We typically order from the downtown Weirton location, but this store is way closer to us. We placed an order for 8 regular slices with mushrooms on a Friday evening around 8pm. They told us the order would be ready in about 15 mins. The pizza was hot and ready as soon as we showed up. We took advantage of the two 2-seater tables right out front to enjoy a few fresh slices. We thought the crust was perfectly crisp, there were plenty of toppings, and the extra cheese we ordered wasn't necessary, but always adds a little touch to the experience. The interior is small, but organized. You can tell by the set up and the amount of people coming and going that they do a good takeout business. We'll be back, for sure. read more

See all

I placed an order for pick up today and want to send a huge thanks to the man who took and fulfilled our order. I explained we were traveling and he bagged everything separately so we could heat and eat at home! It was just like eating it in the parking lot!!! Delicious!! We ordered 10 slices and a Capo sandwich. Outstanding!! Thank you!! read more

Mario DiCarlo's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Weirton, West Virginia

See all

Went on Saturday on our way to the casino. I walked in and ordered 5 slices for carry out. Had to wait for them to make a fresh tray, so it took a few minutes to receive my food, but let me tell you..... When I say that this was probably the best pizza I've ever had in my life, I mean it with every word. The crust was crispy and hot, the sauce was sooooo good, and the cheese was perfection. The fella that waited on us kept us updated on time, and I really didn't mind the wait. I cannot wait to return for another visit! read more

My favorite pizza in the tri state area!! There are many places that have great Pizza in the area but THIS is my go to!! I remember going to the 3rd Street location in Steubenville Ohio when I was young and waited in line half way down the street!!! It was 10 cents a slice then Still delicious!!! Also had fixed salad and arancini !! read more

See all

They have the best sausage sandwiches in the valley. They also have an excellent antipasto salad with very good house dressing. The service is also very good. read more

Pizza is always good. Pasta salad is best I've had and there limoncello cake is absolutely delicious.

Just toppings easily slide off. Half baked , I mean it it really is half way baked, lol. It is tho better than vocelli and pizza hut. Vocelli is like someone dumped a bunch of salt over it. Rotten....and pizza hut in Weirton is plain gross! They make it with cinnamon and sauce, totally nasty. Wtf is wrong with the Pittsburgh and northern Ohio valley area? God, pizza joint every 14 feet and it's all sh******* read more

Love it. Best ever friendly and courteous every time we have ordered. Would recommend if you're in the area.

Never seen a place like this before. You can't order a whole pie, but the slices are square and small. Order was mushroom & onion but got sausage and pepperoni. Slices were not cooked, cheese was just put on cold, maybe this is how they do it but I wouldn't recommend. read more

Fresh and tasty, crust was nice a crispy. Yummy. The workers were friendly and prices reasonable. read more

Mario DiCarlo's Pizza - Extra cheese, I had one before I remembered to snap a pic. - Pizza Near Me - Weirton, West Virginia

Love the pizza hate the attitude. Employees can't be bothered to come up front to ask you questions and make customers yell across the counter read more

I am a huge pizza lover and I just love this pizza!! It is always ftesh, all of the workers are always very kind, and they are located in a great area! read more

Mario DiCarlo's Pizza - Absolutely my favorite place to get pizza!!! Cheese pizza! Great customer service! - Pizza Near Me - Weirton, West Virginia

is good. Seems to not be as good 2 years ago though. I like the employees at both Weirton WV locations. One of the men that works late at 3 springs is so handsome! I am so happy to be female and live in this area because it's like 70 read more

Mario DiCarlo's pizza in Weirton is my favorite place to grab a tray when visiting from Atlanta! It is always one of our first stops. The pizza is consistent and crispy. read more

I called to order at 4:00 pm... 12 pcs... they said give us 10 minutes? I said OK. I arrived at 4:20 (as fast as I could get there)... it wasn't ready- so I waited until 4:35 and asked what's up? (they were NOT busy at all)... they then said give us another 5 minutes? It was finally ready at 4:45! Instead of 10 minutes it took 45! Anyway, even though it's my favorite and the best pizza in town, I may not return.... There were SIX employees working! Not competent ones... read more

"HAHA, Bro, we don't do that!" -Their response when I asked if they could make a salad without egg for somebody that was allergic to egg read more

Great pizza. Get an extra bag of cheese to throw on. Recommend the desserts also!! All the DiCarlo's I've been to are good.

