Came here for a Bachlorette weekend get away and this was one of the stops we had to go to for breakfast! I love that this was walking distance from the house that we had rented out but we def had to call our friends to come pick us up because we def got a bunch of bagels for the girls to have for breakfast. We each got different types of bagel and a container of their fresh baked coffee cakes. EVERYTHING was delicious and still hot when we brought the food back home. The staff were super friendly and fast at getting our orders in and checking us out. Love the different types of sandwiches that they offer - my friend and I ended up saving one of the bagels to eat on the way back home to RVA. read more

Delicious bagel sandwiches in the heart of Corolla. Friendly staff and quick process. Visiting during the off season was a great perk as well. Lots of bagel flavor options and each were well-made. The shop has good parking. Can't wait to go back! read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Stopped into this place to grab a bite after morning walk. It was busy but service was quick. Bagel was done well and no skimping on the lox or cream cheese. Lots of outdoor seating. Lots of bagel and cream cheese varieties to choose from! read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Salt Bagel with Cream cheese and lox - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Placed order at counter and took the ticket to the register. Paid for order and when got home they neglected to include one cinnamon raisin and a blueberry muffin in our bag. Very disappointed as they talked a great game at the counter and register about how great the food was. Not going back. read more

I feel like I have to speak up about my experience here, because it was genuinely shocking. I walked in, ordered a simple bagel sandwich -- nothing complicated, no special requests..and the girl working the counter was blatantly rude to me from the moment I said hello. I've never seen her before in my life, and I was polite the entire time, so the hostility made absolutely no sense. As a business owner myself, I would never in a million years allow my staff to treat customers the way I was treated today. Customer service sets the tone for a business, and when someone makes customers feel unwelcome for absolutely no reason, that's a reflection of management just as much as the employee. Read the previous reviews- this is not the first time someone's had a completely left field experience with waitstaff. This could have been a regular spot for me and my family, but after that experience, I won't be returning. read more

Nice bagels. Lots of options. Nice outdoor seating. Only complaint is that it took forever...... not because the staff were slow but they were so busy!!! It was about a 20 min wait just to get to order and another 15 mins before we got our bagels. The Turkey Bang Bang was amazing read more

See all

I'm a big fan of bagel and lox and this place had the best it was so good I was almost finished with it before I realized that I needed to take a picture of it. It was deliciously fresh with just the right amount of cream cheese and red onion and capers my mom also purchased an assortment of different bagels for the house she said that the service was friendly and quick although their online ordering was a bit confusing because you could not make any changes. My cousin was able to get the bagel she requested in accordance with her dietary needs though. Will definitely come back when I can! read more

See all

If you want bagels that are lacking in seasoning, come here! See the attached pictures for what their "everything" bagel looks like. If anything it should be called a "somethings" bagel instead. This is the sad ghostly whisper of an everything bagel. I know this sounds dramatic but was greatly disappointed. Also, was super disappointed that we order bagels and cream cheese in addition to our sandwiches to go thinking we were going to eat them the next day and the cream cheese was smeared on the bagel not on the side so now we can't reheat them the next day. Line was out the door and took a good amount of time, but ambiance was nice. The filling of the sandwiches was nice but the bagel itself was a major major disappointment. read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

See all

As a born and raised New Yorker, I must say they make a damn good bagel. They are bigger than what I'm used to getting, in fact they're almost huge, but they are baked right and you can tell they make them they way a bagel should be made. They are delicious. The garlic and herb cream cheese was fantastic!! Oh, and the crumb (coffee) cake tastes like New York too, and it's as good as I've had anywhere. The place gets BUSY in the morning, especially when they first open. We got there at 7:05am and the line was to the door, but we were waited on in less than 10 minutes. And this was in the middle of April, not during the summer months. It appears they get a bit backed up if people are ordering sandwiches, but if you're just getting bagels (or items that don't need to be cooked there), you should be able to get in and out fairly quick. They do have a website where you can order ahead, and a pick up window, which may be a time saver (especially in the summer). My only issue, which is why I gave it four and not five stars, the bagels are expensive. A dozen was over $30, which is twice as much as you'd spend in NY. Yes, the bagels are bigger, but that's a steep price. Then again, I'd gladly pay that for a real bagel versus getting fake bagels at Panera Bread. read more

