Monday September 28th, 2026. We went to Little Nickys Pizza. We ordered a Large Pie with Cheese. And half of it has mushrooms on it. It was fresh Hot and Delicious! read more

See all

I wanted to like this place. They always have so many good looking options up at the counter. However, they look good, but they were not good at all in my opinion. I don't know about you, but I want a chewy crispy pizza dough, their pizza dough crumbles like a cracker. There's nothing chewy about it. It's very strange. They put way way way too many low quality toppings on a slice of pizza. The bacon ranch pizza was absolutely disgusting. They were huge chunks of fat like pork belly fat not bacon. The entire underneath layer was a thick layer of ranch. It was so gross. I couldn't even eat it. The sausage pizza was extremely greasy way too much tiny sausage. The grandma's pizza must've been way too old for them to be selling it. The cheese didn't even melt in the oven and I didn't think their marina was anything to write home about. My significant other agreed with me he was not impressed with his meat lovers pizza. We would never go here again. Also, the people working there really need a better education. They didn't know what anything was and then when we were very specific in picking our slices, they even got the order wrong. Somebody else came back in who must've driven drove all the way home because it was like 15 minutes later they returned, saying they gave them the wrong order. It was busy, which really surprised me because we tried a lot of things and nothing was good. The pizza dough was not pizza dough. I really don't know how they have stayed in business. I never give a bad review unless it's really terrible. read more

Little Nicky's - Chunks of pure fat not bacon. Way too much ranch. Chicken was dry. - Pizza Near Me - Douglassville, Pennsylvania

See all

Stopped in finally after seeing the signs so frequently nearby. Got a cheesesteak, pretzel dog, and some garlic knots. Everything tasted great and prices are awesome. read more

First off, two slices, one with a topping, and a fountain drink for under $7. Nowadays I'll take that deal every time. And for that price you get two decent slices. The sausage topping had great flavor. It came out a little floppy, but very good. The plain slice maybe had a little bit too much oregano but overall good flavor and good amount of cheese. read more

Little Nicky's - Pizza Near Me - Douglassville, Pennsylvania

this is NOT the place for an Italian Sandwich! ordered with extra onions and hot peppers! No peppers... barely any onions, no lettuce, no oil or vinegar! if you are hungry for an Italian sub/ sandwich/ hero... this is not the place! Had no taste at all read more

LOVE! The pizza was amazing. the service was really good . I see them keeping the store clean. I love it must try

Great pizza! ! love the variety they offer and everything seems so tasty. The staff is very friendly and accommodating....overall I prefer Nicky's over the competition....and the prices seem reasonable.....may they continue with great success!!! read more

Very busy joint with plenty of seating and a counter full of pizza options, recommended for sure.

Great food and love the variety of slice options. The staff is always super friendly and they do super well managing the busyness on the weekends especially. Little Nicky's is our go to spot on pizza nights now! read more

Friendly staff ! They are extremely knowledgeable and friendly , the food is always delicious

Consistent and very good pizza and sandwiches. Our go! Checkout their website lots of daily specials. We love the Tuesday pizza deal

I've driven past this place hundreds of times over the years but never actually stopped in to try it. I finally did that today and was very happily surprised! It's clearly geared to pizza and sandwiches, not pasta entrees. They offer a few of these, but not many. Probably a good thing so they can concentrate on their core offerings. I had a Hawaiian slice with bacon and a veggie lovers slice and both were fantastic! Slices are quite large and toppings very plentiful. The sauce was flavorful and not salty. Order was piping hot when I got it - a big plus! Probably some of the best pizza I've had anywhere. Pizza displays at the counter are nicely laid out and very colorful. It's good to see the product showcased for customers to see before they buy. It also says that they are proud of their product and they should be based on my experience today. As others have stated, the staff are very nice and quite accommodating. It's always good to find a new place worthy of being on my bucket list, and this one is close to the top. Will certainly return, and soon! read more

Very fast service when you order by the slice. The ambiance is very casual and family friendly. I personally recommend their buffalo chicken slice. read more

They have a great selection of pizza and they make a decent cheesesteak, as well. It doesn't look like much from the outside, perhaps even a bit drab, but the food is pretty good and the service is friendly. read more

been going to this place for years and until recently have always enjoyed the food and atmosphere. How ever the food and servce has gone way down I blame this on the cook who is somewhat of a nit wit. He is not a cook, and I have complained several times to the manager, but they still keep him on. The cook is very combative thinks he is a bad ass and has no place in a good eatery that little Nicky has strived to keep. I and my friends will not be back!!! read more

It's perfect just everything is perfect especially the meatball Parmesan ,pizza ,and the fries

As good as any pizza I get at home in NY friendly staff great price I would stop by any time I'm in the area.

Our seafood was good. Portions were large. My linguini with marinara sauce disappointing.

Love everything here... pizza, cheesesteaks, and steak Stromboli! Oh so good! If you haven't been there give it a try!

Always a great meal at Little Nicky's! More than a dozen specialty pizzas greet you as you approach the counter. Buffalo chicken pizza is one of their stuffed specialties (pictured below) and one of our family favorites. They have the usual specialties like grandma's pie, holiday pizza, cheesesteak ,,and the ni so usual pizzas like Francesca (ham and green olives), Wild Mustang (grilled pepperoni, red sauce, ricotta, two other cheeses) and so much more. Each time we go back theyve created something new. Dont over look their pasta, calzones, garlic knots, fries (huge portion), it's all equally as wonderful as their specialty pizzas. read more

Little Nicky's - Little Nicky's Buffalo Chicken Double Stuffed Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Douglassville, Pennsylvania

We ordered a medium regular pizza with extra cheese and a grandma's pizza. The regular pizza was good but the Grandma's pizza was terrible. It was soggy, cold, tasted awful. Had to throw it out. read more

Come here a few times, be a friendly customer, and you will be treated as a regular. Best selection of slices for miles!

