Growing up on Krispy pizza in Brooklyn, I have high expectations. I'll start by saying the recipe is clearly the same. The sauce has a hint of sweetness, the cheese is top quality. And, as always, it's KRISPY! I haven't gone into the establishments myself, just ordered delivery/pickup. The staff is pleasant, I tried ordering online to use my new customer discount, it wasn't working but hopefully that will be fixed soon. I notice the menu isn't as extensive, I'm wondering if it's bc it's essentially on a college campus? To have Krispy open more locations in NJ and thrive is essential to me. Prior to us knowing, we'd drive back to Brooklyn just for a slice regularly lol THIS is what pizza should taste like. read more

We finally had the opportunity to try Krispy Pizza, and it definitely did not disappoint! We ordered a round pie made half pepperoni and half cheese, and every slice was packed with flavor. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside while still soft and chewy on the inside. The sauce had a great balance of sweetness and tang, and the cheese was melted to perfection. What really stood out was the quality of the ingredients and the attention to detail. The pepperoni had just the right amount of spice, and even the plain cheese side was incredibly flavorful. You can tell they take pride in what they serve. If you're looking for great pizza with fresh ingredients, a crispy crust, and authentic flavor, Krispy Pizza is definitely worth a visit. We'll absolutely be back for more! Highly recommended! read more

Krispy Pizza - Half & Half - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Tried the three sauce pizza and chicken vodka. Both were good and crust is very crispy. Could have used with more sauce. Good place for a nice crispy flatbread pizza. Name lived up to the crisp. read more

Krispy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Been seeing their fun family videos for quite sometime so when a work trip lead me to the east coast I had to try it. Found their location near Rutgers university and popped in for an early dinner so it wasn't very crowded. They had a good amount of selections in their showcase. Went with the following: Buffalo chicken pinwheel - this was good. Could have been a little hotter but I was hungry so didn't bother to reheat. Great flavors and textures. Crispy outside with soft chicken and buffalo buttery flavor internal. Great for a snack for all that like buffalo chicken. Sicilian - great pillowy fluffy bite with everything you're looking for in a Sicilian. Great fresh ingredients complimented each other well. I would get this every time. Margarita - just like the Sicilian, you can taste the quality ingredients and certainly with the crispy charred bottom made the crust flavor pop nicely. Overall really happy with the trio I got and loved the experience from walking in, ordering, indulging and being thanked on my way out. True class through and through here! read more

Krispy Pizza - Buffalo pinwheel, Sicilian and a margarita slice. Can't go wrong. - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Pizza was ok, thin slice, good crust, outdoor & indoor seating. Prices not posted on menu wall. Convenient location. Street parking. read more

See all

Pretty good pizza tbh, price seems high for some slices though. Overall would recommend its quick and easy

Love, love, love Krispy's Pizza!! It's always fresh and full of flavor. Definitely a place I keep coming back to. The service is also wonderful, which just makes the whole experience even better. 100% recommend! read more

I've found New York pizza in NJ. No, it's not just around the corner? At almost an hour to drive here but what treats await. The Sicilian is savory. The pepperoni is crisp and incredibly juicy and the regular slice sings a perfect song. I'm coming back. It's that good. read more

See all

I was verbally harassed by the man working the cash register on September 22 around noon. I was waiting for my order and picked up one of the plastic forks at the waiting area before deciding I didn't need it and put it back. In response to this, the cashier decided it was appropriate call out to me in a rude and accusing tone: "Stop picking up the forks if you're not going to use them. Why are you picking up the forks if you're not going to use them?" I was pretty confused. I understand in a college areas cashiers often deal with rowdy customers, but his response felt completely disproportionate. I would have understood and complied with a simple "could you please not touch the forks unless you are not going to use them". Instead, the cashier verbally harassed me in front of customers, making me feel scared and embarrassed. It was almost as if I was being punished and bullied for spending money in the restaurant. The pizza was decent, and I would have came back if it weren't for the rude interaction the cashier initiated with me. However, you lost a potential customer, because I will not go back to a restaurant where staff feels it is appropriate to harass customers and make them feel unsafe, and I recommend anyone considering this place to stay far away. read more

I've had Krispy before and rated them a 5. This time was a bust. The pizza slices were ice cold. They were not even heated! A shame for such good pizza. The dinners were just ok. Maybe it was my menu choice but I was disappointed. I like well done pizza but not shrimp. It was deflated and over fried. Oh well. ugh idk... read more

