Way better service and food than Slim & Jumbos next door. The food was very good! Cool atmosphere, highly recommend

Excellent pub food! Had the Guinness burger - so sloppy you could hardly hold it - loved it! Pub chips were great. Service was great and the atmosphere was truly a small town local bar - absolutely wonderful. A great experience. read more

Stopped here randomly on the way to somewhere else for a late lunch on a Saturday. It wasn't very busy and we got to sit right away. The staff was super friendly and helpful. I had the fish and chips which was fresh cod and perfectly beer-battered and cooked. The house chips were good, but the onion dip they made was phenomenal. Cole slaw was okay. My wife has the Rueben sandwich was also amazing. And our nephew had chicken fingers which had a nice peppery batter. All good. But the best part was the Irish Cream Cake. It was a secret family recipe and I totally see why they keep it a secret. It would definitely draw me back here. Moist cake, chocolate syrup and a gooey center that was to die for! If I was ever passing through this town again, I would definitely stop here to eat again. read more

Sean's Pub & Eatery - Fish and chips - Pubs Near Me - Garrettsville, Ohio

This was a nice little find. We came here off a recommendation from a local. It was later in the evening and we had not had dinner and just wanted a quick but good dinner. This was perfect. It was not crowded on a Thursday night at all. Just a few people. Which was fine with us. We sat ourselves in a booth in the middle of the room. Told the server that we had never eaten here what is good. She said wings which were on special Thursday. And the burgers and corned beef. We both opted for the corned beef and got the rueben sandwich with pub chips and French onion dip. Let me just say, the French onion dip is homemade goodness at its best. The chips are very crispy and the dip is cool and flavorful. I could have ate a vat of it. The reuben was good. Meat was lean. Good amount on grilled bread. Sauerkraut was good too. And they have a homemade 1000 island dressing. This was a great find. The place is an old pub. The tables and bar are worn. Old Guinness posters hung up and Harp sign. There is a giant fireplace on 1 wall. When you walk in you can smell the fire. Parking is right outside. Service was nice. Prices were good too. The only downside which I knew the answer before I asked was - can I get the wing special to go. I thought I could buy some for lunch the next day. But you cannot. The special you have to buy and consume there I guess. Not sure how to-go orders would work then. Anyway I was denied. Personally I don't see what the big deal is. In this case they would have sold another meal and up'd our check total and I would have a good lunch. It's a win-win. Regardless we will be back. read more

Sean's Pub & Eatery - Reuben with pub chips and French onion dip and 1000 island dressing - Pubs Near Me - Garrettsville, Ohio

Service was excellent, cozy as you walked fireplace was going we went for lunch !Fish was frozen , mashed potatoes were instant and the salibury steak was a fried hamburger with gravy . read more

Excellent food. Great service, the burgers are super good! Great beer selection, lots of locals. read more

I've been a resident since 2019 and this restaurant was my very first in the neighborhood. My daughter had saw that the restaurant had pretty decent reviews and she recommended it we went in. We were greeted very friendly. I wasn't sure what to get. My waiter suggested the burgers. I had a taste for corn beef so I got the blarney, it was the hamburger that I wanted and also the corn beef that I wanted it was delicious and so were the homemade potato chips and the coleslaw was excellent. I had two takeout orders since then which was recently 2023 and it still had the high standards From my very first order I will certainly consider being a repeat customer. The food is good and the people are very nice and it has a nice old time feel to the restaurant as I am a senior citizen. I did love the ambience so glad to know that there is delicious food in GARRETTSVILLE read more

Love this place! Cozy, friendly, great service and terrific food, with a few Irish faves. Their Reuben is amazing!!

Good pub atmosphere. Loved sitting by the crackling fire with my wife. Family run business with kids helping so better service.

