Spending a lifetime in Queens NY the pizza was #1. This place reminds me of the pizza I miss. #1 as far as I'm concerned. Will definitely be back!! FANTASTIC read more

Mario's is my families Friday night dinner, every Friday! We love the food; excellent pizza (and the crust is great). The place itself is a bit dated, but its always clean and the service from staff can sometimes be a bit short, but that's just because they're so busy! Overall a great place. read more

Good service. I had a slice of pizza which was delicious & a dozen of hot wings. The wings were crispy & tasty. My new favorite place in Owego! read more

I go to Mario's or have them deliver about once a month over the past 16 years so I'll base this review on my approximately 192 experiences with Mario's. Always a top notch 100% authentic New York thin crust pizza baked to perfection! Every single time! Now here's where they shine: if you put veggies on your pizza like onions, peppers, olives etc, it's hard not to get a soggy pizza. Not at Mario's, the crust is always crispy, never soggy and in the 200 times I've ordered their pizza, it's perfectly cooked. I probably should have written a review years ago, guess I took this place for granted but man they are a class act. I've eaten inside a few times and the service has always been friendly and prompt. The ambiance is quintessential local pizza joint--wonderful. My employer is about 3 miles away and we always go to Mario's for special lunch events or order for on-site visitors. It's just a well rounded perfect pizza joint and the price is super affordable. Love this place! read more

I been going to Mario's since I was a kid and I can't ever recall getting a bad meal. The service is excellent, and definitely a friendly environment. read more

We love this place. We have been going for years and have never had a bad experience. The dinner portions are huge and food is fresh. We have gotten the pizza to take home many times never disappointed we love it read more

Very rude I asked a question about the price of a sheet of pizza the lady hung up on me

Amazing pizza around our area! We have tried the mild and hot wings both are great. Everything we have tried in past couple years have been great (meatballs, manicotti, spaghetti). Recently I've been diagnosed with celiac and their gluten free pizza is so yummy! All workers have been so friendly! read more

I have never had a bad experience with dining in or delivery! I know plenty of people that would agree on them having the best pizza and staff around! read more

Got the bourbon glazed chicken wings- don't have a picture because they were too good to stop for one! Pizza was delish too- crust nice and crispy & perfect sauce ratio. This was our second time at Mario's and we loved it!!! Will be back for sure. read more

I think this place might have the best NY style pizza in the entire 'Binghamton' area. 2 plain slices & small drink for $5.99 with tax. It's a bad sign when a pizza joint keeps their slice pies in the glass box warmer and then give it to you warm (instead of reheating it & giving it to you hot) but their 'warm' plain slice is still excellent! read more

Swung by quick to grab a couple slices for take out and they were just as good as I remember! Used to frequent this place often when I lived in Owego. Their sheet pizza is top notch, and provides a different style than what you would find at Rossi's or Nirchi's. Next time I'm in town, I'll be dining in to order some wings! read more

Mario's Pizza - Two slices of cheese to go - Pizza Near Me - Owego, New York

My family and I are in the area camping, and we decided to visit Mario's Pizza. We have visited this area many times in the past, but we had never stopped at Mario's. I can safely say that we will be coming back. My father and sister ordered a medium chicken spiedie pizza, and some wings. I ordered garlic knots and a meatball sub. The garlic knots were perfect, just the right amount of garlic salt and other seasonings. My meatball sub was toasted just right and tasted delicious. According to my family, the wings were also great and the pizza was pretty good. As we were eating, we noticed that the place seemed to have a lot of regulars and was very crowded. This coupled with the good food, shows that Mario's is one of the best places to eat around here. We will be coming back again at least once or twice while we are camping here, and if I have any updates for this review I will post them. But for now Mario's gets four stars from me! read more

Local to the area, service was baaad. First thing we get asked "are you guys ready to order?" No offer for drinks/beverages, then only saw her a few other times throughout the dinner. Alfredo and vodka sauce were terrrrible, Alfredo was curdling as I eating. Pizza was super greasy, tasted good tho. Won't be back and don't recommend read more

Great service by friendly staff. Some of the best pizza I have had in Upstate NY! They really offer an amazing all around experience.

I don't think the chicken wings were cooked long enough. My mild wings tasted spicy and my mouth was on fire. On wing night you better eat all the wings there because you get charged full price to take them home. I felt very uncomfortable because it felt I was being stared at by the waitress for almost my entire meal. I won't be returning and will definitely take my business elsewhere. read more

Kind service, typical of a family owned shop. Very reasonable prices. However, the pizza is so-so. The pizza was far too greasy and the crust too thin. On the bright side, the garlic knots were delish! read more

My husband and I love this place and have come here for years. They are a good solid family-based business that have helped our community over and over. They have a comfortable family style seating dining area with Italian festivity decor. Our servers tonight were very friendly and attentive. Our food came out quickly, it was fresh delicious and hot. My husband got the stuffed pepper soup which is his favorite, he loves the spaghetti and meatballs here. Me being gluten-free had the grilled chicken antipasto salad with peppercorn Parmesan dressing. Very nice mixture of vegetables cheese & meat. They have a gluten-free pizza here that is pretty good! My husband also loves their regular pizza, it's been a hit for years and they are consistent. They have great take out too which we usually get for a Sunday treat every week! read more

See all

We come here with family and friends for the bigger gatherings and the pizza is very good! Last time i came the dough was a bit... doughy but it was still good! read more

Very tasty pizza! We loved our white sauce pizza with speedies and can't wait to visit again and go here.

