Good Fellas

Omg so many thoughts on this experience…read more I'm so glad i didn't immediately know it was a restaurant located in a hotel. This prob would have deterred me, even a little bit. The Apple map directions here confused me a little due to this, but parking was really plentiful so that's a huge plus! I went on a Sunday morning and lo and behold there was a hole farmers market or pop up set up all through haymarket! Busy weekend for a brunch but haymarket is SUCH a cute little vibe and town with so many hidden gems, like this one!! Literally every single item I saw waiters bring out from the kitchen looked so scrumptious, every person around us immediately began digging in and enjoying their meals...and honestly, no crumbs were left behind pretty much every time. We started ordering a yummy cocktail. I was really in the mood for the Paloma with grapefruit juice but sadly they were out of grapefruit juice fortunately, they had plenty cocktails available that were not explicitly on the menu! I ended up having a delicious espresso martini, prepared, right and honestly, I would have had another!! Not too sweet. Not creamy. And with 3 beans. Impeccable no notes. I ordered the red House breakfast. Man those home potatoes were so delicious....they clearly cooked them seasoned deliciously and then flash fried, so crunchy!!!! Amazing. I found that their execution on their meals was really impressive. My sunny side up eggs were cooked perfectly and paired so yummy with the toast. The bacon had delicious flavor too. I ordered a biscuit because I had heard that their biscuits were really yummy but unfortunately they did not have their bacon biscuit so it was just a classic biscuit. It was good, certainly dense and clearly homemade. My girlfriend got the poutine. Looked so delicious and was really enjoyed! The gravy was thick and flavorful! We sat down and enjoyed plenty of conversation and a really nice environment. Nobody rushed us, service was just the right amount of attentive without interrupting conversation constantly, and the floor to ceiling windows let in beautiful natural light and views of the town. It was the perfect brunch spot for a low-key, but delicious meal. Just a hair out of the way without being too far. I came out with a really good friend of mine to celebrate my one year wedding anniversary with her and it was the perfect possible location. Shout out to the staff for being so welcoming and kind, and even taking a picture of us when we asked to commemorate the occasion. I'm sure they are used to people walking in to the hotel lobby looking as confused as I was looking for red House Tavern.

Not the best experience for brunch. The waitress was unenthusiastic and came back to the table…read moremultiple times to let us know they were out of items including: the juice that came with the mimosa flight after we ordered it, another bottle of champagne for anyone else who wanted mimosas, (so mimosas overall, lol), the avocado toast, the poutine and another key ingredient in a cocktail we ordered. The food was average at best when it came out. Super disappointed. We came here for my mom's 5 year beating cancer anniversary and it wasn't much of a celebration.

View of open kitchen area

Pain Perdu

See all

Seasonal Spiced Champagne

Giuseppe's Italian Restaurant

3.1(239 reviews)

Not sure why they got such a low rating of 3.7 - I think they should get a much higher rating of…read more5.0! Their pizza is delicious! (I get one slice pepperoni & green peppers and one slice cheese) - sometimes I get the French fries with it. I also love their grilled chicken salad (with extra ranch dressing) and garlic bread. It's a relaxed atmosphere and the food is downright delicious!

I got a bruschetta ($12) and the fettuccine adriatico($20). Food came out in a decent time. 10…read moreminutes for the appetizer and about another 15 mins for the entree. The pasta was cooked very well and the sauce was a great combination of Alfredo and tomato based sauce. I was very happy with the food! Staff were friendly and this restaurant had a nice local feel to it. Definitely would come back again! Food(50%): 7.8 Staff/service(25%): 7.5 Value(25%): 7.5 Overall: 7.6/10

See all

Stuffed Shells

Hidden Julles

4.2(575 reviews)

0.3 mi

we LOVE hidden julles. they have a lot of option for food smoothies and coffee and everything we…read morehave had has been great! the service can be slow sometimes as they do get very busy but everyone is so kind and helpful

Price vs experience…read more For a 2 egg omelette, I spent almost $20, which did come with a generous fruit serving. Flavors were good but with a walk up dining experience price feels high, almost double from photos here on yelp. The experience, it was 58° outside but they had their ac on full blast, so cold I had to grab a jacket. The espresso machine was broken, so no coffee for me, would have gotten a tea, but didn't feel like paying the $6.29 for just tea from their disorganized kitchen. Broken furniture and the floors were dirty. Sorry guys, missed it for me.