Krispy Pizza - Shrimp Parm - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Great variety of options from pizza, pasta, salads, apps and drinks; location at The Yard immediately across from the bus stop so easy access and service is fast and amenable. You can pay w card, Apple Pay and I believe the RU meal card. Kids like it but for me the options I've tried over time were just ok, a bit on the bland side. Everytime we go I've ordered something different but always walk away hunger satisfied, but flavor disappointed. Krispy, yes, and the guys are always friendly. There was a worker eating right behind the counter with his hands and taking orders from customers at the same time which I didn't find hygienic but should the kids ever want to return here I'll take them, but I will no longer be eating there myself. ParkMobile street parking, wheelchair accessible for ordering but not eating as table and counters are high, still family friendly and available outside tables in The Yard. Atmosphere is energetic as there's always people coming and going. Limited seating to keep it moving. Nice deco. read more

Krispy Pizza - Eggplant parm - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

This is the biggest pizza I've ever had. I ordered it delivery and it arrived earlier than I requested, still hot. The restaurant called to let me know it'd arrive early and to tell me once it arrived at my hotel which was nice. The ingredients taste quality, not super greasy, very cheesy. Great pizza. read more

Krispy Pizza - Hot Honey Pesto-roni - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Place is bonkers and well known for a reason. You typically see their tri color slice blasted over IG but that isn't even close to their top slice The best slice of theirs and without a doubt the best speciality slice of pizza I've ever had is they Hot Roni with pesto. Mike's hot honey goes a long way and they show you They use the little roni cups for their pizza AS EVERY pizza shop should. Great sign right there. Crust on all slices is... krispy. I even ask the dude whenever I go to make it extra krispy and he always does. He's also super cool and huge ball buster Storefront is on Rutger's campus. Inside it's a nicer college campus style pizza shop but still get the New York vibes read more

See all

TLDR: Solid pizzas with a variety of fun options. Some of the pizzas are crispy, but they all have a rock hard crust. The pizzas are mostly tasty, and I enjoy the variety of options like the Krispy special or penne vodka pies. The pies are relatively thin and have an enjoyable bite (either crispy or chewy depending on the pie you pick). The crust of each slice is rock hard and not great to eat. read more

Krispy Pizza - Penne Vodka Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

I cant believe this place Before the pandemic i would eat here atleast 4 days a week faithfully I decided to give this place another try after years to see if they got it together because they have been onna downhill streak I couldnt be right The food is no good Like at all The chicken gets overcooked The fries are cheap garbage they get hard and change color while you eat them The food is no longer any good but thanks to all the drunk rutgers kids Theyll always keep this place afloat Dont waste your time looking for parking or money here read more

Krispy Pizza - This is what you get when you order the chicken wrap Dry overcooked burned chicken with a side of old hard fries. - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Ordered a whole Margherita pie and it seemed like they had a premade one which was just warmed. We always order the same pie from other pizzeria and it would be hot and cheese would more liquidy even after we bring it home. Here the cheese were just hard. Crust didn't seem like they cooked it enough and it was chewy from the first bite. It wasn't a freshly prepared one. Also I have eaten at their Jersey city location and was excited to try this place since it's close to my home. Total disappointment!! read more

Been ordering delivery from the New Brunswick location. Well worth the price. They use fresh ingredients, have some creative specials, and outstanding customer service with a keen eye on quality control. One day soon I'll try their other dishes, but their pizza--particularly the Palmero--is among the best I've had in the area. read more

Just had it delivered some of the best pizza I ever eaten. Always order from there. The chicken salad is very good also

The pizza was excellent. Absolutely the best NY style pizza I've had in New Jersey. The crust was crispy and after two slices I wanted a third!!! My waistline is grateful that we don't live too close to the restaurant. You must try it if you are around Rutgers NB. If not, they have other locations as well. read more

Rutgers students rejoice, for you are really lucky to have such a reliable and resounding pizza joint in Krispy Pizza. This is a pizza joint that is reluctant to resonate in all the glory, but rather retake the field in revolutionary and reckless fashion. For your realistic expectations, you must relate to every room that romps their way to chomp on this New York style slice into rambunctious ravenousness. This rare breed of a rags to riches story from Brooklyn, brings no rest for the weary. It resists the urge to be a college pizza, but something bigger and better, roaring back to a time when pizza ruled supreme over ramen and rice. Krispy reaches higher, and rises to the occasion respectfully and ruthlessly without any regard for its competition. This is a pizza that reigns in a solid slice with consistent regularity. By no request, this pizza deserves religious fervor in deciding nothing but a positive review. I have researched many pizzerias in the past year, and regard this one as a pretty good one. With that, I highly recommend. read more

