We stopped at Mama's Pizza for lunch on our way headed further east on 64. I tried the Salami Sub while my dining companion opted for the baked Ziti. My sub was definitely on the sparse side. The 6ish inch sandwich arrived at the table warm on a small metal tray. The serving of salami was skimpy; I seriously doubt that it had much more than an ounce of salami and about the same size serving of mozzarella. Despite the modest amount of protein, it really was OK. I've had better versions of this sandwich, but I've had worse too. The baked ziti showed up piping hot in an enormous baking dish that dwarfed the metal tray of my sandwich. It was easily a large enough serving for two or possibly even three. I got to try a bite and it was also OK. There was a lot of pasta with a barely adequate serving of meat sauce and there was a lot more tomato sauce than meat in the sauce. The sauce was definitely on the sweet side; I've had baked ziti many times and do not recall ever eating sauce this sweet before. Our server was not overly attentive but did eventually refill our drinks. The restaurant is clean and had a bit of a 1990s feel. We both noticed that there was pay telephone in the lobby that appeared to work. It definitely reinforced the 1990s vibe. The restaurant charges a 4% fee to use a credit card. There really aren't too many dining options easily accessible off of highway 64 east of Rocky Mount until you reach the OBX. Momma's Pizza is a reasonable choice as long you have modest expectations. read more

I have been here several times, mainly during the lunch service. It's a nice eatery in a small Eastern NC town. Staff is always pleasant, service is always good. It's a normal wait for the meals. As I mentioned in a previous review, the decor doesn't give the customer an "nice Italian dining" vibe. The pasta dishes are a good portion and has the flavor of standard Americanized Italian fare. That's not a negative opinion of the food, just a little info for the potential customer anticipating a gourmet Italian meal. My only serious ding would be the decor, tables, and seating are in dire need of replacement or renovation. read more

Mama's Pizza - Chicken Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Williamston, North Carolina

See all

Dog-friendly patio. Open Sunday. We enjoyed Father's Day lunch there. Fried mushrooms for appetizer, eggplant, Parmesan, and Caesar salad. All good. Service was very friendly and prompt. Got a cannoli to go for dessert which we enjoyed later and was delicious. Very fresh. read more

Mama's Pizza - Hayden the doodle - Pizza Near Me - Williamston, North Carolina

See all

I really enjoy this place. The food is so good. The service is amazing. The atmosphere is so nice. I will indeed come back soon.

I love everything about this restaurant, including the owners and the staff and the food is amazing. I love their lasagna and their spaghetti with meat sauce and their pizza pizzas. Highly recommend! It's just a family atmosphere and it's just relaxing. read more

Great pizza! Using the Slice app for takeout makes the drive through pickup an absolute breeze. The takeout service is the best in Washington NC read more

Food excellent and services is good. Most reasonably priced in County. Just miss Annmaria and Carly. All the staff are super. read more

Absolutely delicious calzone. The crust is wonderful and chewy, plenty of ham and extra stretchy mozzarella.

The food was good here. Our server was friendly and attentive. We would give it a 4 * if only judging on those 2 criterias. There are two reasons that bring this establishment down to a 3 * rating. First, the place was not that clean. The bathrooms were a mess and there was one soap dispenser that was out of soap. I even saw a dead cockroach in the corner. Ewww! The second reason was that the prices were quite high for being located in a very remote area. Not sure when we will be in Williamston again, but we would have to think about dining here. read more

See all

We were very disappointed with our food order on 10/20/2024 @8pm. My sub was not made according to what I requested but the real problem was the burnt onion rings in which should have never been boxed and sent out. I called back about 8:30pm no answer so I called today and their response was my husband should have checked the order prior to leaving. We were beyond dissatisfied poor quality....poor service read more

Went for the brick oven pizza - ordered the Works. Friendly young servers. Relaxed old school Pizza Hut / Davanni's vibe with variety of appetizers, pizza, pasta menu. Perfect late lunch stop off US-64 from OBX to Raleigh. read more

This might be a little spot off the beaten path, but it's a great place to go while on a road trip! Delicious pizza and wings, great service, and very clean! It's clearly a locals hang out and for good reason. Next time we come through the area we will be back!! read more

Good food great prices would recommend this restaurant in Williamston NC convenient to thus area extremely friendly staff

Good pizza- very hot - which is good but be careful! Restaurant needs an upgrade and improvement in cleanliness would be good. Service was very good and earned a 4 star rating instead of a 3. read more

Great food and great service! Love the salad bar! Pizza is very tasty not too crispy and just the right amount of dough. Not to greasy

Yes yes yes I had the manicotti and several times previously ordered calzones and they're huge especially the family size! Trust me it is !! The bang bang shrimp is as good as you hoped it would be. read more

Mama's Pizza - Manicotti - Pizza Near Me - Williamston, North Carolina

Not only is the pizza amazing the staff is always so nice. We pop by when in NC traveling to see family from our home in Delaware.

Had the best pizza but now the pizza taste like store bought frozen pizza. Not sure if we will ever eat pizza there again. Sad that things has changed. read more

Best pizza in williamston. The salad bar is great just wish they would bring back buffet but that doesn't take away from the quality!

