Hey there for the first time the other night. I would go back for a burger or a pizza. The pastas are OK. Service was great and all in all had a nice time it's much more of a sports bar than an Italian restaurant read more

Everything was perfect. We ordered their famous mushroom soup it was not your typical cream of mushroom soup very good. read more

Excellent food, beautiful atmosphere with outside views, and friendly professional staff.

Good friends brought me to Martell's while I was visiting from another state. Martell's is certainly a very special place, from it's exquisite menu to the stunning setting and scenery that you can enjoy through the picture window that blends the beauty of nature with the climate controlled and elegant dining room. Or if you prefer, you can opt for outside patio dining closer to the gorgeous pond. I also enjoyed the stonework features on the building both inside and out. The food was first class, mouth-wateringly delicious, cooked to perfection, beautifully presented, and served with a smile. For an appetizer we had the Sherry Onion Dip which has caramelized onion, roasted garlic, cream cheese, and a pita-like bread for dipping... it was awesome. Then I had a dinner house salad which features mixed greens, dried apricots, candied walnuts, sliced brie, citrus vinaigrette... I loved it. For the main entree I had the 10 oz prime rib with mashed potatoes and veggies... Everything was perfect. I wish we had a Martell's in my hometown. The service was first class, professional, friendly, and attentive. Martell's is a perfect for date night as it is elegant and has tables that provide an intimate setting. But it is also wonderful for friends meeting up, family gatherings and celebrations, and groups. I'd love to return and dine on the patio. I'd be willing to drive a couple of hours to have dinner here again. read more

See all

The entrance now seems a little drab like they need to brighten up the restaurant no longer do you get bread and butter unless you ask for it. They are a little skimpy with their shrimp on pasta three shrimp so I have to order Extra. That has been my favorite restaurant in Kalamazoo until this year. read more

Wonderful food and service, we've had multiple work Christmas parties here and they were wonderful.

I got the Cesar salad and their buttered noodles (special request) the salad was amazing as was my pasta! I will be back soon and their food is so yummy. read more

Martell's - Cesar salad! - New American Near Me - Kalamazoo, Michigan

See all

I've dined many times over the years, and the food and service have always been excellent. Best prime rib in Kalamazoo area.

Delicious, well prepared food. Great ambience. Excellent service. Friendly staff. I recommend this place.

My wife and I went for lunch today, it was our first visit here. Josh our host seated us at a table with a nice view of the water. Our server was Carlos, he did a great job of taking care of our order and serving us. I had a cup of their famous house made mushroom soup. It was very good and deserving of its popularity. I ordered the Orechiette which was very good also. My wife had the Prime Rib Dip which she shared with me. The beef was lean and very tender and the au jus was full of flavor. We loved the fact that they where open at 11:30 for lunch service with the full menu. We will be back to try some more of their dishes. read more

See all

What a great atmosphere!! A group of 7 of us had a reservation and the place was full. We were seated immediately even before our group arrived. We had appetizers and i had the salmon. I liked everything on my plate but it had too much salt. Our waiter was slow and did not take command of our orders. Usually in nicer restaurants like this the waiters are more A type personality. He was super quiet and did not suggest much. He was pleasant maybe he was new. I would definitely come back. read more

My sister and I took our friend here last week for a birthday meal. The food was great! I had the pork chop. It was thick, juicy, and tasty. The tiramisu and cannolis were delicious as well. Others in my group enjoyed their meals as well. The service was friendly but a bit inattentive or slow at times. Still, I'd highly recommend. read more

While planning for prom, I reached out to this restaurant over a month in advance to make a reservation for a large party. Each time I called, I was told my request would be passed along to the reservation manager and that I'd receive a call back--but I never did. After multiple follow-ups, I was finally told that my information had never been taken and that they were already fully booked. The lack of communication and follow-through was frustrating and a waste of time. If you're looking for a reliable place to make a reservation, I wouldn't recommend booking here. read more

We came for the view, which is amazing, and the food, delish! My husband had the pork chop and I had Tripoline. We ordered half salads which were also good and priced right. For dessert I had Tiramisu and he had the chocolate torte. Our server was very attentive and professional. Our only complaint was the table behind us with about 7 people was LOUD. They obviously had no idea they were in a public setting. read more