Chicken Philly with Fresh Salad

See all

Mediterranean Avocado Toast - YUMMY!

Valentino's Pizzeria

3.9(106 reviews)

0.3 mi

Stopped by for lunch during the weekday & opted for their weekday lunch special of $10 for 2 slices…read more& a drink. Ordered a slice of: margherita, grandma pizza, BBQ chicken, & plain cheese. Pizza here is delicious!! Great, thin, crispy crust. The Margherita here is with a white sauce, not red, but still enjoyed it. My son LOVED the BBQ one. My favorite was the slice of grandma's pie. Slightly thicker crust & I loved the red sauce on it. On the tangy side, which I prefer. We recently moved to Haymarket from Fairfax area & was bummed we couldn't find a good pizza spot that could compare to our favorites (Andy's, Crust neapolitan). Lo & behold, this is it!! We'll be regulars here for sure. Great, quick service too. Already planning a big order for my son's upcoming birthday party :)

Great, real New York style pizza. The best you will get in Northern Virginia. I ordered in-store by…read morethe slice and the pizza was oh so good. Hot, cheesy, and fresh. Just like back in New York where I grew up. Don't often get that here. Service was quick, prompt, and efficient. There is a cooler with drinks, one cooler for non-alcohol, one cooler with alcohol. There are some tables inside to eat at after you order at the counter, or you can get takeout or delivery. Parking is a bit confusing since there are a lot of other stores, but you will figure it out. You can park behind or to the side of Valentino's and walk a tad bit. No more than a minute. It's fine.

Margherita Pizza - so incredibly tasteless!!! Not even worth buying!!!

See all

Hawaiian and buffalo chicken pizza, and a pepperoni pinwheel

Parrando’s Tex-Mex Grill

4.0(131 reviews)

The food here is genuinely good -- well-cooked, clearly upscale for the Tex Mex category, and the…read moreservice staff are attentive and friendly. But a few things held this visit back from being a great experience. The biggest issue, and the one that cost the most stars: the noise. There's essentially no acoustic treatment in the dining room, and even at maybe 25% capacity, the sound is overwhelming. We couldn't hold a conversation without leaning in and repeating ourselves constantly. That's a real problem. It also had a direct impact on our order -- our server couldn't hear us clearly either, so a simple substitution (no beans, double rice) came out as no beans and no rice. Small thing, but avoidable. On the menu side, the descriptions need work. The patron salad lists "house dressing" with no further detail -- turns out it's quite sweet, which felt out of place on that dish. That's emblematic of the menu overall: the flavor combinations lean creative, sometimes mixing profiles that don't really belong together in a Tex Mex context. It's not bad, just occasionally confusing, and more transparency in the descriptions would help guests set expectations. Bottom line: solid kitchen, good staff, but fix the acoustics and tighten up the menu copy and this place has real potential.

Huge fan of the food. Very flavorful!…read more They have an outside patio which is covered. Food is excellent. We got the nachos which is good for 2 people or a meal. Margaritas are excellent and good portions of the food. There is also one in sterling which I enjoy. Will definitely be back.

Inside looking out

Churro dessert plate with vanilla ice cream, fresh strawberries and whipped cream

See all

Parrando's 4th of July.

ALDI

3.0(3 reviews)

I love my Aldi. The food is high quality, the prices are low. The atmosphere is perfect for what it…read moreis - quiet deals. Always different food options weekly along with stocking the favorites. Aldi notoriously does not have a bunch of staff which is just fine - assume you are doing self-checkout but usually there will be a lane that will open for you if you show up at the staffed/unstaffed register. I love the efficiency, cleanliness and helpful staff if you need to ask a question.

Meh, not what used to be available as far as product. The listeria or ecoli outbreak in meats…read moremight have affected that. Now there is 1 cashier and the rest are self check-out. What a mess! The 1 cashier has to check those out and help out the self checkout problems. A huge time-waster for all. People frustrated and the poor cashier! I won't be back! Knock off products & takes longer to checkout. Several grocery stores nearby and closer to where we live we have 4 large grocers. Time to stay close.

