Folks, if you have not tried the pasta dishes at Manhattan, you are missing out. Best Bet in Town, and you can get Delivered instead of "others" that will NOT. Pizza always good choice but take another look at menu. PS Gelato too.. THANK YOU MANHATTAN PIZZA GAINESVILLE, So Glad you are here. read more

I ordered a manhattan club sandwich with no ham, tomatoes, and substitute provolone for Swiss. An extra large cheese with half sausage. Received a sub with club ingredients on it. I've been ordering here for years and never ever have gotten a sub instead of a club sandwich. The amount of meat on the sub was a bit excessive. Please do better and send club SANDWHICHES and not Club Subs. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Manhattan Club Manhattan Club - Sandwiches Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

Staff is all about the customer! They are welcoming and extremely nice! The slices were all gone and the staff made more pizza! Thank you!!!

I saw some positive reviews for their Cheesesteak so finally I tried one today. i adore a good cheesesteak but this one falls pretty far down the line compared to many other places. The flavor was a bit odd; I think they butter the roll and that's not belonging in a cheesesteak. the meat seemed cheap and I bit into a bb size piece of bone! the roll was almost too soft and full of grease. the sandwich really just fell apart. I won't order this again. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Cheesesteak - Sandwiches Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

I was coming here several times a week, but the food is inconsistent. Sometimes it's great and other times as of lately it's not been good at all. I definitely think it's who's cooking in the kitchen. But I'am super disappointed and won't be coming here so much. read more

I have been eating steak and cheese sub sandwiches for more than 50 years. This by far is one of the best I've had in all that time. The bread is perfect not too crispy not too soft. The steak onions and cheese are delicious and the most crispy onion rings ever I recommend coming here. - Paul G read more

Manhattan Pizza - Two slices of pepperoni and a soda - Sandwiches Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

See all

The food is great. The prices are very reasonable. And the service is fast and friendly. The two slice lunch special is very inexpensive and the slices are massive and delicious!! Five Stars!! read more

Rip off, too expensive. Pizza: Sauce is sweeter, cheese tastes like rubber, crust okay. read more

We ordered from Gainesville and food was ready super fast! Very cheesy The pizzas were packaged well and food was delicious. Softer crust still held up well. Nice Job! We will order again read more

Manhattan Pizza - Cheese Pizza (Medium) - Sandwiches Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

See all

Went today, Sunday early afternoon the place was empty. There was no pick ups coming and going while I was there so I don't quite understand why it took so incredibly long to get a small pizza , over 25 minutes after cashing out. They make a thin chewy style pizza,not what I think of for thin crust pizza.. The staff was pleasant and the restaurant is clean so it's just middle of the road for me. The toppings stopped pretty far from the edge so I don't really think it's a great value at 12:99 for a small pizza with just vegetables . Soft drinks are Pepsi. With that style crust, calzones might actually be interesting, so I'll try it next time. I'm not going to avoid the place, but not going out of my way to get there either . read more

Manhattan Pizza - Close up of veggie pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

Overall, this pizza place is ok. If you like New York style pizza, you may give it 4 stars. The staff were pleasant and this location was clean. However, the crust and the pizza sauce were fairly bland and overwhelmed by the cheese. The pepperoni rolls were just ok - a lot of dough with a little pepperoni. Worth a try if you like cheesy NY style pizza. read more

The food was great - it always is. However, the next time your driver rings my doorbell and walks off, leaving my order on the doorstep after I've already tipped them 20% in advance (we're regular customers), it will be the last time. This is unsatisfactory, and you are *not* DoorDash. I expect better from a restaurant I patronize regularly. Your driver deserves no tip, and this reflects negatively on you. read more

Manhattan Pizza finally opened today in Gainesville, VA! I ordered the cold version of their Italian Sub. It was fresh and tasty! They served it with oil and vinegar on the side. Came with lettuce, tomatoes, banana peppers, and onion on a sub roll. Next time I'll have them add some mayo to the sub. A welcome addition to options for subs/sammiches/pizza in the area! #ManhattanPizza read more

See all

The food is great and they always take care of the customers i suggest a chicken Philly if you like subs it's one of the best I've had around the area and they make them nice and bulky not skimped 10/10 spot read more

Always a fan favorite of my family. Service is quick and the wide variety of food is great when you have super picky eaters. Plus GELATO! Amy and the team are friendly and always make sure the experience is excellent. Plus, they are now doing kids art and craft nights - which is an awesome idea when you are looking for a great dinner with family-friendly activities :) read more