We have been ordering the prime rib sandwich at Martells for years. Thursday night we were served tough, overcooked dried up, and fatty prime rib. The price of $28 has steadily increased, and the quality is worse. The service was good in the bar area. We did not complain, but I hope this doesn't start a trend. read more

Remember when this was the Black Swan? I digress. We received got takeout from here, and had such a good experience. The staff answering the phone was pleasant, patient, and kind. The staff that helped during pickup, same! The food was (mostly) hot, even though my husband had to wait a few minutes. It was expertly packaged and quite delicious. We got the burgers and the taste was divine. Of special note was the vegetable side that day, a mixed root vegetable medley. It was extraordinary! read more

This place is straight out of Rex Morgan, M.D. Need I say more? Patio especially nice In season.

Had lunch at Martells today. The food was good, though I felt it was missing a little something. The staff were professional but came across a bit stiff and unsure. What really stood out was the natural scenery, absolutely beautiful with the water features adding a perfect touch. read more

Martell's - New American Near Me - Kalamazoo, Michigan

Ate here tonight to celebrate our son's graduation. The views are nice, atmosphere acceptable, and our server was really good. The food and drinks were both really good. The only complaint I have is the expense of a neat pour of whiskey. I understand establishments sometimes charge more for neat drink pours, but it makes no sense. A $3 up charge for a base level bourbon, simply because I wanted it neat vs over ice is unacceptable. Although this didn't ruin the evening, it does leave a bad taste. Give this place a try if in the area. read more

Kalamazoo College reunion receptions were hosted here this weekend. It's a beautiful space (I remember going with my aunt here to the Black Swan 20+ years ago, it was pretty enough to be memorable). The food was good and pretty. It was a lovely place for a reception! read more

Martels has long been a favorite lunch and dinner spot for me. The attractive surroundings outside and inside help make dining an event. The food is reliably tasty.Consider joining the Millennium Rewards Club, it has some nice benefits. read more

this place is very fancy but disappointing on how long it took to get our food. Over an hour is insanity

First visit was 9/20/25 and it will not be the last. I live over an hour away and the prime rib dip is worth the trip! Feel free to steal that for a slogan....THE DIP IS WORTH THE TRIP!! read more

Great food and service. Big selection of food. Come support this business! Both dine in and takeout are well done! read more

Last night a group of eight of us dined at Martell's to celebrate a friend's birthday. While we had a reservation for the main dining room, we opted instead for a large table on the bar side. Our waitress, Marissa, was very accommodating when we decided to move and we were very fortunate to have her! I hate onions, so when I eyed the mushroom soup on the menu I ask Marissa if she knew what exactly went into the soup. She went back to the chef to find out, then came back with a small sample of the soup. OMG, it was absolutely the best mushroom soup I've ever had (and no onions!). One taste revealed the flavors of fresh cream and butter, as well as beautifully cooked mushrooms. I ordered a whole bowlful of it and was not disappointed; I even commented that the soup was so good I wanted to take a bath in it! I was going to order the roasted beet salad, but Marissa said they had just finished the season for that and were on a new item: a poached pear salad with spring mix, dried cherries, candied pecans, and champagne vinaigrette. It was truly a delightful combination and, again, I'll say it was the best salad I've had in a very long time. Oooo, that vinaigrette! It was slightly sweet yet had the punch of the vinegar, a masterful fusion of flavor. Let me just say that Marissa, our busy waitress, is the kind of person you want in a restaurant. She was able to meet the needs of all eight of us in a a delightful manner. In fact, she was such a great waitress that my group applauded her near the end of our time there. All in all, my first time at Martell's means it won't be a my last. read more

Had THE BEST dinner we have had in Kalamazoo maybe even in Michigan! The service was amazing..never had to ask for a refill or anything actually! Our waitress was so sweet and was training another lovely server. We sat right in front of the fireplace and looked out on the water which was so beautiful! It was cozy and quaint! We started with the crispy Brussels sprouts as an appetizer and they were perfect! I think my husband wanted to lick the plate. I had the filet which was cooked perfectly and melted in my mouth! My husband had the shrimp pasta which was just mouth watering. This is our new favorite spot..Izzie the Chef came out and she was just so kind and beautiful! We couldn't rave about this hidden gem in Kalamazoo..so happy we found our perfect date night spot! LOVE Martell's!!! (PS this was our first time here! We can't wait to go back!) read more

