Unfortunately, this was one of the worst dining experiences I've had in a long time. Our waiter spent most of his time sitting at the bar instead of checking on his tables. We were never asked if we wanted another round of drinks, if we needed napkins, or if everything was okay. We had to flag someone down whenever we needed anything. The piña colada was incredibly watered down and lacked any real flavor. On top of that, the drinks have noticeably shrunk in size compared to previous visits. It's disappointing because this restaurant used to be one of our favorites. The service and quality have clearly declined, and based on this experience, I'm not sure we'll be returning. I hope management addresses these issues because this place has so much potential. read more

I wanted to like La Herradura more because the prices are really good for Mamaroneck and the menu has a lot of options. The food was okay and the music was nice, but the service was a major issue. It took forever for someone to even take our order, and our server barely checked on us afterward. Everyone we did speak with was nice, so maybe they were just understaffed, but there were times when it felt like there were no servers around at all. I'd consider coming back but the service needs a lot of work. read more

La Herradura - Enchiladas tres amigos - Mexican Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Great for lunch! Awesome specials, great drinks, will be coming back soon for sure! Portions are super generous.

Awful experience , we walked out! We were seated at a table surrounded by screaming children. I walked up nicely to the maître D and asked for a quiet table in the back of the restaurant. I went back to my table and saw the maître D walk to the table behind me, point to me and tell them that I complained about their children. We've walked out. Unacceptable!!! read more

I went here for lunch, it was a great deal for the amount of food. More importantly the food was great! They have a great selection of margaritas as well! read more

This was a really good place. I wish I found out about it earlier. Really good Mexican food for the East Coast which is rare.

I got there with a friend and was seated promptly and friendly. Him and I already knew what we wanted and we've been there before for other dishes but specifically we came to have Tacos de Lengua. Ambience was quite not many people just how I like it! She brought us two modelos promptly as well. The tongue tacos were juicier and tender than we had before or expected or remembered. The salsa verde y roja made the tacos taste outta this world. Come here once in a while but this time the Tacos were delicious. read more

La Herradura - Tacos de lengua served with rice and refried brown beans and salsas were delicious especially mixed with beans so good - Mexican Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

we love this place! it's been our go to mexican resturant since we moved to mamaroneck!!! love it. food is very good, drinks are great. i've always loved to come to happy hour and i love the traditional latino music. today... i asked can we get regular music on? there's so many commercials, TV's are usually on but silent and under the music. Tonight i was treated to MTV with all the commercials, they didn't turn it off. so irritating. i'm honestly like questioning coming back it bothered me that much. TV's being the background noise at a resturant not great. Not a great night here. service was off. food always solid, read more

The people where are kind and helpful. I say that you should come here one day it a good restaurant to come to.

Not sure why this place only gets 2.8 starts (at the time of this review). I feel like I am a conservative critic and would easily give La Herradura 4 stars. There are so many options on the menu and never been disappointed. The staff is friendly and the food comes out quickly and hot. Personal favorite is the Pollo a La Parilla. Only critique is the beverage situation where Tamarind juice and Horchatas appear to have different consistency each time and are usually overly sweet. I've sent back my horchata before and had it remade, which I appreciate. The prices are very reasonable compared to other restaurants in the area. read more

I've been to La Herradura about four times in the last two weeks primarily for happy hour and I've been very satisfied with their happy hour promos. Their Cantaritos, their margaritas, their other specials and their very tasty fajita burritos, tacos and fajitas are all excellent. read more

I came with my family to eat in the weekend and it was one of the best experiences with restaurants. The food is delicious. The waitress was very attentive with us and pleasant. Will come back again :). read more

Ambiance/Decor: 10/10 Service: 7/10 (Fast but felt a bit rushed) Food: 6/10 (Enchilada rojas were good, side of rice was not) Price: 9/10 (Entrees we're reasonably priced, and portion sizes were adequate) read more

I have been here multiple times. The tile work on the floor and tables, the lighting, waitstaff attire and music are all authentic and make you think that you are in Mexico. The waitstaff was almost adequately attentive. I did have to get up from my seat and ask for water a couple of times. The music and noise was not annoying nor did it impede my ability to hear and be heard. The chairs were not overly comfortable. Lighting was adequate but it was daytime. They served complimentary chips and salsa. The former were crisp and nicely salted and the latter was tangy and tasty. I had lunch there today and the fajita portions were generous. the shrimps were plentiful, plump and awesomely spiced, ditto on the chicken and beef that were moist and perfectly sliced. All of the food was hot and the salsa and sour cream sides were thoughtful and ample. The rice and beans side were also generously sized, warm, nicely spiced and flavorful. My friend got the veggie enchiladas which you can see in the picture. Look at the nice presentation! He let me try some and the veggies were well cooked, superbly spiced and perfectly softened. read more

