This is probably a pizza place or something. The guy with the face was pretty dang cool. He put something in my mouth and it was.....red? I wanted an espresso and I got it without much hassle. I like ice tea. read more

We never had a chance to try the pizza. The service was so awful, we left. And we will not be back. Perhaps Magpie should try hiring waitstaff who have NOT worked at the Pint-another eatery with terrible service. This place definitely needs some customer service training-and not a moment is too soon! read more

Awesome restaurant. Creative, casual and comforting. Exquisite, carefully prepared food,- generous portions! Excellent service, great bar offerings and fantastic tasteful decor - hip but not obnoxiously so. Truly a 5-star experience. read more

Very Very Good Food! I am really a big fan. Not always consistently good, which is why I do not give it 5 stars. When it is good, it is the BEST. I also love the incredible creativity with the menu. It is so refreshing to go to a restaurant that wants to play with food, in the best possible way. The specials are so unique and lovely. I also really love the staff, I have enjoyed becoming a regular here! read more

Well... I wanted to like this place more than I actually did. I plan on going back again to give it another shot but...well...my expectations are definitely adjusted. The menu is great. It's really well balanced, has a lot of options, good for everyone. They have specials - I have no clue how often they change - but they were relatively seasonal and had a lot of appeal. There are some brains behind this kitchen. The problem falls in the execution. Take, for example, a special we ordered, "Spring dug parsnips, honey butter, and flake salt." The "spring dug" parsnips were very haphazardly cut, in irregular shapes and sizes, which kept some downright crunchy - nearly raw in parts - while others were practically disintegrating and heavily caramelized. The honey butter was clearly made with hot honey, or honey with chili in it - which was actually really nice, but was either a mistake or should have been mentioned in the description. And lastly - there was absolutely no trace of salt - flaky or otherwise. I could see this dish being really enjoyable - but the whole thing fell flat because of remedial kitchen mistakes. The lack of salt was a theme that carried throughout our meal. We couldn't find any indication of it being used to season or finish anything we had throughout the entire meal. Thankfully, there are shakers on the tables. The pizzas had potential - the crust was blistered in parts, and had a pleasing texture and taste. A pretty weak cornicione here, but I don't think they are going for anything quite like Neapolitan style. This is easily the best crust I have had in this part of New England - which is plagued with horrible pizza. I was not a fan of the bruscetta tomato on the margherita - I could see it being good when tomatoes are in season but in March...it doesn't quite sing. The potato pizza was the one dish that suffered the most because of the lack of salt. Adding salt from the shaker can only do so much when you have so much unseasoned potato, buried under a thick layer of cheese (which kind of eliminated the possibility for any crispy potato bits). Potatoes really stand up to a lot of salt...and really the only way I could see this being fixed is slicing much thinner (and actually seasoning) or cooking them in heavily salted water. I did like this as a cold slice the next morning more than the margherita....which was better when it was warm. The other stuff we had isn't really worth writing about...because it will just sound redundant. read more

magpie with beautiful woman. warm greens are fantastical side salad with dressing that was not over-the-top the pizza and its fresh toppings were excellent. the crust was great (and i dont like crust). a little sad that the center was kinda soggy, but overall really really good. our waiter was attentive but not annoying. quick hits: everything ok? need more of this? like some of this? kudos to him. we thought the bill was wrong it was so inexpensive. do it! read more

This is what I would call gourmet or GOOD pizza, PLUS other dinner entree choices! + dessert + organic coffee/espresso... Top quality ingredients, like from local farms, thin, but by no means scanty, crust, straight out of the woodfired oven. Everything tasted fantastic. Local sodas. I wish I lived closer to Greenfield to come here again! Something for everyone; they will make a red pizza for the lactose-intolerant. If you're a fairly hungry bunch, I would each get an individual pizza and enjoy the leftovers...or not. :) read more

Magpie has great brick oven pizzas (when not burned) with fresh, local, quality toppings. They also have excellent homemade meatballs & lasagna. Regarding the meatballs, I would get the appetizer portion. When I got the entree portion, the pasta was overcooked & actually burned. Only 4 stars because they have the tendency to serve burnt food. read more

Delicious and amazing. Strong drinks, lively atmosphere and the friendliest staff around. I can't speak for everyone but the server we had last time we were here was great, I can't remember his name but he was a gentleman and he was very funny and very nice. I look forward to returning here soon, they have delicious food and not the overly pretentious attitude that other popular restaurants around tend to.... read more

Magpie is wonderful, wonderful, wonderful. Artisanal pizza, but not in a jackassy way. Great starters like the meatballs and the roasted veggies. Community and ambition. Hosts events for the area. Great drinks. Restores, or multiplies, your faith in humanity. read more

Wood-fired awesome. Best pizza in Western Mass hands down. It makes me miss San Francisco just a little bit less.

