This was our first time trying Lucille's, and it didn't disappoint! We went on a Friday around 3pm after a successful interview. My partner had already eaten, so we ordered just the margarita pizza for food, and it was delicious and the ingredients were fresh. We each got a beer and as an IPA lover I really enjoyed the Double 755 IPA, I rated it 4.75/5! After ordering we saw a few signs about happy hour, and asked our waiter. We found out that on Fridays from 3-6 they put out a variety of their pizzas and you can grab a few half slices to try some different pizzas while having a drink at the bar. I've noticed recently that restaurants are pulling back on happy hour offerings, so it was awesome to see such a great happy hour here. The staff were welcoming and helpful, overall a great experience! read more

Lucille - Margarita pizza, Double 755 beer - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

This place is a Madison must! I must have come here at least 20 times over the last 3.5 years and I leave so impressed every. single. time. Their drinks are amazing (love the pink chimney and any of the seasonal ones), the caesar salad is to die for, and any of their pizzas are always a hit. The two story layout with the bar in the middle gives a really cool vibe, and they do such a cute job decorating it in the winter season for the holidays! I have never been, but they also have a REALLY cool downstairs lounge/converted vault for larger parties. I know handful of people that have rented it out before for birthdays and they always say how fun it is. read more

Lucille - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Highly recommend the Wednesday Date Night Special! A fun, delicious takeout option to enjoy with someone special! $30 for 3-courses (salad, pizza, and dessert). The caesar salad dressing was honestly probably one of the best I've ever had - perfectly savory and creamy. For pizza, we got the Umami pie which was outstanding - loved the topping combination - one of my new faves, definitely delivered on the umami-ness. For dessert, we had 2 huge cookies plus ice cream - we're talking nearly face-sized cookies. We honestly probably could've just shared 1 cookie between the 2 of us but carpe diem. read more

Lucille - cookie. caesar salad. umami pie. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Got takeout to give this place another shot and was unimpressed again. Sauce on the side was a necessity even just to eat the edges which were just greasy melted cheese on dry bread. Basil was an extra $2 and could barely taste it. Sausage not worth $5. read more

See all

The cheese curds and pizza were both delicious. The service was nothing short of weird. I sat waiting to order to the point of awkwardness. There were only 2 other couples at the bar and 4 people behind the bar. It stayed weird til the end where I was asked if I was finished, said yes, and the server just left. I had time so I wasn't upset but I'd have much rather left a 5 star review. read more

Food was delicious. I arrived when my food was supposed to be ready for pickup and the server said it would be ready in five minutes. I got my pizza 20 minutes later and by then it was cold and I had to put it in the oven at home. read more

Had the Sausage and Rabe and it was so good. The crust was great and the cheese was even better, highly highly recommend

Delicious pizza. We got a pan and a thin crust. Service was lacking. We arrived and waited 5 minutes with no waiter or receptionist seating us, we went upstairs and asked if we could be seated they said we needed to wait for a receptionist. We went back down and wait for another few before just sitting at the bar since they said there were no available tables. I'm assuming they just didn't have the staffing since all of the upstairs was basically empty. The service at the bar was also less than desirable. Our bartender seemed distracted with friends at the bar. Never asked to refill my husband's drink but did notice when I have my husband my second drink. Perhaps we were there in an off day. The food and drink menus were great for a pizza /Mexican fusion . read more

See all

Madison has a ton of great cocktail bars, and Lucille is certainly a part of that list. Let me be clear: it would be up there with Merchant/Mint Mark/Robin Room if we were just talking drinks. The food, however, just doesn't do it for me. The guac starter, while huge, is $14 for bland oily chips and a vat of guac that just isn't really good. It tastes like the factory made little sealed individual guacs. Not worth it. It does come with some lil veggies so that's nice but not enough to change my opinion. The Detroit style pizza is decent, not the best I've had and not the worst. They have some good flavor combos, and just one of these feeds 2-3 so it's a decent value. I will say the pizza tastes better Fridays at 4 when its free. TLDR: 4 stars for drinks but 3 for if you're hungry read more

Lucille - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Lucille was not the name that comes to mind when I thought "brunch" after getting a breakfast burrito, pizza, and an amazing dessert however, I have pulled a 180! To me, brunch means the best of both worlds, and well, Lucille delivers. The breakfast burrito had a crisp crunch, flavorful bites, and was served with perfectly crisped potatoes. The queen the pizza (recommended by our amazing server) was equally delicious, thin, and crisp. Naturally, we also devoured a homemade chocolate cookie the process! Especially during yhe holidays, the atmosphere is GREAT, can't wait to return! read more

See all

The location, service and ambiance are the only reason for the two stars. The food will take it down. By much. We will not come again

It has a good atmosphere and love the Christmas Pop-up! Lots of great drinks and music also!

