Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mcartney Property Management

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 8:00 am - 6:00 pm

    Services - Mcartney Property Management

    Property management

    Mcartney Property Management Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mcartney Property Management

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mcartney Property Management

    You might also consider

    Central Florida Property Management - Police report for theft

    Central Florida Property Management

    (62 reviews)

    Colonialtown South

    I have been working with Daniela for two years. She has been great getting my properties rented…read more She is very professional and the communication is top notch. The reporting keeps everything simple and payments are on time. I highly recommend them if you want a smooth and simple process.

    I will not be able to recommend this management company to anyone in the future…read more I engaged Peggy for tenant placement services based on a referral from my agent, who assisted me in purchasing my first investment property in Orlando, as I reside out of state. My unit remained vacant for three months without a tenant or any discernible progress. My calls went unanswered, and I had to repeatedly contact her via text messages, to which she would typically respond two days later. When I brought my concerns to upper management, she attempted to rectify the situation, but unfortunately, it was beyond repair. Ultimately, I had to terminate the agreement. I then engaged a management company that proved to be exceptionally proactive and communicative. They successfully identified a new tenant within a week, and the tenant moved in the following week. It is truly regrettable to operate and work in such circumstances when one cannot conduct business professionally. I have unfortunately expended my time and resources by placing my trust in a central Florida management company that proved to be untrustworthy.

    The Realty Medics

    The Realty Medics

    (113 reviews)

    East Orlando

    As an investor living in Texas, I wanted to find a property management company I could trust. I…read moredid a lot of research and narrowed down my search to a few different companies to call. Jason answered all of my questions about The Realty Medics and their services and we decided to work with them. Once we signed the agreement I dealt with Emi and she was extremely friendly and helpful with getting our property setup in their systems. Once the property was listed they quickly found a qualified tenant and I was assigned my account manager, Eva. Eva is fantastic at communicating with me the few times there were issues with the property. She also conducted a market analysis when it was time for the tenants to renew their lease. My experience with The Realty Medics has really given me comfort knowing my investment property is taken care of well and that my husband and I do not need to worry about this aspect of our retirement plan. I would recommend The Realty Medics to anyone who is searching for a professional property management company to take care of their investment. Debbie Kofler Kaufman, TX

    Horrific experience. Prospective House had squatters ( not their fault) followed up with them…read morefrequently to see when we can go see the house after they kicked squatters out and repaired the damages. Once applied , the person dodged our calls and emails after taking our application fees for weeks and then finally said "oh someone else applied and it's pending". No one else applied before we did , the manager dragged their feet for weeks after 27 phone calls and 8 emails. I look forward to their response on this one with some altered fabrication of Reality.

    Alfano Property Management - Find out what great service can be.

    Alfano Property Management

    (3 reviews)

    Millenia

    These people are a scam there's nothing professional about this company once you don't have their…read moremoney they will kick you out of their house I understand it's a contract written but they surely don't care about their tenants if I can give them a Zero review I would they're a joke keep away from this stupid ass company I wouldn't recommend this company not even to my worst enemy as I said before they do not care about nobody but themselves and their pockets run away from this company get you another professional company to rent from

    From the beginning I felt like the property manager, Nick, had no issues rejecting your application…read moreif you did not meet immediate expectations for being a tenant. He does not speak on the phone, but feels comforted texting all the necessary information rather than speaking like adults. From when you first apply, the application process takes until you contact them for a viewing the property to even be considered for the property. I had to wait a week to figure this out. Once you tour, they hassle you to get in all your verification information in 3 DAYS or they deny you. Once you scramble like a chicken to get this information by THEIR timing, you still have the option of being denied, EVEN WITH A COSIGNOR, even after all your applications fees, even after your HOA fees, and even after your security deposit. THE ONLY QUALIFICATION THAT I DID NOT MEET, WAS CREDIT, WHICH IS WHY I REQUIRE A COSIGNOR. I wasn't notified about the rejection until I got to the HOA approval process, from which I was notified I cannot be approved because I have a cosignor. I wish this information was granted BEFORE I applied to Alfano Property Management and BEFORE all the required fees they made me pay. On top of that, they don't even know the facility companies who run the associations on their property, falsely providing information that is not relevant to the current tenant. All this to say that if you don't have a 750 credit score when applying to Alfano Property management, don't bother because they treat you like an orphan who can't get adopted. This manner is timely and I have wasted an entire month dealing with this management company. The only professional I spoke to was Dominic, the owner of the company.

