We were looking for pizza that was decent before heading back to DE and chose Mancini's to try. We got way better than decent, the pizza was amazing! The crust was crisp and light, and the sauce was very fresh and very flavorful. We got the Margherita, a white slice and 2 cheese slices. Our 2 granddaughters ate every bit of their slices. We are hooked! Next trip to South River will include a stop at Mancini's. read more

While having our vehicle serviced at a nearby Safelite, we decided to have lunch at Mancini Pizza since we heard many positive reviews We ordered the Grandma pie which was delicious. Our server was awesome, polite and friendly. The ambiance was a classic old pizza shop look and feel. A great pizza dining experience overall. read more

See all

So I haven't been to Mancini's in YEARS. Not since I worked in East Brunswick which was sometime back in 2015. But even then the food was just OK. Anyway just recently stopped in because I needed to make a drop at the UPS store near by. Idk if these guys got new owners or what but I saw that they had Buffalo chicken pinwheels and since I had only seen those advertised for a pizza joint in NY on TikTok I had to try them. I ordered the last 4 that they had and I'm so glad I did! They were INCREDIBLE! My family loved them! I will definitely be back to see if everything else is just as good! read more

Mancini Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pinwheels - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

I am slowly working my way through a Pizza Passport gift. A pie named after the man himself was a solid choice, but the Godfather pizza stole the show. Vodka sauce is always worth trying on pizza. This place worked was a great choice on the way home from a week d trip. read more

See all

this place is absolutely phenomenal. I was door dashing and I came here to pick up an order and I saw how beautiful their pizza creations are. I have been trying to remember what the pizza spot was and a low and behold it was this one. I got the Barada slice, and my boyfriend got the buffalo chicken when I tell you these slices are massive, they are basically two slices in one. This was the most delicious pizza that I have ever tried, it was so tasty. The service was great, they're ready to take your order as soon as you walk in and if you need a minute, they don't mind. The ambience was nice dim lit with plenty of seating, just like any other pizzeria . read more

Mancini Pizza - This was yummy! - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

I was excited to try a new cheesesteak spot and was hoping it could become my go-to. This weekend, I ordered the cheesesteak special (no mushrooms), but I was disappointed when I opened the box. There was very little meat and barely any cheese. Definitely not what you expect from a cheesesteak. For $13.25, it didn't feel like a good value, especially since the bread-to-meat ratio was way off. There's a place another ~6 minutes out that offers wayyy bigger portion and is generous with their servings. Unfortunately, I wouldn't order it again. On a positive note, I also tried the spicy vodka pizza slice, which was good. I'm giving the second star because the staff was kind to the very young boy ordering and offered him a garlic knot lol. read more

Mancini Pizza - Cheese Steak Special (no mushrooms) - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

The best pizza I had in my life go to spot. The guys there are very friendly. Prices a little high but it tastes amazing. They have seating inside as well. $40 for the best pie of your life so worth it. read more

Mancini Pizza - Vodka - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

this is my second visit to this place. my toddler loves pizza slice from here. service was good and quick. ample amount of sitting tables for dine-in. would love to go again and try different options. read more

Mancini Pizza - bruschetta - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Unfortunately I have to update my review to only one star after ordering from their regular menu and not ordering pizza. Tonight we came here for dinner and wanted to order from their regular menu other than pizza which was a BIG MISTAKE! We thought that food would be delicious because it was priced higher than other pizza place in the area, and we don't mind paying extra for good food. My husband's lasagna was flat as a pancake with a big slab of mozzarella cheese on top. It had zero layers as a lasagna should have. My baked ziti wasn't good either as it barely had a ricotta cheese. To make matters worse is my husband asked for a cup of water and was told we can only give you water if you purchase a bottle! Never in our entire life from any pizzaria or even a high end steak house we were ever told we can't give you a cup of water unless you purchase a bottle! We were dine in customers and we each ordered a drink with our meal. I had a coffee and my husband had soda and we couldn't get a cup of complimentary tap water! How DISGUSTING and CHEAP are the owners of this establishment! On top of that we didn't even receive a piece of bread with our dinners! Every pizza place in NJ gives bread when ordering two dinners especially since we paid $53 for lasagna that was flat as pancake and baked ziti with barely any ricotta cheese! There are far better places that know how to treat customers that won't deny you tap water in a cup! read more

