Cancel

Open app

Search

Maker Pizza Thornhill

4.6 (50 reviews)
Open • 11:30 am - 9:30 pm

Maker Pizza Thornhill Photos

Business Info

MAKER PIZZA THORNHILL ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Maker Pizza Thornhill

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Marvin S.

Definitely the best pizza I've had in Toronto. The everything bagel seasoning on the crust took it over the top.

Pie menu
John Y.

Finally found my favorite pizza joint in Markham. Went on "National Pie day" where slices were only $3.14 (nice play on words). Warning- if you grew up on Pizza hut, Pizza Pizza. Domino's, Papa John's or any other generic pizza chain, you will be severely disappointed. No globs of stringy flavorless cheese, sweet tasteless tomato sauce and spongy soggy doughy crust, bye bye Felicia. My dearest pizza lovers, we are talking top quality pizza ingredients here, no joke. Got the basic cheese slice, didn't want any add-ons to distort the flavor profile. YOLO'd it and also got the pepperoni vodka sauce slice. After about 15min wait. The slices finally arrived. They were getting slammed, lines of people waiting for their slices/pies. Got bad as some people were waiting over 45mins for their orders. One thing I didn't like was that they sprinkled parmesan cheese (at least I think it was parmesan cheese) on both slices. It added to the flavor profiles but it really wasn't necessary, some people may like it. I don't. Both slices were on the thin side but packed with flavor. The rich tomato sauce profile came through with a nice balance/ratio to the cheese. Some like globs of cheese on their slice, I prefer a balance between the cheese and tomato sauce. The vodka sauce on the pepperoni slice was excellent and had a nice spicy kick to it. Both slices might be considered on the salty side (for those who are sensitive to salt), this coming from the richness of the cheese and especially from the pepperoni. Finish this all off with a nice crispy flavorful crust. It was so good, I ordered an additional two slices to go! Mamma mia. That's some great pizza

Polidennis S.

Tried one slice of cheese and one slice of pepperoni. I would rate the cheese slice 8/10 and the pepperoni 8.5/10. This is some of the best pizza in the GTA. Nice flavourful crust, good quality sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese. Im going to come back and get a full pizza next time for my family. I look forward to trying some different toppings.

Burnt Marshmallow cookie
Vonny W.

I couldn't be happier when the team from Maker's Pizza decided to open up in my neighborhood! I love using their app for easy online ordering. You can see their full menu, as well as current offers/deals, and pay through there to either place an order for ASAP or scheduled for later, via pickup and/or delivery! This visit, I saw there was a promotion for a 12" pie plus a dip and drink for $25, so I went with Frank's Best, their garlic dip, and a Nestea. I also couldn't resist to get three of their Burnt Marshmallow cookies. Frank's Best was loaded with caramelized onions, goat cheese, grass-fed mozzarella, and rosemary, making it such a flavorful pie, you don't even need a dipping sauce to pair. Despite the use of sea salt on this as well, it's actually quite sweet. To finish, they brush the crust with organic honey and sesame seeds. I love the chew on the crust and it's slightly crispier exterior. Now, I did say you don't "need" a dip to pair but their garlic dip is a must try! It literally tastes as if there's an entire garlic in this 4 oz dip, making it so good. I always save up any leftovers to use in wraps/sandwiches I make at home later in the week. It adds so much flavor and goes with everything! As for the cookies - these might not be well-known yet, but I can't gatekeep these! They're a little doughier on the inside but have a crunchy exterior. The melted marshmallows on these make them elite! They are quite sweet but I love 'em and grab them when I want to indulge. Not the mention, their size! I couldn't be happier when the employee told me upon pick up that he gifted me an extra cookie. Why? I don't know but I didn't question it! Pick up at the restaurant is super easy and efficient. Service is also friendly and efficient. I love that for takeout orders, they keep the pies in a warmer until you arrive and all dips/drinks/cookies are packaged in a eco-friendly paper bag for easy transport. You're welcome to help yourself to paper plates and (good quality) napkins which are placed on the counter. The place at a glance every visit is well-kept and clean. There are a couple tables for dine-in, not serviced, but I've never sat in myself.

Franks best  Caramelized onions, goat cheese, grass fed mozzarella, rosemary, sea salt, organic honey, sesame crust (applied with honey)
Doug G.