Good food and service! Stopped by here on the way to new jersey, Margarita pizza was yummy

Average Italian for the area....but one outstanding item that we've ordered repeatedly is the Sicilian Style pizza. It's a taste I crave and after many years of missing it and searching for it...VOILA! Mario's has it right!!! Family friendly retaurant with decent food at decent prices. (I wonder if megan t's review is about the sicilian...it is served in a "sheet" form?) read more

Good pizza, but menu (or service?) errors--- why would the deluxe pizza be described on the menu as having anchovies on it when they don't put it on unless you happen to be clairvoyant and know you have to specify that they should be included? Mario's, add a note to you menu. Nice of person at payment counter to offer a side of them to go, very disappointed that the waitress we first asked about it didn't offer that while we still had pizza on our plates. Subs are very dry, whole lot of bread, some filling.. Again, menu says includes oil. No oil on the sub we ordered. Overall, if you don't order expecting to get what is described, the food is really quite good. read more

Mediocre food and terrible service. Go to the Mexican place in town, great service and amazing food!

This is simply the best pizza that you will find anywhere. I grew up in Owego and live in San Francisco, and I come back 2-3 times/year to visit my family. Mario's is a must-have every time I visit. Every element of the pizza is fantastic. Their other dishes are good as well, but if you're passing through Owego, just get the pizza -- you won't regret it. read more

Mario's sheet pizza is like biting a heavenly pizza pillow. Fluffy dough, balanced buttery crust... I can't find anything like it in California and always get it when I'm home. A sheet pizza is the perfect compliment to any party. mmm...i wish i was eating it right now... read more

The prices have gone up quite a bit over the years but the food continues to be good.

Wings are AMAZING! They have the best pizza in the area. I love their pastas & salads.

I grew up in Owego and Mario's pizza and subs has always been there with amazing food at amazing prices

Mediocre food for a high price. I would not recommend this restaurant considering how bad the service was

Great people great prices! Family friendly and welcoming when you walk in. When I vet done with work and my children decide they want pizza instead of the things at the house we can call them up get delivery and have the food very quickly. And their delivery drivers get to know you if you order a lot haha! read more

We go to Mario's quite often and usually we have good service. Well, tonight was not so good. We waited at our table for a good 10 to 15 minutes waiting for someone to bring us a menu. I also have dietary restrictions and usually I can get something with in those restrictions without costing an arm and a leg. I ordered the stuff shells which comes with the marinara sauce, salad, and bread. I Informed her that I could not have the salad, bread, and the marinara sauce. She asked if I wanted soup in place of the salad, after fingering out what soup I could have, accepted it. Then I asked her if I could have Alfredo sauce in place of the marinara sauce and she said I could. She brought me out about a cup of soup and my two stuffed shells (which weren't very big) in Alfredo. The soup was very good, but the stuffed shells not so good. When I got the bill I was shocked. They had charged me $5 for the Alfredo sauce! The cost of just what I ordered came to about $16.70. That's for a drink $2.75, soup & two stuffed shells $8.95 plus $5.00 for the Alfredo sauce. Our total bill came to $43.43. All my husband and son ordered were two small Stromboli's and drinks. The Stromboli's were $9.50 each ($19 total), plus their drinks $2.75 each ($5.50 total). So what they ordered totaled $24.50. We will not be going back and we don't recommend this place. read more

The pizza here is really good. I also like the antipasto salads. I have gotten the Italian sub numerous times and it is my favorite.

The sheet pizza is possibly the best pizza I have ever had. I've never found a sheet pizza that is as good as the pizza here. It's generally pretty fast when you call in to get one. Delicious! read more

Best pizza I've EVER had. Visited upstate; and on our way back we stopped at Mario's, I couldn't stop eating! Had to even search if there was a Mario's on Long Island (sadly no), that's how much I liked it! Waitress was very nice as well. If I ever visit upstate again, Mario's will be a definite! Just wish the prices were lower! read more

i haven't had much from these guys, just pizza and wings. i've stopped in a couple times before and just got a slice of their round pizza, which i thought had a pretty good flavor. a friend of mine from owego always raved about how great their sheet pizza is, so i tried it and i didn't care for it too much. i dunno what it was but something seemed off. the crust is crispier than nirchis but not as crisp as vestal bakery, it seemed a little too bready in relation to the sauce and cheese. i got wings too and the flavor was good, but they could have been more crisp. read more

The food used to be good. They need to stop using the microwave and start using a stove. Anyone who thinks this is good food needs to stop by Rossi's or Tony's. Their pizza is way over priced for what it is. Little Caesar's is better and it's only $5. I remember when their chicken wing pizza was actually made with real chicken wings not cubed veiny chicken breast. I'll never eat there again and I'll tell everyone I know about how bad that place is. They have had their run and now it's time for them to leave the Italian food business to places that know real Italian food. Go to endicott for real Italian. It's worth the drive. But I guess if you don't know good food you might like this garbage. read more

Standard pizza joint, nothing more, nothing less. Reasonable prices and good pizza / italian standards.

Mediocre food....ridiculously small Calzone...don't waste your money...where they shine is their "sheet pizza" as they call it. It's what I know as a Sicilian Pie, and by far is the best around. Prices are ok. Waitstaff is ok. read more

Very good round veggie pizza but the crust can be hit or miss sometimes...not sure what they do inconsistently with it. The eggplant parm sub is very,very good but a bit pricey at $10.00. The place is a locals favorite in Owego as they are always busy. Stop in if you're in the area and try it for yourself. read more