Excellent customer service!! As soon as you walk in It's very warm and clean. The food is a 10/10…read moreand everything is fresh and the wings are HUGEEE!!!

Carry-out Order Bone-in wings were dry/crunchy as if they…read morehad been setting under a warmer too long. Cole slaw was room temperature and served in an open container. Fries also were lukewarm and dried out. Overall not a good meal.

Delicious food! I had the Patty Melt with their famous Rum Runner, which is a frozen slushie type…read moredrink. They had a fun summertime topper of a pink pony duck to make your drink a "Quacktail" instead of a "Cocktail". FUN! Sit outside if possible for their gorgeous view of the water!!

Pink Pony is an absolute must when visiting Mackinac Island. The servers are great, the food is…read moreexcellent, and the vibe is relaxed. There is almost always a wait to get seated so get there early to get your reservation in. They will text you when your table is ready. Today, I had the Apple, Brie, and Walnut Flatbread and Boneless Chicken Wings with Mild Buffalo sauce. I typically order a salad with the flatbread but trying to be cautious right now with the lettuce issues. I rave about this flatbread - it has never disappointed. The taste is so good combined with the honey drizzle on top. The Wings were good - fried perfectly - and the Buffalo sauce complemented them nicely. We will be back on our next trip to the island!

Great cod dinners...excellent service and atmosphere...well worth the stop!…read moreExcellent beef menu and real prime rib Definitely be here again.

There is no warning about the step coming in I tripped and dropped my four year old. He hit his…read morehead on the concrete. Screaming bloody murder when the bartender finally came over after sitting for a few minutes, he had an attitude. If I could leave negative stars I would. He didn't even make sure my child was okay.

Caroline was the perfect waitress. We had the jalapeño Dip with pita bread, AMAZING. I save a bit…read moreto put on the Hangover Burger. The other two dishes Mac N Cheese with Brisket, Mac N Cheese with pulled pork. Hats off the kitchen staff. Food came out quickly and hot. So good we bought some Merchandise. T-Shirt and sticker. Great Stop. We loved the Squirrel decor.

Should I do another review? Well, I did miss our waitress, Amanda this time, but the server that we…read morehad was spectacular as well.. This is just a happy place. The food was perfect and yes, I had the Squirrel salad again, but my sister had to build a burger with extra crispy sweet potato fries and her friend had a grilled chicken burger. He thought he was following doctors orders, but my sister took the bacon off it for him and ate it herself! . We couldn't sit in the sports part because I had something to do with the fan in the kitchen, so that's the only thing I didn't like as we sat at a different table than our absolute usual. Other than that, I can't help but giving this epic place with its epic chef five stars. It has to be my favorite place ever to eat at in Gaylord.

We enjoyed a late afternoon drink and wings at the outside bar. Beautiful view of the lake and…read moregreat service from Joel. He recommended the wings and did not steer us wrong. They were huge and juicy and delicious. Came with 4 dipping sauces but honestly, they were so tasty they didn't need any!

Menu keeps removing things we like. New waitstaff are terrible. Ours was socializing at the bar…read morewe could see her and brought our drink 20 min after they were done while she just talked and hung out. There are some other good wait staff but be warned some are terrible. They have a food runner so other than order and drinks the waitstaff don't have much to do. A 3% fee is now added to your bill without your choice to cover employees benefits. Steak portions have shrunk while prices went way up.

Hands down the best Jamaican food we have had in Michigan. The service was excellent. It was nice…read moreto be served by fellow Jamaicans. The restaurant was very relaxing and a nice of change of scenery from the business of Mackinac island. The red peas soup was very flavorful and hearty. It was perfect for the cold day we had. The smoked fish dip was delicious and we ate the entire bowl which was huge. The jerk chicken I recommend getting the sauce on the side. The sauce is delicious but very spicy. It works better if you dip the chicken in it instead of having it lathered all over the chicken. The rum flight was tasty but we had to drink slowly as it was very strong. Overall highly recommend

The food was good, nachos were much better than the jerk chicken…read more Service was above average. Ambience...we're originally seated next to several employees that were discussing their dating drama. We moved as it was a bit much.

I had just arrived at the counter. There's one person in front of me as soon as I arrived. The…read morecashier looked at me and said can I help you very exhaustingly. I have a takeout order and I was disappointed already because I had trouble online ordering and they offer a burger for the first time ordering ever on the app. When I called the person that answered said there's nothing they can do. So I took a picture of the front door that has the manager's number. Since they have such low reviews, I thought I would try this place because I have a gift card. That was part of the problem I paid with my gift card online before I realized that I had to add on the Burger myself. I'm not really great at ordering online yet. Ambience is kinda casual sport Bar feeling. I'll see how the food is before leaving stars. I will post pictures of the two kids meals I ordered. I'll see what my mom feels about this if her taste in approved, Perhaps I'll overlook what I thought was faulty in my order. A free burger would have been nice. I had planned to drop it off to my sister on the way home. The chicken is super crusty and crunchy. The fries are already salted. Beware. Burger not as good as Culver's, kind of dry, per mom. A 3

Absolutely NEVER AGAIN! Walked in and was told we were not fact that they only had 2 cooks…read more.. I was blown away at the complete lack of preparation, professionalism and overall brand representation that this location displayed..