See all

stopped in here for a quick slice. I actually ended up getting two slices hanging out and talking to the staff. These guys were great. They were a pleasure to talk to and let me tell you they had an amazing pizza and I don't just tell you that I really mean it their pizza was incredible. Great sauce, and I'll be back for sure. read more

Mancini is literally the best. I haven't had it in years and just cannot let that much time pass again! The menu is huge but it's really hard to avoid the classics. The vodka pie with mushrooms is top tier. It's the best vodka pie out there. The chicken parm can also hang with some of the best. An order is absolutely massive and can feed an entire family of four. The mozzarella is fresh and the red sauce has amazing flavor. This is the kind of pizza place / Italian restaurant that every town needs to have. Chefs kiss! read more

A couple of yelpers at a Yelp elite event told me about this place, and hence I had it bookmarked on my bucket list. I ordered the margherita pizza. It was absolutely delicious. It was vibrant. Crust was perfectly baked with the cheese stretching off the pizza with every bite. I also ordered their garlic knots/bread, which too was very tasty. I told workers to glaze it with extra extra extra garlic. There was alot of traffic in n out for take out orders and they have a very big business model for ordering pizza by the slice. I had ordered the entire pie. Ambiance was nice. Like your typical sit down pizzeria place. Service was fine. I will visit them soon again. read more

Mancini Pizza - Large Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

9/14/25 - NFL Sundays are made for pizza. So we did take out from Mancini's Pizza in East Brunswick, NJ. We sat outside while they prepared our order --- one large Sicilian and one large pepperoni. The friendly and helpful staff even tapped on the window to let us know our order was ready. Yes, the restaurant is crowded and does a brisk business which is another good sign. The pepperoni is a neopolitan style and a bit on the thinner side. The sauce is absolutely incredible. The cheese is clearly premium. The pie is perfectly prepared and the Italian spices are noticeable with each bite. They use thicker pepperoni slices which I really enjoyed. The big disappointment here is the slices are not very crispy and are very limp. When you pick one up, unfortunately, everything slides right off. It doesn't make it taste bad but its annoying nonetheless. The Sicilian slice was by far my favorite. It has that fermented Sicilian crust flavor and when you add their spectacular sauce and premium cheese, it is Sicilian pizza nirvana. The crust is crispy and not dry at all. Great care is taken here paying attention to every detail of this masterpiece. The prices here are not friendly for the budget conscious diners. But if you want quality, you have to pay for it. Overall Rating: A- read more

See all

Mancini Pizza did a wonderful job catering my late mother-in-law's Celebration of Life service. We ordered a variety of food, enough for 40 people, and got a lot of delicious food at a good value for what we paid. Everyone was saying how great the food was and many people went home with leftovers. We got linguine with Clams, rolls, Caesar salad, marinara sauce, salad dressing, Vegetable lasagna, veggie wraps, broccoli rabe, and chicken with mushrooms. Everything was delicious! Mancini staff delivered to the church right at 2:00 p.m. as promised. Thank you Mancini Pizza for making our family's occasion go smoothly. read more

See all

Service was great and fast. Got plain slices and a vodka sauce, burrata and pepperoni slice, which was delicious! Inside the usual pizza place inside. read more

Mancini Pizza - Outside - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

We stopped by Mancini Pizza while waiting for Safelite to replace our windshield. We ordered the Grandma pizza. One of the best pizzas we had. The crust was excellent. The whole staff was very friendly. read more

