Carmelo's Pizza

Mario's pizza shop is like stepping into a very traditional Italian experience I have often…read morearrived early for my order and have enjoyed listening to the different conversations and soaking in the tasteful decor. The staff makes you feel right at home and often engages you in conversation while you are waiting. The staff also seems to take great pride in their community and is often a source of great things upcoming and happening! My favorite dish would have to be pretty simple and that is their cheese pizza if I am feeling very fancy, I may add the mushrooms, but again the pizza itself is so authentic and great. I don't feel the need to venture or mess with a perfect combination of flavors for a very reasonable price these days! My kids also enjoyed sitting in the boost as they were nice and cozy, and always a lively and upbeat experience!

The location did re-open as new business "Philly Jawn" sandwich shop + Italian market in July 2026…read more Today 2 months later they announced on Facebook that they are shutting down.

Sign and hours of business

See all

Large pepperoni pie!

Josh's Pizza

3.6(34 reviews)

0.2 mi

Every Friday we enjoy stopping and getting a delicious sandwich! The new angry josh steak is a…read morewonderful addition to the menu! We just had one and I could eat some more! Thanks joshy!!

Solid Freaking Pizza! First time in a long time for Josh's…read moreand we did NOT have disappoint. Went for an old standby- a large cheese pizza. And some additional garlic knots. The pizza, really good initially and as leftover. Doughy crust with crisp. Didn't cause a lot of chew. The pizza was sliced into well proportion. Cheese to sauce ratio was well done. Saucy was tomato - no acid, no sweet, easy tomato. Not too oily overall. The garlic knots were a delight! This thing could feed the family itself, lolol. (We actually ate them for 3 days.) Garlic, butter, oily and puffy! Super Yum! A terrible, delicious carb feast. We will certainly have Josh's again. Easy, good pizza!!!

This 1/2 half of a Large 12" cheesesteak with coopersharp and fried onions

Garlic Knots

See all

Argento's Pizza & Family Restaurant

3.5(63 reviews)

0.7 mi

Went with the veggie white pizza. Pretty good. A touch of ricotta would been nice but I'm not…read morecomplaining. Will be back to try some of the other specialty slices.

Argento's is our go to for pizza. The pizza is always great. We usually use the drive through and…read morethe service is always quick and easy. We have eaten inside, a few times, and the dining room is clean and pleasant.

Argento's Pizza & Family Restaurant - Menu

Comfort food

See all

L'insalata perfetta!

Iezzi's on 3rd

3.3(61 reviews)

0.2 mi

This place is great, nice atmosphere, good food. Nice local…read morecrowd and staff is very attentive and friendly. People who have a problem with the staff here likely have a problem most places, lol

I've had a lot of bad restaurant experiences, but this one takes the cake for sheer absurdity…read more We've been coming here for years to celebrate a family member's birthday. This visit ends that tradition. I ordered a veggie grinder. No tomato, no mayo -- that's it, that was the entire modification. My server, who I want to be very clear was fantastic, confirmed she understood exactly what I wanted since she's vegetarian herself and orders the same thing. What arrived was a bun with cheese, pickles, and peppers. Not a "vegetables" sandwich by any definition. When I pointed out this wasn't even close to what I ordered, my server went back to have it corrected -- a completely reasonable ask for a mistake that was 100% on the kitchen. She came back looking rattled and told me the kitchen had yelled at her and refused to remake it, and that I should just pick something else instead. Let that sink in: the kitchen botched an incredibly basic order, got asked to fix their own mistake, and responded by berating their own server and stonewalling the customer rather than just doing their job. This isn't a case of a complicated substitution or a busy kitchen slammed during a rush. It's putting vegetables on a sandwich. The fact that the staff back there couldn't manage that -- and then had the nerve to act put-upon when asked to correct it -- tells you everything about how that kitchen is run. Whoever is managing that line needs serious retraining, because right now they're making their front-of-house staff absorb the fallout for their own incompetence. The server deserves a raise for keeping her composure under pressure. The kitchen deserves to have their heads examined. After years of celebrating birthdays here, we won't be back -- and I'd think twice before ordering anything that requires the kitchen to follow basic instructions.

Fish was tasteless and mushy.

See all

Tavern Classic w onion rings and a side of Iezzis sauce

The Other Farm Brewing Company

4.0(144 reviews)

0.0 mi

Food is amazing, service is fast and friendly…read more.... it's very loud in the dining room , but nice , clean and comfortable for a brew/ restaurant. original vegetarian options !! we visited on a saturday at lunchtime and it was very busy ( loud). service was prompt and friendly . drinks within 5 minutes and apps out less than 10! we had their homemade mustard and pretzel sticks ( beer cheese on the side), and truffle fries . both are delicious. i ordered the asian style salad and it blew me away how biggggg! and delicious it is . the kim chi and mushrooms are a delicious blend with fresh cabbage , edamame and spinach and other fresh garden delights. my son had tradition kids meal fries and burgers and ate all of it sooo must be good lol! lots of options for food for everyone and nice adult beverage selection of beer hard cider (local) and cocktails definitely a gem in a small town that you need to check out

Food was not very good. Brussel sprouts were very greasy and had fries and onion rings in them (a…read morelot)- obviously didn't clear the basket. Service was slow and got mostly everything wrong. Had to ask for plates for apps and silverware.