Don't sleep on Maker's Pizza. I hope and pray this restaurant thrives in Thornhill. Parking: Ample parking in the plaza Ambience: Take out spot, good date spot for something casual. Issavibe. Service: Ordered take out from here many a times, always on time and always fresh. Food: 12' Frank's Best (caramelized onions, goat cheese, grass-fed mozzarella, rosemary, sea salt, organic honey, sesame crust) Savory, well balanced, nice texture with the goat cheese and the mozza. Sesame crust is a nice touch as it gives it a sweet flavor to balance the saltiness. Rating: 5/5 12' Dr. Pepperoni (double natural pepperoni, grass-fed mozzarella, toasted fennel powder, organic tomato sauce) If you like meat, this is it. This ain't no joke of a pie. Super salty (not a bad thing in this case), the tomato sauce gives it a nice sweetness to balance it out, the fennel powder cuts the saltiness too. Rating: 5/5 - cause I love meat. 12' Spicy Vodka Pep God (parmesan, mozzarella, vodka sauce, pepperoni, chilli flakes) The vodka sauce is sweet, pepperoni is salty, chili flakes is nice but could be spicier, chili oil maybe? Fresh mozza, parm, can you go wrong? Rating: 5/5 12' SO Mushroom (basil, cremini mushrooms, grass-fed mozzarella, mascarpone, fresh garlic, grana padano, sea salt, cracked pepper, lemon zest) Wife's favorite so far, great balance of flavors with the mushrooms, basil and lemon zest. I'd eat this again too but I need to eat a Dr Pep after to balance it out. Rating: 4/5 (only cause I like pepperoni on my pies and some kind of meat) Fly By Jing Cumin Lamb Garlic Fingers (spicy cumin lamb crumble, fresh garlic, mozzarella, chili flakes (light), parmesan, freshly chopped basil, finished with Fly By Jing chili crisp and sesame (applied w/ honey) crust. Includes Fly By Jing chili crisp) Don't sleep on this, it's delicious, cuminy, hearty, lamby, salty, flavorful, you can taste each ingredient and care that was put into this dish. *Must try Rating: 5/5 - Please get this if you get Maker's... you will not regret it. Dipping Sauce: Spicy Creamy Garlic Parmesan with Chili Crisp - Good, very creamy, you don't need it for the pizza but this is fire. Rating: 5/5 Creamy Garlic Parm with Salsa Verde Nice change of pace from the chilli crisp, good salsa verde flavor, not overpowering when dipped with the pie. Rating: 5/5 Maker's pizza does not disappoint, you are paying a for a premium product and it's worth every dollar. Each take out experience has been phenomenal. Hope y'all are still here and open more locations.

See all

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Worst pizza ever. So salty and too much cheese. The pizza was also so oily. The garlic bread was spicy and also salty and greasy.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Delicious pizza. Friendliest staff. Easy to order on App. A real asset to the neighbourhood. Will definitely return.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Maker Pizza Thornhill Reviews in Other Languages

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 8,354 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Jersey Mike's Subs

Jersey Mike's Subs

4.2(42 reviews)
8.5 km•Brown's Corners
•$$

2026 Birthday Series -- Stop #4: Jersey Mikes…read more I'm kicking off a series reviewing all the places I visited to redeem my birthday goodies in July 2026. Along with an overall rating, each spot gets scored on redeemability (how easy it is to claim) and actual value. Jersey Mike's Redeemability: 5/5 (requires sign-up up for the news letter) Actual value: 10/5 (A WHOLE SET OF ONE REGULAR SIZE FREE SUB (ANY) and a drink!) WOW! Aside from the fact that Jersey Mike gives out the BEST BIRTHDAY FREEBIES out of all the cafes and restaurants (with absolutely no convoluted process to redeem - the staff were extremely nice and friendly), the sub itself was freaking amazing. I got the big kahuna - the beef was freshly grilled with LOTS OF white American cheese that melts all over, and the delicious grilled vegetables on top. I swear to god, this was perhaps just as good as the Philly steak sandwich I had in Philly if not better (as a birthday present). The store was as also super clean albeit extremely popular, with freshly cut meat and cheese served in an efficient speed. Tho I got a free combo, I also saw that the sandwiches were very reasonably priced - the quality and the price were unbeatable and I'll def come back often. I'd say jersey Mike's is my FAV sub restaurant now, far surpass subway but also firehouse sub which I often found overpriced. Highly, highly recommended.