Mancini Pizza - Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

Hidden old school pizza parlor on Rt 18 in East Brunswick nestled in a strip mall. I had their traditional cheese pie, but they had many choices including grandma, Sicilian, etc. Dining room isn't very large but it's nice inside. Pizza was traditional, not thin crust bar pie. It was excellent! Prices are fair. Place was busy with people picking up to go orders, line was out the door. Staff were very friendly. Definitely worth visiting if you are in the area! read more

Every time I'm in the East Brunswick area, I have to stop by Mancini Brooklyn Pizza -- it's just that good. This might even be my second review, but when a place consistently delivers incredible pizza, it deserves all the love! On our latest visit, we had plain, pepperoni, and white slices -- and every single one was fantastic. The ricotta and mozzarella on the white slice were unbelievably smooth and creamy. Their pizza sauce is fresh, flavorful, and perfectly balanced -- you can really taste the quality in every bite. And the crust? Absolutely delicious. Crispy yet chewy, with just the right amount of char. It's the kind of crust you actually want to eat all the way through. We keep saying we need to try their entrees, and after so many great pizza experiences, I know they'll be just as amazing. Mancini's is truly one of the best pizza spots around -- if you're anywhere near East Brunswick, don't miss it! read more

Mancini Pizza - 6 Garlic Twists - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

We were visiting from Texas and were on the hunt for a traditional NY style experience/pizza. This place did not disappoint! There was a good line in here. The staff was hard at work like a well oiled machine cranking out pies. Loud hustling and bustle here. Lots of variety and it came out fairly quick. Just make sure you're paying attention to whose next and when your up. They may yell at you! lol read more

See all

Good authentic food and incredibly generous portions. Family tried a little bit of everything and enjoyed it all.

Visited because the reviews were promising. Tried their pepperoni pizza and chicken parm sandwich. Both were good for the area. As a native NYer and having lived in North Jersey- I know good pizza. This place claims to use NY water. Sauce and cheese as good. Crust didn't taste like they used NY water, so I think this may be unlikely. Haven't found a fav pizza spot yet but this place is a decent contender. Just know, they are PRICEY. It seems like they nickel & dime for everything. Appetizers are pricey also. They also don't provide tap water. No big deal. But as you review the menu you'll see what I mean. Extra $4 for this and extra $1.50 for that. I never mind paying the price for good food. But the food should match the dollar tag. I'm not sure if it does. I'll have to return and try some of their other pies. read more

Mancini Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

Spectacular!!! Delicioso!! Amazing!! I will highly recommend them. Best time to come is any time!! The freshness and authentic flavors will keep you coming back for more. It's a craving you must get!! Every time we come, we leave happy and satisfied. Everyone greets you and service is amazing. We eat there every time. We live close but not close enough. Ambiance is welcoming. They don't rush you out. It's an experience you won't forget! read more

Mancini Pizza - Pepperoni pizza and artichoke and spinach pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

Ordered a veggie pizza and an eggplant rollatini. Loved both of them - quality, taste, presentation and quantity. Will definitely recommend this restaurant for food and great conversations with the team working in the front. read more

This was the most expensive pizza I ever bought AND the WORST! They charged me $10 for two slices of plain cheese pizza and a can of soda. That alone is outrageous, but I paid for it because I was in a rush on my lunch break. I had no idea until I was back at work that the pizza was black and inedible. Look at that picture! I tried to eat it but it was awful! The worst experience ever with pizza!!!! read more

Mancini Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

Spicy Vodka and Margherita slices are my Absolute Fav! The Pizza Sauce is sooooo Good. read more

Mancini Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

Absolutely loved their burrata slice of pizza - portion is huge and the flavor is delicious! My friend who I went with chose the place and made the bold statement when telling me about it that their garlic knots are the best in NJ! I don't know about that - but I would say they were YUMMY! And yes, I'd get it again. Pricing is $$ than your average pizzeria but it's also more elevated toppings. Service was good no complaints and ambiance fits your elevated yet cozy pizzeria. Many folks were doing takeout while we opted to eat in. read more

2nd time in a month I've eaten this and favorable, they deliver and seems like good competition for other locals I will continue to evaluate. They threw in a couple of extra slices for the last delivery tonight so that was sweet. read more

