Cancel

Open app

Search

Maddy’s Diner

3.3 (49 reviews)
Closed 6:00 am - 4:00 pm

Order Maddy’s Diner Takeout or Delivery

Maddy’s Diner Photos

Business Info

MADDY’S DINER ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Moderate noise
Good for kids
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like Maddy’s Diner

Recommended Reviews - Maddy’s Diner

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Current 4/2025
Darren G.

A very clean and retro style diner, nice to see. Menu was surprisingly lean and to the point, rather than other places where the menu is a small binder of item that range all over the place. The staff were nice and pretty neutral, not much to say for it. The meat lovers skillet was very good, love the finely minced ham, sausage and cuts of bacon, although I will say unsurprisingly it was pretty salty. Sunny side eggs were great, and for the home fries at the bottom, could use more seasonings otherwise great, I did find it weird to use cheese slices over shredded cheese for the skillet. The sourdough toast very generously buttered was a pleasant surprise over plan toasted.

Chili Omelette
Jeffrey H.

Came here on a Sunday morning and I was not disappointed. The parking is tight which I discovered as I drove the big truck there. Walked in and this place reminded me of a diner from back in the day. It was a fairly large sitting area of tables but being in this kind of diner a Booth is a must. We were greeted by the friendly waitress and soon after sitting down drinks and food were being ordered. I ordered the chili omelette and this did not disappoint. It was stuffed with chili only thing you could add some cheese if you enjoy that but I kept it protein packed. Tossed a little hot sauce on it and I was in a food nirvana. Chili and eggs go together with home-fires surprisingly well. The big breakfast was delicious and cooked just as requested. The price matched the giant plates and I am looking forward to going back and eating a burger. 5/5 stars!

Aj L.

Cozy diner in Middeltown, right next to residents. The food is pretty good. I just wish they had fresh squeezed orange juice . The service is always pleasant. They got plenty of parking space Everything is pretty affordable Definitely a place to stop by for quick breakfast

Chicken & waffle, "Almost healthy" skillet scramble, fresh fruit, buttered biscuit, coffee
Margaret C.

Terrific small-town diner--the classic experience. Friendly, efficient staff and great food. We thoroughly enjoyed the chicken & waffles with sausage gravy, and the "almost healthy" skillet scramble. Fresh fruit, a tasty biscuit, and plenty of hot coffee. Highly recommend!

Breakfast Tacos @ Maddy's
Lisa G.

Ideal diner! Super clean! Friendly service & nice meals. It's not gourmet (aka pickled jalapeños) but good quality ingredients: chorizo, tortillas, perfect avocado...It's top notch for a diner. My only complaint is that it is so clean I could smell cleaning product before food when first entering. Which is not entirely a bad thing.

Over cooked pouched eggs.

Every time I order from this diner they are ALWAYS forgetting something and then when you call and tell them, they argue with you. Please make sure people are getting what they already paid for and stop arguing with customers. Where is customer service???

Farmer's Breakfast, iirc.  Maddy's 6/16/17
Dave R.

Came back to Middletown after many decades, and friends took me to Maddy's for breakfast. My one visit piggybacks on their multiple visits. A good, solid, friendly diner. Unpretentious and comfortable; small but with sufficient parking. Nice booths. Daily specials. I had the farmer's breakfast, I think. See photo. Left satisfied. Coffee was okay.

reuben, louisiana burger
Tatiana S.

stopped here after a hike and it was perfect! great burgers and reubens. very clean, great prices, really friendly staff! highly recommend

American cheese omelet with country potatoes and rye 7.95

See all

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Food was good. Service a bit lacking. Was not busy at the time 1230-1330. Did not offer a coffee refill during meal. Decent for the price.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Maddy’s Diner

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for American 388 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Americana Diner & Restaurant - BLT Sandwich

Americana Diner & Restaurant

3.2(180 reviews)
1.5 mi
$$

I love the food here when I come with my boys. Kim was my waitress the last few times I sat. We had…read moreexceptional customer service With her, combined with the sweetest personality. When I come I look forward to having her as my waitress. A few people I know have mentioned her after a night of partying and we all know that could be alot, yet she took care of my friends regardless of how hard it could be to deal with loopy or hungover people lol. This is exactly what we need in diners and restaurants. It's hard to find good waitresses that don't have nasty attitudes and ruin the sit down experience for you. Idk what the bad reviews on the food are all about, but I love their food And love their staff. Amazing service the last few times i sat with her.

Went to the Americana diner on Monday January 26 2026 for breakfast. I ordered a grilled cheese…read moresandwich and home fries. How disgusting it was - There was a dark hair in my plate. I have the habit of moving my food around to check and there it was a long black hair. I felt bad for the waitress she was very nice. And she felt horrible about it. She could not stop saying I'm so sorry Now the lady that stands up front with the limp has always been so nice and this time she wasn't-- she was annoyed I complained about the hair. Just done with the diner will never go again - a man walks in with a dog in his man. It wasn't a service dog and she said nothing about it. When my husband brung it to her attention she was very rude. The place should be renovated. It's a mess. I can't imagine how it looks where they store the foods how it can look. The place is always full and they can't afford to fix the place.

Photos
Americana Diner & Restaurant
Americana Diner & Restaurant - BLT Sandwich with spicy waffle fries

BLT Sandwich with spicy waffle fries

Americana Diner & Restaurant

See all

D Lux Diner - Fish and Chips

D Lux Diner

3.4(173 reviews)
2.8 mi
$$

Had lunch, Tuna on Rye, grilled cheese with Fries all made fresh…read more.. Great "NY" Diner!! The Waitress was attentive, checked on us several times. The diner is laid out nicely, booths are comfortable and everything is clean. If you want a True NY DINER this is it!