    Elite Management & Leasing

    Elite Management & Leasing

    (8 reviews)

    Millenia

    I left 1 start because theres not a 0 star option. I would…read morelike to start with this. I was in the Army for about 10 years and I dealt with plenty of property managers and this by far the WORSE experience ever. to the point that I dont want to deal with property managers ever again. Kim You charged me for stuff I know for a fact you don't do. You charged for seeds for the grass that grass was trash when I moved there. And still treat it but that grass was already trash there's No seed that can repair that nasty grass. You also charged me for "cleaning" when I got the house that house was nasty and dirty, I sent photos I have proof the carpet was trash the house is trash just like you do business trashy if we can even call that a business very unprofessional and cheap property management. You Kim, you are very cheap and very unprofessional You Don't even have a place to take care of clients thats how cheap you are. I'll make sure at least 100 customers don't go your way. I promised that. Please run AWAY from this SCAM property manager they will do anything within their power to retain your deposit money without any reason.

    I seen a rental home that I liked on trulia.com and was contacted by Kim Cochrane to schedule a…read moretour for the home on elitepropertymanagement.com while browsing their site I seen another home that I loved even more and scheduled a tour. Along came my 18 year old nephew and my 9 month old son. Before going into the home, Kim Cochrane states "Do you want to leave the baby outside with him? (My nephew) People usually don't bring their babies." Very rude and first red flag. Families go to see homes together all the time? Second red flag I was rushed through the tour after 10minutes of looking around she turns off all the lights and locks the doors. I had to ask her to reopen so that I can at least get a video. I leave her with the $60 money order for the application and $2095 personal check deposit to put the house on hold. I get home and apply for the beautiful home. So, she calls me the following day and tells me I didn't get approved for the house. She said it's bcuz they "can't verify where my income is coming from" (her exact words) MEANWHILE I provided her with business bank statements as well as personal bank statements all going back 6 months and two years worth of tax returns LOL I asked her what else can I provide her with she tells me "the answer is just no" she's a joke! I'll keep looking that place wasn't meant for me. Edit: She just commented some excuse about "policy" lol if that is the supposedly policy Kim, why was it not mentioned prior to showing? Or at showing? Btw her demeanor has completely changed now that the public is watching. She was extremely rude in person as well as over the phone. I even called my family and friends after because I was just in shock at how rude she was. We definitely will not be going through this company being that she's the "owner" BEWARE!

    407 Properties

    407 Properties

    (9 reviews)

    Uptown, Lake Eola Heights

    For those that don't know, 407 is a sister company to Central Florida Property Management, which is…read moreanother fantastic firm. Both are headed up by Steve Simpson, but I will focus my discussion on my realtor, Peggy, whom was fantastic throughout the process of selling my rental property. Offering a wealth of knowledge and skill, she did a fantastic job of diligently working with me to explain every step of the way, without being overbearing or pressuring me. She advised me on the best time to sell my property, kept me apprised of the costs throughout the process (effectively my biggest concern), discarded offers that were unreasonably low and not worth my time, and persistent for a good 3 months before we finally found a buyer at a price point that hit about 90% of my criteria. Thanks to 407 and Peggy's hard work, we were able to be alleviated of the credit burden an unwanted investment property brings and we left the sale with enough money to put towards a home that's just for us! I would strongly recommend them if you are either in the market for a highly competent property manager or a seller's agent.

    Absolute best service I have ever received. I can't say enough about Ryan and the staff at 407…read moreProperties. Very professional, efficient and knowledgeable. I have worked with them several times and each and every time they go above and beyond to exceed my expectations. Thank you again for all you do.

    Mcartney Property Management - propertymgmt - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...