I've only had their pizza and I thought it was very good I was walked in ordered my pizza within 10 minutes I had three pizzas and was out the door and it was at 5:30 on a Friday read more

Was in williamston in a Sunday night and our go to was closed. Tried this place in a whim and was glad we did! He had a steak and cheese with fries. The bread was toasty and fries were hot and crispy. Steak was of good quality. I had a side salad off salad bar (had pizza'esque toppings available like canned mushrooms), but a good salad with tasted like homemade ranch. I also had a pepperoni and onion pizza that was really good. I asked for thin crust. Theirs is hand tossed so not like a cracker, but was thin and crusty how I like & not doughy. Ample pepperoni. Service was also good. Will definitely be back! read more

I love the food, I had the philly wrap today and it was fantastic. I've eaten here quite a few times and never had anything that wasn't good. The servers are all friendly and attentive. Great place!! read more

This review is for the buffet as I did not order the fresh food. The buffet was recommended by our waitress. My wife and I are pizza lovers and thought the 4.5 stars would translate to the buffet. The first two pizza slices I got were cold and greasy/wet on the bottom. The chicken Parm was probably the best tasting of all the things I tried but was also cold and pretty flavorless. The spaghetti was literally noodles in tomato paste. No spices to be found. Then I saw it. A fresh pizza appeared. Hawaiian with ham and pineapple. One of my favorites. The pale pineapples should have been the first clue that my experience was not going to improve with this slice. I'm not sure how they store their pineapple slices but it's prob not in pineapple juice given the rubbery piece I ate. For desert they had nice rubber nuggets covered in a sugar based icing. They were quite cold and definitely gave my jaw a workout. Again, I'm not saying all the food is bad here. I'm just saying on this particular Sunday at noon, the buffet was cold and left me unsatisfied at $8.99 per person. read more

Mama's Pizza - Cold rubber nuggets for desert. - Pizza Near Me - Williamston, North Carolina

Amazing pizza !!! And the service was amazing ! They made sure everything was great and made sure my food was amazing.

Great staff. Manicotti is wonderful. Always ready for large parties. Salad bar is ok. Prices are good

I have only had their takeout but it was great! We come down from VA quite often to visit family. Different ones have tried many menu options and I've heard nothing but good reports on it all. My personal favorite is their lasagna (ricotta is optional, I recommend.). The portion is huge, definitely big enough for two. Make sure you're hungry! read more

This deserves the stars. Amazingly friendly people. Samantha was the best waitress yet. She ran the place. We had a party of 13 and she had to handle rest of customers. She is polite even when running back and forth. She earned these 5 stars. Now the food. I had a Stromboli. And it was so good. The pizza that the kids had was very good. Cheesy and delicious they described it as. The regular wings were enjoyed more than the boneless wings. Moma's did a excellent job today. We were glad that wings and things were closed. This place was better for everyone. read more

Mama's Pizza - Stromboli. This was a regular size. And it was filled and delicious - Pizza Near Me - Williamston, North Carolina

See all

We were in town for an equestrian event at the nearby Bob Martin Agriculture Center and decided to give this place a chance. I am so glad we did!!! Amongst several friends, we got the lasagna, buffalo chicken wrap, Italian sub, and baked spaghetti. I honestly can't tell you which was my favorite because they were all DELICIOUS. The service was quick and the staff super friendly! I also had a real appreciation for the authenticity of this place. I have spent much time in Italy and they had real authentic Italian dishes to try!!! I will most definitely be back!!! read more

Quick stop on our way out of town, and it was amazing. One of the best stromboli we have ever had. Jalapeno cheese bites were bomb as well. Will be stopping by again when coming through. read more

Went for a quick bite to Mama's with co-workers while in Williamston and wanted a sit-down dining experience and so Mama's was recommended by the group. We were able to choose our table, place was crowded, but not packed. Our server came over, obtained our drink orders and we opted for the buffet. The buffet had a really fresh salad bar with what appeared to be freshly cut veggies. My only issue- iceberg lettuce. Ugh! Not a fan of iceberg, but oh well. At least it was fresh. Also available on the buffet were various pastas, pizzas by the slice, and some cinnamon dessert options. I didn't have dessert but another member of our party loved it, and went back for seconds. The food tasted like they were cooked fresh, not canned or warmed up, which is always a plus. Since Williamston lacks many food options, they are lucky to have Mama's. I would definitely dine at Mama's again. read more

Nice place. Good decor, and menus that don't stick together. If you're local, you already know, but if you're just passing through it's worth a stop in. Pasta dishes made to order, and tasty. Good food, for not a lot of money. Tucked away near Sherman Williams, Mama's is possibly the only choice for Italian food in this part of NC so they are automatically 'the best!' read more

Parking lot was a little bit dirty and so was the entry area but the food was excellent. We got takeout and I ordered the Italian sausage sub read more

If you actually do want a pizza I think you should go here they have better pizza than Domino's I like The salad I like the football pizza. I just feel like this is a good places to go read more

We were just passing by on Hwy 17 and stopped here by chance. The food was fresh and delicious! We were pleasantly surprised by the authentic Italian pizza and Greek salad. We started asking questions and met the owner, Sal, who is Sicilian! That explains the great food. Highly recommended read more

Stopped in for a quick bite to eat on our way south. Once again, Yelp steered us right. My pizza was delicious and my husband also enjoyed his food. If I'm passing through again, I'll be sure to stop! read more

Went to mama pizza today in williamston nc the pizza was so good and the service was great and if you ever in williamston check them out

I live in the area, and only like certain places here, but Mama's pizza has good food, and reasonable prices. The portion sizes are good, some dishes large enough for me to split with my husband.I love the eggplant parmigiana, add onions and mushrooms, really good. The calzones, and stromboli are good too. I also like the pizza steak sub. All in all, lots of choices at good prices. read more

I always enjoyed the bacon cheese fries and salad bar as a teenager. Always fresh and made to order pizzas. This is where I developed a love for mushroom and Stromboli. They have BY FAR the best marinara sauce. read more

My favorite place to eat when visiting Bear Grass. Had the white pizza minus the chicken. Good stuff, would be even better with some caramelized onions as I had on another white pizza recently read more

This is a great place for pizza and subs. They have a buffet that includes a salad bar at lunch time.