Sports card inventory is varied and impressive, from vintage through junk wax to modern stuff…read more Honest and fair trade-in. Surprised it was so busy on a Thursday before dinner, which gave me a really good impression (people must be coming back). Despite this they made sure to help me out. It seems like Pokémon, etc is a huge part of their business too but there is enough room for both TCG and sports.

This was absolutely amazing. They charge beautiful prices. DJ was so nice. He gave us drinks and…read morethey have a big free boot stall that he gave free cards and out of a 295 pack. I pulled the amazing card. He gives free sleeves amazing vibe. Definitely returning

I think a lot of their newer tabletop books are kind of expensive, and they look up online prices…read morefor old books that they probably got for 2-3 bucks at the thrift store, so that is -1 star. The free play tables however, are great. Fun commander magic games and enjoyed a few sessions from dnd here. The dnd minitures that they sell here are pretty cheap, for the lower end minis at least. And they have interesting and large selections of those. I like their minor tabletop card game collections, some are really cheap and look awesome, so that's great.

A huge variety of card sleeves, packs, playing mats, chess sets, mini figures, and assorted table…read moretop board games! More than half the store was playing tables and theres a tiny bit of BO stank, but that's to be expected with card playing spaces unfortunately. Wish it wasn't so, but I felt very unsafe in there. Bought nothing. Took a lap around the store and had to leave fast. They have a consistent group of people going in for tournaments (lorcana, magic, Pokemon, but not as much yugioh) Won't be back.

My boyfriend and I enjoy checking out local trading card game stores and we wanted to check out…read moresome stores that we haven't been to. We had stopped by Kent for a meal and decided to check out The Game Shelf as they weren't too far. The parking is huge and shared with a lot of businesses and it was Friday evening, so it took a little bit of time to find parking. Once we parked, we entered into the store and were greeted politely by the cashier. There was a Magic the Gathering event going on and it looks like their events calendar always has something going on each day which is great. They even did Final Fantasy TCG which we have yet to see anywhere else and we have been to card shops in several parts of Washington. They had quite a massive selection of wares from desk mats, card holders, sleeves, deck boxes, board games, dice, and much more. We bought a few things and as we were checking out, the cashier mentions to us about their reward system which is a character sheet that you can fill out and there are six slots that they will add up from each amount you spent. Depending on how much you spend will determine your discount which I think is really neat and unique from other card shops. It rewards you no matter how much you spend rather than a point system that could take more than a few purchases to accumulate. I also asked if they were dog friendly and they are, they just ask that your dog is well-behaved, don't make a fuss or bother other patrons, and to clean up after them.

This place is amazing. Has everything you need for D&D, to start and grow your campaign. Absolutely…read morelove it. I went in 5min early as the door was unlocked. I felt bad because the person working there was clearly chilling and I felt bad to disturb their morning relaxing time before they started work. They still greeted me and were friendly and kind. Helped me choose the first D&D book I need to begin my adventures. Super excited and absolutely love this place. Highly recommend. Every Friday at 7pm is D&D night with a group who are willing to teach you:) they have events and other games there as well that people come to play. They have a fridge with drinks as well for purchase and games you can play off the shelf.

Ilan is super nice and always gives me the best recommendations. When I went in today, he was super…read morefriendly and helped me find all the comics I was looking for and a few more I didn't know I needed. Today he recommended this Wonder Woman comic to me with beautiful art and I've been loving it so far. The first time I visited Mighty Moose, I was looking for Shadow Service published by Vault Comics. I was travelling shortly, but Ilan found all the issues for me and held them until two months later when I returned. I really appreciated him going above and beyond to get me the comics I wanted. When I went in today, Ilan was working on a video of some super vintage comics for social media and it was really cool to see them up close. Yes their cards can sometimes be overpriced (I collect Pokemon cards), but sometimes there are great deals! Ilan sold me his entire stock of leftover Halloween Pokemon cards early last year for super cheap and I gave them out to my nieces and nephews who adored them!

Do not sell your comics at Mighty Mouse I brought In a comic that eBay last soles were like 30-50 $…read moreand wanna know what he offered 3$!!!

This has to be my favorite comic book store in the area!…read more The selection is incredibly extensive, well taken care of, and pretty well organized. I found several books that I could not find anywhere here. Prices are great too! It's my second time coming in and the owner has given me a solid deal om the books I have bought both times. The owner is a great guy that I can tell genuinely loves what he does, and has a passion for sharing all things nerdy with everyone that walks in the door. I definitely need to make this store a routine stop :)

Amazing selection, has everything you need collectible wise and comic book wise. Great place to…read morepurchase anything that you are looking for!

