Nah... I went to the cookie place next door and decided to try the smoothie place right there. I tried some kind of coconut beach smoothie. The lady behind the counter was very cranky. It took her about 2 minutes to make the smoothie. I realized later that maybe I did not see any fresh fruit to make the smoothie. It would take more that 2 minutes to make if it was all fresh. It was just a pink gooey mess in the cup. read more

I've been a regular at Madison's for a couple of years now. The owner is very friendly and the food is amazing. I don't eat dairy and they are very accommodating to that. The "World's Greatest Egg Sandwich" may ACTUALLY be the world's greatest. Would definitely recommend!! read more

Madison's Smoothie Cafe - The World's Worlds Greatest Egg Sandwich - Juice Bars & Smoothies Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Ah Madison's. I used to be a huge fan of Madison's when it first opened in Bellmore back in high school. I just started recently going to the new location in Wantagh and haven't had any bad experiences until yesterday. I wouldn't even call it bad, just somewhat odd? My boyfriend and I stopped to order some food after the beach, and as we were about to order, the lady behind the counter said that they are technically closed for labor day at 1 pm (I think it was 1:45 at this point). She said that she was waiting for the group of customers sitting at a table to leave even though she had told them the place was now closed. She said the cafe was only still open because they were there, and that we can still order smoothies and the pastries, just not food. We were just confused as to why she couldn't lock the doors from the inside and kind of felt bad/weird ordering anything so we went somewhere else. We appreciated her being still somewhat open past the closing time to accommodate some customers but we wanted a nice place to sit down and enjoy a quick meal. I will probably be back as I like their food, smoothies, and free popcorn. Just thought that encounter was a bit strange! By the way- The veggie wrap featured in the picture was from when I went a few weeks ago! Very good. read more

Madison's Smoothie Cafe - Veggie wrap with beets, hummus, avocado. So good! A bit messy to eat. I like how the tortilla is toasted - Juice Bars & Smoothies Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Quick service and they always help me out when I can't figure out what to get. Tried the go green smoothie and added strawberries. Sooo good and filling! Great location just not too much parking read more

Madison's Smoothie Cafe - Go green smoothie - Juice Bars & Smoothies Near Me - Wantagh, New York

I love this place and had been going here since before they moved to this new location. We've since moved out of the state, but every tine we visit family, I make it a point to stop here. In the mornings I get the egg sandwich with Swiss and vegetables. My wife used to get the egg sandwich how she liked it, but now gets the açaí bowl. The Larissa's secret shake is really good too. If we come for lunch, we always like to try new things. I'm quite often weary of places that have this much to offer in terms of variety because that no restaurant can be good at that many items. This is one place that proves me wrong because I've never had anything I didn't like. On top of all that, I honestly love the staff. read more

Wow! What a surprise this place was! After joking about their sign in the window advertising world's best egg sandwich I just had to try them out and I am so happy I did. They have a really great sandwich and it's also the best deal. $4 here gets you a perfect bacon, egg and cheese served with a crispy hash brown patty and a choice of coffee, tea, or juice!!! The owner is super friendly and they even have a reward point system. "This is the best breakfast ever!" said my 6 year old son. And I cannot disagree with him! read more

See all

I went into this Madison's Smoothie Café in Wantagh. The man with lovely gray blue eyes was my server. He did have to ask the woman there what things were. I saw a list of smoothies with School Names and decided upon a Wantagh Warrior which has lots of very sweet mix of peach, mango, and orange. I found out it is served in a 24 oz. cup and he was kind to separate it to two 12 inch cups. The lady even added a couple of pretty little paper umbrellas. I also ordered a quesadilla. It comes with 3 cheeses and is put in a wrap in the oven (I believe it is an air fryer or conventional) which melts it together. It was like a light grill cheese sandwich slice. There were four cut and placed in a pizza box. The Pepper Jack cheese has a nice tiny bit of extra flavor in it and the man had asked me if it was for me, noting for children he uses American cheese as the third choice instead. It was on a bit of higher cost than a few other places I have gone. Though everything seemed fresh made and the place seemed clean. The menu seems pretty extensive with varieties of things to choose from. I was given a black and white copy from here along with a color copy of another owned store in Southgate called Crostini a Pizzeria and Restaurant, showing coupons and noting "Little Place Big Taste!" The drink was very sweet but tasty and the Quesadilla was light and filling. A place I might visit again should I be in the area; along with one future reference to look for in Southgate. read more