I've been coming here for years. Always fresh ingredients and excellent service. The smith wick french dip is out of this world. The burgers are hug, I end up taking half home. read more

It was ok food nothing special to report came it ate and left satisfied it was awhile ago so I can't remember everything but I'll try again and leave a more detailed review read more

They have a great selection of burgers and timely service. Actually the only place in Garrettsville I would go to for a burger

Always welcoming and a go to for family and friends! Their shepherds pie is always my fave or of course a basic burger and fries!! I don't drink much now but they have an Awesome selection and a warm fun atmosphere for you to come and hang out!!!! When there is a festival tho it will get crowded so just watch that time of year! But come in and be apart of our awesome community! read more

Very friendly wonderful atmosphere delicious bar food!! Love love the Chili!! The Rueben is phenomenal!! Staff is awesome!! Great place to know to kick back on the weekend after a full work week!! read more

Great find when driving through Garrettsville. Looking at the outside I was hesitant, but am sure glad we went in. We had delicious, hot food and a friendly attentive waitress. Would go back again if we were in the area read more

The food is always wonderful. The atmosphere is such a nice little pub. The service is wonderful.

Tuesday night's are the best with $6.00 burgers and fries!!! I keep working my way through the menu. Whether alone or with friends the service is good and the food tasty! read more

The best way to describe the food I guess is "comfort food". We had several different meals and it was ALL good. My Chili was excellent. Burger was very good. Son said his fried fish is some of the best he had ever had. Wife life the Shepard Pie. The dessert called "Irish Cream Cake" is delicious! It was just like being in a real Irish Pub. Well, I've never been to Ireland but, I've been to Germany so close. Staff friendly, service very good. Cozy/family friendly pub environment. Will be back! read more

See all

Great local pub in Garrettsville. Very friendly staff an patrons. Smithwicks on tap makes everything better. They have a decent selection of other cervezas as well. I had a reuben with fries. The sauerkraut and corn beef were perfect. Sean's Pub and Slim's are in the same building. I think the delineation is they are on separate floors. No matter, it was a great experience. I will definitely go back and try a burger as they looked awesome as well. read more

The Ambiance is great! I met my husband on a blind date there 18 years ago. The food was much better then, but it's still pretty good.

Sean's is always a hit. We sat in the patio and had a lovely time. The server was friendly and attentive. I love their side salads because they include green pepper, which is delightful. The fish and shrimp was a great hit! Their homemade chips and dip was the perfect side! read more

Fish was nothing more than frozen Gorton fish sticks. Fries were cold. Wife's Irish stew (beef and mashed potatoes in a bowl) was good. Overall, more disappointing than fulfilling. read more

A group of us were in town for a race and we wanted to go there after the race. We're a group of folks over 40 (so not a bunch of rowdy peeps) We were DENIED entry and they didn't think they could accommodate us?? REALLY?? We went next door to Slim and Jumbos who gladly welcomed us. Talk about losing out on business. read more

Just went here. This is a great place. The food was amazing. Had the fish fry with pub chips. The fish was perfect. The service was great considering there was only one waitress. Take the opportunity to go when your in the area read more

This place is a Garrettsville treasure. Whether it's the cozy restaurant, with beautiful old-school decor, or the sports bar it connects to, both serve the same great food. That includes some of the best wings I've ever had. I've tried many of their flavors. All were good. The honey siracha and hot garlic are among the best I've ever had, especially served traditional style. The chicken quality, crisp and moist, is also really good, a key differentiator from some other places. But don't get this confused as just a wing place. They have a big menu. My dad loved his wrap. My girlfriend liked her salad. They have deadly garlic parmesan breadsticks and beer cheese dip. And they have some incredible wing and drink specials that make this place a particular bargain. (If you want to really save money, check out the specials before you go to help pick a night!) read more

Sean's Pub & Eatery - Pubs Near Me - Garrettsville, Ohio

Love coming here. Always get the same lady as our waitress and she is so friendly! The food is amazing too!!

We always have great service and delicious food! Sean's pub has the best reuben's around!!! Hands down the best I have ever had.

Excellent. Great food, great service. Great location. My children enjoyed this as well. They had the fireplace going which was awesome on a super snowy day. read more

Wings! This place is my favorite townie bar. The staff is awesome, the wings are amazing as is all the other food also. If the table by the fireplace is open, grab it. A pint of your favorite draft beer seems to taste better next to a crackling fire. read more

We had a great time and the food was excellent. I can only echo previous reviewers and say that the fish, the onion dip, and the Smithwick's au jus sandwich are all must-haves! Can't wait to go back for the Shepherds Pie. read more

Cute, comfortable atmosphere. The Rueben was very yummy and my husband enjoyed the pirogies. Plus, the service was fast and friendly.