Krispy Pizza - Outside - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

5 stars for sure!! Love the pizza here. You have the option of grabbing a slice as you like or ordering a full pie. My favorites are pies with vodka sauce, regular and penne, and the tri sauce one. They use sesame in their crust which I've never seen before but adds a level of texture. The only thing I've had here and don't recommend is the garlic knots, those are a pass read more

had Krispy pizza in January at the Rutgers campus. pizza was delicious. bought 3 home for my 70th birthday the following day and iy was easy to heat and tadtec just as fresh. read more

Not crispy but definitely tasty pizza. Got a few pies for takeout from here tonight, a half pepperoni half plain and a fat Krispy pizza. Ordered this on the app and picked it up 20 mins later, it was done when I walked in, didn't have to wait. It was a 20 minute ride to home where I was going to indulge in this awesome pizza. Got home and noticed that the cheese on the half pepperoni had moved a little bit (all good!). The fat Krispy was awesome, the "special" sauce tasted like thousand island or Russian dressing drizzled over a fries, mozzarella sticks and chicken fingers (definitely a nod to the fat sandwiches once offered at the trucks that used to occupy the space years ago). Definitely a solid offering and brings back memories of fat sandwiches I used to eat years ago! Overall, the pizza was good, the fat Krispy was excellent, however, the pizza didn't live up to the "Krispy" in the name, it wasn't crispy! Could've been because of the 20 min ride home in the box, definitely worth another try to see if it truly is crispy right out of the oven. read more

Krispy Pizza - Fat Krispy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Had a couple of their three sauce slices - marinara, pesto, and vodka - fantastic. Service was quick and ambiance pretty standard for a pizza joint. Would recommend. read more

Krispy Pizza - Sicilian pizza with three sauces - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Pizza is my favorite hot food so I'm excited that this spot is on College Ave. they had a wide variety of pizza and they also make other foods (haven't tried them yet, just the pepperoni roll). The pizza has a good crust on it. It's the closest you're getting to a NY slice in the area. On this particular day I grabbed some plain slices but the margarita pizza and pepperoni are also really good. It's a little greasy so I let it drain a bit before enjoying. The service has greatly improved since its opening, making it a better experience to pop in and grab a slice. They are also pretty good on delivery when we ordered several pies. read more

See all

I'm going to keep this short and sweet. This pizza is bangin. My sister continuously raved about this place, specifically the vodka pie and on Pizza Friday, I had to give it a try. Yeah, you're going to pay 20 bucks for a pie, but it is so worth it! The ingredients seem to be top notch and the taste... YUM! I love the hint of sweetness in the vodka sauce that complimented the salty cheese. I can't wait to go back and try other pies and items on the menu. read more