The quality of Madison's has significantly declined since they opened. The store feels dingy and behind the counter does not look clean. Even the smoothie blenders were questionable. They don't have as much of a selection, although now I'd hesitate to buy food there. And for the smoothies it seems like they don't really use fresh fruit anymore. My smoothie separated and you could see the strawberry syrup at the bottom. Customer service is also lacking. read more

Yelp's 2-star description, "Meh. I've experienced better," is accurate for my coworker and I's recent visit here. I had not had a wrap in a long time and my coworker was craving a smoothie, so we went to Madison's. I vaguely recall enjoying my smoothie the last time. We were going to order to take out. When we arrived, only one woman was working behind the counter, and she was engaged in a very involved conversation with a customer she either was friends with or related to. As she chatted it up with the customer and slowly put together her acai bowl, we considered leaving as we and the dad and son who came in after us were ignored for some time. We decided to stick it out since we were already there. The place has some seating to eat in, with an extensive smoothie menu. As she was finishing up that person's order, she took my coworker's smoothie order, which was the orange cream that was supposed to have "ripe oranges" and nonfat yogurt, and my order, which was for a BBQ chicken wrap with grilled chicken, mozzarella, BBQ sauce and pineapple. I was especially looking forward to the pineapple as that set the wrap apart from typical deli fare. The smoothie was over 5 dollars and the wrap was nearly 7 dollars. The woman working moved super quick making our orders. I did not see her put my wrap together but I saw her package it. We watched her look over the blender for my coworker's smoothie, which clearly lacked yogurt and ripe oranges and was very liquid, like only orange juice. After being handed our orders, she again chatted with her friend before we could finally check out. My coworker was super disappointed in her smoothie that really became just a frozen chunk of orange-colored ice with no fruit at all and no yogurt texture or taste. She could not finish it. When I opened my wrap, I was happy to see well-melted mozz and a generous portion of chicken in a thin but full whole wheat wrap. However, the chicken was drenched in the BBQ sauce and no pieces of pineapple were to be found. I had to suck on some lozenges afterwards to get the overwhelming BBQ sauce taste out of my mouth. Very disappointed. Unfortunately I do not believe we will give this place a return visit. read more

Yum! Tried the harmony smoothie and it was so delicious and refreshing. The service was great. The gentleman behind the counter was very pleasant and kind. We will definitely be back here! read more

Madison's Smoothie Cafe - Harmony smoothie - Juice Bars & Smoothies Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Ive been really sick past two days so i needed something to drink other than water cause im getting super dehydrated. I went here and got a Peach smoothie and its wonderful. Real fruit and delish. Im back in bed now and hoping this smoothie rejuvenates me so i can function again. read more

Madison's Smoothie Cafe - Peach something - Juice Bars & Smoothies Near Me - Wantagh, New York

I loveee the sunrise surprise smoothie. I got two egg sandwiches today one with turkey and one with bacon, both with cheese. I liked it better than the two delis nearby. The gentleman who made the sandwiches and his wife were super friendly. He insisted i take some left over sautéed onions that he had made and i said no thank you. But he gave them to me anyway on the side and i am glad he did. He wasn't wrong when he said they were delicious, and went great on the turkey, egg and cheese. Oh and they also came with a hash brown, which i didn't know and definitely was not sad about. read more

Madison's Smoothie Cafe - a sandwich wrapped in aluminum foil - Juice Bars & Smoothies Near Me - Wantagh, New York

This place is perfect for a quick sandwich, wrap or smoothie! The food is great, the staff is always helpful and friendly and they have free popcorn!! I had an issue with something I purchased and the owner personally called me and handled the situation in such a professional manner, I continued to be a regular customer since then. They also participate in a reward app that gives you free stuff for check-ins! Always a perk. read more