I've gone here a few more times since my initial review. Their pizza is still the best I've had in the area and their crust especially, is excellent. Also, OMG they put so much cheese on their pizzas, I love it. Good pizza, great value, exactly what a local mom&pop pizza shop should be. read more

They have a lot of options for slices. I got the stuffed Buffalo Chicken, it was really good but the crust could've been a little crisper. The grandma pizza is always good and a classic. I also got a cheesteak. It was good , the bread was crispy and fresh. Great food read more

Little Nicky's - Buffalo Chicken slice, Grandma Slice, Jalapeno poppers - Pizza Near Me - Douglassville, Pennsylvania

This pizza is excellent Bruschetta pizza The buffalo wing-chicken ranch was very tasty The staff is very pleasing read more

Got a meat ball sub today. This is probably one of the best meatball sandwiches I have ever had. The pizza looked really good too. I would definitely recommend you give this a try or you will miss out on something fantastic! read more

Little Nicky's - Meatball sub - Pizza Near Me - Douglassville, Pennsylvania

I absolutely adore the chicken strips. They come out fresh from the fryer. Great serve.

Quickly becoming one of my favorite places to grab a slice. 27 varieties, but my absolute favorite is the Honey Mustard Chicken Pizza. A must try. Subs aren't too shabby, either. Had a Roman Grinder the other week, and it was pretty nicely done. Only knock is that it seemingly took FOREVER to pull it all together. Could just be because I was starving. read more

Our family's favorite pizza place. We especially like eating there and ordering our favorite specialty slices like the Meat Lovers, buffalo chicken or "Grandma's Pizza". The slices are huge and so are the portion sizes for other meals. Most of all, the staff there could not be nicer. They go out of their way to make sure your order is perfect. A very family-friendly atmosphere with awesome food. read more

I always loved little Nicky's, today after calling in my order I arrived with sign on door saying no mask no pizza I thought awesome a safe place to get food I walk in and both cooks have their masks under their chin, I mentioned something and was told by the counter clerk that they get to hot. If I had not already ordered I would have left with out food. But it is hard on businesses right now. I guess they should be glad I was not the health department. Covid is spread through nose and mouth. read more

Awful experience trying to order the everyday special 2 large pizzas with 1 topping advertised for $21.99 their website. I had to call the store and ask about the special because I wanted light cheese and pepperoni and I wasn't able to order online like I usually do. When I called to place my order and asked about the advertised special for $21.99, I was told "the price just went up to $24.99 yesterday, we didn't have a chance to change it ON OUR WEBSITE." I asked to speak to the manager, who got on the phone and refused to honor the advertised price. Unbelievable that Little Nicky's would have the wrong price advertised and not honor a long time customer. I will take my business elsewhere and never eat from there again. What an unprofessional way to handle this issue. read more

Oh boy is this place great. This is an example of a restaurant that DOES IT RIGHT! I was in the area and figured I would try it. It is a little place and was not expecting much. Blown away is all I can say. The store was clean, and when I walked in the counter girl was cheery, friendly, and warm. The slice selection was huge. I think they had over 10 gourmet slice pie selections. They even had a few signature slice pies. I have had a lot of good pizza and this immediately ranked up there in my top 5. I was so suprised that I brought a few friends back the next day and all of had the same experience. Cheesesteaks and burgers were great. Can't say enough good things about this place. If you are in Douglassville, PA - Make this your lunch or dinner choice. read more

So I stop in here on occasion and the pizza is fresh and fantastic! I recommend the Tuesday deal. However, I am writing tonight because it was 15 minutes to close and I ordered a large cheesesteak. It was prepared in 2 minutes! I promised to be done by 10, as I was super hungry. They didn't rush me at all and were understanding. I did finish the sandwich with 3 minutes to spare! To the sweetheart wearing the JMU hoodie, she knows how to make a cheesesteak! better than the dopes in Phila! Thank you Little Nicky's Cheers! read more

This is the best pizza we've had in Amity. Their wings are also the best that is close by. I love their bbq. Also love the variety of slices you can get in store. read more

The service at Little Nicky's is always great! They have tons of different pizzas, especially on Fridays (you gotta go on a Friday since they have 25 or 30 different pizzas displayed). They have a Tuesday special of a large cheese pizza for $7.99. Even when they are slammed, they keep everyone moving pretty well through the line. The 4 stars is only for the fact that the seating area could use some updating and when they are busy, it gets neglected on cleanliness a little bit. Still a must try! read more

One of the best places to get Pizza quickly on a Friday night. I wish they had delivery service as we dont have too many places that deliver in Douglassville. read more

BAIT AND SWITCH. I pointed to a specific slice I wanted (meat-lovers) but at the last minute the attendant at the counter gave me a slice from another pie, made much earlier...not as good looking and not as fresh. Plus it seems they use cheap pepperoni...not good taste. All to say, go somewhere else. Even the nearby Domino's would be better. read more

Great pizza parlor pizza. Way better then the big chains. Best specialty pizza in the area too. Love the buffalo chicken stuffed pizza! Sicilian is also very good. We always order one or two for a party. It is a real crowd pleaser. I have frequented this place many times and will continue to go back. If you ever get the chance to eat in the restaurant I recommend it. There is something really special about a pizza right ot of the oven as opposed to bringing it home in the box. read more

Best wings ever!!! I love how they always ask you how your pizza looks. This place is our Friday wing & pizza place.

Good takeout, but not consistent. There are days you can get a really good pizza, and the next day you have a tomato sauce moat with little cheese civilians just drowning. Buffalo ranch chicken cheesesteak pizza is bangin though. read more