If I could, I would give 0 stars. I was so disappointed as I had never been there before and was looking forward to going to an office party there. First, they put us upstairs, which is not good fit for a party and they were also seating people for dinner in the same area. WTF! I have never seen that before. They had 2 servers who were border line rude. You couldn't move to talk to different people. The food came out so slowly. Never again. I would not recommend this place for anything but leaving. read more

They don't have their stuff together whatsoever and the staff was ridiculous and pretty rude to us. Honestly felt like the hosts were all hosting at a restaurant for the first time that day. After waiting more than 5 minutes for the 3 hosts to check in the one group in front of us, I went to the side of the stand to get someone's attention and asked "Can we just take one of the open tables outside." We were told yes by the hostess who seemed to be in charge. It was about 5:00pm. 4 kids and 4 adults. We took the one table that we would fit at and settled in. A waitress brought out stuff for the kids to color, waters, took our drink orders, and to set up the table. A few minutes later she came back and said there was a mistake this table was reserved. I asked if it would be possible to switch the other group to another table, we are 8 people including 4 kids under 5 its quite a process to move and you said take any table. She said no, we're trying to figure something out. We started getting our stuff together, and I went inside to see what the situation was. I guess the hosts didn't realize I was with the group they were moving, because they were talking rudely about us right in front of me. That's when I said "no, I asked and you said take any table you want." They didn't seem to feel bad whatsoever that they were saying that stuff in front of me. While this was going on the college students that they were seating at our table came over, they were only a group of four. They offered to sit elsewhere and apologized. The staff told them no, we are going to honor your reservation for this table. Ok so now you clearly just don't want kids around, what else could it be? I took a spin around the restaurant and came back and said "you have something like 9 open enormous booths that will fit us upstairs, can we sit there?" I was told there are reservations later tonight so "we can't, but we're working on it." I then said we'll be out of here in an hour, I feel like there are enough empty tables that you can make this work." She again declined and told us then said that the restaurant next door was pretty good and we should check it out. The food looked gross anyways and we had an amazing meal next door so I'm glad we left. Just say you don't want kids at the restaurant you prefer people that run up a bar bill. When we walked by an hour later after our great meal next door I looked up and saw at least 1 empty booth. read more

Welcoming decor and waitstaff. However, we had an overall poor experience with this restaurant: Strike 1. No reservations available so we phoned the restaurant and we're told to call ahead. Later in the day when we called, the story changed to "we are short-staffed and you will first have to come to the restaurant to give your name. Hostess would not honor the morning commitment. So a 25 minute walk plus an hour wait while at least 15 tables sat empty. Strike 2. Ordered peach cocktails. No peach. Orange instead. Terrible cocktail-- sour lemon, undrinkable. Returned them. Strike 3. Pizzas were undercooked. Soggy crust. Runny watery toppings that were undercooked. Half it it left uneaten. Not likely to return. Ever. read more

See all

Lucille has traditionally been one of my favorite restaurants in Madison. Recently, the service has not been up to par with what they used to provide. We went in for the holiday pop up bar for a birthday celebration and it was a very poor experience. The first 5 drinks we tried to order off of the special menu were already out and we had to settle for drinks that we didn't really want. read more

First off, the food was absolutely amazing. Hands down some of the best food I've had in Madison. We had the cheese curds and pork belly lettuce wraps for appetizers. Both were great, but the cheese curds were the best in the city. We had multiple pizzas, trying both the wood fired and steel pan. Hands down amazing, likely favored the deep disk style steel pan. And the best part ... the drinks. My wife and I got two separate drinks and both were phenomenal. Get the Painkiller, hands down. Only negative comment are the prices, which were a solid 20% higher than they should be. But it's hard not to argue that the food was not worth every penny. read more

I eaten there and the pizza is great. The people that work there are always very nice and helpful. The prices are very expensive and it would be nice if the prices weren't so expensive but the food is good. read more

This restaurant is fine... I wouldn't go out of my way to go here. Service was meh and food was ok.

We heard such great things about Lucille! Sadly, I wonder if our opinions would have changed if we were seated inside. It looks like a fantastic atmosphere inside, but we sat outside on the street because we were told it would be a 45 minute wait for the inside. To be honest, it seemed like it wouldn't take that long since it was not that busy at 5:30 yet... So not sure why we were quoted such a long wait time. Now I don't mind waiting for delicious pizza though! We ended up splitting two pizzas. The umami pizza was absolutely mouthwatering and I really enjoyed it! The crust was done perfectly and the toppings were top-notch. I do recommend this pizza and would order it again without question. Sadly, the steel pan pizza we were looking forward to was not as wonderful as it looked at first. For some reason, the bread got soggy and doughy. The toppings were heavy, unbalanced, and the flavor fell flat. I took a photo, but I deleted it since it reminded me of how disappointing it was! We wished we had gotten another pizza, so maybe it was just this one. For the price, items did feel $2-3 more expensive than they should be. Great spot for a group gathering it seems! read more