Superb simplicity. Lots if interesting choices on the menu and pizza that is always superb. Excellent service, a great location and fine value. read more

This place is great. The pizza is make with real food yet still tastes like pizza. I've only been there twice but so far so good. Try the Meatball appetizer. read more

I eat a lot of pizza, in a lot of places. I drink a lot of cocktails, in a lot of places. This pizza holds its own against the best I've had. The pepperoni pie is, in fact, the best I've had. The cocktails are rock solid, in particular the specials. I've also had some very nice red wine here. Safe for hipsters, prep school parents, and families with children alike: a rare thing indeed. read more

I love the hipster vibe of magpies. I love the friendly staff. However, the menu is lacking and, well, overpriced for the quality of the dish. The pizza is pretty basic, the gluten free pizza is depressing. Tonight I ordered the "Fazzioletti Crepe". I was expecting a warm appetizing dish, but in reality I was handed a plate with a medium- sized crispy crepe filled with mostly Swiss chard. The dish honestly smelled like old dish water. I really want to like this place. I've come here several times and I always leave disappointed. read more

This was a pretty spectacular dinner spot for us lower pioneer valley visitors. We had amazing eats, and a Fennel Infused Vodka that was a life changing event for me! We're doing the no carb thing -- so why on earth would we go to a pizza joint? Well they have so much more. I had a pasta dish, well really I sort of blended the pasta dish with a roasted veggie dish, the sauce was a calamari whites sauce and was divine! We had salads and veggies and satisfaction and awe are the best descriptors! Now, I'm not saying I won't ever have the pizza, cause I am a gourmet pizza lover! I can't wait! Might have to plan it... Greenfield is a bit of a drive! Thanks, from a Bottle of Bread fan, from back in the day! read more

Excellent thin crust pies. Finally! Great pizza in western Mass.

Well after a long ride home from Vermont I was starved. My boyfriend asked me to look for some pizza places on yelp. I came across magpie and thank god. It was just opening. We got right in and we were completely satisfied with out pizza!! It was so tasty! I had the potato garlic and added meatballs. He has pepperoni and sausage. Both different and just delicious. Highly recommend it. Yum read more

So much more than just pizza. Packed for a reason. I've come to this place for two years, and there's always something new and delicious on the menu. The starters and small plates are excellent. The salads are always fresh and exciting. My favorite eatery in the Valley. read more

Really excellent pizza, but the apps and specials are great too. I just had short ribs which were delicious, and huge, and $16. Haven't had better short ribs this side of the mediterranean. And certainly not for $16. Their homemade ceasar dressing is pitch perfect, and the prociuitto wrapped figs are a revelation. great drinks. a really, really well executed establishment. read more

Great ambiance on a cold Friday night. Bar tender super fast, efficient and fun to watch! Sitting at the bar on a busy night, totally worth the wait. read more

Delicious! The pizzas only come in one size, good for 2-3 people. I would recommend the warm herbed goat cheese, almond spread + bread and the Pepperoni & Mushroom pizza with caramelized onion, tomato and mozzarella. yum!! read more

Went to Magpie for the first time last night after running into a closed Hope and Olive on a Monday. It was nice to have an option in Greenfield other than People's Pint as an alternative (we drove down from VT). We started with bread, olive oil and sea salt, as well as a split caesar salad. The bread was great, while the salad was a bit bland, but a good size for the price. My drink was good - Lime Derby, a nice rum concoction, and my husband was happy with his glass of Italian Red. I found the wine list to be very lackluster, and there were no options in terms of different price points for wine (everything was on the "cheap" side). For dinner, I had the Margharita pie. It was okay - glad I asked for light garlic, because even that was a bit overwhelming. The crust was fine, but had big burnt air bubbles all over it. The biggest disappointment was my husband's dinner - he had the roast pork tenderloin special. It was bone dry, with no sauce, served with dry giant asparagus stalks and dry roasted potatoes. We skipped dessert as there were only two "eh" options, tiramisu and fudge bottom pie. (I should note that I'm very attached to Fireworks Marg pie, and this just couldn't compare, so take my review with a grain of salt). The atmosphere (we went on a Monday) was very pleasant - no wait, not too busy, and although the place filled, it was still fairly quiet. The kitchen crew looked calm and un-frazzled. Service was fine - pleasant, not overbearing, a little slow to start, but with so many menu options, it was no big deal. Overall, it was a good atmosphere, decent food (save the entree) for very reasonable prices. read more

Absolutely delicious pizza and a nice decor. My only complaint is that the kids' pasta is extremely salty. But the place is lovely and a wonderful addition to the area. read more

A Nice casual place with a good vibe and top notch pizza and very friendly wait staff.