Loved it good was great I've been there twice both times food was great they keep the prices low and the staff was very friendly

Omg, this place is just too cute! I love the tiny fireplace, the outdoor patio & the woodwork throughout the building. I purchased there Smithwick's Beef Au Jus & could not get over this new twist on a classic French Dip. The french fries on the side were perfectly crispy & delicious as well. My mom ordered The Pub Club , which is huge!, and was equally impressed. The menu also has some unique items such as, the sweet Guinness burger & Guinness garlic steamed mussels! Where else could you find such a thing? Our server, Randy was really nice and accommodating. The prices were fair and the portions large. Definitely will be coming back time & time again! read more

The food seems ok,nothing special. BUT I ordered a 2 margarita's that cost around 16 bucks and were undrinkable. They use the cheapest high fructose drink mix's they can find. My stomach can't handle high fructose so I've never been back. There alwas seemed to be a different bartender since they get fired often. How can they screw this up? Tequila Lime Juice Cointreau Simple syrup (sugar and water) read more

Had a fun afternoon at Sean's Pub today catching up with a buddy, watching a ball game, and enjoying great food and a friendly visit with staff and fellow diners. Can't say enough good things about the place. Great time! My wonderful experience here was tarnished by one minor detail. Midway through my sandwhich (the western burger is delicious, totes recommend!), in come a couple jokers who proceeded to rant at staff because the dinning area isn't large enough to accommodate every member of their massively large clown posse. I hop on the interweb this evening and LO! These jackwagons had the nerve to complain! Anne H, you and every other member of your farce, listen up. The staff at Sean's was nothing but professional and kind to you. I listened as a friendly bartender calmly told you that it just wasn't possible to accommodate a group of so many individuals. You and that schmuck you were with were nothing but rude to the poor girl. Shame on you! Please race back yellow brick road to the circus you came from, and on the way stop to see the wizard who will, without doubt, give you many many doses of RESPECT, something you clearly lack. You could have put a blind man inside that dinning area without his cane or seeing eye dog and he would have been able to tell in half the time it took you that the room simply isn't large enough to accommodate the extremely large group that you spoke of. To Sean (if the owner of the fine establishment's name is indeed Sean), Bro you gotta be proud of the kind and professional staff you have working for you, they deserve the highest praise! They handled a group of nasty complainers with kindness, respect, and professionalism. Thank you everyone at Sean's for a great meal and a great time. read more

Okay, I haven't been eating out for a couple of weeks, since I had a doctor appointment and found out I was gaining weight. Today I decided to try a new place, and found this gem here in Garretsville. I got coffee, Shepherd's Pie and a salad. Everything is great, including the atmosphere. I'll have to bring my sister and her husband in here to tell me how authentically Irish it is, but I like it and will be back. read more

First trip to Garrettsville. Our waitress was prompt and attentive. We had the fish basket special of the day. Delicious. My specially made drink "blue mermaid " was awesome. Huge list of beer choices. We would definitely go here again. Even though it was packed our meals arrived in 15 minutes. read more

My husband had to drag me into a pub to have "dinner" and I am so glad he did. The food and atmosphere are wonderful! The staff is friendly and most feel like old friends by the time you are ready to leave. Any time we have company we take them here to have a nice time and meal. We come in about 3 to 4 times a month, just my husband and I. Love it! read more

Went to Nelson-Kennedy State Park and decided to stop in town to grab a bite to eat and a drink. Must say this is a pretty cool place. It's actually a few bars that are all interconnected. Everyone from the staff to the patrons were very respectful of COVID-19 precautions. Excellent selection of adult beverages and food. Great location with other places in the area to check out. Make sure to walk across the street to check out the elevated walkway behind the buildings along the river, VERY cool. Had a great time and will definitely be back. read more

The rating says it all, and they have a St patties Day countdown clock! The Beer Battered Cod Fish and Chips is utterly delicious and they have a decent mid and top shelf liquor selection. Relaxed, friendly atmosphere. read more

Sean's Pub & Eatery - Pubs Near Me - Garrettsville, Ohio