See all

Driving into the establishment is a delight! As it is surrounded by a lot of scenic areas to walk around, sit outside, and watch the water! I like the seating how it overlooks the water and the bar area is cozy. We got the MUSHROOM TOAST- it was quite flavorless but the bread that came with it was yummy! The SMOKED BRISKET RAVIOLI had a wonderful sauce and it came with 6 so it was perfect for our table. The WHIPPED GOAT CHEESE was the winner of the appetizers! The entire table loved it. I got the ARUGULA salad with salmon on top and the grilled salmon filet was perfect! Flavorful and didn't even need the side of lemon. We ordered the WEDGE salad and it was okay. The SUMMER BERRY SALAD had a great dressing and you cannot go wrong with it! The MUSHROOM SOUP was pretty similar to the mushroom toast just more soupy, but delicious! The biggest portions were CAPELLINI with about 4 shrimp on top, and the HALF ROASTED CHICKEN. Now the half chicken had fantastic flavor with a lot of vegetables under it. I will order it again sometime! For dessert, we got CANNOLI which was pretty big, and the CHOCOLATE TORTE which was gobbled up so quickly I wasn't even able to sneak a bite! The snickerdoodle martini was an exact replica of a snickerdoodle. All in all, we had a great time. It was Mother's Day at 5 pm so naturally the staff were pretty whooped by the time we got in. We ordered a bottle of Sauvignon Blanc and enjoyed ourselves. read more

See all

Martell's has a charming ambience and is absolutely a fixture in Kalamazoo. In the summer, it's airy and you can enjoy the views out the big windows and in Winter, the big fireplace always hits it. You look around at the crowd, and you know these folks have been coming here for years. Watch out for prom season and homecoming. Service is always friendly, spot on, never pushy to move you along. The food for my family just never really hits the spot. We've been there three times over the past couple years and it's always just not quite good enough for the price. Our most recent trip was for my Birthday this past weekend, during no-man's time between Christmas and New Year's. It's pretty representative of our previous trips as well. Wine list is good, but they surprisingly didn't have any Zinfandels. The Rioja blend I settled on was fine. My wife found good Pinot Grigio. We had a shrimp and scallop appetizer, which was two quarter sized scallops and three larger shrimp. You can always complain about scallops being too small, so I wasn't too verklempt over this and the red sauce was tasty. We ended up enjoying that red sauce on our table bread for longer than on the seafood. I had their prime rib (middle size, medium rare doneness.). It was a very fatty cut. A playing card deck size chunk of fat on one end and a 1" thick edge down the length of what was left. It looked like 30-40% of my steak was garbage. The seared edges of the cut were about 1/2" of very overcooked and overly salty meat. What remained looked the right color, but was tough to cut. I thought the skin on mashed potatoes and sautéed vegetables were quite delicious. My wife had an Orecchiette Pasta that was cooked nicely al dente, which is important because they serve West Michigan Pasta and Provisions products. And yet, maybe there was more garlic than emphasized in the sauce ingredients or something like that because she left feeling sick to her stomach for about 12 hours. The food just doesn't live up to the expectations here, or at any of the Millennium Group restaurants in the area. Service and ambiance, as usual, were well done. read more

Jodi in the bar is the attraction here! Great drinks and knows everyone! The restaurant reception staff is at times not friendly but the food is always great and waitstaff good! Could be more welcoming! Go visit Jodi!! read more

Looking for a new place in KZoo and was craving Italian, ended up here. Service was fantastic, sat at the bar. Sounded like a lot of regulars around me. The mushroom soup was great, I'd like it a tad thicker but flavor was spot on. Went with the rigatoni, and wanted some ital sausage as well. Pasta and sausage were both 5/5. Bolognese sauce was 3 ish. I did like the bread rolls that come with the dinner. Had 2 glasses of the house wine - very nice, but pricey. There is no question I'll be back. But, when the 2 glasses of wine is more expensive than my entree with add on and soup, that's an issue. Food and service is solid. Next time I'll stick with a sandwich and a draft, but it will still be good. read more

Martell's - New American Near Me - Kalamazoo, Michigan

The food was incredibly tasty, probably the best steak I've had this year and the dessert was to die for. The atmosphere was great, and our server was top-tier. We will definitely be back. read more

Good service. Very attentive. I got the Cesar Salad with chicken the chicken was over cooked. Very Dry.