Stopped by lighthouse bagels with my friends and the bagels here are crazy good. We're from New Jersey so we know a good bagel when we see one and this bagel is BETTER than good. It's up there with New York and new Jersey bagels, I got the everything bagel with cream cheese and scallion cream cheese. It tasted amazing and the bagel was super high quality and tasted like some fine artisan bread. Best bagels in the outerbanks and I don't even have to try any other bagels to say that! read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Awesome bagel place! We're from NJ and we're sooo excited for this bagel shop and we heard the recipe came from Jersey too! We got a bunch of bagels and they were all good! The french toast bagel was awesome. Would definitely recommend to anyone coming down here! read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Rosemary bagel & French toast bagel - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Service was fast, staff were kind. There are tons of bagels to choose from and then tons of flavored specialty cream cheeses to add with them. They also have the option of a variety of sandwich combos. Lots of cream cheese on the bagels (NY style ) and the bagels are made perfectly! read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Salt Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

See all

Best bagels on the east coast Friendly service they all seem to care I like the variety and the price it not bad for the size of the bagels read more

This is the best bagel you're going to find in the Outer Banks, and if you want one during peak season you're going to have to wait for it. We came here twice during our recent visit to the Outer Banks and waited around an hour both times from start to finish. The line was out the door both weekday mornings we came (around 9/10 am). It was about a half hour wait until we got up to the counter to order (and had we only ordered a dozen bagels and some cream cheese that could've been it), but the wait for our breakfast sandwiches was another half hour after that. It's a casual to-go spot that has no indoor seating, but plenty of outdoor tables if you can't wait till you get back to your beach house to devour your order. That said, the breakfast sandwich creations they have on the menu this year are on point and worth the wait -- and that's coming from a New Yorker. The Bang Bang sandwich was a standout and an absolutely perfect combination in my opinion -- fresh turkey, swiss cheese, arugula, eggs and spicy bang bang sauce all come together in the most delicious bite of breakfast sandwich your tastebuds have ever seen. You can order ahead online if you're getting breakfast sandwiches only, but not all of them are available via the online portal as of me writing this message (the Bang Bang isn't on there yet unfortunately). All that said, this review was written during the first week of them being fully open for the summer with a brand new staff, so they're still working out the kinks. I'm confident that if you're coming here later in the summer, the wait won't be as arduous. read more

Skip a brekky sandwich and order a bagel with cream cheese. Everyone in my group who ordered a sandwich felt the filling wasn't balanced with the bagel, so the bites just felt like a whole lot of bread! With the one bagel with cream cheese we did get, it was phenomenal! There is a ton of cream cheese to balance the bagel and honestly, it was the best French toast bagel I've ever had. And the cinnamon raison cream cheese was to die for!! read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

See all

I've been waiting to try this place out for several years because of the great reviews, but never had the opportunity until now. When you submit an online pick up order, you have to purchase at least $25 (which I've never seen a place do this before) - what if I just want one bagel sandwich? Also, you cannot purchase a plain bagel, half dozen bagels, or dozen bagels online. But you can purchase a tub of cream cheese (to eat it on a bagel(s) you cannot purchase?). I ended up getting several sandwiches and bagels w/ cream cheese because of the $25 min purchase. I wanted to try the french toast bagel that everyone raved about in the reviews - it was not that great tbh. I also ordered bagel with egg/cheese - there was hardly any filling inside. I felt like I was eating a really dry plain bagel at that point. Save your money and head over to Waveriders if you can. read more

Love their bagels...so good esp toasted with a flavored cream cheese spread... Their staff is ready to serve and does great to expedite a crowd.:.the lines get long but the staff works quick... read more

Top Notch bagels away from home!! We usually go there before we check in to our house for the week and chill before hopefully hitting the beach! I always like to come back mid week and get a bunch of bagels and spreads! The employees are alway on top of their game and best bagels outside of the Nj/Ny area!! Can't go wrong!! Can't wait to be back in Aug!! read more

Bagels-to-go IN THE OFF SEASON - my favorite time to go to Lighthouse lol - any time there isn't a line snaking out the front door and I can walk in and walk out with a bag of freshly made bagels under my arm is my favorite time to go. (But during busy season, there's good reason for there being a line out the door every morning - just a solid choice for a North-of-Duck helping of bagels and bagel sandwiches (including piping-hot-and-hefty bfast egg, meat and cheese bagel sandos). If you're here on the OBX before crazy I mean busy season starts and are hankerin' for bagels, take advantage of their pre-season opening (be sure to check business hours before hopping in the car as pre-season hours are shorter) and GO check this place out. Friendly, casual, great service and the folks working there know their stuff! read more

See all

Delicious bagels, but I will not purchase again. Everyone is entitled to their own political opinions, but I prefer politics not to be on the menu. "The MAGA King" read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

