Fish wasn't fully cooked, forgot our fries, and Cole slaw wasn't edible.. was given a full refund. Will not return. read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

See all

Food was good but portions were incredibly small especially for the price you pay. Staff was very polite and checked in often which was great! The overall atmosphere umm go in with an open mind, it's clean but set up differently. Not sure what it was prior but they worked off that set up. Food 8/10 portion 4/10 Service 11/10 Place 5/10 read more

Good atmosphere and good food . I ordered a Texan tree burger to go. It was cooked perfectly and the side slaw was delicious. The waitress was friendly and helpful. read more

Stopped in for an early lunch right when they opened at 11am, and we're so glad we did! My husband ordered the bone-in wings--super flavorful and cooked perfectly. I went with their famous chicken tenders and got the Caddy sauce on the side...delish! The tenders were incredibly moist and well-seasoned. I also grabbed a side house salad, which was excellent--packed with fresh veggies and super crisp. The staff was so friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Great spot, great food, and we'll definitely be back! read more

Came here tonight for dinner and ordered the Magic Haddock dinner. You can have your choice of preparation; broiled, blackened, or panko coated . I chose panko, and it was delicious. The meal comes with your choice of soup or salad. I chose the salad, and it was good... not your typical iceberg lettuce. This salad was more of a spring mix, with cucumbers, cherry tomatoes and croutons. Fresh cut French fries and coleslaw also came with the dinner and they were both very tasty. The service was quick, and the staff is very friendly. Nice large bar area and a separate dining room make this spacious bar/restaurant a nice place to meet friends and have a drink or dinner. read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - Magic Haddock dinner - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

Service at the bar was exceptional. Quiet and relaxed atmosphere on a Monday night when most restaurants in the area were closed. We had the peppers on pretzel crostini. Could've used more peppers and if the pretzels were fresh versus they old toast, it would be much better. But over all the flavors were good. Also had a hamburger that was well cooked and very flavorful. read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - Hamburger - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

There were four of us, the place had a nice feel, several big screen TVs and a huge bar. We were greeted and seated almost immediately. A server provided us with menus, the experience appeared to be heading in the right direction. However, the experience just wasn't great after we sat down. It took about 20 mins. just for water and to place a drink order, and another 20 mins for our server to return and take our food order. We than waited 30 mins. for our food. The place really wasn't too busy, it just seemed to take a long time for everything except being seated. They appeared short staffed, however, it's just nice if someone would have just acknowledged us. read more

See all

I came to this place with some coworkers and we truly enjoyed it! We had some appetizers: we tried the pretzels, the mushrooms and the spinach artichoke dip, and everything was great! I ordered the chicken & greens sandwich with mixed vegetables and it was really good! Service was great, folks were really kind and the pub ambiance was awesome! read more

My son took me here for a belated Mother's day lunch. Seating is open. You can go whereever you like. They do have a daily special chalkboard. I found the booths very roomy and could accomodate a small group of people. I decided to order the cranberry turkey wrap with bacon along with a side of green beans. My son had the vegan gyro with vegan mac and cheese. The pretzels looked inviting however, since they are made with butter then they are not entirely vegan. We got our food in a reasonable amount of time. I enjoyed the wrap although it was a little bit too seasoned for my taste. The green beans were cooked to perfection. My son loved his vegan gyro as well as the macaroni and cheese. They have a full bar here as well as large TV screens. We had good service and an enjoyable meal. Located in Boardman, Ohio not too far from the PA state line, they have their own private parking lot. read more

See all

We arrived at 6:30 PM on St Patrick's day for dinner. We were seated in about 10 minutes. The waitress took our drink order and did not return for approximately 45 minutes to place our food order. We had to wave her down and she said sorry I thought you ordered. They had a limited menu which is understandable. My husband wanted the regular pretzel and she said they only had the small one. I wanted the Reuben rolls, she said they were out of them. We then asked for bill. $18.00 plus for 2 very bad lemonades and one drink. Will not be back. read more