So Wilde Everything Pretzel

See all

Marco's Pizza

3.3(56 reviews)

1.0 mi

My boys & I wanted a late night Sicilian Pie. Marco's stayed open late for us! Great service!…read moreSicilian pie was AmAzing! Reheating a slice was almost better yet Third time I ordered their Italian Hoagie, their homemade hoagie roll is out of this world! I'll need to ask for white onion versus purple onion Marco's put on their hoagie and some meat too next time. Highly *recommend Marco's over any hoagie shop in Boyertown. Talarico's was the BEST, so glad we've finally found a replacement

As a vegetarian I was served food that unexpectedly had ham in it and when I shared that I was a…read morevegetarian I was told well at least now you know how it tastes! Appalling!!

See all

Sicilian Delite Pizzeria & Ristorante

3.7(14 reviews)

0.4 mi

Pizza bland. No seasoning whatsoever. My dogs like it for the most part…read more Prosciutto sandwich bland. Prosciutto cut WAAAY too thick. They did give extra so I'll make my own otherwise not good. Fries came with it. Should be given the option for chips. Fries cut way too thick and no potato seasoning tasting. Prosciutto cut WAAAAY to thick in case you missed that. Tried it. Do not recommend it. Won't go back there again. Shoulda stuck to Thanksgiving leftovers and saved $30

Delivery: we used yelp and was on time exactly about 40 minutes…read more food was very hot and fresh . nice sauce and side sauce . mild not too sweet or greasy. was not typical gravy that is heavy meatball flavor that some like although they are named siciliano, out thin crust was Neapolitan like i like ( we are northern Italian). decent crust no flop and cheese was perfect. i don't think it's 00 flour because the crust was i bit dry , but still tasty and thin . my son got fries with cheese on side and loved them . kids meal chicken fingers were same as every local place . garlic knots were good nice flavor and definitely closer to NYC style but not quite as tight and oily like the 00 crust from NyC , much better than most in this area . Definitely recommend them , first time order .

Got a slice of plain pizza. Had absolutely no taste whatsoever. But my dogs loved it.

Sicilian Delite Pizzeria & Ristorante - Cheesesteak and a Garden salad. The beef cheesesteak was delicious and flavorful, the roll could have been filled fuller with meat

Cheesesteak and a Garden salad. The beef cheesesteak was delicious and flavorful, the roll could have been filled fuller with meat

See all

Prosciutto sandwich and fries.

Scotty's Pizza

4.0(5 reviews)

1.0 mi

Great chicken salad and Italian hoagies, quick service and friendly staff. Will definitely be back!read more

Been going to Scotty's since I was a kid. People either love the sweeter sauce or hate it. I love…read moreit! Great hoagies and sandwiches. I'd give 5 stars, but have had several occasions over the years where my order has been messed up. Still right majority of the time.

Carmelo's Pizza of Boyertown

3.3(7 reviews)

0.0 mi

Walked in during a town special event and couldn't leave without a slice. Pizza was really really…read moregood. Definitely will return.

New Owners, New Owners This place is great, excellent food,…read moreall new interior and very clean. Pizza is excellent. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed. Remember new owners.

Doc's Irish Pub

3.0(120 reviews)

1.1 mi

Ordered steam clams angry Irishman awesome food. Service…read moreoutstanding Place was very clean being outside

The best Wings ever!!! Can't get enough of their teriyaki crispy wings!! unfortunate however, they…read moreeased up on their sweet teriyaki sauce that used to smother the wings! Also, unfortunate they add a little too much heat to the teriyaki sauce :(

French dip with house made coleslaw

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Angela C.

2 years ago

Food was delicious and the atmosphere was pleasing. We received our food quickly and it was hot. Servers were friendly. Will be back again.

Jean B.

3 years ago

Horrible pizza The establishment is so dirty and disgusting I will never go back It's the worst place in town read more

Mary G.

6 years ago

This place never disappoints! Not only is the food great, the staff is so friendly! This is my go-to.

Athena H.

11 months ago

best place in Boyertown and the most friendliest staff and owners and really really good food

Carmelo's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Restaurants near Carmelo's Pizza

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Coffee near Carmelo's Pizza

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Parking near Carmelo's Pizza

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Desserts near Carmelo's Pizza

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Things to Do near Carmelo's Pizza

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Breakfast near Carmelo's Pizza

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Dinner near Carmelo's Pizza

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Shopping near Carmelo's Pizza

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Burgers near Carmelo's Pizza

BEST of Boyertown, Pennsylvania Movie Theatre near Carmelo's Pizza

Best of Boyertown

Things to do in Boyertown

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Carmelo's Pizza also viewed

Bella Cucina Pizzeria

3.5

(26 reviews)

A pizza place has to be able to produce a good plain pie, and Bella Cucina succeeds in that. We…read morehave been pretty loyal to another shop in the area but that might be changing. First, the crust is excellent. Crisp, thin, and little well done. Crust is about 60% of the equation and they hit it out. The cheese is good, not sure if I detected a blend but heavily mozzarella. The sauce is ok. Honestly, it tastes a little massed produced to me thus the 4 instead of 5 stars. A little too much oregano. Overall, great pie. Not 5 stars but after all this is Perkiomenville. Well done.