I've been a Krispy Pizza Customer for over 3 years, and after today's experience I will no longer order from them. I walked into this location and as soon as I walk in, one of the employees is on the phone at the front counter, joking and trying to make an appointment with his barber. He's on the phone for at least 30 seconds before he even acknowledges me. I notice that there are only 2 stale pies at the counter. Once he gets off the phone, I walk up to him and tell him my order number and name, thinking that my pizza might just be under the counter or in the back, because I did not see it where they normally hold pick up orders. He immediately says, "Yeah, we don't have either of those slices." I placed my order 20 minutes before I went to go and pick it up, and not at any point did they call me to tell me that they didn't have any of those pizzas. Normally, they call and tell me if they don't have one of the slices that I've ordered, and I'm able to choose from other slices that they have available. But instead of calling me to tell me that they don't have my order, I walk into this location and see this guy on a personal phone call. He was very nice, but he tried to offer me the stale grandma, plain and margherita slices. I told him that I just wanted to cancel my order at that point and he was understanding and actually very nice. However, this other employee walked out from the back room, and is digging into his nose with a tissue for about a minute. They both don't have masks on, and I already knew that I did not want to eat anything from this location after seeing that. The employee who came out of the back, looked at the order and said to the other employee (who I first spoke to), you saw that this order was placed at 7:04, and didn't call to say that we didn't have these slices? The guy shrugged and didn't say anything. The employee from the back then turned to me, while still playing with his nose, and asked me if I didn't want the stale slices, in exchange for the premium slices that I paid for. I said no, and he said that he'd make a whole pie of one of the slices that I ordered and give me a slice from it. He never asked me which slice I preferred, because I ordered two different slices. He murmured that he'd make the easier pie. It may be the easiest, but it wasn't the slice that I favored, and he did not even care to ask me what I wanted. I simply just wanted to cancel my order, there's no harm in that because it wasn't there, and they wouldn't have to be forced to do extra work. I had no problem up until that point, I just wanted to leave and go back home. And I said, "No that's fine." His response was, "Why?! You can't wait 12 minutes??" No. I did not what to wait another 12 minutes. If I wanted to wait, I never would've placed my order online, I would've just gone in and placed my order. I'm not sure if he made an assumption and thought that I was a college student and deserved less respect. But I have other things to do with my time, it's not like I walked down the street or came down from my dorm to pick up this order. And even then that is ridiculous, any customer deserves the same respect. So no, I'm not waiting an extra 12 minutes. I already DROVE 20 minutes out of my way for this non existent order. I was very respectful the entire time, and I was adamant about not wanting the order anymore. And they just kept fighting me and wanted me to accept anything from them. If I want to cancel my order, just let me cancel it. I never would've written this review if the 2nd employee wasn't being rude to me. I said nothing about them not wearing masks, because it's their choice and I can not force them to wear one. But I also have a right to not want to eat anything from them. They voided they order and refunded me my money before I left. But the guy who came out of the back seemed to have an attitude the entire time. It was an unpleasant experience, and I won't be visiting this location again, even though it is the closest to my house. I'd rather drive 40 minutes out of my way to go to the Old Bridge or Jersey City locations, because there's always a problem at this location. read more

Krispy Pizza - This is the screenshot saying that my order was ready for pickup. - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Krispy Pizza was on my "must try" list for the unusual pizza creations they come up with. It was only fitting that when I had to travel through New Brunswick right around lunchtime, I would come here and order the two most interesting flavors I could find: half cheesesteak, half chicken ranchero. Cheesesteak pizza: This. Is. Cheesesteak. Way better than I envisioned a cheesesteak pizza could possibly be. I even had it cold and it was still tasty, which of course is the ultimate test of a good pizza. 5/5 would order every time. Chicken ranchero: Interesting, unusual, definitely pizza. Sorta like a loaded dirty fries with pizza crust replacing the fry base. This one I had a few days later as leftovers warmed to room temperature, and that was most excellent. So that's 2/2 on the "still good the next day" test. 4.5/5, not a "must have flavor" but would not turn it down any day of the week. I'm a pizza purist, but if I want something different, and my choices are this or... what else even is there? CPK? Pizza Hut's buffet? Most places don't do unusual. If anyone wanted to have pizza in New Brunswick, I'd steer them here so I could get more cheesesteak slices. read more

Krispy Pizza - Chicken ranchero left, cheesesteak right - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Once again Good delivery dinner. On time, good food, huge portions for affordable prices. This place is a must try. read more

I've only been at Rutgers for a semester but have been here a handful of times already. Their pizza is so good- I've tried their pesto, margherita, cheese slices and one of their chicken wraps (which was slightly dry but still good) and none disappointed! I'm excited to be back on campus - I'll definitely have my lactaid ready though since I'm lactose intolerant (yes, it's that good). read more

I want to love Krispy Pizza so bad but it would take some time. I've been eating pizza from the city so it's really hard to compete. I'm a jersey girl and I will always rep where I'm from and I was hoping a Krispy Pizza would give the city a run for their money but nope not even close. We got a personalized large pie. Basically a trifecta pie (red, pesto and vodka sauce) topped with hot honey pepperoni. The workers there were super nice enough to accommodate our order, even if it was a bit difficult. And the pie came super pretty/instagram worthy and I initially thought wow this might be my "Prince Street" Pizza shop without traveling all the way to NYC. But honestly, everything was pretty good until we got to the dough. The sauces and pepperoni were good (not enough pepperoni though). But the dough just didn't do it for me. It didn't taste as fresh or chewy and this is super important because the dough sets it off. It didn't have that WOW factor for me, especially for someone who does not like Sicilian pizza, I'm super hard to please. This doesn't mean I won't try Krispy again but prob wouldn't get a Sicilian pizza lol. read more