Magic Tree is a great spot to grab some delicious food in the Youngstown area. It's easy on-easy off the freeway. We ordered up the famous one pound pretzel. Omg it was sooooo good! The beer cheese dip was money & as was the pecan caramel dip. They are a must! I opted for the side salad & Mac n cheese- both just as delicious as the pretzel. The Mac n cheese was soooo cheesy, yum! My man got the hand cut chicken fingers & fries. They were amazing! The portions are large, so the prices fit the portions. Perfect for sharing. The ambiance is brewery-esque, with a whole rail of microbrews on tap. You can tell the owner takes pride in the quality of his food served. Stop in and see for yourself! It's a great spot! read more

See all

Ordered a delicious burger with fresh jalapeños and roasted red peppers. Sides of French fries and Mac n cheese. $3 mimosa because the draft lineup left a bit to be desired. Quality food. Very nice bartender. Fairly large space. I'll definitely be back! read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - Magic 8 Burger - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

See all

The food was fine but the entire restaurant smells like sewage and poop. We went four months ago and decided to give it one more chance and it still smells like poop. read more

Food was great! The fried green tomatoes were perfect! The ambience was quiet and I was a bit skeptical but then I ate the food and it was the best thing ever. The service was on par and the waitress was attentive as expected. read more

Came here after a local Christmas craft show and some shopping . My husband has wanted to try this place as he works locally. We ordered the giant pretzel ( speciality on the menu ) came with three dipping sauces. We had the bacon beer cheese, IPA mustard, and the pecan caramel. All of the sauces were luscious and incredible with a hot, salty pretzel. Ordered the Nashville hot chicken and my husband ordered the Jan burger. This establishment is also known for their chicken tenders and the chicken is the same as the fried chicken sandwich. The fried chicken sandwich was incredible! It was huge! My husband really enjoyed his burger. The flavors commended each other eloquently. I would come here again. read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - Fried chicken sandwich - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

Was bedding down in Youngstown on my trip through to Chicago, and was looking for a gastropub in the area. Magic Tree came up on Yelp and I gave it a shot. Glad I did. My server Macy was nice, attentive, and the right level of conversational. She knows her stuff, and is an asset on their staff. Had the Black n Blue Burger with their homemade brew chips, and the local Penguin City Ale - all great. And they had this insanely delicious (and simple) french onion dip for the chips that was a perfect match. Will absolutely look to visit again on my next cross-country drive. read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

We visit Boardman for two reasons: shopping and Vintage Estates Wine and Beer. About 3 (maybe 4) years ago we stopped here and were blown away on how good it was, how fresh the beer was, and the selection. Unfortunately that is where it ended. Last year we came back. New menu. Bad beer. The beer selection was poor (not in quantity but in quality). The taste of the beer was bad (flat and vinegar undertones from uncleaned taps and lines). The wine was bad. We came back recently and it was equally bad, if not worse. We'll never come back. We found that it's under new ownership thus the changes to the beer and menu. Perhaps the WORST thing about it was we came on a Saturday afternoon. Instead of the loud sound of college football, they blasted teenage angst music which was utterly annoying and depressing. It's just awful. They'll be out of business soon (likely due to new ownership who is dropping the ball). read more

Service was excellent. Food has slightly gone downhill. My sister had always raved about the garlic chicken pasta, garlic was burnt and chicken was rubbery. The caddy Mac was good, chicken tenders were also good. We were surprised how dead the restaurant was on a Friday night. The atmosphere was still as good as ever! Bring back Cajun chicken Alfredo!! read more

Never let "Teddy" back into the restaurant. He kept drunkedly telling everyone in my group how much he hates his son. I had an incredible Moscow Mule, best drink i've ever had. The pretzel was a bit soft. read more

Fabulous beer selection! Good service, good food. Nice place to hang & enjoy good company.

