Does NOT allow dogs. Not even on their patio. Despite what Apple Maps says. If you don't have a dog, it's great food and atmosphere. read more

The ambiance was wonderful, I felt like I was in Ireland. We sat outside and ate and there was no Irish band. The waitress was attentive and a the food was delicious. read more

See all

Underwhelming meal at May Kelly's. Complete with nostalgic decor, I was really hoping it was going to live up to the reviews I had read. The chicken pot pie was awful. Large chunks of tough chicken. The puff pastry placed on top was not fresh. It had clearly been baked off previously. They didn't even pretend it was freshly baked on top of the pie because it wasn't even warm. My husband enjoyed his steak & cheese with french fries, which is the only thing that made this a 3 star review. Very disappointed. read more

See all

This is definitely my favorite Irish restaurant/pub and wish it was closer to me. The decor is pretty cool and unique. My family and I enjoyed dining there. The service and food were fantastic. I had an Irish coffee with Bailey's and it was so good I had to have another. For my meal, I did the Irish sampler; 3 bowls consisting of Shepard's pie, beef stew, and pot pie. All were amazing but my favorites were the beef stew then the Shepard's pie. Overall, a great spot for some Irish food and can't wait to go back! read more

See all

We stopped at this wonderful restaurant before our long journey home. We hadn't seen such an interior in a tavern for a long time, even though we've traveled a lot. From the very beginning, it felt like we had stepped into a museum, and it was very interesting. The restaurant has a fireplace, which creates a festive and cozy atmosphere. The restaurant has a fireplace, which creates a festive and cozy atmosphere. The staff is very pleasant, and the bartender made perfect cocktails. Thank you very much for your hospitality. read more

See all

May Kelly's certainly has an eclectic way of being decorated. It has a lot of antique signs and objects throughout. We booked the "red room" for a party of 10 patrons which we scheduled far in advance. The people that were in the room before us ran over on their time, so we had to wait about 18 minutes after our reservation. The room is pretty cramped due to the length of the table, but it was cute and cozy. The max amount of people is 12 in this room. I had the taste of Ireland, which gives you three dishes in sample size: shepherds pie, beef stew & chicken pot pie. For $19.00 (kind of steep) it was okay. You can tell that there's a lot of pride, and it has a "just like mama used to make" method of cooking. Seems like they take a lot of pride in all of their dishes. It seems that everybody truly enjoyed their dishes, even the ones that had salad. Again, it was really nice that we were able to have our very own room. I would certainly come back and have the corned beef and cabbage meal; that's what my mother had and she said it was great. The only negative thing I would say is that our waitress seemed like she was a bit annoyed, having to wait on a large group and we needed to split our checks. Other than that I felt that our service was sufficient. read more

May Kelly's - Taste of Ireland (starter) but more like a meal! - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

This was my second time at May Kelly's and it will definitely continue to be a regular stop whenever we are in North Conway! It is such a unique little place with great hospitality and delicious food! It's called May Kelly's Cottage for a reason because the moment you step in you feel like you're in someone's home and you're greeted by a friendly face. The decor is quirky and tables are spread around multiple different rooms. They also have a nice bar area and outdoor space. They have a great menu with both Irish and American classics. Lots of comforting dishes that would hit the spot after a busy day exploring, hiking, or skiing. I had the roast turkey dinner. It was fabulous and included an absolutely enormous portion of tender roasted turkey breast. The turkey gravy was light but still loaded with turkey flavor, and the sides were delicious as well. My husband had the Reuben sandwich with fries. The corned beef was cut in a thick slab and was super tender. The fries were thick cut with skin, and nice and crispy. I was way too full for dessert, but I did have a glass of their homemade Irish cream and it was delightful. Just the right amount of booziness, not too sweet with hints of espresso and chocolate. I highly recommend it! As with many of the restaurants in North Conway they can get very busy. Go at an off time if you don't want to wait, but it's definitely worth the wait! read more

See all

Outstanding service and very quick. Food was excellent. Guinness was great and Irish options are on point. Highly recommend. read more

