You really need a reservation on a Saturday night, but we waltzed in the evening before my dinner companion was set to run the Barrie waterfront 10K, hankering for pizza. The hostess could have easily turned us away--no tables available--but instead, she warmly seated us at the pizza counter, which turned out to be the best seat in the house. We had a front-row view of everything going into and coming out of that wood-fired pizza oven, and some of what we saw was absolutely exquisite.
This place is about a 10-minute walk up Mulcaster Street from the Barrie sign on the waterfront. Inside, it's a series of large dining rooms with big wooden tables and comfortable chairs which is both inviting and spacious.
The cuisine is Italian with a smaller, specialized menu of typical Italian offerings. There were only four pizzas on the menu, for example, and similarly four pasta dishes. Steaks, salad and antipasti were also available, keeping things focused and well-executed.
The staff were excellent being very attentive, responsive, and genuinely friendly. They helped with recommendations and made us feel right at home from the moment we walked in. That kind of warm, inviting service makes all the difference.
We settled on arancini, olives, and focaccia to start, then shared a pepperoni pizza. Everything was delicious, and the wood-fired crust was exactly what we were craving.
If you're in downtown Barrie and want solid Italian in a lively atmosphere with a staff that actually seems happy to see you, this is a great choice. Just remember to book ahead on weekends, unless you're feeling lucky. read more