Lucille - The Umami Pie - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

My time at Lucille was great! We got the cheese curds and they were delicious and the ranch was good. I got the Queen pizza with prosciutto and it was delicious. The atmosphere was nice and we had a great view of the capital! We loved our experience and would come back again. read more

See all

Great patio space that was paired well with solid service. The nachos were a tasty start before going to pan pizza. Will come here next time and try more pizza options along with the inside of the restaurant read more

Went here on a Saturday night and it was truly packed. 1.5 hour wait starting at 7:30. Was the wait worth it? Meh, not really. I really love the decor of place! It's so beautiful inside!! We ordered the veg fest and the meat lovers I think. They first mistook our order of the veg fest for the sausage fest and had to redo the order. Should maybe thinking about differentiating those names. Also Ordered the Airmail Cocktail and it was delish! I would come back here for the bar but not the food especially with that wait time. read more

Lucille - Airmail - yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

I love the ambiance and typically come here for cocktails but the food here is also great! I tried all three kinds of empanadas (chicken, beef and veggie) and I'd highly recommend the veggie empanadas which is filled with plantains and black beans! read more

Lucille - Empanadas and Cheese Curds - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

One of the best spots in Madison! I've been to Lucille 5 times now, and every time the experience has been incredible. From the food and drinks, to the service and ambiance (both inside and out on their patio), this place is just about perfect. I even brought my mom here (who is not easy to please), and she agreed that the cheese curds are the best she's ever had. I also love their pizzas and cocktails. Their date night menu is an absolute gem ($50 for two people with an app, entree, desert AND a bottle of wine is a great deal). I've never had a bad meal here, and every server I've had has been kind and the perfect level of attentive. I plan on continuing to come here for as long as I'm in Madison! read more

I've been wanting to come here for so long and the food did not disappoint. Would highly recommend the steel pan pizza and anything with red sauce - it was so good and I could totally go for a slice of that right now read more

See all

Extremely rude hostess. Turned 12 well dressed adults coming from a wedding who were stone cold sober. Apparently there were too many of us even though there were many tables empty and we were just having drinks. And she knew it. She WAS NOT KIND or accommodating. It's understandable, if it's true, NASTY woman. At the bar alone my brother counted 10 empty seats. NEVER AGAIN. We are all in dresses and suits and we have people from Australia, a U.S. diplomats, a veterinarian pathologist, 3 teachers, and retired folks, among others. Why would you turn away paying customers? read more

The food here is below average. I ordered a pizza and was really disappointed because it tasted like cardboard. The aesthetic and service were so good though. The overall ambiance of the restaurant was super cute to! Definitely overpriced for the food they are serving though. read more

Lucille is a really cool restaurant just off of Madison's square. The inside is two stories, with a gorgeous industrial design. It's normally very busy so I would recommend making a reservation ahead of time. I ordered a personal 10'' Umami pie, which was delicious. It had Kale, grilled chicken, roasted mushrooms, and a black garlic cream. The ingredients on top of it may seem strange to some, but that's what made it such a unique option! The crust held together well under the weight of all the ingredients and wasn't soggy. I also ordered a side of the cheese curds, which came with two great dipping sauces to enjoy them with. Our pizzas took a while to come out, but the place was packed, so the pace made sense in that regard. Our waitress was really friendly and attentive; she also made some awesome suggestions in regards to pizzas choices. Overall, I really enjoyed my dinner at Lucille and I wouldn't hesitate to go back! Definitely a cool place that shows off Madison's impressive dining scene. read more

Food was average service below par. The drinks were delicious but small and pricey for the size. I can't believe I paid $39 for a three topping pizza and was still hungry afterwards. You can go to a steakhouse or a fine dinning night and save money from this place. read more

Stopped in today for some pizza and mimosas with a girlfriend. Service was timely and friendly The space is gorgeous. Very open and lofty and fresh vibes. Their wood fire grill is out and visible and pretty neat. The location is gorgeous with capitol building views. I gave them a 4/5 because although our pizza was good tasting, it was luke warm:/ read more

Lucille - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Yeeeahhhhh.... abouuttt that..... Standing 40 foot tall, weighing 900k pounds, dishing out BURNT PIZZA.. I give you, Lucille!! *crowd booing* How underwhelming this place turned out. People gathering outside to get in.. I LOVE OVERCROWDED AND LOUD RESTAURANTS TO WAIT 15 MINUTES TO GET A DRINK.. YEAH...... no. Construction is beautiful, but the owners are raking in the dough from a below average restaurant. You do you, but I'll call you guys in a Glass Nickel Pizza to show you how to flip a pie. Bartenders partying together versus grabbing me a drink. Again.. y'all do y'all, but I'll head over to Johnny Delmonicos to grab a drink. I'd rather pay the 3x on a cocktail than watch the bros high five and do Jell-O shots off each others ripped abs. Food.... I'll let the picture do the talking. Overall, You get the picture. You do you. read more

