Went there twice... at 11:30 and then at 1:30 Store was empty, order 2 slices each time.. Not sure how Floridians like their pizza But I like mine HOT... And it couldn't have gotten cold from the store to the car.. Overpriced, cold, and really, not that tasty .... read more

Mark Anthony Pizza is a little tucked away but it's well worth it. Got my first pie and it was outstanding.. truly a New York style pizza. Crust was nice, thin and crispy and the sauce was beyond good. I don't think you'll be disappointed stopping here. As Arnold Schwarzenegger always said I'll be back. Thank you for a great pie Mark. BTW The grandma's pizza knocks it out of the ballpark. read more

Mark Anthony Pizza - Pizza pie - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Florida

Ordered a gramma sausage, mushroom and black olive. Good things first; the crust gets a 5 hands down. Best pizza crust I've had in Florida. Unfortunately that's where it ends. Sauce looked like watered down marinara, Sausage should be chunks of italian sausage not an italian hot dog sliced up, toppings were sparse and who puts canned mushrooms on a pizza? Gross. The pizza had a good garlic flavor but everything else seemed flavorless. Maybe it was an off night but I'm not willing to plunk down 30 bucks again to find out. read more

I recently moved to this area from Philadelphia and all I can say is ... if you're looking for good pizza THIS. IS. THE. SPOT. The pizza here was better than some of the pizza I could get back home in all honestly. The crust was crisp and the sauce to cheese ratio was great. I am more than happy to keep supporting this place that gives me a small piece of home. read more

Mark Anthony Pizza - Hawaiian pizza with bacon and ham - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Florida

Hell yeah! Now this is pizza Spring break 2021 Florida You have no idea ‍ how much we miss NJ/NY pizza we don't have this in Georgia. This is how you know a true pizzeria I worked at one in NJ for years and yes I know how to make a pizza The fun we had ahh the memories dancing to freestyle sorry back to the present 1. Sells by the slice 2. Sells Calzones 3. Garlic knots $0.75 each 4. Antipasto salad 5. Stuffed shells/Manicotti Last but not least has to have "Anthony" in the name 100% legit read more

Mark Anthony Pizza - Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Florida

See all

Enjoyed our second Mark Anthony dinner last night...a meatball calzone and it was as delicious as our first meal...the grandma pizza!! This is some of the best Italian fare I've had in years and that's saying something coming from an Italian-American. Can't believe it's taken me so long to find this amazing spot, considering we've both been around these parts for years. Buon appetito!!! read more

The is the best pizza around! Mark Anthony's has the best flavor and is always consistent!

Phenomenal dough, good people, awesome spot. As close to a NY slice as it gets.. two years of living in the area, dozens of tries, never disappoints, genuinely. Good job and thank you good sir! read more

I'm so disgusted and praying no I'm in my family gets sick. Ordered from here because of the ratings, but the ratings are not true. This pizza is overly greasy, tastes awful, is NOT NY pizza-- I don't know what this is. Spent $75 on multiple pies and one kid is already in the toilet, I'm nauseous ... it's going to be a long night. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE read more

Mark Anthony Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Florida

Pieces are delicious. Pizza is homemade all the toppings are excellent. Best pizza in Springhill.!!

Best pizza and amazing service!! Cheese raviolis are amazing and the cheese on the pizza is to die for I always get extra!

Not the best, just moved to area and it wasn't great, unfortunately hubby and I got sick. I unfortunately would not recommend was fooled by the reviews. read more

Authentic NY Pizza and Garlic Knots. Found this place 8 months ago when I moved down here from New England. The pizza is always consistent, and you can tell when fresh ingredients are used. The staff is friendly. The restaurant itself only has a take out counter and two or three small tables for two. So if your a family of 4, take it home. read more

old school NY style pie.. oily and addicting.. no frills.. just good pie with the original rays vibe. read more

Fresh pizza!!! NY style, cheese, crust, sauce all have good taste. Better than most in town read more

Definitely NY style pizza. Tried several places in this area and Mark Anthony hit the spot. Their cheese pizza is Thin crusted and the sauce was on point! Their Sicilian was amazing true thick crust. The antipasto salad had so much meat in it. Their price is amazing too! Very nice owner. read more

See all

Mark Anthony's pizza will never disappoint you. If you are craving delicious, real, freshly made pizza, this is the place. They are always so friendly and welcoming . Food is always delicious and made just as you order. Prices are amazing! Best pizza around! read more

Mark Anthony Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Florida

See all

first time back in awhile. 13.00 for 3 item 16" pie. not unreasonable. pie was very good. they do have a one item special for 10.99. but we liked the pizza. always the best in spring hill. was hard to navigate the road next to checkers at night. there is a back road much easier. but worth the effort. never disappoints. read more

Very good pizza. I tried the slices. 2 of them a dollar each. Pizza was excellent. It was not to thin or thick. The Sicilian and garlic knots were very enticing. I will come back and share an extra large with friends for $6.95. Very friendly staff!!! I shall return :) read more

See all

Best pizza I have ever had hands down! Definitely will be back can't wait to try Grandmas pizza, ravioli and calzones next

Not that much to the menu. Pretty pricey! Food was pretty good. Way too expensive though.