We got there when it was busy with a wait - waited 30 minutes to be seated. Multiple parties who…read morecame in after us walked out prior to being seated so we remained the last people waiting. We finally get seated and then quickly after we are seated they seat 3 walk in tables next to us. The server comes to our table first of the 4 tables and takes drink orders and says she will be right back to take our order, but then proceeds to take the 3 other tables food orders. Not one after another, but take an order put it in, walk around, take another order put it in, walk around..... The table next to us had their food by the time she took our food order. I told the host/manager and he gave me an attitude and said she is taking the orders now, yet ours still wasn't taken for quite awhile. Food is delivered with a comment of will be back with toast, that was another 10 minutes wait for toast while waiting with over easy eggs which were cold by the time toast came out. She brought 2 plates, any decent server could have also brought toast.... Another long wait for a check, not surprising we were the last of the 4 tables in the section to get ours. I've worked in the service industry and know how hard it is, however this service was terrible. Server could clearly not handle her section and could not handle breakfast volume in a diner, other servers seemed to be doing just fine. Do not recommend between the poor service and lack of management concern was a horrible experience.

Photos
D Lux Diner - Interior

Interior

D Lux Diner - The 2-2-2: waffle with banana, chocolate chips, and coconut, 2 eggs, and bacon

The 2-2-2: waffle with banana, chocolate chips, and coconut, 2 eggs, and bacon

D Lux Diner - Our view as we walked from our hotel

See all

Our view as we walked from our hotel

Oak & Reed - Chicken & Waffles

Oak & Reed

4.6(267 reviews)
1.2 mi

I've always loved Oak & Reed for dinner and brunch but now trying them for breakfast new love…read moreunlocked. The breakfast was simple but then of course Oak & Reed throws in their flair. The eggs were perfectly cooked soft and buttery. And the sour dough toast with that perfect sour dough tang was the perfect edition. Even the coffee in the French press takes the coffee to another level. But talking about Oak & Reed flair the signature waffle was possibly one of the best things I have eaten. The waffle with that pearl sugar is the way a waffle should be made but then they have that waffle filled with Dutch caramel and that mascarpone on top is perfect. The tang, sweetness, butteriness, the crisp yet fluffy waffle it all was an equation for an amazing breakfast item. I could eat that every time I go. Truly amazing. The staff in Oak & Reed is always amazing attentive and kind. Live the open kitchen concept. Especially with my two year old currently in a Ratatouille kick so she wanted to see the chefs while she looked for Remy cooking. All in all Oak & Reed never disappoints.

Unfortunately I have to say this place was just meh!…read more This is one of my friends favorite restaurant, she even wanted to have them cater her wedding. So I was excited when we finally got a chance to try it. And here is where it may have been my fault, maybe I hyped it up too much. So the funny thing when we arrived at the restaurant and I saw another friend. She told me it was her first time and it wasn't good (this was a warning!) she said especially the chicken and waffles. So again maybe it's my fault because I didn't listen. My heart was set on the chicken and waffles and she was right. It was not good. Like how do you mess up chicken and waffles? It was lacking all types of flavor. It was bad. Why 3 stars than? Because their Spicy Pork Congee was amazing! It's an Asian rice dish and everything that lacked flavor in the chicken and waffles was made up in this dish. The problem? This is only an appetizer. It needs to be an entree, which would mean making it a larger portion. It was fantastic! They also had a decent beer selection which we got. The inside of the restaurant is cute. It has so much potential I just think maybe a revamp of the recipes. But maybe another dish would be good. We came for brunch so I don't know how their dinner menu is. I will probably give them another chance because how amazing the congee was I know they have potential to be great.

Photos
Oak & Reed - Interior

Interior

Oak & Reed - Skirt Steak with chimichurri, sweet potato hash and eggs

Skirt Steak with chimichurri, sweet potato hash and eggs

Oak & Reed - Oyster

See all

Oyster

Goshen Plaza Diner - Lumberjack!

Goshen Plaza Diner

3.1(195 reviews)
6.2 mi
$$

The Goshen Plaza Diner is about a five minute drive from Legoland, so it's the perfect stop for us…read moreto get a yummy, reasonably priced, filling meal before embarking on our ride home. The scene is a basic diner, but there is something very comforting about that to this Jersey girl. Upon walking in, my daughter was immediately taken by the display of cakes. The staff was all very lovely and took good care of us. My daughter got a hot dog, my husband eggs and bacon, and I got the pastrami burger. Everything was delicious, though the burger itself was immensely big! Next time, I'll know to share it! We couldn't leave without trying a piece of chocolate cake. My daughter was very happy with it, but my husband acknowledged that the bottom layer was very dry, but the rest of it was yummy. I don't think I have ever ordered a piece of cake from a diner before, so I'll take that as a rave review.

In town for some work for something close to where I'm staying. Found the Goshen Plaza diner. I'm…read morevery busy very loud very family oriented. Walked in. Could see the desert display looked amazing. Order the chicken madeira for dinner came out relatively quick food was hot. Taste was very good. It was heavy on the cheese but the mushrooms and sauce had great flavor. Chicken was cooked just right. Waiter was Amazing constantly checking making sure everything was done properly. Overall, pleasant experience would go back again.

Photos
Goshen Plaza Diner - Booths and decor

Booths and decor

Goshen Plaza Diner
Goshen Plaza Diner

See all

Maddy’s Diner - tradamerican - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...