Pizza is fantastic, salads and entrees are terrific, awesome hand crafted cocktails! They always have a ton of local products on their menu - fruit and vegetables, meat and seafood, beer... the list goes on! Atmosphere is always warm and friendly with the nicest staff and servers! My favorite pizza joint in the Valley! read more

Magpie is a pleasant addition to this area. I'm in love with open kitchens, which they have, so that's a plus. I had the margherita pie, and it was just what I had expected. The service was great, as well. Last night was my first visit there, and they have me craving more. I will definitely be back. read more

Magpie - Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Greenfield, Massachusetts

Best brick oven we have ever had!! Wow. Great ambiance too. Id say just get a margarita pizza SOOO good

Really nice, casual place for gourmet thin crust pizza. It's bigger on the inside than it seems. We had the meatball pizza and it was delicious. read more

Best pizza in town for a great price. Wait staff is pleasant and still operate decently when it's super busy. I highly recommend this place to anyone who enjoys pizza. read more

As I make my way around the Greenfield restaurants, I came across Magpie. The concept sounded right up my alley. A woodfired pizzeria... and I'm a guy that likes woodfired pizza. I wanted to love this place. I really liked the interior of Magpie. A decent sized bar area with a separate dining area, and nice local decor. I took a seat at the bar, and was pleased to find several local beers on tap (off to a good start). I took a look at the pizza menu and decided to go with the Margarita pizza, only I chose to add the house made sausage to it. I know that makes it far from a true Margarita pizza, but hey, I was trying to add a little bit of Chicago to it. Unfortunately the pizza was very underwhelming. None of the ingredients had much taste, including the sausage which actually kind of tasted like ground beef. I may give Magpie another chance because I do think it's a nice local restaurant, and the service was very good, but I'll definitely explore other options on the menu. read more

Magpie - Margarita pizza, with sausage added - Pizza Near Me - Greenfield, Massachusetts

Love Magpie for yummy pizza, starters and salads. Lots of tasty and creative options that go way beyond pizza. Inviting space and service with a smile. read more

Great service, great salad , and good pizza that doesn't weigh you down. Inviting atmosphere in downtown Greenfield.

Very good pizza! Great meatballs! Everything else is hit or miss. Seams like everyone in this area eats early so make sure you make reservations or get take out. read more

Great pizza!!!!! We love coming here with a group. Cocktails are always inventive and consistently well mixed. Very balanced atmosphere. Love it :) read more

I eat a lot of pizza and prefer the fancy kind they serve at Magpie. It's nice to have a variety of vegetable options for pizza, not just canned mushrooms and maybe frozen green peppers. I often get spinach with carmelized onions and roasted garlic and it makes me do my happy dance every time. The bread and ricotta appetizer is amazing. Crusty and yummy. The dressing on the house salad is subtle and just right. I can't go there often because of the price, but it's worth saving for. read more

As shocked as I am to say it, I had the best pizza of my entire life last night at Magpie. It was almost too good. The crust was tasty, crisp on the edges, and chewy in all the right places. My husband and I shared the pepperoni mushroom pizza with carmelized onions and roasted tomatoes, and all of the toppings were perfectly cooked, fresh, and delicious. They even use fresh, spicy, thick-cut pepperoni. The atmosphere was lovely, the service was attentive without being annoying, and I was basically blown away. read more

Love the pizzas and the people! I almost always try the special pie and I've never been disappointed. There aren't a lot of taps, but they always have a good selection with at least one solid IPA, like Pretty Things Meadowlark. Kid friendly too. There are a couple of tables that make for a very good date spot or just sit at the bar. read more

Clean. Tastiest four cheese pizza and the freshest garden salad that I have had in quite some time. We look forward to returning. As we are fans of the People's Pint, we were dismayed by the selection of beers on tap. The Smuttynose IPA was excellent and they do offer the extremely common BBC Steel Rail. I would like to see more BBC selections as well as some offerings from the local microbreweries on tap. We'll return. read more

I want to give this place 5 stars but our waitstaff experience has been a mix of wonderful to completely horrid. Our waiter whose taken care of us before and is typically always rude took our table over after our orders were in. He brought only my meal and my partner was left without a plate for 10 mins as we tried to get his attention. He seemed upset we had to let him know and when we got the plate it was ice cold. Again another ten minutes went by and we flagged him with his eye contact on us and began walking to us and stopped at the table beside us to take their order. At which point he finally came over and was so rude about my partners food being cold, offered no apology and it wasn't really just whatsoever. I don't think I'll ever dine in here again. But everything else about magpie is awesome!! read more