Mario's pizza shop is like stepping into a very traditional Italian experience I have often arrived early for my order and have enjoyed listening to the different conversations and soaking in the tasteful decor. The staff makes you feel right at home and often engages you in conversation while you are waiting. The staff also seems to take great pride in their community and is often a source of great things upcoming and happening! My favorite dish would have to be pretty simple and that is their cheese pizza if I am feeling very fancy, I may add the mushrooms, but again the pizza itself is so authentic and great. I don't feel the need to venture or mess with a perfect combination of flavors for a very reasonable price these days! My kids also enjoyed sitting in the boost as they were nice and cozy, and always a lively and upbeat experience! read more

Mario's for the win!!! Unassuming Pizza Star After an early family party, my husband and I were hungry and wanted a snack, before we watched a movie for the night. Was on my drive to Walmart to just pick up something and detoured in seeing Mario's light on. Came in deliciously clutch!! Time was after 8pm (maybe closer to 9pm) The pizza was made fresh and to order, a cheese with mushrooms. Chit chatty staff. Ok, don't look around inside, lolol, but found the food wasn't a risk. But a reward. Brought the pie home & was so excited for my find, and ourselves we ate almost the whole pizza. It was crunchy, not too cheesy, neutral sauce- just a Good pizza sauce, and fresh mushrooms. Fun at-home date night supported by Mario's!! read more

The location did re-open as new business "Philly Jawn" sandwich shop + Italian market in July 2026. Today 2 months later they announced on Facebook that they are shutting down. read more

This place has outstanding pizza! Great crust and cheese. I never get plain pizza, but I would have eaten two more slices. Don't expect a pleasant greeting or plush surroundings; just great pizza. read more

Joe's pizza is old school and traditional and is the best pizza in Berks County! We have been eating it since 2004.

Ive been going to Mario's since I was a little kid. Joe is an icon and has been serving some of the best pizza for 50 years. Service is always top notch. Sad to see him retiring soon. This place is a gem read more

I tried to visit here today and the place appears to have shut down. Very dirty windows and a closed sign in the front window.

Offered me a free stay out of the snow storm while my cars windows were being tinted I bought some wings and invited a buddy to eat as well he ordered cheese steak and fries we both enjoyed the experience. read more

Thanks Joe!! You still got it! Haven't been here in awhile but I promise I won't wait so long to come back. Thank you again Joe. read more

Mario's Pizza Shop - Large pepperoni pie! - Pizza Near Me - Boyertown, Pennsylvania

Best pizza in the area ! Boyertown's best kept secret . Cheese steaks are awesome too.

Didn't want to cook tonight and wanted pizza so asked the hubs to pick up a pizza from Mario's. We are long time Mario's customers, but this time was really exceptional! The crust was yeasty and full of bubbles and the sauce was full of flavor with just the right amount of cheese. Had to be the best we ever had. Go to Mario's, it's worth the wait! read more

We were out antiquing the other day and needed a bite to eat. We happened to upon Mario's and my gosh...we are so glad we stopped in. We have lived all over the world and this pizza is some of the BEST we have ever experienced. (I ask for mine "well done" and it is perfection!) If you aren't in the mood for his amazing pizza, try a hoagie or his chicken meals. Can't go wrong. read more

Mario's is a good place to eat he always had great food always gave me a extra slice of pizza or a extra drink he has been in business for a million years also! read more

Mario's The owners are from OLD-Brooklyn, NY sounds like straight from ITALY, speaks 5 languages They make their Dough daily, I worked in 4 *** Rest Boston MA, This PLACE Real-Deal, yes it's old inside Never judge book by its cover!!! You will miss-out on some of the BEST Pizza...My son made me try this PLACE, regret we waited so long it's AMAZING we-buy the sicilian rectangle PIZZA sometimes takes 30-45-mins because we LIKE Well-done!!! Worth the WAIT!!! Christine S read more