Will only use cashier! Self checkouts are Slllloooowww!!!!

See all

USA-BBQ

4.5(13 reviews)

1.9 mi

Northern Virginia Community College catered welcome back to school lunch from here. It was a nice…read moretreat from NVCC, but food was average. Burgers are premade frozen type. Didn't get a chance to try chicken wings or hot dogs. Appreciated Martin's potato buns and rolls. Had sliced American cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, relish, ketchup, mustard, and Duke's mayo for condiments.

Had it for lunch today at Sunshine Ridge. The pulled chicken was very dry and flavorless. The sides…read morewere average, a best. Both sauces were good.

Family event made even more special by USA BBQ the food and staff was amazing!!!

See all

The food was so yummy and the hospitality was amazing!!!

Pizza Boli's

3.4(75 reviews)

1.6 mi

For $12 bucks, this was good. I have no complaints as the fries were hot and crispy, and the sub…read morewas meaty and filling. ( I will order more cheese, but again thats just my preference). I had ordered on door dash or Grubhub. I would order this again.

Want your pizza cold and French fries soggy? This is your place. Want any response from…read moremanagement when you explain the problem? Nope. I live less than five minutes from Pizza Bolis. It's clear the driver made multiple deliveries before ours. The result of food sitting for more than 30 minutes in a car is entirely predictable - and it's not pretty. Equally if not more concerning was the lack of management response. Apparently they have all the customers they need because they now have one less.

See all

Chick-fil-A

3.0(85 reviews)

•$

This smaller sized Chick-Fil-A is located in the heart of the quaint town of Haymarket! The…read moreservice was great and they were super attentive to our needs. My spicy chicken sandwich was ok. It tasted great, but the bun and cheese were cold... this was unpleasant to find out and eat. However, the cookies and cream milkshake was delicious and like drinking an Oreo!

By far the worse customer service of any Chick Fil A there is. Employees have attitudes, talk back…read moreat you, and really don't care !! I wrote in a complaint and gave them a chance to make it right, but whoever Jason Ward is, writes back a BS letter but really doesn't care, mainly because he didn't make things right, just blew smoke in a letter. Will never go there again and would skip a meal before giving them any money !!

See all

Monroe Bay Oysterette

4.5(136 reviews)

We just recently discovered Monroe Bay Oysterette and our first experience there was just…read morefantastic! The food is truly exceptional. EVERY dish is fresh, creative, perfectly cooked and beautifully spiced. You can watch the chef at his craft and it's easy to tell he enjoys every minute in the kitchen. Serious attention to detail. The service is impeccable and the atmosphere relaxed, friendly and comfortable. A great find - we will be back! Very Highly recommend!

Food was great! Khatera was awesome! She was very attentive…read moreand engaging. Will definitely be coming back.

Interior kitchen

Lobster roll

See all

Lobster roll

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Indira J.

15

80

32

3 years ago

I recently tried the thin crust pizza and wings at Goodfellas, and I must say, it was absolutely delightful! The thin crust pizza had the perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness. The flavors of the sauce, cheese, and toppings blended together harmoniously, creating a mouthwatering experience with every bite. As for the wings, they were cooked to perfection. The crispy skin gave way to tender and juicy meat, while the sauce added a delicious tangy and spicy kick. Whether you prefer mild or hot, there was a sauce option to satisfy everyone's taste buds. The combination of the thin crust pizza and wings made for a fantastic meal. It was the perfect balance of flavors and textures, and I found myself craving more even after I had finished. The portion sizes were generous, ensuring that I left feeling satisfied and content. Overall, I highly recommend trying the thin crust pizza and wings at this pizzeria. The quality and taste are exceptional, and you won't be disappointed. It's the perfect choice for a casual meal with friends or a tasty treat to enjoy on your own. read more

Phil B.

0

11

2

2 years ago

This family-owned business is known for serving up some mean pizza. If you're a fan of pizza, I highly recommend trying their Goodfellow pizza. While some people have expressed concerns about pricing, it's essential to consider that costs have risen across the board. However, the deliciousness of their well-cooked pizza makes it well worth it! read more

Sara K.