La Herradura - Enchilada - Mexican Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

Hours say open until 10 pm on Saturday night. Was seated at 8 pm. Staff was not attentive and acted like we bothered them for coming in at 8. They started aggressively cleaning and shut the music off at 9:15 and when I asked for something else the waiter got visibly annoyed and walked away. Stick to your hours or change them to close earlier if staff doesn't want to work the hours of operation you have listed. read more

Amazing food and amazing service. Would 100 percent recommend. Make sure to get a reservation on weekends tho lol

This is a great little Mexican restaurant with pretty decor and good drinks. The food is also good with decent service. I would definitely go back, but the ceviche was not the freshest, if you're walking on mamaroneck ave. definitely good spot to stop in for margarita and fajitas. read more

Best quesadillas ever, lots of food for low price, one of the best spots in mamaroneck read more

La Herradura - Mexican Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Delicious food and a super friendly staff is all you need to know. Go here and see for yourself.

Absolutely disgusting and inedible. This was Friday eve the 25th. Will never order from this place again. The steak in the tacos was literally raw and tough. Took 3 bites spit it out. The steak burrito tasted like the food was old with that freezer taste and the rice was all dried out crunchy. Threw both items out. The appetizer banana thing was decent, guacamole was good A 60 dollar meal thrown in the garbage. Went to Chipotle to get dinner. read more

I don't recommend this place. The service was absolutely awful. The employees did not care the steak fajitas dry and chewy. We waited 40 minutes and one of the meals never came no apology. I also order the queso dip and received something totally different again no apology. I would never go back. read more

Worst service ever. Ordered drinks, appetizers and food. They left hot salsa on our table. I asked for water. 20 minutes later, my server still hadn't brought water to the table. Three other tables outside were being ignored. I walked in and let the server know. Instead of coming out and helping us, or bringing water, he told us we could leave. read more

This place deserves 0 stars. We ordered the enchiladas with Molé sauce, chicken. This was a very salty, mole sauce, chicken was basically what they use for the fajitas not the shredded kind, honestly could do better at Taco Bell. Also ordered the Carne Asada which was drenched in butter, and somehow still not good. Lots of fat and tough to chew. Fajitas are awful as well. Not sure how this place is still open, the only thing I can think of is that the ambience is sort of cute and the service was decent. read more

All employees are working in a sad mood, something happened to them, manager has to take a look, they are not happy, the service is so poor! Food ok , but service is horrible! July 2024! Don't ruin your date, go somewhere else! :( read more

Wife, child, and I stopped here en route from Ossining to Larchmont. I didn't have particularly high expectations; wife's from the area but hadn't been before -- mainly wanted some Mexican food, and we thought our son, who's 4, would appreciate a plate of arroz con frijoles. Son was acting up when we arrived, low blood sugar perhaps, and didn't want anything initially. He wouldn't even look at the menu, and claimed the music overhead was driving him crazy. We got him a cup of chocolate milk, and things perked up a bit. Our own food was surprisingly good. Wife enjoyed her fish taco, I the enchiladas verde, with a tangy, mild green sauce and perfectly done marinated grilled chicken. I prefer refried beans with the consistency of beans and not the mushy variety, but that's a minor quibble. Herradura gets an extra star for allowing my son to go slightly off-menu and have white rice and black beans with his single chicken taco. By the end of the meal, Mr. Fussy was right at home. read more

La Herradura - Mexican Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Not a friendly place. No smiles makes a person feel that they are not needed. Drinks expensive food ok. Asked for Nachos without all the fixings said don't do that but will however but I have to pay the same price. Not much booze in the drink. Does not make you want to come back. Frank G read more

Rude staff . I went for a drink but I was with my son who is underage so I had to sit at a table instead of the bar . the waiter rolled his eyes when I said I didn't want food . I have to mention the restaurant was empty since it was 3 o'clock of a Wednesday, so it is not I was taking nobody's table or anything. The bill was 30 dollars . I gave them 2 bills of 20 dollars . They didn't bring any change . They decided that was their tip. Leaving the place , my 5 year old son wished them thanksgiving. They didn't bother to answer . I don't recommend this place . read more

When you plan an afternoon to have authentic Mexican food and come to this place you are truly filled with disappointment. Ed Sheeran, Drake, And The weekend are apparently authentic Mexican Music. The tacos were a 5/10 kinda dry. I've had better, staff was amazing tho so get at it :) read more

The Burrito Supreme are good size and tasty but the beef is tough. All the included sides are small. If you have a craving for Mexican food, it is a second choice. No delivery and pick up only. Enjoy ... read more