I had the pomegranate fever smoothie. It was very sweet and very sour. I would order a different smoothie next time. The price was fair at about $7. The service was quick once I placed my order. read more

Can't say enough good things about this place. I get my morning exercise done as I make my way towards this place and I reward myself with a healthy smoothie jam packed with all suitable add-ons for my needs. I've also had the burrito and the acai bowl and everything is awesome every time. Staff is very helpful with helping you modify your order and making recommendations based on your needs or wants. I've been coming here for a few months now and continue to find new awesome stuff every time I visit. Def recommend if you want to stay/get healthy. One thing I've noticed about LI since I've been here for a year now is that unless you're cooking it's very hard to find a genuinely healthy store to eat in. This place is it. Recommend to everyone. read more

Madison's Smoothie Cafe - My post-workout custom smoothie and their amazing Acai Bowl!!! Gotta refuel after the burn!! - Juice Bars & Smoothies Near Me - Wantagh, New York

This is a great hidden spot. I don't want to wait on lines, but here it's so worth it! Like, you know, a great spot just for me. And I share with my friends. And now with you! I hope you enjoy as much as I do. read more

We really like this place. Fun to have self service yogurt and toppings. Staff is always friendly. My only complaint is the music is way too loud. However they can't turn it down due to management so I'll have to figure that out. It's nearly impossible to have a conversation there. I love it when the back patio is open. Quieter out there and relaxing. read more

absolutely disgusting served EXPIRED/ROTTEN meat in their corndog I took one bite and threw up i probably have rat poisoning in my system now read more

Madison's Smoothie Cafe - a hand holding a half eaten donut - Juice Bars & Smoothies Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Love coming here , the place is local and close to my home. The service is always good and the food and smoothies are reasonably priced. I usually go during the day and the women Jess that works there is great. She is friendly and before I order she knows what I'm having and starts making it. I would recommend this place to anyone. read more

Honestly, when this place was closer to the high school I loved it so much more I feel like they aren't giving it as much effort now unless it was just the night I went but the two kids behind the counter were talking to each other about their night and how they couldn't wait to leave and texting. The phone rang for a delivery and they complained. And the girl did such a sloppy job on my acai bowl which was incredibly sweet and just so much acai and not enough toppings. And the prices were pretty expensive. I also got a chicken quesadilla that I had to drown in salsa and sour cream because it had zero taste. It used to be so good and maybe it was just an off night so I gave it 3 stars. I will try again another day and hopefully change this review! read more

I've been working in wantagh for about a year now and I can't believe it took me 10 months to find this place. The service is fast and the food is amazing. They give little encouraging notes with your order which always puts a smile on my face. This is my new go to lunch spot. read more

This my go to place to get smoothies. Not only do they have smoothies, but they also have a variety of sandwiches, wraps, and pizzas. I love the kiwi craver and sunrise surprise. read more

Really liked this place until today. Met the most cranky person behind the counter. Complaining to other customers about the working conditions and quite rude. Don't think I'll be back. read more

Worst customer service ever. I walked in with my husband and two babies and we waited patiently for the woman behind the counter to take our order. She didnt acknowledge us as all, not even when we walked in. She just continued having a conversation with the man in front of me about a bunch of different topics and we were totally ignored for 15 minutes. We had to be somewhere and I was just watching the clock waiting. After standing there sweating, holding our children, and being ignored completely we decided to walk out. It was our first time visiting and last. read more

I had high hopes for this place, but was disappointed. The place itself is cute but little. The woman who took my order seemed like she couldn't be bothered. In the middle of me placing my order she walks around from the counter and goes to get something from the yogurt topping bar. It took a little longer than I expected as well. The same woman made my wrap she kind of just rolled it towards me on the counter. Not only was the customer service less than pleasant, but my wrap wasn't good. It was mostly cheese with dried chicken. $14 for a wrap and smoothie is a little pricey. Next time I'll stick to tropical smoothie. read more

I come here about two to three times a week because of how well they consistently make their smoothies, my favorite is the Mangosteen Queen. I finally ordered their chicken quesadilla and now I'll be hooked on that for awhile. Friendly, affordable and fresh! read more