Most of the staff are very friendly but the staff member who called himself the "Magic Guy" was…read morevery rude. He accused me of taking pictures of the store to make a scam site online (I was just using my phone to zoom in on the small prices on the wall), and then while I was buying something from another staff member for the posted price, he interjected himself and repriced the item raising it nearly $100 while I was buying it (about 20% over tcgplayer price). The other staff member looked really uncomfortable, I asked him why he did that and he just walked away. I said forget it, went to walk out and another staff member apologized for his behavior, said he was having a bad day. There are a lot of places to buy cardboard, most of if not all of what they sold is cheaper online. I like going to a store and buying it off a shelf instead of on a website, but not if they're going to treat people poorly. There are a handful of other shops as well between tacoma and federal way. Again, the rest of the staff was great and I hesitated to even bother leaving feedback, but I haven't been back there since and figured I'd share so people know who they may run into when they shop there.

Trust the recent 1 star reviews, and do not waste you time at this place…read more Scammers. Selling to shops as a female is always a hit or miss of whether they will underestimate and take advantage of you. They seemed to think they could try to offer me $70 for hundreds of dollars of cards, including graded, numbered and autos. Dude took out 60 of my cards and didn't comp any of them, including graded and numbered and auto ones, then proceeded to tell me they were all each worth about $1-3 each spending about 5 minutes max going through them and not once comping cards to average recent last sold prices. Knowing that was extremely low and that they didn't comp like all other stores, I let him know I'd be price checking before accepting any offers, which I always do. Once I spent 30 minutes of my time checking the cards for recent last sold prices, and found half of them were worth $15-$80 EACH, and removed them from the original pile, I was told they were closing in 10 minutes and could no longer offer me anything for any of them. Wasted about an hour of my time total in that store for them to just attempt to completely scam me and then give me attitude when they realized they weren't going to be putting one over on me. One of the cards he quoted was a few dollars only I had just been offered $40 at a previous card shop and still declined because I wanted more than 50%. This place is scum. Not to mention, I am pregnant with twins and did not need to be wasting my time or having a grown adult stress me out and waste my time. Terrible business. Maybe the owner shouldn't own a shop if they don't want to accurately price match, so they can scam pregnant woman and then be rude to them when they don't allow it. I am the only one who price matched and averaged recent sales of my cards to find you were trying to rip me off for hundreds of dollars. They didn't price match ANY and went through a stack of almost 70 cards you pulled in 5 minutes then added up some BS $70 number in your head. Maybe this shop shouldn't be open if they don't know how to do business or average last sold because they just want to scam people because using those methods and offering 50-70 percent is the standard. They also replied to my google review acting like they did price match last sold and I was just looking on eBay when that is completely false. He pulled 60 plus cards and added up a number in his head and did not price comp them. I also went by average recent sold not current eBay bids. This store is disingenuous to the bone. Their reply also falsely accused me of coming in after their cut off time for selling yet still accommodated me, when in fact I got there 15 minutes prior and spent 10 of those waiting to the buyer to come back from break and I wasn't even told of them having a cut off time until the very end. Goodluck with running your business like that. Avoid this place. There are other store between Tacoma and my favorite RENTON that are genuine, runs by best practices of comping, and offers 60-80 percent. Westside Sportscards is a fraud.

Overpriced Pokemon cards. $159 for Ascended Heroes ETB. The highest I've seen is $130. I get that…read morethe market value is high, but no. I'm not going to support a shop that likes to rip off customers. I'm instead taking my business to Curio in MLT. Much better prices and the people there are super nice and helpful. I will gladly support a business that cares about the hobby and not so much about the profit.

Well, visiting from out of town and saw this shop. Decent selection of baseball, vintage too. But…read morewow, vastly over priced. I realize condition is everything, but raw vintage cards were priced as if they were already graded 8-9s. Wouldn't negotiate to reasonable comps. Heck, even new cards were priced way high. Literally twice recent sales, or more..Had a rc priced at $8 that i showed last 10 sales were below $2, wouldn't budge saying the guy was a good player. Another PSA 10 was listed at $50 and selling for $30, said he overpaid and would just keep. Ok, finding another store....

Owner is very sweet and took the time to talk me through selling to them as a new collector. Store…read morecredit is kept track of by them and a great selection of Pokemon TCG singles. Very organized store and 2 price system offering a lower price to rip in store. Thanks for the singles and taking my plastic packages when I rip in store. Excited to come back again and again.

Adam and Jo are super friendly and make each visit great…read more Couldn't recommend this place enough for the value they provide to collectors and the community. If you're looking for reasonably priced options, this is the place to check out!