Cancel

Open app

Search

Maddy’s Diner

3.3 (52 reviews)
Closed • 6:00 am - 4:00 pm

Order Maddy’s Diner Takeout or Delivery

MADDY’S DINER · YELP ASSISTANT

Ask Yelp Assistant

Maddy’s Diner Photos

Business Info

MADDY’S DINER ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Moderate noise
Good for kids
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like Maddy’s Diner

Recommended Reviews - Maddy’s Diner

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Breakfast menu
Shawna M.

Service is very quick. Our waitress was here right as we sat down to get our drinks. Our food came in less than 5 minutes of ordering. I'm wondering if they just microwaved it because it was that quick! Food was once again just ok. Nothing spectacular.

Chili Omelette
Jeffrey H.

Came here on a Sunday morning and I was not disappointed. The parking is tight which I discovered as I drove the big truck there. Walked in and this place reminded me of a diner from back in the day. It was a fairly large sitting area of tables but being in this kind of diner a Booth is a must. We were greeted by the friendly waitress and soon after sitting down drinks and food were being ordered. I ordered the chili omelette and this did not disappoint. It was stuffed with chili only thing you could add some cheese if you enjoy that but I kept it protein packed. Tossed a little hot sauce on it and I was in a food nirvana. Chili and eggs go together with home-fires surprisingly well. The big breakfast was delicious and cooked just as requested. The price matched the giant plates and I am looking forward to going back and eating a burger. 5/5 stars!

Current 4/2025
Darren G.

A very clean and retro style diner, nice to see. Menu was surprisingly lean and to the point, rather than other places where the menu is a small binder of item that range all over the place. The staff were nice and pretty neutral, not much to say for it. The meat lovers skillet was very good, love the finely minced ham, sausage and cuts of bacon, although I will say unsurprisingly it was pretty salty. Sunny side eggs were great, and for the home fries at the bottom, could use more seasonings otherwise great, I did find it weird to use cheese slices over shredded cheese for the skillet. The sourdough toast very generously buttered was a pleasant surprise over plan toasted.

Aj L.

Cozy diner in Middeltown, right next to residents. The food is pretty good. I just wish they had fresh squeezed orange juice . The service is always pleasant. They got plenty of parking space Everything is pretty affordable Definitely a place to stop by for quick breakfast

Chicken & waffle, "Almost healthy" skillet scramble, fresh fruit, buttered biscuit, coffee
Margaret C.

Terrific small-town diner--the classic experience. Friendly, efficient staff and great food. We thoroughly enjoyed the chicken & waffles with sausage gravy, and the "almost healthy" skillet scramble. Fresh fruit, a tasty biscuit, and plenty of hot coffee. Highly recommend!

Breakfast Tacos @ Maddy's
Lisa G.

Ideal diner! Super clean! Friendly service & nice meals. It's not gourmet (aka pickled jalapeños) but good quality ingredients: chorizo, tortillas, perfect avocado...It's top notch for a diner. My only complaint is that it is so clean I could smell cleaning product before food when first entering. Which is not entirely a bad thing.

Over cooked pouched eggs.

Every time I order from this diner they are ALWAYS forgetting something and then when you call and tell them, they argue with you. Please make sure people are getting what they already paid for and stop arguing with customers. Where is customer service???

Farmer's Breakfast, iirc.  Maddy's 6/16/17
Dave R.

Came back to Middletown after many decades, and friends took me to Maddy's for breakfast. My one visit piggybacks on their multiple visits. A good, solid, friendly diner. Unpretentious and comfortable; small but with sufficient parking. Nice booths. Daily specials. I had the farmer's breakfast, I think. See photo. Left satisfied. Coffee was okay.

reuben, louisiana burger

See all

Photo of Jessica S.
15
111
26

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Ethan F.
111
10
0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Food was good. Service a bit lacking. Was not busy at the time 1230-1330. Did not offer a coffee refill during meal. Decent for the price.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Maddy’s Diner

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for American 400 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Switch Inn

The Switch Inn

3.7(21 reviews)
1.2 mi
•$

It's kind of a dive bar, which isn't unexpected as it's not in the best part of Middletown;…read morehowever, it's actually got pretty good food. The server was very nice, the guys hanging at the bar left a little to be desired lol but it is what it is. I got the French Onion soup, very tasty and the buffalo wings, they were large not tiny like some places and very juicy. My sister got a burger and said it was good and the fries were good not like those that stick together, the good kind. We went early evening on a Monday so it wasn't busy but I'm sure when they do events it probably gets packed as the dining area is small.