62

26

8

2 years ago

Hi! I highly recommend this place. The food is absolutely delicious, with a great variety of flavors that are sure to satisfy any craving. On top of that, the staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming, making the entire experience even more enjoyable. read more

Hemila J.

2

6

0

1 year ago

it's so so good when I go to the pool I all ways get it by the way it me Daniel.

Good Fellas - italian - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Restaurants near Good Fellas

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Coffee near Good Fellas

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Things to Do near Good Fellas

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Pizza near Good Fellas

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Desserts near Good Fellas

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Dinner near Good Fellas

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Cocktail Bars near Good Fellas

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Parking near Good Fellas

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Wineries near Good Fellas

BEST of Haymarket, Virginia Shopping near Good Fellas

Best of Haymarket

Things to do in Haymarket

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Good Fellas also viewed

Goodfellas

3.4

(27 reviews)

This may be the best pizza this side of Front Royal. I was amazed at how good this was. It is thin…read morecrust and the pepperoni, sausage are wicked good. The sauce, the crust... wicked too. This will be my "go to" from now on!!

The pizza was great, we just got a pepperoni. The salad was okay, I love a Greek salad but could've…read moreused more cucumbers, olives and chopped onion not the whole slice. The service was fast, only waited not even 10 minutes. It's definitely more of a pick up and take back home environment because it is very tiny inside.

Brooklyn Bros Pizzeria

3.9

(150 reviews)

Top notch pizza, can't understand why it doesn't show up when we search best pizza in Gainesville…read more I has 4 stars and I give it 5 consistantly.

Well the pizza was average and their bacon cheesy fries way over prized. The restaurant staff is…read morelovely. The restaurant is very comfortable but I just felt dissatisfied with my meal. I don't think I'll return.

Valentino's Pizzeria

3.9

(106 reviews)

Stopped by for lunch during the weekday & opted for their weekday lunch special of $10 for 2 slices…read more& a drink. Ordered a slice of: margherita, grandma pizza, BBQ chicken, & plain cheese. Pizza here is delicious!! Great, thin, crispy crust. The Margherita here is with a white sauce, not red, but still enjoyed it. My son LOVED the BBQ one. My favorite was the slice of grandma's pie. Slightly thicker crust & I loved the red sauce on it. On the tangy side, which I prefer. We recently moved to Haymarket from Fairfax area & was bummed we couldn't find a good pizza spot that could compare to our favorites (Andy's, Crust neapolitan). Lo & behold, this is it!! We'll be regulars here for sure. Great, quick service too. Already planning a big order for my son's upcoming birthday party :)

Great, real New York style pizza. The best you will get in Northern Virginia. I ordered in-store by…read morethe slice and the pizza was oh so good. Hot, cheesy, and fresh. Just like back in New York where I grew up. Don't often get that here. Service was quick, prompt, and efficient. There is a cooler with drinks, one cooler for non-alcohol, one cooler with alcohol. There are some tables inside to eat at after you order at the counter, or you can get takeout or delivery. Parking is a bit confusing since there are a lot of other stores, but you will figure it out. You can park behind or to the side of Valentino's and walk a tad bit. No more than a minute. It's fine.

Jackleg Pizza Company

4.5

(54 reviews)

This is an unusual location; it's really where DC's extended suburbs start to turn into country…read more The surroundings are green, and there is just this little strip mall that has some breweries and a couple of nondescript doors that don't look like they'd lead to food. One of them, at least, does, in the form of this pizzeria. I ordered online and it was ready about when they said it would be. Notably, they close early on Sundays so I just got in there. They have indoor seating, but I ate a bit at one of the numerous tables for other businesses in this stretch and took the rest to go. Their interpretation of a margherita didn't wow me. As the picture will show, it seemed to be like 30% crust. And the NY style pizza is actually an upcharge from the other varieties. Don't get me wrong, the toppings and crust were overall of high quality, but it wasn't a filling pizza for the price at all, and I didn't have anything to do with all that extra crust except try to fold it over. Wished I'd brought some hummus or something. The pizza I really came for, however, was a Detroit style pizza, of which I ordered as a veggie special. The vegetables were ample but didn't overwhelm, and the crust for this pizza was more substantial. The browned edge of cheese that one comes to this style for was present in spades. It's hard to believe it actually costs less than the NY style, because it was much better. Their other options included some drinks, though I suspect many will patronize the next door brewery for beverages and some bread appetizers and only one salad; nothing that really enchanted me. So, a real mixed evaluation from my perspective. The right pizza order can be quite good, I'll say that.