May Kelly's - Beef stew - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

May Kelly's Cottage always struck me as maybe "too close to downtown" and "too big to be good," but stepping inside proved me wrong. The place is packed with authentic Irish décor--antiques, signs, old photos, and plenty of details to look around at and talk about. It feels genuine, lived-in, and full of character. The food held up too. I particularly liked the Irish Sampler, which lets you try the Beef Stew, Shepherd's Pie, and Chicken Pot Pie all in one go. It was hearty, flavorful, and a fun way to get a little bit of everything. Service was great, and there was live music in the bar while we were there, which made it feel even more like a true pub. If you're lucky with your seat, there's also a nice view, and I noticed what looked like outdoor seating for when the weather cooperates. It's the kind of place that wins you over with atmosphere as much as with food and drink. Near the hostess stand, I spotted a framed picture of the rally for Irish independence at Fenway Park in 1919--just one example of the many unique details scattered throughout. Overall, May Kelly's is a fun, authentic Irish pub experience in North Conway. Great staff, solid food, and enough atmosphere to keep you coming back--and probably lingering longer than you planned. read more

Great service, food and cocktails. Bar staff was fantastic. Atmosphere is cool and they have a nice patio.

Sorry. I didn't take pictures here. But what a cozy place. There is Irish memorabilia everywhere. Very interesting. Many different rooms as if you were in a home. Didn't eat anything as we were on a pub crawl. The bar was small but the service was great. My significant other had the beer sampler which featured a variety of Irish beer. I would recommend for sure. read more

Driven by this place many times usually in a rush to get home after some outdoors activities, fortunately today we had a bit more time to stop in. Great vibe inside and you could take awhile just to look around at the decorations etc. try to spot the stuffed owl. Draft beer! Yeah they have Kilkenny Irish cream ale - a rarer find and now another known purveyor ! Food was great, we shared a pear salad and the roasted turkey sandwich - enough food for a nice lunch. Service was also friendly and prompt. read more

May Kelly's - Kilkenny Cream Ale...yes ! - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

One of the best Irish pubs I've ever been to with authentic Irish food and drinks. Very eclectic ambiance with decorations that ranged from antiques, to classic Guinness memorabilia, to a tribute to It's a Wonderful Life. Loved the seafood reuben I ordered and my wife had the corned beef and cabbage. Yummy. You can lose yourself for hours looking at all the art and memorabilia. Great service. read more

See all

Fantastic food and service. Love the vibe. It was great to meet the owners and listen to how it all started. Recommend highly

I felt like good hardy food for our 44th anniversary and May Kerly's didn't disappoint! I made reservations, we were immediately seated and within 10 minutes we had our dinner! The turkey was so tender I did not need to use my knife. The stuffing was very well seasoned and when combined with some cranberry sauce, gravy and turkey was a perfect bite! My husband really enjoyed his chicken pot pie, especially the puff pastry crust. The decor was fun and interesting, and the staff were all very friendly and helpful. We will go back when in the area! read more

May Kelly's - Chicken Pot Pie - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

See all

From the moment I walked into May Kelly's, I knew I was in for something special. The decor is unique and full of Irish character, every corner tells a story! The hostess was incredibly kind and welcoming, The food was delicious and authentic, must try Shepard's pie and corned beef dinner, the Guinness was poured to perfection, and the staff were so friendly and accommodating. We were lucky enough to visit on a Sunday and enjoy live Irish music -- it truly felt like being in Ireland. An unforgettable experience! read more

See all

This place is absolutely amazing! May Kelly's is an Irish restaurant/pub! The staff are great, the ambiance is perfect. There are area you can dine and simply relax and then there's the pub, a super fun atmosphere with music and a great drink selection. The food we ordered was delicious and left nothing to be desired about this place! We'll definitely be returning! read more

We happened to be "in the neighborhood" for this past St. Patrick's Day and wanted to enjoy the vibe at an Irish Pub if we could. Well, we and EVERYONE else with the same idea descended on May Kelly's (one of only two or three Irish Pubs in the area--and likely the most popular). Our strategy was to come in the middle of the day--after the early crowd and before the late crowd--but they were still slammed. We got extremely lucky and were able to be seated at a 2-person high-top in the bar area that someone had just vacated.  Of course, it was a bit chaotic--it was St. Paddy's Day--but the bartenders who cared for the small bar and the high-tops were attentive. After a discussion about what I like, the bartender/server recommended an Irish whisky, and we looked over the large menu. Given the holiday, we went full-on Irish: me a Traditional Irish Shepherd's Pie and her a Corned Beef & Cabbage. Both were very good.  Overall, it was a great experience, and while we may skip trying to do this again on St. Patrick's Day, we will be sure to pop into May Kelly's when we are in the area. read more