We got pizza from here first (take out) and were waiting forever. Tried again and got a sandwich to go- it was good but I almost didn't eat it after seeing the inside of the place- looks like a third world country. The counters are cluttered with dirty dishes and food containers, no AC and no gloves in sight. It doesn't look clean or at all organized. There are plenty of other establishments for pizza and hoagies around. read more

Wow. It doesn't look like much, but don't let that fool you. The food here is excellent. We got a large pizza (meatballs/cheese) and a large Italian Stromboli. When you order large here, you get LARGE. The portions are huge. I am from CT, and I know good pizza. The sauce was excellent, the cheese generous, and the crust was soft, thin, and delicious. The guys are friendly and nice. It looks like COVID has hurt their business a little (take out only right now), but I highly recommend Mario's read more

5 stars for the pizza. Never had anything else from here but the pizza is just the way I like it. The place definitely looks old and tired but that doesn't matter to me. The guy who makes the pizza also looks old and tired but that doesn't matter to me either. What does matter is that he knows what he's doing when it comes to making pizza. He's not some punk kid who decided to start making pizza with food supplies from Sysco, I.e. the pizza will taste like every other white boy pizza shop. Don't let the dreary atmosphere inside deter you. I rarely see too many people eat in and there is generally lots of take out. I'll have to try an Italian hoagie to see how it goes. read more

The pizza was good and the medium Italian was delicious! We were happy to have stopped by here! It looks old and run down but definitely worth a stop! The employees/management were extremely friendly and nice! Definitely will stop by again if I'm in the area!! read more

Been going to Marios since I was a kid, Joe the owner is old world Italian and makes the best food . I visit there several times a week when I am in the area. He is struggling due to the economy in Boyertown so if u want awesome food, especially pizzas and hoagies...go here and support his business read more

How does Marios have NO reviews? I adore Marios and I live on the other side of the country. When we fly here (growing up it was very frequent-almost once a year) Marios is one of the first things on my mind. Over the years I have eaten Marios pizza Several times and it is consistently excellent. Not like anything I can get here. Afted a recent trip I remembered that I had not reviewed this place. For pizza, this is as good as it gets. Solid cheeses, awesome basil-y sauce, and fantastic crust with just the right amount of chew. read more

Anyone who has been to Mario's knows just how great this place is. The food is awesome. The staff is great, especially Joe. This is the best pizza around. Just remember this is a cash only place. NO checks, debit or credit cards are ever accepted. read more

I've been going to Mario's since I was a little kid and remember when he first opened on philly ave where panda garden is now. Joe is a first class guy and he has the best pizza in town. read more

We love Marios. It's a great pizza and sub shop. Joe is great! He's very warm and outgoing. He is very proud of his establishment. CASH ONLY!!! read more

I put a search in for best Pizza in Boyertown and Mario's came up number one. When I arrived the Pizza order was incorrect. It is easy to confuse Pepperoni for Peppers over the phone. Then when I handed my credit card they told me cash only. They sent me across the street to the ATM. I was thinking this Pizza better be really good since I was charged $3.00 for the ATM fee. Well I was really impressed when I picked up the box and it was really heavy. I thought this pizza must be huge. Not only was it huge, it was fantastic! Nice crust, generous toppings, good cheese! When I paid for my order they gave me a price break since they made an error. I will now be ordering my Pizzas here. They most definitely do have the BEST pizza in Boyertown! read more

How this place has stayed in business so long amazes me. Lousy food, rude owners, horrible ambiance, (even for a pizza shop) not to mention uncomfortably hot, and to top it off they only accept cash. With the many other pizza options, only blocks away, i cant see any reason to go back to marios. read more

I've been eating there for over 25 years! The owner will always remember you and greet you with a smile! I live 2000 miles away and still make an effort to get there as often as possible! Mario's has the BEST pizza and Italian steak sandwiches you'll ever find...... read more