The pizza crust was dry and tough to chew. There was a very small amount of sauce beneath the cheese. And the pepperoni was paper thin, so as to be tasteless. The chocolate cake was likewise dry with a small amount of frosting. The order was so underwhelming that I doubt that I will be ordering again. read more

Very unfriendly and rude counter staff. Asked questions responded was look at the menu. He was too busy talking to his coworker in the little nook with the computer, There was only one table with customers, their order was just sitting on the counter while counter staff was to busy searching the internet to serve customers. Terrible first impression. When I asked for manager the counter staff said he was out on delivery. With this type of service good luck staying in business. read more

I love coming to Manhattan Pizza!!! Dimitri and his team make you feel right at home as soon as you walk into the restaurant. The food is amazing and the service is fast and friendly. The place is spotless, and the menu is incredibly well assorted. I've always said Manhattan has the best pizza in town, hands down. read more

Food isn't bad, pretty tasty but was disappointed with lack of sauce on pizza! What's up with that Manhattan Pizza? read more

Manhattan Pizza - Where is the SAUCE? - Sandwiches Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

Holy cow. Holy COW. I ordered their pepperoni roll for take out and I am beyond satisfied. The roll is crispy with a light crunch on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside and just a touch of CRUNCH from the pepperoni. If I ever unfortunately end up on death row, this would be one of the foods I would request (*knock on wood*). read more

Manhattan Pizza - Pepperoni roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

I've gotten take out from this location over the last year and I'm updating my review to 3 stars. Sometimes the grilled chicken in the Caesar wrap is so dry I have to take some strips out to throw away. The onion rings are mediocre. The pepperoni rolls are so delicious but so greasy they give me a stomachache a lot of the time. My husband loves their calzones. We really don't care for their pizza. Not a fan of the sauce, cheese or crust. The staff here is friendly and take out is easy, but it's not the highest quality food. read more

See all

Best pizza in Gainesville! Never disappoints! Always friendly service and a family-friendly atmosphere!

Anytime I have an event at my house, people always ask for Manahattan Pizza because they really enjoy it. I also like to order the pool special in the summer. read more

Just ordered from Manhattan Pizza. What a disappointment. I don't know what all the hype was about. We waited so long to try it! The pizza tasted like cardboard. It was dry worse then cafeteria pizza when I was in elementary school. I also ordered the wings. They hurt my teeth. They were over cooked, I will never order here again. The brownie was terrible was well... never again..$53 down the drain. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Cheese pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

this place finally opened! went there twice so far and both times have been delicious. got the gyro and fries as well as a pizza since the place is called Manhattan Pizza after all. Gyro was very big and good! lots of meat and toppings. it is comparable to paisano's gyro and I like both of them. The fries they use are different though. pizza had fresh ingredients and tasted great! wouldn't say it's anything super special but it's not bad either. lots of toppings which is perfect. I personally think it tastes like papa John's and that's fine by me as I love papa johns. a bit pricier though for the same taste. biggest difference is the new York style so the dough is thinner here if that's your preference. inside decor is very nice and modern vibe. lots of spacious tables for seating as well as outdoor seating. What makes them unique is that they also serve Gelato! I didn't get any but had a free sampling and it was delicious. definitely recommend! read more

See all

I just should have gone to Costco. There is no "Manhattan" in their pizza. They really need to remove the name and just call it pizza. First and last time going. I should just gone across the street to 7-11 a lot better and cheaper. read more

The service was good. Nice kids at the counter. BUT, naming a Pizzeria Manhattan Pizza is not showing respect for REAL pizza that is made in NY or surrounding tristate area. Please, change the name to Gainesville Pizza and my expectations will equal the quality of the pie. I hate to trash someone's business, someone who is probably working hard, but don't fool a customer thinking they are getting an authentic NY pie. Real pizza crust is made from had rolled dough not a Boboli type premade crust. Cook the pie in a slate bottom or wood fired oven, not on a wire rack. I had the buffalo chicken. Too much cheese not enough chicken and lacked buffalo sauce. I had to ask for some to give me taste. Sorry to give 1 star, but I hope the franchise fee is not big$. Drop the franchise and hire a real pizza maker! Go on your own. Go taste Tony's Pizza in Haymarket or in Bristow. See what I mean read more