I went here for my birthday dinner, and everything was impeccable. The service was terrific too. It's very much a gastropub (over 41 beers) with a very eclectic ambiance. I was pleasantly surprised with the outdoor patio as well. I ordered almost every appetizer because I wanted to try everything. I will say you must try the Pretzel Charcuterie. It is amazing. It was a one-pound pretzel, topped with butter and salted. Served with hot and sweet soppressata, imported meats and cheeses, cherry tomatoes, pickled onions, grapes, Dijon mustard, hot honey dip, IPA mustard, hot peppers, and oil, and finally topped with fresh crispy apple slices. It was indeed unlike anything I've ever had, worth the trip alone just for this beauty. Edamame, Hot Chips Chips w/ French Onion Dip,) and Fried Green Tomatoes was all very average to me and didn't stand out. They were tasty but would not be something I went out of my way to order again. Now the Cadillac Cauliflower, which I could eat as a meal, was lightly battered and fried cauliflower tenders. This was far better than many chicken tenders I've had, honestly. It came with their signature Cadillac sauce for dipping, creamy yet tangy with a bit of kick but a smooth version of a Buffalo sauce. It's worth buying in bulk. If they offered it, it's so tasty. I swear this is the uniquely delicious food dreams made of. I've been craving this dish ever since I tried it!! I ordered for my meal the Caddy Mac, which was a four-cheese Mac and cheese served with spiral noodles and served with chicken tenders breaded atop and doused in that signature Cadillac sauce. This was good too but a bit spicy, not too spicy it wasn't enjoyable, but I could feel the heat as I ate it. This ended up being about four meals just with this dish for me because it was so large. I only really took a few bites at the restaurant, though, due to going overboard with the appetizers. Next time I will probably get the vegan Mac n cheese and ask to sub in the cauliflower instead of the chicken, topped with a cardiac sauce. That would be everything I love about this restaurant in one dish. The decor was more an industrial inside feel but still quiet and chic enough to be a great date night spot easily. The outdoor patio was impeccably large as well, and also, as the temp was lowering, they had heaters and a fire pit going. This is a must-try in Boardman!!! read more

See all

This USED to be a good restaurant, and known for their giant pretzel. I have been there once in the last year. I ordered the pretzel and it came out black. I re-ordered it and it came out black again! They claimed it was the lye, however there was a perfect pretzel on the table next to me. I told the manager I wanted my pretzel to look like theirs. She told me she will bring me raw pretzel dough and to cook it myself. They won't "waste any more of their time or money". That was enough for me. Oh the rest of the food (that I STILL paid full price for) was simply AWFUL! DO NOT GO HERE EVER! read more

We went to magic tree with a large party, and it was a great place for something like that. It is definitely a pub feel and the menu was very reflective of that. While I thought the pretzel along with the sauces was one of the best I ever had, the steak sandwich I ordered could have been much better. The hostess was very nice and patient with us which we appreciated. We arrived hours prior to close, but felt very rushed. It was apparent we wanted to socialize with our party and enjoy our drinks, but were asked multiple times to put our order in right away. A few of our orders came out wrong, which was fine, but they did not end up bringing the things we asked for. Overall, I would come back just for the pretzel, but the other food was not the best. read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - Pretzel - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

Astoundingly good. The pretzel is a true gem. Got a 1lb charcuterie pretzel for dinner and it was excellent. The cheese and meat were fresh and the pretzel was perfect. Incredible. read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - Charcuterie Pretzel - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

overpriced, -taste like reheated frozen food They charge entirely too much for it. It's a shame they used to have really good food. read more

Excellent service. Food tasty. Both my husband I ordered food that was spicier than we expected but very tasty. I enjoyed the homemade black bean burger. Loved the vinegar cole slaw side. I held the onion and chipotle mayo. I requested the Cadillac buffalo garlic sauce on the side, but it was way too spicy for me. read more

Unbelievable. My husband and I took a day trip to Ohio, and along the way, we stopped at Magic Tree. We liked the ambience, and our server, Bruno, was very kind. We each ordered a beer; he had the steak sandwich and I had the Haddock Wrap. I was just about to take the third bite or so, and my mouth felt something strange-foreign. I pulled the object out of mouth, only to discover that it was a metal and plastic twist-tie! I am not normally a "what if?" person, but what if I bit down? Swallowed it?! Now, having worked in a few restaurants, I know, as well as anyone, that mistakes happen. Accidents happen. I am not as upset about the incident as I am about the way it was handled. I called Bruno over, who did exactly what he should have; he took the plate back to the manager. After a rather long time, in my opinion, she came to our table and told us she was very sorry. She'd informed the cook and staff, and she took the wrap off of the bill and gave us a free appetizer card. Am I wrong to say that that is what you do when a food item is burnt or distasteful, not when a HAZARDOUS FOREIGN OBJECT is found in food? This is negligence. I was surprised to see that we were still paying for the rest of the check. While Bruno, who we know had several tables, and not to his fault, took 6 minutes to bring back the check, I noticed that there was a large chip in my water glass. Maybe that was the poison icing on the cake. I asked for the manager to come back, and when she did, we informed her of the glass. Again, no further compensation for the meal. What I am asking, what I feel is right, is for our check to be voided. Seeing that there is diligent attention to Yelp reviews by the owner, I request a response to this matter. Thank you. read more

