We ordered a cheesesteak that looked and tasted like it was made with steak-umm; the cheese was not even melted and they charged us $1 because we requested the sauce on the side instead of on the sandwich. They charged $1 to put our mayo on the side of our sandwich instead of on it as well. Our waitress did not tell us this in advance - she said they charge for the tiny plastic container they use for the condiments. Seriously? Never again will I waste money on below mediocre food there. read more

While working at the plant right down the road I ordered lunch for pick up here twice. Both times our food was done relatively quickly and always tasted good. The cashier was super nice and even helped bring all my food out to my truck. Nice, small family owned and operated business. Will return next time I am in town. read more

Been eating here forever. My go to's are the pizza and the pasta dinners (spaghetti or ziti with meat sauce or the baked ziti Roman style) . It's always been amazing and still is. Staff is always friendly and the food is always on point. read more

Great good, great service, nice size portions! The only thing yelp has their address wrong they are down the block at 2141 River Road. read more

The food is always excellent and the service is always great. It's close to home and prices are very reasonable.

Outstanding Sauce, say no more... I'd love to have them add SCUNGILLI to their menu! I can't find an italian restaurant for an hours drive, or in NYC Little Italy, to get it :( read more

Prepare yourself to be nickel and fined here folks. I ordered a chicken sub to stay and asked for pickles. Eighty cent up charge on the bill; no forewarning from the server and no mention of the price of pickles on the menu. In America, it's almost time honored that pickles are gratis with a sandwich. The buffalo chicken I ordered was actually quite good. Flavored nicely with some fresh tasting sandwich vegetables. The hero bread was very obviously not freshly made, but it still was acceptable. The pasta dish my wife ordered was just bad. The chicken tasted like it came from a Lean Cuisine frozen dinner box. Really poor quality on the in breaded chicken. Prices at face value were okay, but the unannounced extra charges were annoying. I could say the same about the service. Decor was actually refreshing as a stone wall mixed in with a tasteful mural made me feel like I wasn't in middle of nowhere PA! read more

Little Italy - Stone facade, comfy seating - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge, Pennsylvania

Place is diamond in the rough! Definitely recommended! Menu is a perfect mix of Italian foods.

Food was outstanding! I called and order in and left the house to pick it up. I walked in to a immaculate restaurant which was fairly busy for a Sunday with great weather and was helped immediately and very friendly. This place is a keeper! read more

Little Italy has the best hot subs in the area. This place NEVER disappoints! I've been going here for the last 15 years. Take my word for it! read more

TRUMP-Lovers are welcome; they play non-stop Pro-trump propaganda on the TV. If you don't want to wear a mask, they won't enforce it. If you want to get a case of Covid-19 with your order, this is the place for you. The food is decent. They mostly get the lower rating for the atmosphere. read more

Food is always delicious and service great! The dining room is clean as are the restrooms. I would recommend this gem of a pizza shop to anyone passing through! read more

See all

I'm cautious with more stars as the second to last visit I was grossed out with the chicken finger meal I took home. It was generous with 5 pieces of chicken but I think they were frozen, defrosted and microwaved to a hard crusty tasteless piece of meat. The fries, as always, were delicious and generous. Now, the last visit I ordered a cheeseburger meal with a good sized, tasty piece of burger on a delicious, fresh roll, generous fries and a drink. This was very satisfying and renewed my desire to go back. Not sure if it was the last time was Saturday and the time before a weekday? read more

This is an amazing family oriented pizza/ sub shop with homemade bread. The owner and employees are always so very nice and the food is absolutely wonderful and large portions for the $$. It's a definite go to at least once a week. My kids really enjoy the French fry pizza. Try it if your in the area, you won't be disappointed. If I had to complain about one thing, it'd be that they're closed on Mondays! Haaha jk? everyone needs a day off! read more

After a recommendation from a friend, we went here and it is slowly becoming our 'go to' pizza place. With probably 20 pizza joints within a 5 mile radius, Little Italy really shines. Their crust is thin and delicious, and their sauce is great too. What really sets them apart are the friendly staff who work the registers and drive thru. We usually only go on Friday night, and are always greeted with a smile and a genuine conversation. Our 'regular' place, even though we have gone there almost every Friday for over 7 years, still doesn't seem to recognize us when we come in!!! read more

Lorelei our waitress was very attentive to all the customers thank you Thanks for the good food Enzo and thanks for taking care of the birthday girl read more

Not a very good meal at all.. We both ordered pasta dishes and I feel a frozen dinner would have been better... Sorry guys! read more

Little Italy - Ziti and meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge, Pennsylvania

See all

Has moved down the road to 2141 River Rd. (Yelp has the old address) Great staff, excellent food! read more

The pizza is decent. Probably the best in the area, but that's not saying a whole lot. Their subs are great though. I like the cheeseburger subs. read more

See all

Stopped here after riding the Northwest Trail. Fast, friendly service and the food was great for the price. Note: address is 2141 River Road. My son had the spaghetti and meatballs and I had the cheeseburger sub. Meatballs were a decent size, the sub rolls were fantastic - and the sandwich was full. We'll be back. read more

We order Little Italy for lunch weekly, food is always great, always consistent. They recently opened their new location which is very nice for a pizza shop. Owners are there always working & helping and staff is always friendly. Would without a doubt recommend this place. read more

maaaaaan oh man.you guys keep getting better all the time.your pizza ch. steak was outrageous as were the other ones we got.the fries are fantastic as always.once again we were very happy.we will be back next week.see ya then.peace read more

We eat here at least once a week! A little jem in a little town. If you're in Bainbridge eat here, don't miss out!