Google for some reason won't let me post this; it was written with that site in mind…read more If you're going here to revel in the antics of Samantha and the other cute barmaids, read no further; it seems like you'll have a good time. If you're coming here to eat, though, read on. I was part of a 16-set whose reservations were made *three* days earlier for 11 a.m., when the Switch opens for brunch on Saturday mornings. About 14 of us showed up. When we entered, we were told we had the back space all to ourselves ... only to find the tables had not been arranged for such a large group. We helped the staff, which is to say one of the attractive young women probably among those mentioned by name in many of the other reviews, put them together--by which it would be more accurate to say we did it for her. Said waitress was the *only* person working the *entire* front ... there were a few other people near the bar. And none of the cute barmaids. This young woman had to do *all* the waitservice *and* all the bartending. There is absolutely no excuse for letting this much service fall on the head of a single staffer with this much advance notice. They had *three days' notice* that they'd have a big table at Saturday's open. That's more than enough time to get someone else to come to work. That they did not suggests that someone was too busy writing emoji-laden one-word responses to Google Reviews to let this be brought to his attention, or that it was and he didn't care because he needs a little help making this month's boat payment. If this had been the only problem, I'd have left a generally favorable review. But instead, it got worse. A friend in the group who has plenty of restaurant experience themselves and noticed these same deficiencies ordered some iced tea with his breakfast--only to be told there was none available. Uh, OK ... these things happen. Immediately afterwards, I ordered coffee. A few minutes later our cute barmaid returned, and said with some evident surprise that ... there wasn't any. Really? On a Saturday morning when you advertise and serve an extensive brunch menu, you have somehow forgotten to restock something so basic? This is Restaurant 101. As my omelet was being prepared (it was good ... the food is the only thing that got a star here), the same cute barmaid came bouncing out to inform me that ... there was no whole wheat bread to toast for the side I had ordered. Would white be OK? Yes. But I was beginning to feel like the Switch's business model was the cheese shop in the Monty Python sketch, and did something I would never have imagined myself doing before: announced loudly that that would mean another star off the Google Review. I guess Mr. Owner was too busy keeping up on *his* strategy of responding to every single review in order to intimidate people from posting what might be more generally bad experiences from which lessons might be learned to actually check his stocks, much less order more (However, maybe there's an upside to this ... if people want to shoot each other in the future, there won't be any bullets available). And while this experience was not the fault of the cute barmaid, who I should say I still tipped (albeit modestly), since she was indeed polite and charming and (importantly) apologetic the whole time, especially again given that she had to do all the front-end work by herself, she did make one significant error my restaurant-veteran friend noticed. Another of our number had his drink delivered without the lemon wedge that was supposed to be in it. She (yet again) apologized, and came back with several lemon wedges to choose from ... held in *her bare hands* when they should have been in a bowl or on a plate. This is an actionable health-code violation, and the only reason I'm reporting it here rather than to Goshen is that, for all the aforementioned reasons, I don't want her to get into trouble and get fired. When I told my wife about all this, she said that a) she would have stormed out and gone to Dunkin' Donuts (which, for her, is saying something) when the coffee wasn't available and b) $14 for even a well-made omelet was way too much given this display of incompetence. So, Mr. Owner, if this the "trying our best" you bragged about in your response to one of your other dissatisfied customers (and FWIW it seems like those reviews have become more common in the last year or so), you are falling far short. As Yoda told Luke, "do, or do not ... there is no try". Maybe you should consider hiring someone to actually run the house and just limit yourself to being the social-media manager you have clearly always wanted to be. The Switch Inn? It should be Asleep at the Switch Inn!

Photos
The Switch Inn
The Switch Inn
The Switch Inn

See all

Maddy’s Diner - tradamerican - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...