The worst pizza I ever had from a pizzeria. This guy had the audacity to charge $4 for a little slice that was horrible. If you're looking for the worst pizza in Spring Hill go to Mark trash Anthony's. He try's to pretend that he comes from NY and knows what good pizza is. He is a pretender that wouldn't last 2 days in NYC. I wouldn't be surprised if this place goes out of business soon. read more

My son-in law's birthday and he wants calzone. Noted that he's also a professional chef. Saw that they had really good ratings so took the plunge. One word, wow!! We were all in food comas after eating the "everything" thin crust, Sicilian style cheese and family size calzone with pepperoni. He picked apart the calzone and admitted that it was better than his! We will be back! Best pizza I had anywhere in Tampa! read more

Called and asked for delivery, female answered the call and said " no we don't deliver" then I was like " hmmm yelp says/shows you deliver" female responds with " nope we don't so ???" Well with that reaction or interaction made me and my wife say well we won't ever call or try this place again, we also agreed we will let people know of our experience with Mark Anthony Pizza maybe the person was having a off or bad day but I was willing to purchase a product from your establishment but word of mouth is more powerful then this social media outlet, I'm just sharing our first and last experience with this establishment.. will try and attach photo showing delivery and take out.. wanted to try and find a pizza like back home in Boston since we just moved to Spring Hill from Boston Massachusetts !! read more

Mark Anthony Pizza - Proof that yelp shows this establishment delivers and has take out also.. - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Florida

Ordered an Everything Pizza and must say, it is delicious! Some of the best pizza I've had! Definitely a must in Spring Hill!

Great pizza - nice neighborhood place - feels like the real, old time pizza shops - NY style!!! Love it!!!

I tried this place based off of some of the positive reviews and I'm so glad that I did. The pizza tasted just like I was used to being from NJ/NY and the portion size was outstanding. I had leftovers for 3 days!! I will definitely be returning back here again and I look forward to trying different menu items. read more

Grandmas style. Held the garlic and oregano. Simply excellent. Crust. Sauce. Both perfect. Best pizza in area by far.

Spring Hill has alot of great New York style pizza places but this is by far the best one. The owner worked at a shop in NYC before he moved down here and definitely took whatever he learned to heart because this place is outstanding!! They do slices or whole pies. No delivery but it's not an issue because they're so fast and efficient! read more

Never even got to have the pizza. When I called, I was told they only delivered through Grub Hub. However I was unable to bring up the restaurant on Grub Hub. So I called Mark Anthonys back so that I could give then my order and they could call Grub Hub and they refused. I am astonished and absolutely furious!!! I will never frequent this restaurant. They have lost my business. We just moved down here and order a lot of pizza. Too bad. read more

Omg this pizza tastes so good whatever the sauce on the pizza is I'm hooked! The owners so nice too ! Best pizza in Spring Hill at an amazing price read more

Mark Anthony Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Florida

This is our favorite hometown pizza place! The price is right and it is definitely good! I'm not from New York actually never been but this southern girl likes this pizza best around here. The owner is very friendly and our family truly enjoys supporting a local business. read more

Marc Anthony's pizza is a classic style and they are pretty consistent with their quality. One of my top 3 pies ever. Fun place. Chaotic and full of energy. Great place to cheer you up and remind you of how great it is to be alive. read more

Delicious pizza for a great price!! You can't beat it. I get the cheese pizza every time, so I cannot speak for everything else they have to offer. read more

We ordered for the first time, the guy was really friendly and the pizza was amazing!! This will now be our place to get pizza! It tastes like we are back in New York!! read more

Mark Anthony Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Florida

Native Italian New Yorker- and I have to say this is some of the BEST NY pizza ever! I'm not sure why the one star dude is so angry over their non-delivery status, pizza is worth the drive in price and flavor. They have amazing garlic knots too! read more

Great, cute little place. Fast, friendly, super reasonable prices!! Will be going back. read more

Mark Anthony Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Spring Hill, Florida

Mark Anthony Pizza is at top of our list for pizza or anything from the menu is excellent. Always- consistent and never disappoints. Great food and a great price. Pizza -sauce crust -toppings always fresh and taste great! It's the best! read more

They gave me a pizza that a customer had brought back because they gave them the wrong one. Then just handed it to me like it was no big deal. The pizza left the premises and was on the way home with the customer before turning around and returning the pie, unsanitary and gross. It's a shame because we order from there quit a bit, but not anymore. read more

Low overhead, single proprietor, independent, attention to quality and simply a great place to eat in and or carry out. Reasonable prices and Pizza you'll enjoy. Voted Best Pizza in Hernando County this year in his 1st entry. read more