When I arrived we got our drinks and ordered fast. Others filled up soon after. When waiting I saw everyone else getting food first and then us. My drink was empty and server was no where to be found. I was told I can get my own drink. Server never came back to check up on us and then I received my bill and became furious it had gratuity on it. I shouldn't have to pay a server 10% when she did nothing and I basically served myself. I will say the food was outstanding and flavorful but my service was horrendous and won't go back inside only order take out. read more

Been here probably a hundred times and haven't had a bad meal yet. Pizza is best in our area, pepperoni logs are amazing, subs are fantastic as are their dinners. Staff is friendly and the service is very good. Only thing I don't like is that they serve Pepsi products, which I am not a fan of. read more

My family and I are up from Texas and ate here because my aunt suggested this place. Alyssa our waitress was very nice. Our appetizer was good. We ordered the cheesy garlic bread. The marinara was very good. I ordered the cheese steak hoagie. It was good. My wife and son shared a cheese pizza. They liked it. The prices were very reasonable. We will come back. read more

Used to be one of our favorite places.The last time we got food there,I complained about their menu no longer being on line.I was told that it was online,but they would include a printed menu.I didn't get the menu with the order and the quality of the food has definitely slid.I still can't find an online menu,so it seems that they don't want my business.So sad read more

Some of the best pizza you'll find around here! Their specialty pizzas are phenomenal; love the buffalo pizza & meat lovers pizza most of all, always so loaded up with toppings. Cold subs & calzones are also extremely delicious. They have new building with drive thru window so you can call ahead & not have to leave your car to get good food! read more

This place used to be awesome when it was smaller and down the road. We would drive 25 minutes to go here. Now that they moved to the bigger place I'm really disappointed, luke warm food, stale or overcooked rolls, poorly assembled pizza, over and over again. We don't even bother to go anymore, there is 15 average pizza shops within 2 minutes of me, I just save the time and gas and stay local now. Also the entire place is waitress service now, I don't really need a waitress for a cheeseburger sub, just call my number, ill walk 10 feet to get it. read more

I have eaten there a few times as well as had food to go. It is normally good. Nothing spectacular. The last time my boyfriend and I ordered a BLT sub to split. IT WAS TERRIBLE. It was not real bacon strips but just a ton of bacon bits. It was DISGUSTING!! read more

OK I really want to do this place justice. For starters if your looking for a romantic setting then I recommend doing that yourself at home and just serving Little Italy's food with maybe a bottle or 2 from the local vineyard (Nissley Vineyards). OK that being said I think they have some of the best Italian food around and there prices are really good compared to most places. My family has been eating food from here since the week it opened. We havent tried everything but I'd say about 85-90% of the menu. There pizzas are outstanding, with crisp outer crust and chewy inner. They dont give attitude when asking for little things like making half a pie with one topping and the other half something else, which for some reason gets me evil glares if I ask at other places. When you order a topping you really get a topping, I mean they put alot on and always high quality ingrediants. They make everything them selves except for maybe the pasta which tastes as good as any homemade pasta I have had. There menu is rather big for being such a small family style resturant. Lots of choices for any stlye of eater even the lowcarb people out there. Ok i could go on and on about there food but now its time to bring up the staff. First is the Owner Enzo who is there the majority of the time, he is super friendly and treats ya like family. Every time I go in hes working hard but alwasy asks about the family and such. His wife is there alot too and is also friendly and helpfull. It seems he gets a highschool crowd working there but as far as I can tell they are all very nice and the ones who cook do a great job too. They dont do delivery which if they did Id probally be like 500 lbs and bed ridden, but It is definatly worth driveing there to pick up or eat inside if you like. My family has probally had there food average of about 2-4 times a month and really never had anything bad quality what so ever. I would recommend this place to anyone who asks. They are so much better then any other Pizza / Italian resturant around. Only compaint i have ever had was onetime my order was slightly off, but only by putting mayo on when I said no mayo but it was also around superbowl time and they were packed. read more

Would actually score this lower, but can't. Had gone here for years, pies are okay they have slipped since they relocated, but not really anything else in area. A couple weeks ago, we got a pie that was too big and jammed in the box on three sides, where crust was folded over on cheese. We call and sent picture of pie to Fran, who said okay we'll give you a free pizza next time you order. Next time was tonight. My wife called in and Fran was upset and apparently had a change of heart and started berating my wife in front of staff and other customers. Also The pizza we got was about three inches away from box on all sides. I guess they wanted to make sure that this one fit, but what really was bad was we offered to run it back the night we got it, but we were told that it was no problem. Keep it and we'll give you a free one next time. We ordered from here 2 maybe three times a month. After the shameful and pathetic display put by this management member and LACK of ANY CUSTOMER SERVICE we will no longer order from here. Good Luck read more