My wife and I have been coming to Johnny's (formerly Rosati's) for about 5 years, ever since her…read moreMom moved to Oconomowoc and introduced us to it. The pizza here is fantastic and has received rave reviews from anyone who has tasted it. We usually order online and pick it up since we live pretty close. You can tell that they use fresh ingredients and care about quality. The people here are super friendly and always have a smile, which is really nice since they are usually slammed with customers. I've even been offered a complimentary beverage when waiting to pick up a pizza when they weren't quite as busy--which I thought was really nice. We really need to give some of their other food a try, it's just tough when the pizza is so good!

Still love this place. I usually try to go when I'm home because the name changed but that's it…read more It's still delicious and the same great menu and staff. My mom and I love the eggplant strips and not many places do them anymore. I also like their Mac and cheese bites. Usually we do pizza but we went with other options since we weren't too hungry and my parents take their leftovers for later. It was pretty busy for the fourth, but I appreciated they were open! Highly recommend always.

Super Duper Delicious Food! 1000% recommend. Those Pep Sticks are to die for. All the co workers…read moreare super nice as well.

We had a large Cheese, double sausage, onion, and mushrooms on half pizza. The crust was nice and…read morecrispy on the edge but was softer as you got to the middle of the pizza. The flavor of the sausage and sauce was very good and had plenty of cheese. The staff is always pleasant and friendly.

A classic home style Italian restaurant! I initially went not knowing their pizzas were a MUST, so…read morewe had ordered spaghetti and meatballs and their chicken parm. Laugh all you want, but I just love noodles, red sauce, and meatballs. We thought "not bad" but knew the next time we came back we had to get pizza. Fast forward to when we returned. We ordered the large sausage pizza and now this is the place we ALWAYS go to for pizza. I normally hate square pizzas because I need all my pieces to have a crust, but this pizza has changed it for me. Great crust and great sausage flavor. We love DeMarinis!

First time in last night. Greeted warmly and excitedly. Sat at the bar and had a wonderful old…read morefashioned(sweet). Very good. Ordered a large pizza cheese,sausage, mushroom and onion. Was recommended to throw on some Pepperoni. If you do tell them you want it "on top" it comes out very crispy. Toasted ravioli was good too. Eggplant app wasn't super great but still good. Staff was friendly welcoming and very attentive.Wonderful place

I always like Noah's, I sent people there and to cut it short they were very disappointed with the…read morepizza they ordered, said they would never go back, so sad I always enjoyed their food.

The sauce has changed. It is so spicy and hot our throats we're on fire . None of us could finish…read moreour food. We use to really love your food. The meatballs were hard as a rock and burnt. Could not even cut them. Garlic bread was the only edible thing. 40 bucks wasted as we had to dump our meals.

We've ordered pizza from Crossroads for over a decade and have always had a great experience. Their…read morepizza is one of our favorites in the area. The crust isn't super thin, but it's not very thick, either.

Where is the zero stars button??…read more I'm new to the area, and was trying to find somewhere I could just grab a quick slice of pizza while I'm on a time crunch. Their website says they sell slices, and I called to confirm. The employee over the phone told me they do sell slices, and gave no further information. After a 10 minute drive to get there, I walk in and don't see any cheese slices. I asked how long I would have to wait, and they told me they don't carry cheese slices. The only slices they carry have pork on them. What a waste of time. I don't eat pork, and I know I'm not the only one. I've never heard of a pizza place having no option for just cheese. I get that the restaurant can choose to run their business however they want, but there should be a disclaimer that they don't carry cheese before people waste their time coming in.

Leaving marcos a second review as my first one was a few years ago…read more Got a rolo last night and it was spectacular, I have been ordering food from here for 20 years and this was the best rolo I ever had! One thing to always remember if they make a mistake or the food is not perfect please voice your complaints with them because if they don't know things are not perfect they can't fix them!!! Don't go complain in the next door app that will get you nowhere!!

Okay first time here. My husband has raved about their calzones (or "rollos") over the years. I…read moretried the baked mostaccioli and it was just okay. Plenty of cheese but the flavor was just kind of meh. The meatballs were okay. The calzone is huge. It was also so greasy that it leaked on everything else. However, I was told that it is still just as good as it used to be. We saw a special for a free garlic bread and tried to use a $1 off coupon when calling it in. When picking up, we were told you can't use the coupon with the bread special. Not a big deal but maybe say that when we are placing our order. All in all, will try again but maybe just stick with pizzas or rollos.

Today was the first time that we tried this pizza. We moved into the neighborhood and when we order…read morefood, usually on the weekends, we like to try local places, This will be a favorite. The thin crust was perfect. The pizza wasn't greasy , right amount of toppings and really good food. You will have to adjust to a few grumpy old men taking the orders and delivering. Almost comical ! As far as the food five stars.

Thought I'd try after hearing the history of the place. I…read morewill say the pizza is phenomenal. Thin, cracker crust, flavorful sausage and served screaming hot. The ambiance and service is terrible. I was eating alone, and there were 2 other tables full. That was it. I was told 2x the pizza will be a little longer due to the kitchen being "backed"up. Not buying that. It wasn't like there was a steady stream of people coming in for pickup either. There is oldies music on the speakers=cool. The floor is dirty and the place is sparse. I'll recommend it only for the pizza. Be prepared to wait an ungodly amount of time.

I got my first Pizza from. Carol Ann's on a recent Saturday evening It was really busy mostly take…read moreout Jo Saw several customers leaving with multiple pizza boxes Mostly 3 to 5 I had phoned in my order and was told what time it would be ready Due the large amount of orders they were turning out it was about 15 minutes late No big deal I understand I had ordered a 16" Supreme It was a beautiful pizza with lots of toppings When I got it home 5 minutes drive We got right to work on it Delicious with a great tasting crust My only negative was the crust was limp It had some browning on bottom could have used more I knew that if I ordered again and asked for it to be crispy I would have a perfect pizza So about a week later I ordered another for pickup and it was perfect For all the ingredients you get on the supreme the price is a deal Highly recommend Great local business run by people take pride in their product

We were invited to our neighbors' house for dinner. When we arrived, we found out they had ordered…read moretakeout pizza from a local pizza shop. I'll admit, I'm not always a huge fan of takeout. It can be a bit hit or miss. They assured me we'd love it, and they were right. Food: The order was placed over the phone and included two medium pizzas. One was topped with cheese, sausage, mushrooms, onions, black olives, and green peppers. The other was a Supreme with all of those toppings plus sausage. We arrived at the restaurant at the scheduled pickup time and were told the pizzas were just coming out of the oven. About five minutes later, we watched them being boxed up. By the time we got them back to the house, about 15 minutes later, they were still hot. Both pizzas were excellent. The crust was thin and nicely crisp without being soggy. The sauce was flavorful with just a touch of sweetness. There was plenty of mozzarella cheese and generous toppings, and the pizzas looked like they had been prepared with care. They were every bit as good as our neighbors promised. Service: The staff was friendly while we waited and kept us updated on how much longer it would be. They also suggested that next time we try their garlic bread, describing it as similar to Mama Mia's, with thick bread soaked in butter. They even gave us a couple of paper menus to take home. Atmosphere: There were several other people waiting for carryout orders when we arrived. They also have a dining room, although it wasn't being used while we were there. The seating is simple, with sturdy picnic table-style tables, but it looked clean and comfortable. Based on our first experience, this is definitely a place we'd be happy to order from again, and we'd also be interested in coming back to dine in.