We had been eyeing this restaurant for awhile. We usually stop at In-n-out across the street the…read morestreet or See's Candies in the same strip mall. We stopped in on Easter Sunday. The food was awesome I got the Taste of Italy. My wife got the pasta combo. We got the stuffed mushrooms to start off. Those were wonderful. The server was very nice and made sure we were taken care of while we were there. The restaurant was empty when we arrived but there was quite a bit of other people that came in and it was nice to have some talking and laughing to make it more a fun experience for us. I would come here for sure again to try some of the other dishes. There was very nice older lady that greeted us and saw us out when we left which made this a great experience.

We met here to celebrate some of my life long friends Birthdays…read more It's very modern inside and has lots of room. The service was great. The food was great too. I had their Carbonara. It wasn't the best I've had and not the worst. The funny thing is I brought half the of it home because the portions are huge and it tasted better the next day. Your dinner includes a small salad, it was delicious and I used their house Italian dressing which was really tangy and yummy. My favorite thing though were their rolls. I swear I could just eaten about 12 of those! They bring you oil and vinegar for dipping and it was hard to not just drink it with every bite of those delicious rolls. In fact I'm going to call their Salt Lake Location and ask if they sell them separately. They were that good. It's a nice change of pace from the usual Italian restaurants so check them out and get extra rolls!

Stella's did it again! So good. So nice…read more Friday date nite. Only bad was finding a parking spot. .

Went on a Tuesday night and got seated pretty quickly. Service overall wasn't super quick though. I…read moreliked the vibe of the restaurant overall and noticed they played a lot of post modern jukebox music Bruschetta: 4/5 we ordered 2 of these to split between 6 people. The cheese and tomatos were super good but the bread was pretty hard on the outside and inside Shrimp carbonara: 3/5 didn't taste bad but the sauce was too thick and oily for me. This also came with a tomato bisque that I liked a lot

The food is consistently amazing. Closest to real Italian as you can get!…read moreLeave room for desert

Chef Boyardee is better than this place Only good thing was…read morethe service The pasta was way overcooked and swimming and watered down sauce. They chopped up the chicken underneath and slather it and tasteless, sweet sauce. They use no spice whatsoever. Everything was tasteless . And they give you a dinner roll and a so called Italian restaurant? So disappointing. Let's talk about the dessert that the owner is so proud his daughter makes at home. The cake was so dry. It only looked appealing, but the taste was not. I left the owner know we had a reservation and he didn't care and he popped his head up and looked over the room and pointed out a table and said oh there's one. Didn't walk us to the table we set ourselves. He finally shows up with menus and his little tablet to show us a picture of the daily special, and then told us a dumb joke and elaborate on the great wine, which was horrible. Please don't come to this place unless you like to play Russian roulette. Place was full, don't know why. They certainly don't know Italian food and the menu is very limited.

Ordered the gluten free crepe. The crepe batter used was good. I ordered the Magna and it was…read moregood although I wish I ordered something sweeter or maybe asked for nutella on the side.

Cute little shop, we stopped in for some sweet treats. Everything we ordered tasted excellent and…read morethe young lady behind the counter was very nice. My only concern is the place is really dirty. The ceiling fans are caked in dust bunnies and the whole place could use a good scrub down. I hope they do so as we would like to come back.

Food is so good! No matter what we order we love it. My favorite is the ravioli with spicy marinara.read more

It is never bad to say that a restaurant is good. Callaway's is a good place to eat, but the…read moreambiance is more cafe than bistro. My wife had the Fettuccine Alfredo, and I had Eddie's Jambalaya. Had I read the description (being under pasta), I would have realized that the jambalaya was made with pasta, not rice. It still had good flavor. Service was good, but not great.

This is my first restaurant review. If I'm taking the time to leave a review, you better believe…read moreit's because it was either that good, or that bad. I took my wife to Bartolo's on a date, and we enjoyed every aspect. Quick, thoughtful service, and they checked on us regularly. Lots of natural light on the North side of the restaurant where they have glass doors that open up to the outside (they were closed because it was a cold day but make for a pleasant atmosphere). The food was excellent. We ordered the house focaccia and calamari to start. Both were incredible. My wife had the lasagna, and I had the spicy crab campanelle (at the recommendation of our server). The homemade pasta is melt-in-your-mouth good. In terms of cost, it is about what I'd expect from a nice dinner out with my wife. My new favorite restaurant. We will definitely be back.

A dark and classy environment. The decor is great and stays true to the restaurant and its meals…read more Though I believe this place to be pretty overpriced, the food is truly delicious ! Everything comes out fairly quick for all being house-made from scratch. The meals are flavorful and great. There isn't anything on this menu that stands out, everything seems pretty standard for a nice Italian place. Our bread and salad starter were great and we cleared those quick ! I chose the chicken parmigiana and found the marinara sauce to be a bit watery/bland in taste. My chicken was a bit dry so perhaps a bit overcooked. The alfredo that came with it was DELICIOUS, perfectly creamy. However...can I justify $30 for the plate ? No. My boyfriend's spicy sausage a la vodka pasta was delicious but again, the red sauce was lack luster for me. It's almost like it was lacking tomato paste and garlic ? The potato side was delicious and surprisingly large for the price ! The aioli that came with it was great in flavor as well. We finished our meal with a creme brulee. It was perfectly torched and the creme itself was delicious and perfectly chilled. The strawberry was a bit sour for my liking, especially for coming with an expensive dessert. But this dessert was one of my highlights of the meal. Although a nice once-off meal, I find Bartolo's to be pretty overpriced, even for delicious italian dishes. I have had ruth's chris meals for this price and understood why it was priced the way it was.

We love firehouse pizza. We come to Bear Lake every year and we love eating here! This is the first…read moreyear we ordered take out and we're super impressed. Our order was ready in 10 min and everyone was so helpful and pleasant. We got the large Cheese bread, Artichoke Chicken Pizza and Firehouse Combo Pizza.

Took a large group here and was immediately seated and waited upon. Food was prepared quickly and…read moreour server was so nice. I really like the cool resin tables. Best pizzas in Bear Lake!