We continue to order from Jackleg almost weekly. The Tuesday 20-inch sourdough pizza is a perfect…read moremix of crunchy-with a little grease. Not typical NY style, but close enough. The staff is always friendly and ensures your order is hot and ready when promised. Perfect little dining area with a few seats, or order it to your table at Old Busthead Brewery.

Pizza NY Margherita

3.6

(225 reviews)

I order pizza (takeout) from this restaurant almost every week. As a native New Yorker, I can…read morehonestly say their pizza is exceptional for VA. Five stars! But, dining in, the service is not good. The wait staff are not friendly which is consistent with other reviews.

This was the best pizza we've found in the area! Great prices for lots of food--delicious, fresh…read moreslices with yummy flavors. They were very friendly, and when the tip of one of our slices fell off in transit, they gave us an extra slice for free. The interior is beautiful and much bigger than you'd think from outside. Very clean and cheery, and would be a fun place to bring a big group. We'll definitely be back!

Spitony's Pizza

3.9

(130 reviews)

•$

The food here is good. Some items are better than others, for example the chicken salad is…read morephenomenal! I've enjoyed several of the subs I've ordered from here. And their pizza is good. It definitely depends on how busy they are, but considering what a limited space they have and the amount of volume especially on the weekends that they enter I can't complain The dining inside is definitely small, but I appreciate the ambience/almost retro vibe of it. Yes, like other reviewers stated there are a lot of "young kids" working here but honestly for the most part they're wonderful kids who are learning what the working world is like ", and I appreciate this establishment for giving them that opportunity. Patience and kindness goes long way, on both sides of the transaction.

This place does nothing well. Its pizza is ok, It's sandwich's are mediocre at best and the service…read moreis pretty ok to bad depending on the day. It's also fairly dirty in the inside and last time I went it smelled like straight piss to the point where I was ready to get up and leave before even getting my food. But yeah it's pretty bad just go to any other pizza place in the area and it's pretty much guaranteed to be better than (Spit)ony's. Also I wouldn't trust a lot of the other positive reviews written up for them a lot of them seem to be written by a bot with a generic review like "Wow Best Pizza Ever, Staff was Amazing!" Trust me I've lived in the area all my life no one has ever given this place a glowing review like that in person.

Tony's New York Pizza

4.2

(268 reviews)

I've had about 10 more cheeseburgers subs since my last review. Had one a few minutes ago. A great…read moreway to finish the day after long teams meetings. It was a till top notch! Recently, I got their sausage and potato entree to go for lunch the following day. Absolutely amazing. The garlic bread seems to have freshly crushed garlic- amazing. The people working there are also extremely friendly and seem to treat everyone like family. Check it out!

Came here after a doctor's appointment nearby and grabbed a slice of pepperoni pizza for dinner. It…read morewas fresh, and decent size. Seems like a place families come to grab food since it felt like an old school Italian pizza spot. Plenty of seating inside and parking outside. You order and go pick up your food once your ticket is called. I've been to their other location in Manassas and would say it's comparable.

Mama Mia Pizza

4.0

(135 reviews)

We were visiting from out of town. We placed a pick up for 2 large pizzas (8 slices each) A…read moreMargherita, pizza, and a pepperoni pizza. They both were really good the cheese, especially on the Margherita pizza was extra good. The pick up was on time. I know that they do deliver to the area we were in, but we decided on pick up.

This place is a hidden gem in Gainesville. It's an authentic, family owned business. I make it a…read morepoint to visit whenever I see a show at Jiffy Lube Live. Please skip the corporate chains in the Gateway Plaza.

Joe & Vinnie's Pizza Subs & Pasta

4.0

(103 reviews)