Lucille - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

This is probably the second and only restaurant in Madison that was close to above average. Nothing out of this world but not a bad pizza joint if you're craving a pizza. read more

Lucille - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Amazing food. The steel pan pizza is delicious. They have great drinks. I'm very impressed with the precautions they have taken during COVID and felt safe dining here. read more

Our first time visiting this amazing pizza joint... We heard the feedback from our friends about just how great the food is and figured we better find out for ourselves. We have pretty high standards when it comes to pizza. Doesn't matter if we judge Woodfire or a Deep Dish! We were spoiled growing up eating some of the best that Chicago / Rockford IL has to offer, which is known for some of the best pizza in the world. So I like to think we are a great non biased couple who can judge Wisconsin Pizza on which ones are above and beyond. I do have two local favorites. Now I have a new #1. Prior to this amazing visit I would have said in my opinion Salvatore pizza in Sun Prairie was #1 and Gem City in Baraboo was my #2. Not anymore..... When entering the beautiful restored old building we were instantly greeted with smiles and welcomes. We were asked if we had reservations and instantly sat. Keep in mind this was on a Tuesday night around 7:30pm. Dinnertime for us! The place was packed and buzzing. Beautiful interior, super clean, classy place, but casual dress code I would day. Main level was a beautiful, big bar that offers lots of seating and dining. We were walked upstairs to our booth that gave us the best view in the house. Right in front of the window facing the capital. Best view in the entire place. We were very impressed to say the least. Off to a great start we both said. We were worried when walking to our table, because we came with our 5 year old daughter and a 4 month old infant and the place was packed. Nobody seemed to mind at all! So later in the evening we both felt relieved that the vibe was ok to have our young children here with us. We instantly we greeted by our server who was very knowledgeable and helpful. He poured us our waters and got our drink orders. I want to comment on the craft beer selection is very impressive.for those of you that care. They offer flights and have some very rare tasty beers to choose from. Almost 40 on draft that alwaysg rotate or more and several more in cans or bottles. They offer all the specialty drinks, wine and martinis as well. We ordered 2 different pizzas! One Wood Fire style that is the thin crust. We went with the Mediterranean style pizza... Yum yum.. Cooked perfectly, fresh toppings, perfect proportions, impressive presentation and best of all great taste. Overall just well made! Then for what they call their Detroit Deep Dish with cheese in the crust we ordered the meat lovers style. Wowsers! With the addition of some fresh sauce placed on top, the crust perfectly golden crispy and the right amount of crunch. Bravo!!!! Lastly before going home we decided to share a dessert as a family. We had a skillet chocolate chip cookie with ice cream. It was served nice and warm.... It was the icing on the cake. Absolutely delicious meal from start to finish. Great views, awesome service, cool atmosphere, great menu options, reasonable prikces, amazing location (down on King Street located one block from the Capital and on and on..... Long story short our new favorite pizza place in the entire state of Wisconsin. We are travelers and we will be back. Keep up the great work Lucille's read more

I drove into Madison from Milwaukee hearing amazing things about Lucille, and THEY DID NOT LIE. The pizzas were amazing. We got the Queen with Prosciutto and the Sausage and Rabe. Additionally, the One Barrel Commuter beer is perfect with the pizzas. I highly recommend this place, and I can say that I've finally found my favorite pizza place in the state of Wisconsin! read more

See all

Thrilled with the response from Lucille to COVID-19. The signage is good, the foyer/maitre d' station is great; the outdoor seating with heaters was comfy as one could hope. Food is real good, servers are super nice, the place is great. I'd maybe give 4 1/2 stars but if i had to choose between 4 and 5 these folks absolutely deserve the round-up. read more

It's too bad, this used to be one of my favorite places in Madison but it has gone straight downhill in the last 4 years. There are a couple of good bartenders who have been there for a while, one or two good servers, but the rest of the staff just does not care one iota about the customer. The check in process is brutal, service is slow, food is just OK (it used to be much better). Whatever has changed in the last 4 years, please undo it. read more

Nice bar a lot of service and they have jazz plays in the window. It sounds great. And the only ones I really liked it.

There are not enough words to describe how amazing the food and vibe is here. We started off with a spicy Cesar salad and empanadas. However those are not the star of the show..... THE PIZZA.... oh my... the pizza is so so good. Our table couldn't decide, so we ended up with four.... Each got devoured. Our server was so sweet and attentive. We couldn't have asked for a better experience. read more

Lucille - 6 Mile Classic - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all