May Kelly's - My Irish gal at one of May Kelly's high-tops - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

Disappointed! Gaelic Chicken was obviously frozen pre breaded patties fried hard with an herb creamy sauce that was blah. Best part of my meal was the 1/2 ear of sweet corn. Mashed potatoes were dry not creamy or seasoned. My companion had the chicken pot pie which was a bowl of a potato heavy stew with a piece of puff pastry laid on the top of the small bowl. I had a cup of their seafood stew which was tasty, he had their French onion soup that was good. We had water for beverages and our meal was $100. Definitely not a $100 meal ! read more

Amazing fish and chips!! Three nice sized servings, filling and plenty for extra! Coleslaw was also so yummy! Fries weren't my fav, but personal preference. Still would order again. read more

May Kelly's - Fish and chips - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

Loved the coziness and eclectic decor. Food was great but be warned the portions are gigantic. Definitely consider splitting at lunch. We stopped in for lunch while passing through so no way to take leftovers. Wish they had smaller lunch sized portions. (Ex:just one chicken breast with the Gaelic chicken meal instead of two.) Hated spending dinner prices and tossing half of our food. Our waitress was friendly and helpful. She kept our glasses topped off and checked on us several times. read more

See all

Food was outstanding. Shepherds Pie made with ground lamb which is difficult to find. Also, peach salad, goat cheese, and baby spinach was excellent. Waitress was helpful & pleasant. Will come back to try other things on the menu. read more

This place rules and I cannot say enough good things about it. As authentic as it gets. We got the shepherd's pie and fish and chips and both were excellent. This is definitely a go-to when we're in the Conway area. read more

Definitely coming back here! This restaurant is pretty cool with all the vintage items inside, and I didn't see all of it. The atmosphere, service and food were excellent. I had the Fish N' Chips, excellent! My husband had the Harvey Gibson Sub, which is their black pastrami sandwich...that was amazing! Their fries are slightly seasoned and crispy - another yum! Coleslaw leans a little on the tart side, again, yum! Portion sizes are pretty good, so we felt you get your money's worth. We sat at a corner table and it was bench style with cushions and pillows, very comfy and cozy, and the view of the mountains outside our window, was gorgeous! Now comes dessert, if you have room....they are not on the menu, you ask your server. That night was only 3 to choose from, due to them getting ready to close for 10 days - this is every year, so everyone can relax and the place is ready for the busy season coming. She had me at Bailey's Cheesecake...the other 2 mentioned was a blurry sound - hahaha - anyways...that cheesecake was awesome!! If you're in the North Conway area looking for some good food, with gorgeous views, oh, they do have outside seating on their patio - check this place out!! read more

See all

The food is awesome. We had the Irish sampler, French onion soup and shepherds pie. Excellent home cooked-feeling food. Great atmosphere, the deck has a beautiful view of the mountains. read more

May Kelly's - Irish Sampler - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

Best meal we've had in the area so far! Beautiful view on the deck and laidback but attentive service! read more

May Kelly's - Best meal we've had in the area so far! - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

See all

Came back w/friends & family - the Rueben was just fabulously delicious as I remembered - juicy slabs of meat - so generous! Split it & a salad w/my mom - the salad had fresh, rich & creamy goat cheese - 10/10 recommend! read more

May Kelly's - Rueben Sandwich 10/10 A+ - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

See all

Great food, staff and cozy atmosphere. We been going here for years and haven't never been disappointed. Highly recommend

I have to say their French fries are the best I've ever eaten. Crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. Almost like they were battered. The corned beef was delicious. My husband had the Shepard pie and it was perfect. Will definitely go back. Try May Kelly's, you won't be disappointed. read more

10/19/24 Like being at a fine pub/restaurant in Galway. Decor perfectly Irish pub perfect. Service very prompt, very attentive. Bloody Mary perfect. We had the Irish grill and corned beef and cabbage. Great Irish fare. Worth the hour's drive. I'd vote this as one of North Conway's best. read more

