Honey~ let me start with an overview & points:
1) This place will keep my 5star rating simply because, I LEFT my wallet behind with my license, DEBIT not credit CARDS, and everything else in it and I never noticed. IT WAS RETURNED, NOTHING MISSING NOTHING UTILIZED.
2) I went for a "date." Glad he chose the place because it's nice not to have chain-food all the time and it's always good to try Southern cooking away from the familiar. It wasn't bad.
3) I don't really recall what all I had but I know I got the smothered pork chops, 2 sides had to come with it, peach cobbler and a soda or something. Hot sauce and other condiments are all around the table.
4) Good value meaning Cost of food + portion amount served = Good Value here. It's like a Piccadilly or any staple in the South. Step up*Order*you get a tray*your plate will be handed to you and you pay at the end of the line.
5) Decor = simple (really basic) but I like the fact that they hang up pics of the celebs and local figures. Cute
Now....I'll say again, I'm a Southerner and don't know the westside at all. But it wasn't bad as some Yelpers have listed. But I also know from living that I'm not crazy enough to half the things that tourist will do ....like....walk through an UNFAMILIAR neighborhood and expect to be welcomed with smiles & hugs at 1am in the morning. Trust me baby, I've lived in New Orleans Pre-Katrina long enough to see Yuppies scroll through neighborhoods drunk/loud/belligerent and shocked when they get robbed. But I went mid afternoon and I was fine. The dining crowd was cool, not loud, and everyone mind's their own business.
Back to why this place gets 5 stars: The lady tried to search for me online to no avail but she found "a relative" which was my mother. Normally, I'm all over my mother about not just talking to people over the phone and giving out information (she's not crazy just Southern - child everybody does it). But she didn't want to talk to this lady but this lady "just keeps on calling." So my mom finally spoke with her and then called me.
I called the lady back to learn - she had my wallet. I didn't realize it was gone. (shaking my head over here) Anyone that has ever had a lost wallet or purse knows its not always about the money but the inconvenience of replacing the Driver's License and everything else. She was willing to mail it to me and I was okay with that, but the date guy wanted to pick it up and bring it to me. Hey! I don't live in Chicago but Wisconsin. At any rate, think what you want about Chicago/the westside or this business but I've had more stolen from people in smaller places like Madison, WI and while on campus in class than anything I've experienced elsewhere.
So my point: I had a redeeming event occur courtesy of MacArthur's. I'm glad they're still in business. It's a worthwhile TO-DO when going to or while in Chicago. Try anything once, but my meal including Smothered Pork Chops, greens and cobbler was nice enough and the price makes it better!
Hell, much of everything is bad for you so don't let that deter you. read more