A sub sandwich chain in Markham. My first time ever trying this out and I was quite intrigued!…read more Opted for the #13 The Original Italian that came with provolone, ham, proscuittini, cappacuolo, salami and pepperoni. Love that they have different sizes for you to pick from, so we got their giant size and wow it definitely was gigantic! You can choose your toppings ranging from lettuce, onions, tomatoes, oil, vinegar and spices, and more. Since it was our first time, we got it served the Mike's Way which had everything on it. Next time I think I'll opt out of the Mike's Way, since I didn't love my sandwich doused in vinegar - it also made it pretty soggy pretty quickly. However, the sandwich taste itself was amazing and so fresh! I can't wait to go back to customize another sandwich to my liking!

Photos
Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs

See all

Lambo's Deli - Italian Trio

Lambo's Deli

4.6(10 reviews)
19.7 km•Leslieville
•$$

Lambo's Deli located at the corner of Queen St. E. and Greenwood Ave. is the sandwich's shop's…read moresecond location (first one being in the Trinity Bellwoods neighbourhood!). This small shop located in Leslieville serves up some great sandwiches in a space that is primarily take out only (although there are a few bar/counter spots if you'd like to eat there. They are also open daily from 11am to 9pm. Menu wise, there are 9-10 kinds of sandwiches to choose from. They are all served on a sesame kaiser roll and cut in half. You're also able to add on ingredients on top of the already selected ones in the sandwiches. Each of Lambo's Deli locations also have a special sandwich, where this time when I went, it was the crispy chicken club. They also have soft serve as well (rotating flavours!). I stopped by Lambo's Deli on a Monday morning before the lunch rush and opted to grab: - Italian trio sandwich (soppressata, mortadella, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, picked red onion, arugula, pesto, Calabrian chili spread) - $18 - Soft serve (flavour was hojicha) -$5 Service was friendly and I received my soft serve while waiting for my sandwich to be prepared. It took about 5 min and it was nicely packed. Staff were great and handed me a handful of napkins as well. I ate my sandwich an hour later and before opening the packaging, the sandwich was pretty heavy! Looking at a cross section of the sandwich, it was packed with ingredients! The Italian Trio sandwich was delicious. The roasted red peppers, pickled red onion, arugula, and Calabrian chili spread added freshness to the sandwich which didn't make it feel so heavy with all the deli meats inside as well as the mozzarella cheese. The sandwiches are big and I could only finish half for lunch. Overall, a delicious sandwich shop in Leslieville. Lambo's Deli definitely packs a lot of ingredients in their sandwiches which make for a tasty meal. Be warned, the sandwiches are huge! Also...don't miss out on their soft serve too!

Stopped here for a sandwich to take to the park and wasn't disappointed. They have a nice simple…read moresandwich menu with all of the classics. They're well packed with ingredients, and cut in 1/2 if you want to eat 1/2 and save the other for later. Cute deli decor. While it's mainly take out, there's a small counter to sit at if you can score a spot. Nice side options if you want to make it a meal (pop and chips). You won't go hungry here!

Photos
Lambo's Deli
Lambo's Deli - Italian Trio

Italian Trio

Lambo's Deli - Out front from the sidewalk. June 2024

See all

Out front from the sidewalk. June 2024

Micatoni's - Micatoni's Porchetta... made to perfection, deliciously seasoned! What a hit at our party!

Micatoni's

4.4(61 reviews)
15.2 km
•$$

This is nestled in the plaza with St. John's Ambulance and TD. There are ample parking spots and I…read morerarely have an issue in this parking lot. Turning left to get out of the plaza could be challenging depending on time of day and traffic. Ambiance: 5/5 - it is brightly lit with the available meat products on display at the left. Freezer products to the right. Some places that sell raw meat can have that smell to it but this place does not at all. It's very clean. Service: 5/5 - they are friendly, and super quick. They have a lot of options ranging and some are already marinated/seasoned. You just have to cook them. Food: 5/5 - brought a pack of bone marrow and 2 New York striploins. The NY striploin are a little pricey but worth the price. I was a little tempted with the no salt herb dry mix staring at me when I waited for the steak. However, a little salt and pepper goes a long way on a high quality steak. Even though I cooked it closer to medium (user error), it was still very tender and juicy. Overall: 5/5 - will definitely be coming back for more. I know they have some hot food items too so I would like to check that out too. On a side note, my toddler wasn't too sure of bone marrow before. I can safely say my toddler is now hooked after trying the bone marrow from here (cooked of course).

Bought 2 different types of bone marrow from this store. The staff were very nice and helpful…read more Pricing were reasonable and the store was pretty clean. Would definitely come back.

Photos
Micatoni's
Micatoni's - New York Striploin

New York Striploin

Micatoni's - Bone marrow

See all

Bone marrow

Maker Pizza Thornhill - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...