Always a great time at Martell's. The patio is so beautiful, waiter was very nice and prompt, and food was PHENOMENAL!

I live in Chicago and was looking for a venue in Kalamazoo for my daughter's baby shower. Wow, did I get lucky! Jess, the event coordinator, was absolutely amazing. There wasn't a question I had that she didn't answer, and she kept assuring me that she'd take good care of us. Wow, she sure did. The room was wonderful and warm, the food was amazing and the team she had taking care of us were fantastic. I've never gotten so many compliments for a party. Cannot recommend Martell's highly enough! read more

Very good prime rib and view of lake. It was very tasty and enjoyable to enjoy with my wife. read more

Martell's - New American Near Me - Kalamazoo, Michigan

We have always made Martell's the restaurant for us to get Prime Rib and Mushroom soup. It has been about a year since we were last able to visit. I noticed the recent reviews were not good as in the past. But having been here many times I disregarded them. Unfortunately we were very disappointed on this visit as well. The Prime Rib was cold and not as flavorable as it used to be. No aujus was served with it. We were told it is drizzled lightly on the plate and then the prime rib is placed on the plate. The vegetables (barely 1/3 cup) that were served with the prime rib were hidden under it. Did not even see them until nearly through eating we thought they forgot the vegetables. Also there was not any aujus on the vegetables so how could it have even been put on the plate? Rolls were not served with the prime rib this time, we had to ask for them. My husband's french fries were cold when served. The mushroom soup was excellent as always. The server never asked if we wanted refills of water or drinks. We felt as though she was agitated having to wait on us. Maybe because we asked why rolls and aujus were not served with the prime rib. We did not mention to her that the food was served cold, we just let it go not sure if it would have mattered to her or any other employee working there anyway. I know restaurants are having issues getting help now. But when you pay $68.00 for a prime rib dinner and it is served cold, no aujus, no rolls and not even a dinner salad well you would expect to receive a decent meal and service. So sad! No matter how much I love the mushroom soup.......we will probably not be back. read more

Value, Service, & and Quality make up all my reviews. So in this case I would do 3 stars across the board, meaning I would try it again. I have been here before with very good results. I'm not sure if it's inflation and thin resources but it left me a little disappointed based upon my past experiences here. I had the sausage rigatoni and added a meatball but it was light on flavor, outside of garlic, and rather dry all together. I needed to request more sauce, which was different than the rigatoni. Also did not provide any bread with our soup, even when requested. read more

Martell's - Rigatoni- I added the meatballs - New American Near Me - Kalamazoo, Michigan

Went to celebrate a 30th birthday, our waitress was very welcoming. The fresh pastas and mushrooms really stood out, we've never had mushrooms with such exquisite flavor. The scenery was so beautiful and elegant with the glass windows and lake right outside. read more

I hardly ever write reviews , but... First time in Michigan ever, stopped for a bite to eat and a glass of wine here and fell absolutely in LOVE with this restaurant. A completely serene environment out on the outdoor terrace with impeccable views of the water & flourishing green trees. My server, Nick, was attentive, kind and down to earth. He made exceptional recommendations which I tried all of. From the decadent red blend wine from Spain, to the house mushroom soup, then pork milanese, finished with a rich chocolate torte. 11/10 experience, any time I am in town I will certainly return. If you are in the Kalamazoo area, take the time out of your day to try this place. You won't be disappointed read more

See all

We went as a couple of four, with two tabs. We ordered at the kiosk. We let them know we were at the same table,and they said no problem. We got three of our four drinks. After 15 minutes of waiting, I went and asked the woman who took the order about the fourth drink. Oops! Her bad. In the meantime,while I was asking about my drink, our companions got their salads. We waited another 15 minutes with no salads. I went back up. I was assured our salads would come. After waiting another 15 minutes, our salads did come and then five minutes later, our pizza. Our friends pizza did not come until after hours. If a restaurant is going to have you go up and order at a kiosk/ bar, the timing of food delivery is important when you're in a group of four- wasn't a big group. Also the salads were quite basic as far as the Caesars, unlike what we usually get inside. The pizza was good. The timing was terrible with everything. I think there were at least 4 to 5 servers standing waiting for food delivery when perhaps it would be better to use them as service staff. I was very disappointed in Martell's tonight. It's a lovely space outdoors. It needs to be run better. Other tables never got their salads.... read more