Friendly, family-run cafe that has a delicious acai bowl. Also has generously sized sandwiches, and a nice looking salad bar. Great place to go with a group if some people want something healthy, and others want a large, filling deli sandwich read more

Madison smoothie gotta be one of the most welcoming cafe I have been to in Long Island the girl with the blonde hair is a sweetheart . Highly recommend to stop in if your in the area . read more

I am a loyal customer to Madison's. However, I had an awful experience about two weeks ago. I was in a rush, I ordered ONE smoothie and it took about 20 minutes to come out. The place was empty, so I really can't understand why my already blended smoothie was sitting in the blender for about 5 minutes before the owner of the store even attempted to put it in a cup. When she poured it into my cup, some of it spilt onto the counter and she proceeded to sweep the excess smoothie from the COUNTER into my cup. I didn't say anything for the sake of time, but this was one of my worst experiences at ANY food business I've ever been to. Has definitely changed my view of Madison's. read more

I just moved to the area and went to tropical smoothie cafe and their meal combos were $10 each so I called Madison's to see if they had a better combo I also saw free popcorn and I love popcorn. No one picked up the phone the 2 different times so I drove over 15 minutes out of my way thinking it would be a better price at least than tropical smoothie and I'd get free popcorn! Well you had no combos! Your smoothie was more $$$ than the same one at tropical smoothie cafe! I was not offered or given free popcorn! Nor was I told about or asked if I had the loyalty app! I tried to support a smaller company and it was a fail. Sent from my iPhone read more

Great food and the customer service is also excellent! Very friendly people... great food and a variety of options. Prices are reasonable. I would recommend this place to anyone! read more

Love this place so much!! The people are nice and the smoothies are bomb!! Everyone has to try the quesadillas too oh baby there're tooooo good!!!JESS IS THE BEST!!! read more

I've been coming for the breakfast special for years now. Great breakfast for a great price. Recently I've added a Sunrise Supreme Smoothie to have for Lunch. Its a nice tasty and healthy treat. The owners and staff have been great. Jill, Mike, and Jessica have always treated me like best friends. To top it all off, they have great promotions. Every so often with the promotions, I end up with a free breakfast or free smoothie. Hey, great taste and free, what more could you ask for :) Come on in and try something on the menu, you'll then be hooked like me! read more

Absolute best place and amazing staff. I love the smoothies there. The best, I suggest this for the best smoothies in town

This is literally the best place ever. Try the Nutty Party smoothie and add chocolate also the food is DELICIOUS! Best quesadilla I've ever had and BEST sandwiches! Bacon egg and cheeses are incredible and at a great post. Overall AMAZING place read more

In the store, Madison smoothie cafe has good service. When they deliver however, it could not be worse. Not only did they mess up my order, they also came to the wrong place and got mad at me when they couldn't find us. When the food finally came after 20 minutes of waiting, we payed and the lady took our money without offering any change when we had given almost double the amount asked for. On top of that, my smoothie was wrong and too frozen to drink. Of the 2/3 times they have delivered to me, I have found problems. read more

Great place, great smothies and everyone is so nice will definitely be coming back soon!

I love coming to Madisons for a good smoothie and a wrap. Danielle and Amanda are the best at making sure everything's clean and just the way I like it. Would definitely come back here anytime. read more

i've been coming here for years, since before they relocated in wantagh. ever since they moved, they seem to not be putting in the same effort. it could have just been the time i was there, but they seemed too stressed out to be effective and were very half a**ed at doing their job. granted it seemed to be during a rush, but when making smoothies i saw one of the workers left a big glob of peanut butter inside one of the pitchers; a big enough glob that i saw it from behind the counter, and then stacked the pitchers up inside of one another. that can easily go from the inside of that one, to the outside then inside of others. DO NOT come here if you have allergies, or if you care about cleanliness, because imagine what else goes on here. you're better off just going with tropical smoothie cafe read more

I went in to madisons the other day and i am very happy i did because i found the best acai bowls on Long Island with great service and very fair pricing will definitely be coming back soon. read more