Had lunch less than an hour ago (09/18/24 1:00PM) at this location. Do yourself a favor and pass this place by. I should have known from the minute we walked in, the young man (quite tall with dark hair...(that's for you mgmt)) at the register was as indifferent as I've dealt with in my 20 years in the restaurant business. When he delivered our order to the table, he simply dropped (and I mean PLOPPED) or food on the table, not a word and walked off. Yes, they'll be nothing else, thanks for NOT asking. The Pastrami sandwich (my order) is most likely the worst I've ever had...no flavor to the meat and if that was spicy mustard on the bread, well vaseline would last better. My lunch partner order a wrap which had browned lettuce and was drowned in dressing, so much so she gagged after taking the first bite. She, never made it past bite three. "I'd rather starve" was her response. We quickly left, and will pass this place by for the deli up the road. Welcome to Gainesville. read more

Excellent Pizza with fresh ingredients. Decent crust for the Pizza. This is New york style pizza so the crust is a but thin and chewy. Nice Salads! read more

The worst pizza I ever tasted. I imagine this must be what cardboard tastes like. I've had frozen pizzas that tasted better. No taste to the sauce and the cheese was overcooked. Won't be returning...ever. read more

amazing food and atmosphere... a very clean place and friendly staff. Wide variety of food

From my 10 y/o: when we got to this place it had some yummy food on the kids menu that I would actually eat and guess what it only took a couple minutes to make the food and we got a LOT of food I got the buttered noodles. When I tried them, they were so soft and airy I wanted to cry with joy. They had a lot of dessert options too. The cakes were good. I would definitely come back again. read more

First time trying this place and most likely won't be returning. Just ok food but really small appetizer portions. Older gentleman at the register wasn't very friendly. read more

See all

This place is right down the street from my house, we took a chilly walk this morning and decided to stop by for some warm pizza! It was DELICIOUS. Let me start with the place is impeccable, it has a little hand wash station in the eating area which is super convenient especially for parents who have little ones. They have a huge tv with all the options, our 3 year old enjoyed watching Moana while eating his pizza. The pizza was delicious, the crust was my favorite part, it was so buttery and flaky and just so delicious, I don't think I'll be ordering pizza from anywhere else. We order pizza a few times a month for dinner so this will be our go to from now on, the wings were a good size and savory too! And the GELATO OMGGGGGG MUST TRY IT! What you see in the pic is a large gelato, one small pie, and 10 wings, it was the perfect amount for our family of 3...our 3 year old asked for an extra slice of pizza though (after he ate he gelato) the only downside is that they don't really have kid drinks, (we don't really drink soda) but the 7 eleven is right there, so we got him some apple juice! Check them out guys!!!! The food is so fresh and yummy, the environment is clean and tidy, and the customer service gets an A+! read more

Manhattan Pizza - Candy dream gelato - Sandwiches Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

See all

The best steak and cheese in the area! This was my first time here. Staff were so friendly and the food was very fresh and delicious. My kids loved their pizza and the ambience was so cozy. I will def come again. read more

Somewhat disappointed..Manhattan Pizza in Warrenton was great!!! THIN pizza...!!!! This place, not so much...okay taste, but can't understand why the difference within the same company...probably won't return.. read more

I've been to the Gainesville location of Manhattan Pizza a few times recently, and it has quickly become my go to place for just about anything. They have a huge menu and you can always eat something different, and it will always be delicious. The staff are incredibly friendly, the food comes out really quicly, and it is always a good atmosphere. read more

I was in Gainsville for my nieces high school graduation and we decided to pop in here after since it was a Monday night and kind of late. The first thing I noticed and loved was that there was a hand washing station right before you get to the counter. It was very nice and fit their decor. I was hesitant about ordering because it was close to their closing time but the cashier was very nice and assured us it was not a problem. We ordered 3 pizzas, 1 of which was a truffle porcini pizza and it was mouth watering good! We also noticed they sold Gelato and came back the next day before catching our flight and bought Gelato and EVERYONE loved it. The cookie butter gelato was soooo freaking good. I'm assuming this place is new because I don't recall seeing it the last time we visited. 10/10 recommend! read more

Absolutely delicious food. Cheese pizza, turkey sub, kids' grilled cheese... all wonderful! The staff was extremely friendly and appreciative of our business. Will be coming back soon! read more

I can't say enough about Manhattan Pizza! We order pizza at least once a week and our go-to us always Manhattan Pizza! Not only is their pizza incredible (their crust is the best!) but their customer service is top notch! Tonight I ordered pizza and pizza rolls (to die for) at 8:11pm and they were at my house by 8:38pm! Our order was not only fast, but beyond delicious, and the driver was polite and courteous. They are a locally owned business and deserve all the praise and respect for doing their best during trying times in the restaurant business. I'm proud to have this establishment in our community and I hope everyone will give them an opportunity to wow you! read more