A little gem here. Went with friends & we all had different…read morethings & EVERBODY said theirs were good. I had the breaded pork tenderloin, with mashed potatoes & green beans w/ bacon. Reasonably priced & good size portions, served quickly & piping hot! My son got the Carlton burger with an egg & said it was in his top 10 burgers! Homemade cherry cheesecake for desert. The service was also good, we were asked a couple of times if everything was good & if we needed anything. Will definitely be back! I neglected to take photos. Sorry.

Spotted this from the road as I have been staying in Newburgh for a business trip this week. Other…read morereviews seemed solid, so I gave it a try - on a Sunday morning. The place was BUSY. But I was seated immediately, and my server had my drink order out quickly. This is a step above your typical greasy spoon diner. It's quite nice, a little loud at times, and if you wanted to have a cup of coffee and listen in on the conversations around you, easy to do. I ordered one of their breakfast platters - country fried steak covered in sausage gravy (yum), scrambled eggs (light and fluffy), hash brown potatoes (excellent) and a short stack of pancakes. Special praise on the pancakes - they were perfect. This place is great. Prices are VERY reasonable for the portion sizes. Would come here again in a heartbeat.

Food is never disappointing that's why it's a place we frequent often!…read moreEven when they are busy the service is always great! The ambiance and atmosphere is great very welcoming!

I ordered a 1/2 Deerhead club sandwich. It is described on the menu as being "thinly sliced turkey,…read moreroast beef, smoked ham and cheddar cheese on a hoagie bun. It does not come with tomato, onion, lettuce of mayonnaise, you have to order it on the side. I also ordered a cup of beef vegetable soup with my meal. What was served to me did not in the least look like what the menu described. It looked like ground beef with cheese melted on top. When I told the waitress that this was not the club sandwich that I had ordered, she assured me that it was their club sandwich. Upon looking at the menu online it appears to be their BBC sandwich instead of the Club. I went ahead and dressed the sandwich with the lettuce, tomato, and onion (I had asked for mayonnaise too, it didn't have any on the side, nor could I see or taste any on the sandwich) I dressed the sandwich and ate it. While it didn't taste bad, the hoagie bun was soft, but the meat and cheese inside were bland and had absolutely no flavor. I didn't taste turkey, smoked ham, or beef. Even the tomato had no flavor. The only thing I could taste was the red onion they served with it. The waitress forgot to bring my soup and I had to ask for it. It was good but could have used more salt. My overall impression of the food was not bad, but I certainly was not impressed. The last time I ate there, I had their Greek Salad (I had been told that it was wonderful, it was not.) I have a lot of friends who love to eat there. I guess I just haven't ordered the right dish. My husband had their Stromboli and said it was very good. I think it will be very unlikely that I will ever go back. The seating was good and the restaurant was clean. Our waitress was nice . Other than forgetting to bring my soup and not correcting my order, she was fairly attentive.

Very friendly atmosphere coupled with wonderful food…read more The food portions are great and the tastes are amazing. A terrific experience to enjoy and to further recommend. All Five Stars A must try restaurant.

It's been awhile since I've been here but we decided to celebrate our anniversary with their…read moredelicious food. I ordered the Vegetarian Combination Platter with a side of their Mediterranean salad. I love this dish because I get to taste a little bit of everything. I believe theirs are the best falafels of those I've tasted. (When we travel I always order them to compare.) Their hummus is also my favorite. I ate some of my partner's tabbouleh which also was tasty. To top off our meals we ordered a piece of Baklava which was ample for the two of us and a perfect ending to this meal. My only negative is the falafels don't come with a sauce, although you can ask for it which I did for an additional charge. The service is fast and the restaurant is clean and bright. We'll be back.

Been eating at hot heads for years in Ohio , so happy they in Newburgh finally , and happy they…read morehave double Stamp Tuesday still !

Food was poor quality, the service was not bad…read more .

Best burger and fries in a while, service was nice and fairly fast. Restaurant needs a deep clean,…read morebooths were sticky and restroom doors were covered in greasy handprints. Outside needs a lot of work on landscape, but was clean. Will order drive thru next time instead of looking at inside. Could be a great little restaurant, but seems to be going the way of Steak &Shake.

I actually used to go here but this morning When I drove by I had forgotten my debit card but they…read morehad posted a sign saying they were no longer taking cash? So I asked if they could even take exact change and that was told me to with a "haha no, we aren't taking cash at all now" so I will just go elsewhere. Cash is legal tender and if you don't want to take it especially in a fast food restaurant; you shouldn't be in business.

You talk about North Main Annex Gourmet Catering dropping the ball!!! They stood up delivery today…read moreat our establishment with a very high profile customer in Evansville, IN. I am talking a big name brand customer in the area. This caterer got the date wrong, even though the correct date is plastered all over and in our email correspondence. We even had high profile executives fly in from Houston to Evansville to attend this very important meeting.

Great little spot with absolute quality food. We came for a…read moresandwich but stayed for the atmosphere.

We love this place! Food is always top notch, service is great and we love the atmosphere…read more The downtown location makes it a great spot to walk around after dinner and there's even a local ice cream shop near by!

I don't even eat cornbread but ate 1/2 it by myself. The steak bowl was good. Decent quality steak…read moremeat used, tender and moist the potatoes were good and the greens were sweet but good nicely flavored. I was visiting from the NYC area and I will say the food was pleasing to taste. I also taste the fried catfish with the red beans and again I was it disappointed. And everything was very decently priced I spent less than $80 in drinks and meals for 2.

I just needed a good comfort food meal and to get away and clear my head…read more Wow, what a great experience here from the focaccia bread with dipping oil to the wedge salad. It was really good. Most places give one big wedge. They do three small wedges here that way you don't get a bunch of lettuce at the bottom and no toppings. The Bruschetta bread was really good. I did the Pick two shrimp scampi with a kicked in up sauce and the other one was scallops with apples and a honey glaze with some crumbles. Service is excellent here. Jordan is a great waiter and very prompt with refills and checking on me. The dining room atmosphere is nice and quiet and charming. Not too busy for a Sunday afternoon.

Visited Biaggi's while in Evansville for a swim meet. The service was wonderful on the floor but…read morethe kitchen was obviously overwhelmed. I found the restaurant to be loud. So loud it was difficult to carry on a conversation and so loud it spoiled to overall experience. Now to the food... the wedge salad was fantastic, the bread was hot and tasty but the entrée was less than satisfying. I asked for a cup of soup that came out with the entrée. The spaghetti and meatball entrée was hot but the meatballs were significantly overcooked. I had high expectations as the decor is very nice and the staff was approachable. I won't be back due to the issues mentioned above.