See all

Incredible! Krispy Pizza is crispy and delicious. I really like how the eatery spells crispy with a K: it's badass and reminds me of the good old mortal kombat days. The staff if also friendly and iconic. I've tried a few of their slices and was ecstatic each time. Eat here if you like pizza! read more

We went to the Old Bridge location and (unfortunately) they're temporarily closed. We call this location at 8:45 and he says they close at 9:30. We arrive @ 9:10 & are informed they're not making fresh pizzas and are offered to choose from a selection of unassorted slices with congealed cheese....no thank you. I would rather drive to Brooklyn. read more

Got the hawaiian pizza and pesto pizza The pesto pizza was dripping with oil, *which is to be expected* because its made from delicious authentic basil pesto. Id be worried if it wasn't. It wasn't salty at all which is what i was worried about. The hawaiian on the other hand was a bit saltier than i had imagined but was still pretty good and thats coming from someone who doesn't even like pineapples on her pizzas. Overall, a healthy amount of cheese on each pizza and that crusts were delicious. They weren't thin little pieces of tiasue paper with sauce on it..it was a substantial, baked crust. Id definitely recommend it and could see myself going back considering it beats all the other pizzerias in the RU area. read more

Krispy Pizza - Top: hawaiian Bottom: pesto (i recommend!) - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Ordered margarita pizza with meatballs. Wow! Meatballs taste like my grandmas...they were very generous with the toppings. Also ordered a salad which was fresh and delicious. Pizza is best I've had in New Brunswick hands down. read more

Krispy Pizza - Meatball margharita pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

I've been to Krispy Pizza a number of times and it has yet to disappoint. Most recently I went for a mid-afternoon snack and the garlic bread caught my eye. Let me say that it was one of the best things I ever ate. I finished the entire loaf before I made it home. My only beef (other than Hawaiian pizza being on the menu) is that the prices are a bit high, but I suspect that's because their target audience is students on the RUExpress dining plans. Rutgers students are lucky to have a great pizza option smack in the middle of College Ave. read more

The pizza was cold. The pepperoni was all curled up. No hot honey, barely any cheese. Dried sauce on the trio. Pretty sure this place has given up on providing quality pizza. We were looking fwd to ordering from here for weeks! Seems like they probably just cater to drunk college kids or lunch crowds now. So disappointed! Vodka sauce was good hence the extra star. read more

Krispy Pizza - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

I feel terribly remiss that I haven't reviewed Krispy yet- it's a dietary staple for me on Tuesdays! The pizza at Krispy is fabulous! I love the Grandma slices and the Margerita ones too. I often pop in for a slice and a drink and always love my food. The pizza is fresh, with a nice crispy crust. The pies always taste like they're made with good, quality ingredients. The young men who work there are always upbeat, pleasant, and work quickly to make sure the students are getting their orders quick. My office is in New Brunswick and we often place large orders from Krispy and we are always satisfied. They deliver quickly and the order is always accurate. They use their own guys to do the deliveries and that's so critical! I can't tell you how many bad Uber eats/grub hub drivers we have had from other places, but not Krispy. I highly recommend that you drop in for a slice, better yet- grab a whole pie! read more

Went here twice. Got the white and buffalo chicken the first time. AMAZING! The white pizza is creamy and the cheese is so nice and gooey (but not too gooey, just right). The buffalo also had just right amount of buffalo sauce, complimenting the bleu cheese well . Both slices also have a nice crunch from the crust since they heat it up before they give it to you (definitely lives up to the name!). I usually am not a crust guy but I finished the crust too! BBQ was a little underwhelming. I guess I was hoping for more sauce. But the Palermo was . It was doughy but not so much that it was undercooked, really great texture consider it also has the crispy (or "Krispy") bottom. The sauce and caramelized onions were also real nice on top. In conclusion, I'll definitely come back again, the pizza is well priced per slice (around $3) and I'm glad this place is at Rutgers! read more

Krispy Pizza - BBQ pizza and Square Palermo pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Krispy is one the BEST pizza spots I've ever been to (in Brooklyn and Old Bridge, NJ). Sadly, this location did not give what it was supposed to give. Maybe I caught them on a bad night.idk absolutely disappointing... ihave it s try because its about 10 minutes close to me but I am not ever going back. My vodka pie was burnt & for some odd reason it was covered in sesame seeds (which were also horribly burnt & made it taste that much worse), & the sauce was bland and flavorless... The Old Bridge location is ALWAYS on point. It's definitely worth the extra gas. Very delicious food and pizza every time. read more