Guacamole is ok very heavy on lime and cilantro. Chips are not homemade I had the chicken fajitas were filled with chicken and had a nice flavor. My girlfriend had burrito pastor with pineapple and she said it was very good, great flavor and great sauce. Overall ok not a bad place if you are craving Mexican in the area. Red sangria is very good. Waiter service is horrible! read more

La Herradura - Mexican Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

The food it's not that good I order enchilada suisa and it was disappointing Grilled chicken instead of shredded boiled chicken The margarita was disappointing read more

I ordered grilled chicken tacos for my 10 year old daughter. The waitress asked if she should leave off the cilantro and onions, which I agreed to. However, the tacos came with absolutely nothing on them. I asked for shredded cheese and sour cream, which I was charged an extra $3.50 for! Such a disappointing experience, this was my go to Mexican restaurant. We won't be returning due to their nickel and diming! read more

La Herradura - Grilled chicken tacos, without anything??? - Mexican Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Food quality has really gone down hill. The food is not cooked as fresh and well as before. Food portions are very small. I called around 9:15 pm on 9/15/22 and a women pick up. I explained my issue and she kept repeating if I wanted a refund to call uber and totally missed the point of working on relating the message to management or cook to work on there food quality. The lady was very rude and hung up phone. Definitely lost a consistent customer who was ordering from you for the past 6 months. Will tell all local neighbors throughout Harrison and Mamaroneck of this experience. That poor service explains the poor cooking quality lately. read more

I have been here several times, but tonight stood out. We were seated quickly, and ordered drinks and the table side quac. they came, and were cold and delicious...but then it was like we weren't even seated at the table. I had to wave down someone to bring us more chips for the Guac, but we were largely ignored. Our server would not make eye contact when I tried to get his attention. Tables were seated, ordered and served their main course before he came back for us to order ours, and a second round of drinks. The drinks came soon enough, but the food took forever. About the food: I will have to say - the highlight of the evening. I had the Chile Relleno stuffed with ground beef and it was superb. My Colleagues at the table were very happy with their food as well. After we sat for another very long time, I had to wave down somebody for the check (which came right away). So - slow service tonight, bordering on negligent, but excellent food. I'm surprised. Every other time I have been here - there have been no issues. read more

Found this place accidentally, great atmosphere and really good food would definitely recommended it and we hope to be back when we are in town read more

We were looking for somewhere for a quick snack. This place was so great that we ended up eating a lot more than we should have! SOOO good!! First, we were brought chips with 2 types of salsa, one hot, one smoky. Both were amazing, very flavorful. It was just enough so that we weren't hungry, but no so much that we were full. We had tostones, empanadas, tacos and sopesitos. Everything tasted really good with just the right amount of seasoning. And plenty of fresh guacamole! All of this for less than $40! And the staff was really nice, service was fast. Do not miss this place!! read more

See all

Where are the good taco spots in Weschester? The chorizo taco tasted like it was reheated several times no flavor or spices was tasted. The draft beer was served warm and the menus were so disgusting my cousin found salsa rubbed on hers and I found a cilantro on mine. If they can't clean the menus makes me wonder what the kitchen is like? read more

I ordered two chicken tacos and a chicken burrito for pick up. When I picked the other up there was a miscommunication they gave me two orders of chicken flauta. Now mistakes happen. I'm not upset over that. I'm upset because when I said no I order two chicken tacos the man argued with me and insisted that I ordered chicken flauta. I hope you enjoy the $50 this meal cost me because that's the last of my money you'll ever get. I can forgive an order mistake but rude costumer service I can not. read more

Food was good, but not memorable enough to bring me back and I Love Love Mexican food. Salsa was tasty and fresh but did not have any heat. Chips were boring and do not appear to be home made. Tacos was ok but sweet and even less heat than the salsa. I did appreciate the fact that they add a very nice slice of avocado to the top and some sour cream/cheese. It could have been more uniformly filled..but the sweet style sauce was muy mal! Tastes like food prepares by an Englishman and not a Mexican. Btw, if the taco meat did not taste like a manwich I would have loved it. You can tell that they use great ingredients and that everything is super fresh. Btw, the taco comes with 3 tacos but I was too hungry and I ate one before the picture read more

See all

The place is very well decorated and the food is very good but the service is terrible. They come to you in the beginning to get your drink and food order and that's about it. I have been here twice and both times I had the same experience. The servers do not check on you throughout the meal to see if you need anything. If you need another drink you have to be the one to get up and get their attention. When you finish your food, they come get your plates but never ask if you want coffee or dessert. They don't seem to understand how to keep the meal flowing. You have to be willing to flag the wait staff down and take the initiative to request what you want throughout the meal because they will not come to you willingly. Making eye contact with them or even just staring at them isn't enough. read more