring a bottle back for my Dad ($49) who is a connoisseur of all things pinot, and he loves it as much (maybe more) than I do. The tasting room is in a cool looking barn, there is seating inside and out, and there are usually some cows grazing a few hundred steps more away from the main road that you can walk up to, chat with, and feed. Another must-stop for a day of tasting on LI. read more

See all

This is a rustic simple experience - a farm with incredible wines. That's what a tasting room should be in my opinion; all about tasting wines. Authentic, estate grown and sustainable wines, the best we had all week. Don't expect air conditioning or music or anything like that. 10/10 read more

This was the second winery we visited during the Vintage Tours. It is a lovely, quaint winery, and they have been growing and sellig mainly Pinot Noir and Merlot since the mid 90s. When we arrived, the owner, Russ, came out to greet us and tell us a bit about his wines, winery, and ranch. Yes, they have a ranch here as well! He told us we could walk over to see the cows if we wanted to. Their winery have a very cute and unique look: cute barn and large yard with picnic tables, therefore comes with plenty of outdoor seating. But, if you prefer to sit inside, or if it happens to be a rainy day, there are plenty of seats inside this barn. We got to taste Sauvignon Blanc, Marjorie's Rosé, and Cabernet Franc Reserve. They were clean, crisp, and refreshing. Next to their vineyards were very white cows. They raise these cows completely organic, grass fed, and natural. (And I believe you can buy the meat addition to their wines) Overall, this one very interesting and fun tour of vineyards. Jo Ann of Vintage Tours made sure we will have a relaxing time here, and we did certainly enjoyed our time here. read more

See all

Unimpressed with McCall. Feels like you're sitting in a horse barn trying wines. Too much Chardonnay on their flight choices. They serve your flight in Little spurts which I did not like. The server brings one glass and pours and leaves and few minutes later comes back and pours another. Seems disconnected. I like All served at once so you can compare them. It's very quiet and feels like you have to whisper. We did like the Sauvignon blanc and bought a bottle to go. I believe it was $24 a bottle. It was the best out of our white flight. The ladies working were perfectly nice and explained the wines. Just missing the ambience and feel I enjoy in a winery tasting area. read more

Without a doubt one of my favorite wineries on the East End. Coming here is nothing less than the total wine tasting experience, great wine in a great environment. Russ McCall is is just a delightful person who loves to speak about his wines and ranch. They also raise grass fed cattle here. I'll make this easy... Try everything when you're here, reds, whites, blends they're all spectacular... I will say that I am partial to the Pinot Noirs and Ben's Blend. Katie, the tasting room manager is a terrific person who can help you through the "McCall Wine Tasting Experience." Come and prepared to sit and relax for a while in the absolutely beautiful Wine Experience. read more

See all

I highly recommend this gem. The service was excellent, the view beautiful & the cheese was the best I've ever tasted. The wine was delicious. I was worried it would be out of our price range, but the prices are reasonable. Make a reservation to guarantee seating at one of their lovely outdoor picnic tables. read more

McCall Wines - Tasting & cheese plate. - Wineries Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

I was there recently and while I did enjoy the Chardonnay reserve me and my daughter ordered I was very disappointed that I could not get my burger well done, the waitress told me that the cows are grass fed , didn't make any sense to me, when I received my burger , it was too pink for my liking, I feel if you pay good money for a burger it should be to your liking. I hope they change their policy on their burgers , because if I can't get it we'll done I will not eat their. read more

We visited because another Yelper said this was their favorite vineyard and I have to agree! Deff Visit! The wine is really good and order a cheese platter! The views are amazing and it feels like your hanging out in your families backyard that just so happens to have a wine bar. My favorite part was the kid at the register was really cool. He's a young kid. I think his name was Christian. Super nice, really knowledgable and personable. There was another lady there but I guess since we're young she wasn't too happy to see us. We were looking for food and since they don't serve anything besides cheese we were kind of bummed. But he suggested we hang out and wait for a food truck that was coming that made really good burgers. Super nice of him. The food truck made the best burger I've ever had! It's naturally grazed so the burger tastes so clean and juicy. It was a wonderful experience and I'd take everyone I know. read more

See all

I could write a novel on my love for Russ and Niki McCall, and everything they're doing. It's one of my two favorite wineries on the North Fork and his Pinot Noirs are the best that you'll find - they compete and many times beat my favorite Willamette Pinots, and are very close to many of my favorite Burgundian Pinots as well. Make sure you visit McCall Winery and Ranch - you will be very happy that you did. If you see Russ or Niki, tell them I sent ya! If you have a large group 6+, you should make reservations... THIS has been a review by Gaurav read more