We were visiting the area and had dinner at May Kelly's tonight. It is clearly a popular place--the parking lot was packed with cars. The service was friendly and attentive. I found the food portions to be enormous. I was looking for some healthier options on the menu, but everything is extremely heavy. My husband and I shared the French onion soup (very salty). I ordered the grilled Reuben. Each half was so think that I almost had to deconstruct it to eat it. The fries were good. I would have loved an option of a half sandwich with a salad or a vegetable side. My husband ordered the turkey dinner. Again, what came out on his plate was enough to serve 3 or 4 people. The turkey was thick slabs, like 3/4 inch, not slices. At first, he was not sure if it was real or processed turkey. It had mashed potatoes, stuffing, and corn on the cob, so major carb loading. So it's not that the food was not good, just that it seemed like they emphasize quantity over quality. read more

May Kelly's - Reuben sandwich - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

What an experience May Kelly's really is! Visiting from out of state and needed a place for dinner. Luckily we were told 20 minute wait for our party of 4 but really only waited about 10. Once you enter this restaurant you are met with such an array of decor. Every inch of the walls are covered with something. We also were pleasantly surprised by some live music being played while we ate. The staff were all pleasant, attentive and helpful with suggestions of what to order. The staff was also extremely patient with the two young children that were in my party as well. The kids meals came out fast and first. We ordered the Irish nachos, cooked perfectly and tasty. We ordered the grilled peach goat cheese salad, very flavorful. Downside, there was too much dressing so I would suggest ordering it on the side. We also ordered the Harvey sandwich, very tasty! We did order the lava cake for dessert and I took a star off the review for this as I was so excited because all the other food was great but the cake tasted premade and was definitely warmed in the microwave. read more

My new favorite restaurant in North Conway. Love the wings but can't get enough of the corned beef and cabbage. Also love the turkey dinner. Always a challenge picking which! read more

May Kelly's - Corned beef and cabbage - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

Exceptional and authentic Irish food. We particularly enjoyed the sampler including chicken pot pie, stew, and shepherds pie, all of which were among the best we've ever had. Will be returning next time we're in NC! read more

May Kelly's - Irish Sampler - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

Fun place good food ! Been coming to North Conway for years and just found it! Glad we did

Cool eclectic Irish on style restaurant. We went on the recommendation of our Innkeeper, who has yet to steer us wrong! Husband got the beer flight, which he enjoyed. I got the chocolate raspberry martini, which was heavy but delicious. We ordered the Irish sampler app... beef stew, shepherd's pie and chicken pot pie. All very good. I especially liked the shepherd's pie, with ground lamb. My husband got the Ruben and I got the steak tips. Everything was delicious. Our server, Nona, was pleasant, efficient and helpful as we were having trouble deciding. We did not order dessert because we were so full, but the dessert menu looked amazing. This was our first visit here and we will definitely be back! read more

May Kelly's - Beer flight. - Pubs Near Me - North Conway, New Hampshire

What a warm & cozy spot this was! The Irish vibe was very authentic and the service was impeccable. I ordered the turkey dinner and my husband got the roast beef. Both meals were delicious, good portions and really easy to eat...not too heavy! Highly recommend if you are in the area. read more

I absolutely love May (the owner) and her restaurant. If you're like me and love a traditional corned beef dinner, you won't be disappointed. Portions are generous, service is great, and the ambiance is anything but boring. Definitely one of our go-to dinner spots. read more

stopped in for a quick bite and cocktail and we were wowed! an irish pub that will not disappoint with plenty of dish options . i had the french onion soup and he had the irish sampler . both were fantastic but he said that the shepard's pie was incredible! the sampler had the traditional beef stew, chicken pot pie and shepard's pie. as usual, we each enjoyed a cocktail. i decided while that since he ALWAYS had a double makers i will include a picture each time. this will allow for "pour" comparison. mary kelly's pour did not disappoint! service was spot on, served hot and fast. i included pics of the bar area but this is a unique spot that you will pick up on immediately. DO NOT miss this unique roadside pub with offerings that will please any palate! read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch while staying nearby on a vacation. The restaurant is pretty cute and has a nice, friendly feel to it. We sat at a table in the bar area and the service was great. Drinks were good and the food was better than I expected. My husband had a burger and I had the meatloaf. Both were huge and we couldn't even finish them. Nice spot to come if you are looking for food and/or drinks. read more