My mother and I brought some rings here to be sized as well as some old items to sell. They did a good job sizing (especially sizing my grandmother's ring to my mother's finger since my mom is a much smaller person but it fits very well; also the two I brought have scrollwork around the stones and nothing was damaged/it looks perfectly new). Their prices are a bit high, but look for coupons in some of the local coupon fliers. Also selling the scrap metal offset the cost somewhat, so if you have anything you're not wearing, why not get a few bucks out of it? Overall, very pleased with the service and quality. Turnover time was about a week on mine; mom is also still waiting for them to source a stone to fit a setting where she lost the original one (which could take time, of course). read more

Matthew Erickson Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Aurora, Illinois

They told me they could fix a watch I brought in. Not only did they not fix it, I waited 5 months for them to return it and it was in worse condition than when I dropped it off. They stated "there was nothing they could do" and had terrible customer service through the process. Do NOT recommend. read more

An excellent jewelry store. A good selection of precious and semiprecious jewelry. They do excellent chain/jewelry repairs and even change watch batteries. Sadly, my wife claims to have enough jewelry and gets mad when I buy her more. I'm a watch addict and unfortunately the store doesn't really sell watches, although they will take links out of watches purchased elsewhere for a nominal fee. read more

The owner is honest and their very nice and professional. I can see they have loyal customer service base.

Excellent experience selling silver to Matthew Ericksons. No hassling, honest service

Over the years, I've been to every jewelry store in town but, Matthew Erikson is - by far - my go-to jeweler. They never try to sell me on something but instead, listen to exactly what I'm looking for and find it for me. The entire staff, and specifically LeAnne, is incredible at helping me get exactly what I want and, their level of personal service is unmatched. If you're looking for a place that will get you that perfect gift, there is simply nobody better. read more

TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!! I went to this jewelry store to have a watch repaired. My first visit was pleasant. Staff there were very nice, accommodating, and respectful. They repaired my watch; however, only days after, it was broken again (Note: no big deal. I was not worried or upset about that at all. "Stuff happens"). I took my watch back today to see if they could fix it and there were two different employees at the front of the store. Both were ignorant, rude, and completely unacceptable communicators. They spoke to me very poorly (as if I was at fault for the poorly repaired piece of jewelry). Especially the man. He was nasty. I sure hope that's not the owner. WoW. Not someone you want greeting or serving customers. He was a pompous jerk with no class. I will never go back to the store again. There are wayyyy too many other jewelry stores with better customer service than this location. At a time like this when people are losing their businesses, you would think they would know better than to treat customers like this! Avoid this place if you can. You deserve better and better businesses deserve your money. Professional development is needed for staff. They did give me a refund per my request so I will take my business elsewhere. I have TONS of jewelry and just moved from Chicago. I was truly excited about this business becoming my new "go-to" place to buy and repair jewelry. I'll take my business somewhere that has staff with TACT and GRACE. read more

We were recommended to Matthew Erickson Jewelers to look at engagement rings. We had never looked at rings before so we were a bit nervous going in to our appointment but all those nerves went away once we were greeted and helped by Steve and Judy. We had a vision in our heads which was hard to articulate and they listened to us, did research and came back to us with great suggestions. We really appreciated that they took the time to get to know us and what we were looking for to ensure we found the perfect ring for us. We can't say enough how wonderful both Steve and Judy were to work with, how exceptionally easy they made the entire process and how much it meant to us that they went above and beyond what either of us were expecting. We would highly recommend Matthew Erickson Jewelers to anyone looking for an engagement or wedding ring!! read more

Outstanding!!! We were out engagement ring shopping and were getting frustrated and overwhelmed very quickly. We decided to head towards a large shopping area to look at lots of options when Matthew Erickson Jewelers popped up on my Google search. They had amazing, consistent reviews so we headed there. Wow!!! They are amazing. We worked with Leanne, who educated us about diamonds and helped us make our decisions while making sure we got what we wanted. She was very patient with our multiple questions and while we decided what we wanted. In about 2 hours we had our ring design and stone selected and had our financing figured out (layaway worked best for us). I have the ring now and my fiance and I both could not be happier!! We are going back for our wedding bands!! read more

My husband purchased my engagement ring here, we had a major issue with it which made me question the quality of it not even a month later. When I called and expressed my concerns the owner was offended and was rude. He ended up letting me pick out another ring because he refused to refund us the money. I would NEVER recommend this place. Not to mention they never answer the phone and their texting system sucks. They can't even give you a call back. read more