Ugh No no no Cheese "melts" on your way home in the box Not in Philly!! Must be a local thing Tasted like Ellios in the box from 1975 !!! read more

Hands down my favorite pizza. Always friendly service, and reasonably priced. Also a good selection of drinks and desserts to pick up with your pizza has been added ! read more

As has been my entire childhood, the pizza was amazing. I moved away & haven't been in years, but finally got some DiCarlos when i was around recently. Staff was also so wonderful. I didn't see a name tag but a man who mentioned having a 14 year old son- you are what customer service is about. Such a friendly guy. We will return!!! read more

WHAT PART OF OPEN TIL 12 WAS NOT UNDERSTOOD!!! On a Saturday night, the kids stopped answering the phone at 1130 and turned me away at 1155. If the shop closes at 1130, post the hours of operation correctly so people don't plan around 12 and starve. Bye Felicia read more

Great pizza for the last 16 years. Very consistent. Recently added delicious hoagies and salads to their menu.

First of all. Never had an issue for the 10 plus years I've got pizza from there. For those complaining about not answering the phone, online it'll tell you they close at 12 and stop taking orders at a certain time. I worked in the food industry and I know it's a pain in the ass to close shop and still make food for people that don't know how to tell time nor have courtesy for people and businesses. Friendly people. Can't get enough of the classic pizza. read more

Best DiCarlo's around. I order from here twice a week. Staff is what sets it apart as well. Fast, delicious, and clean.

I am a huge fan of square pizza, and I had their pizza bunches of times. I like the crunchiness to the crust. I also like the idea of putting cheese on it after it comes out of the oven even though the cheese may not stick to a slice when I cut it. Two slices is never enough for me! read more

Love this pizza. Always good service. Sometimes they skimp on peppermint or cheese. Depends who is making it I guess but regardless good pizza. I like that they are trying to expand the menu also. Hope one day they will offer a variety of subs. read more

I have been here twice while visiting Weirton. My mother grew up there and my grandparents are buried in Weirton. The food here is really good! Nice non-pretentious place for solid food. read more

This is the best DiCarlo's in Weirton. Very clean, doesn't have boxes stacked up around the counter so you can't see what's happening in the back (yes, you downtown). They are friendly. Best pizza in the world. Have relatives from Virginia and Cincinnati that come to take home boxes. I'm now in Pittsburgh and crave this pizza. Haven't found a pizza place around Pittsburgh that's even close to this. Yes, they put on the pepperoni after. That's what makes it SO DAMN GOOD. The best places are cash only. read more

A part of any trip even close to home is Di Carlo's. Not much to say here other than it was as good this trip as it has ever been. I went twice while I was home this last time and it was awesome both times. read more

Hand's down the best pizza around. Every time I've ordered from here the pizza has been perfectly delicious. Is there a difference between the Three Springs Drive location and the downtown Main Street location? I don't know. I used to order from the Main Street shop, but now I always order from the Three Springs Drive store because its closer. But both locations have always served up amazing, 5-star worthy pizza every time I've ordered. read more

This DiCarlos is by far the best DiCarlos around! Never bad pizza, always fresh! Get the extra cheese option.

One of my favorite pizza haunts!! Square pizza!! And when they make that Italian bread (oh my). Consistency depends on who is cooking though (hence the 4 stars). read more

Great Italian. Great salads. Exceptional staff. Nice environment which has been updated recently. Looks great.

My family and I are frequent visitors to this DiCarlos. We have driven across state lines to just get pizza here. By far, unanimously our favorite pizza. Chain or mom and pop. Perfect, every time. The associates are always pleasant, the wait is short and the establishment is always clean. Today set the bar higher. When asked how I would be able to take some home for my wife and daughter, the gentleman in the kitchen went above and beyond. Packing the best cheese I've ever had on pizza, separate. Giving tips to recreate the in house taste. But, above all, taking time to help. Today that is the anomaly. This is why we go here and not places that I can walk to. To DiCarlos, I say thank you. read more

Pizza is good. But go downtown. This store doesn't answer their phones. Can't order anything within 2-3 hours of closing if you try to call

This is the best pizza around. You can't find any thing like it. The may be other "Dicarlos" pizza shops around, but I ensure you this is the best. read more

The customer service was absolutely terrible. They were undeniably rude and treated us terribly. They don't even take credit cards... what is this 1995? Who doesn't take credit cards. The pizza was luke warm at best and most likely reheated. Avoid this pizza shop at all costs. read more

The only good thing about this place is the price, you can get a few slices for under $5 which is still too much for this pizza. More time then not there is hardly any cheese on the pizza and its almost always burnt. I moved here a year ago and I can't for the life of me understand how this pizza is popular. read more