There delivery driver legit turned my pizza box vertical before handing it to me n ruined the whole…read morepie me n my kids were just waiting for then when I told him it was fucked up he wanted to ask what the issue was like what do u mean what's the issue kid also dropped my fries on my drive way before picking them up n handing them to me i am repeatedly done dealing with this place n it unprofessional work ways and the point of the fact that the will mess up ur order slash food n give no compensation

Josh's Pizza

3.6

(34 reviews)

Every Friday we enjoy stopping and getting a delicious sandwich! The new angry josh steak is a…read morewonderful addition to the menu! We just had one and I could eat some more! Thanks joshy!!

Mannino's Pizzeria

3.1

(57 reviews)

SOO gooddd omg the cheesesteak is fire the steak cheese and bread really high quality you can just…read moretell!! Love the new location soo pretty and clean

Man this hurts me to post. I love Mannino's and have been going there for years. I was sad when…read morethey closed the old location, but was so happy the reopened right up the road. I wasn't however happy to find out they're no longer doing daily specials, so the Tuesday Cheesesteak went from an amazing $9 Sandy to now $16. It was a really good cheesesteak but I'm not paying double for it. Sad.

The Pizza Box

4.3

(24 reviews)

On our first visit, We ordered an Italian Focaccia and an antipasta salad to share. My brother…read morerecommended the focaccia and I was craving a salad. We got two meals out of the focaccia (order it double cut as it makes it easier to eat). Here we are two days later and we had the salad for dinner not sure how it would show. The lettuce mix was still fresh and crisp. The meat was generous and delicious. We will definitely be back for more salads. Perfect for a warm summer evening.

Pizza, steak sandwiches are great and plenty of variations. The girls that work they are very…read morepolite and knowledgeable. Outside seating

Nicky’s & Sons Pizza

5.0

(4 reviews)

First time we've been there Pizza, cheesesteak and French…read morefries Pizza had great flavor, crust was crispy but pliable in Cheesesteak was outstanding On a corpollede roll. Lots of meat and cheese made to perfection. Fries were amazing. They cut fresh in house (we watched). Next time we will order them hard cooked, but they were delicious as served

Here we go again- more pizza in Boyertown!! But aren't we…read moreblessed as locals to have a pick of many.... And here now with Nicky's & Sons, it's become a fav among many! Have taken too long to take to a review, as now our orders are about 4x over in trying. Each order was prompt for time of pick up, hot and fresh. Highlight and standout goes to the Cheese Pizza. Just a great, solid slice. Not fancy, not greasy, not too cheesy, sauce not too tangy or too sweet. Just there and just GOOD. For Nicky's it is a warm welcome to the neighborhood. You stand out on your own!

Brother's Pizza

3.9

(40 reviews)

I haven't been to Brother's pizza in a while and I was really happy with the pizza I got…read more It was just a medium plain pizza but it was so tasty. The jones hit me again today and they are closed. It will only make it taste better when I finally get it again. The pizza was ready when they said it would be and even though it was a little quiet they were cleaning and making the dining area look presentable. Can't wait to go back

Decent eats at this pizza shop. I ordered an eggplant parmesan sammie and some fries. I did not…read moreanticipate the portion size when ordering. Generous amount of fries. The sammie could have fed two people. Price wasn't bad for the amount of food. There are tables but no table service. You order at the counter and someone brings your food. There are enough seats if you want to stay and eat but most patrons were doing takeout. Counter staff were polite and friendly. The wait time was reasonable considering it was a busy time of day. Would definitely stop again.

Pizza Villa

4.1

(26 reviews)

Said it before and I'll say it again, "the best wedge salad anywhere!"…read more Definitely an entrée salad for sure ! Our regular Pizza restaurant as always!

got take out for my Mom& myself and my as given the wrong entree- the young wonderful mgr not only…read morefixed it with a new entree but she was so understanding and kind. I'll be back again!! Ty ty!!

Sicilian Delite Pizzeria & Ristorante

3.7

(14 reviews)

Carmelo's Pizza of Boyertown

3.3

(7 reviews)

Walked in during a town special event and couldn't leave without a slice. Pizza was really really…read moregood. Definitely will return.

New Owners, New Owners This place is great, excellent food,…read moreall new interior and very clean. Pizza is excellent. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed. Remember new owners.

Little Gio's Pizza Shop

3.5

(55 reviews)