Good place for bar food and bar/restaurant experience. They pretzels are awesome! I've been here many times and never had a bad meal. COLD beer too read more

I have recently relocated back here to my hometown after residing in Southern Florida for 43 years. I have had the most incredible memories take place at this establishment over the past 6 years!! The food is excellent, The employees extremely attentive. There has been numerous times when they would accommodate a large group of people on very short notice. I was able to see so many friends from my high school days in a place of great ambiance. Thanks to all at the Magic Tree read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - This is a "Magical " signage that meets you at the front entrance at the Magic Tree !! - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

The place always has a great atmosphere for relaxing and dining at anytime! The food is very good and they have added a few vegan dishes to their offerings. read more

This used to be a great place to go to for food and music. Now, you wait 20-30 minutes just for them to take a drink order. The quality of the food has gone way down. Meat is either burnt or raw, nothing in between. Fries are raw in the center. The signature pretzel is hard on the outside and raw in the middle. The wait staff hides in the back once plates come out, I'm guessing because they don't want the complaints. I've heard from others that the new owner also owns Coaches, which speaks volumes because Coaches is not very good anymore either. read more

Slow service and pricey food not worth the money. Good beer choice is the only plus. They even screwed up Saint Patrick's Day. Most of the music were cover bands with little traditional Irish music. read more

Avoid. Walked in and walked right back out. Host was rude. The people in front of us walked out as well.

Gluten-free available, including hamburger buns. Stopped in around 4pm, Saturday, Oct 21. Maria was our server- she was attentive - thanks! Two college football games were on. Although there were other tables available, we were seated under one of the tvs with the volume up. We still could hear each other, but that is the reason for the one star deduction. read more

This town has a problem. They need to understand how to welcome people into their establishment. Smile, welcome them and bring them to a nice table in a timely manner. Respect their reservations and their needs. That's really all it takes. If you're hostesses don't know how to be nice, train them! Oh, good food helps. We liked some of the dishes, but wondered why there was no salt, pepper, any kind of condiment on the table. We would have liked to have flavored our food to our individual choices. read more

Went here in my second date with my Soulmate for my Birthday in 2020 yay!!! It taste awesome read more

Magic Tree Pub & Eatery - Salmon and Mac and cheese. He had their meatloaf - Pubs Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

Too at magic tree is so cute! Love the food, music, drinks, and staff! Always a great experience

This is a cool local pub. The selection of beers they have are really good. I generally get the fish and chips, which just brings me back to all the times I had that meal in the UK. Whether they are busy or slow, I've gotten great service. The vibe of this place is very relaxed and friendly. Another great spot here in the Youngstown area. read more

Never answer the phone and when you order something for pickup on DoorDash and they don't have it, they do not call you to let you know. Then, when you show up, nothings ready and they ask if you want to order something else and you have to wait. Place has really gone down hill. read more

first, the Mac n cheese was SWIMMING in sauce. I have had this Mac n cheese many times before. I couldn't even SEE the noodles. second, my chicken tenders were burnt and my fries weren't cooked all the way... make it make sense? THIRD, they also burnt my hot chips. burnt half my food and didn't cook the other. very disappointed in the food we ordered, yes we ordered take out and the pickup was for 10pm. but you don't close until 11 and even if I came in and did an order closer to 11 the food quality should be the exact same no matter what time. I work in the food industry and many people walk in minutes before we close and we don't serve food like that. wish I could've said better things but this food was not good. read more