GREAT FRESH bagels. The cinnamon burst is my favorite. Friendly and efficient staff working there. Despite the large crowds, they get you in and out quickly. Definitely worth checking out if you're staying in Corolla. read more

This place was amazing! They have so many options from different types of bagels to different types of cream cheese! I hope you like a lot of cream cheese because they load it up! The wait was a bit long but it is so worth it. I highly recommend Lighthouse Bagels! read more

I remember this being much better about 10 years ago. Got the wrong bagel, fine - no biggie. But the Styrofoam cups with hot coffee? come on! first yuck (leeching chemicals from the cup) and also you are at the beach and using styrofoam? Use paper! read more

Horrible service, rude staff, undercooked breakfast sandwich. Not sure why others rate it highly. Guess they are just used to poor customer service. read more

Amazing! Hooked it up with the bagels and house made cream cheeses. Great folks. We'll definitely be back.

Awesome experience. Tried to use a rental coupon but got a bit confused with the mobile ordering. Store called me right away and explained I had to come in. Came in a bit later in AM to avoid massive wait. Staff was friendly, efficient and offered great suggestions. Snagged a baker's dozen. At checkout, spoke with the manager about prior experience and he made it right (without asking or prompting, totally unsolicited). Walked out with a big smile. Took bagels home and shared with friends + family, and everyone got even bigger smiles as they were hot and delicious. Highly highly recommend and will absolutely return on our next trip. read more

The best bagels around! I'm almost nervous to write this review and make it even busier than it already is!! The staff at lighthouse is always so kind and helpful. Their bagels are extremely fresh and bulky and have the perfect amount of cream cheese... YUM! Always a stop when we're in Corolla. read more

Great service good food.manager is a great person and cares about the customers getting ready to order again !

A little busy and they closed twenty minutes before closing time the day before, but food was excellent. Would definitely return. Cute place ! read more

The vegan way bagel is so good, I went all three days I was in town! and the staff are quick and friendly. The line can be long but moves pretty fast! Nice outdoor seating as well read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Vegan Way on Sriracha Everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Below average bagel. Very bready and they don't put enough seasoning on. Definitely not a NY bagel. The lines are long but not worth it.

So good!!! Loved the bagels! People were very friendly and great location! Would definitely go back!

This place is only open seasonally but they make the BEST breakfast sandwiches! We were staying in a house right around the corner from here and decided to pop in. I am not sure how anyone can have a negative review for this place. My husband and I went here every morning we stayed at Corolla. I had their breakfast sandwich on the Sriracha bagel which was amazing. The next day they were sold out. My husband loved the French toast bagel. Their coffee cake is amazing... we got some to go and we were happy we did! Great prices I highly recommend! There isn't much around, but this place is a gem. read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

Great Bagels, breakfast sandwiches and coffee. Had to wait in line but worth the wait.

Best bagels I've ever had, definitely worth trying. The bagels are high quality and delicious, my favorite item on the menu is the bacon egg and cheese sandwich! read more

Excellent variety of bagels n flavors. Big bagel sandwiches, friendly staff. They get very busy in morning so order online or there could be a wait but it normally moves pretty quick. read more

I usually check the bad reviews first and see if they're petty or if there's some real issues. This is no exception, we've been coming here for close to ten years now and consistency is prefect, year to year. Same people all this time. Being from Jersey, I have to say that north Jersey bagels are the standard in my opinion. With that said these bagels are always fresh, perfectly crusty outside and doughy/yeasty inside. Always friendly service, always prompt. It's absolutely as good or better than north Jersey bagels. If you want a bagel, this is the only place in this area to go!!!! Unless of course your a very sensitive woke snowflake who needs absolutely everyone to cater to your every whim and is easily triggered by words, then maybe go to the food store. read more

Lighthouse Bagels & Deli - Bagels Near Me - Corolla, North Carolina

I don't usually actively search out bagels, but the misses craves them. But this was the first time I've had bagels that rivaled what you can get in New York City. Their online ordering system is quick and efficient and helped me preorder for the following morning pickup. They have a pickup window for orders and I was out of there in a couple minutes despite a lot of guests waiting inside. Their everything bagel with scallion cream cheese was the favorite combo I tried over a few days. read more

So good! Huge bagels and fast service! Got there 15 mins before closing and still got good quality bagels quickly!

Bagel were authentic and delicious but came with fam for a quick stop before getting in the road back home and waited 45 mins for a few bagels with cream cheese and a couple custom bagel sandwiches. Granted they were busy when we first got there but I saw small order competed 20 mins prior to ours which was frustrating. A plus service tho otherwise very friendly read more