I can't say enough good things about Matthew Erickson Jewelers. When my fiancé and I decided to get engaged I knew better than to pick out an engagement ring on my own, and after not finding something we liked at the big chain stores, we elected to get a custom ring made. I can't imagine our ring turning out better anywhere else. From the excellent customer service of the two salespeople we worked with (Leanne and Judy), to the fair pricing and solid diamond education we received from the manager (Steve), to the skilled craftsmanship of their in-house jeweler (Carlito), our experience from start to finish was wonderful. I'm sure we set some sort of record for longest time from initial conversation to final product (our fault, not theirs!) but everyone was patient and helpful along the way as we picked out the stone, sketched the ring on paper, and saw it through from wax to rough metal to polished masterpiece. They made us feel like friends, not clients. Seriously, if you need custom work done, or just want a varied selection of in-the-case jewelry, skip the mall and go here. read more

Purchasing an engagement ring was an intimiating idea; however, that all went away the moment I stepped foot in Matthew Erickson's. Judy was absolutely amazing in finding the different styles I was interested in and calling me on a weekly basis to stay on the same page. Matthew Erickson's staff made me feel extremely comfortable during the process and I would definitely recommend to anyone if given the opportunity due to the high quality of the customer service and the product itself. My fiancé is in love with her ring and I have Judy and Steve to thank for that. I visited most of the chain stores and there was one similarity between them all and that was pushy staff looking to get the sale at point of meeting. I knew Matthew Erickson was the right fit for me as I met Steve, the owner (GIA) in my first visit...I don't think you get to do that at the chain stores. read more

I have been shopping for a vintage wedding ring for my wife. When i found there store over ten years ago. the service and selection is by far the best in the area and if they dont have it they can make it. I had them make seveal personal sets of custom earings for my wife who can only wear leaver back style earings. No only were they able to cange them from post to leaver backs but they aslo wer able to take my ideas amd make them into reality. Over the years they have far exceded my expectaions and the prices i got for being a loyal customer are first rate. They even will go so far as to give you apprasies on your items you buy for your insurance records if you ask for little or no charge. I highly recommend them and you will not be disapointed by the service and selection as well as the prices. read more

Excellent customer service! I recently purchased an engagement ring a couple of days before a vacation trip, on which I planned to propose to my girlfriend. My plan was to pick up the ring on my way to the airport but time didn't allow. As I would be gone for 1 week, I started to think about a backup proposal plan upon our return home. 2 days later, I was contacted by Judy as the owner wanted to see if they could next day air the ring to me at the vacation location. I was so impressed by this idea, being a first time customer. I received the ring the next day and was able to propose to my darling on our vacation. She loved it! Matthew Erickson rocks!! read more

There is no better jeweler than this store. The staff is professional and extremely knowledgeable about diamonds and gemstones. I had saved a mailing that was sent out in the mail randomly about 8 months before. I walked in with my fiance' and Steve immediately knew what I wanted . They have jewelry that is unique and affordable. The pieces aren't like all of the mall stores. And, they treat you like family. They will have my business for a lifetime. read more

Rude. And when I said I'll come back when the jeweler is present so I can see what my options are for fixing my wedding ring, the saleswoman got offended. I wasn't going to leave my ring with someone who had no clue what it needed. She wouldn't give me straight answers to begin with! read more

I took a sentimental but not expensive piece of jewelry there to be fixed and I was so pleased with the outcome and the price. They were so nice and professional even thought my necklace wasn't purchased there. I had originally taken it to Perle Jewelers to support my local downtown businesses but received a quote that was more than the piece is worth for a very simple repair. Thank you Matthew Erickson Jewelers I will recommend you highly. read more

Does not even deserve 1 star !! Stay away from this place.....Met with Steve in order to have a diamond reviewed and possibly purchased by this jeweler. Steve advised that he could only offer $750 for my diamond but would give me a store credit of $1500. Stated that he can purchase diamonds from China cheaper. ALL OTHER JEWELERS WHO LOOKED AT THIS STONE OFFERED ME $3500 +. My diamond was appraised at $8,700. Do not buy or sell from this place!! read more

I went into their store on a whim -- looking for a right-hand ring for myself. I purchased a white gold 1/2 carat TW Journey ring from their clearance case and it is quite beautiful. After wearing it for a few hours, I decided that the ring was not as comfortable as I had hoped it would be. I went to return the ring only to be informed that they would only issue a store credit since it was a clearance item. I was not informed of this policy at the time of purchase. If I had been informed, I would have not made the purchase immediately. That being said, I would only purchase their clearance items if 100% certain of my decision. Just thought I would share this with others. I will shop there again as they have lovely pieces that you don't see in the chain stores. read more