Spicy vodka pie was excellent! As were the garlic knots. Staff was friendly and very kind to my 8yo who gave it a 10/10. Dining room was clean and certainly did the trick for a by the slice lunch. 5/5 is a lot for a pizza spot, but this place really is that solid. read more

I could not recommend this spot more if you are looking for a good dinner spot before watching a movie at the North Brunswick AMC! This place has both take-out pizza pie and entree options and also a dine-in option in the spacious dining area. We did dine-in and our waiter was friendly and our food came pretty quickly! We got the Rice Ball Parmigiana to start- loved the cheese sauce with the rice ball. I only wish the rice ball was crispier. 4 of us shared the Large Da Robbie Deniro Pizza. This pizza was delicious, the balance of sausage to broccoli rabe, cheese, dollops of tomato sauce was perfect! The crust was also perfectly thin, chewy and crispy. With the app and pizza we were full and satisfied! read more

See all

Stopped by Manchini's after a client appointment with a colleague. Place was pretty quiet but had a steady flow of people coming in and out. We ordered a large Margherita pie and left them with a dish that had a couple of crumbs on it. We really enjoyed the pizza. Crust was perfect, nice amount of sauce and good cheese. The place was full of friendly faces offering up both great food and service. I've passed this place a million times over the years but will definitely stop by more often to grab a bite. Looking forward to trying other menu items. read more

Mancini Pizza - Large Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

Extensive menu of pizzas, subs, pastas and other dishes. Perhaps one of the best prosciutto and mozzarella subs I ever had. My wife had the roast beef sub which was also just spectacular. And the young owner took the time to talk with us and came back several times to make sure we were satisfied. Truly good food and service. read more

This is our go-to stop on our drive from the DC area to New England to visit family twice a year. Close to the highway, and they sell slices, so everyone can find something that suits them. The staff is SO nice, and the pizza is unrivaled (I'm sure it's even better if made to order, but we always do just fine with a slice). read more

My husband and I were traveling up from South Jersey to see a show in the area. Before the show we wanted to grab some dinner and when we searched local restaurants, this pizza place had great reviews and food looked great. We seem to have arrived right before the dinner rush. We were greeted and seated by a young man who was able to make a great recommendation on a pizza for my husband and I to share. We really left it up to him. He recommended the Marco Polo pizza and we were not disappointed at all! This pie was amazing. Great crisp , amazing cup pepperoni, with hot and honey drizzle on top, and fresh basil. While we were there, a family came in who addressed the staff immediately that their child had severe allergies and would need to speak with someone about ordering to make sure that all the allergies were considered. Within a few minutes a man named Leo I believe came out from behind the counter, who I can only imagine was the owner. He introduced himself and very intently listened to all of their concerns. He asked a ton of questions and really took responsibility to make sure that he put their safety first when cooking and prepping their meal. He made sure that he cooked everything himself. I was blown away by his attentiveness and willingness to provide amazing service and accommodation. The vibe is very casual, TVs on playing sports network, lots of fun chatter from behind the counter where they're prepping the food, Music playing. During our time there every table got seated and the place was packed before we knew it! We finished just in time and had plenty of pizza to take with us. Highly recommend if you're in the area. They do have a full menu. Lots of appetizers, soup and salad options, some pasta entrées, and then a huge pizza menu. It also looked like someone brought a bottle of wine so it appears to be BYOB. read more

Mancini Pizza - Marco Polo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

Great Jersey pie! Crispy crust, BIG sliders, delicious. Italian family feel to the place.

Food is good but way overpriced. Mozzarella sticks come 5 to an order and are about $14. Also got a wrap, sandwich and side of fries. Whole thing cost me $75. read more

There was a moth cooked into the pizza. We got a salad pizza and the moth might have been in the salad mix, however there is no excuse for this. When we called the restaurant, the manager said it must have been the delivery driver and that the pizza was $18, so he'd give us a gift card for $20. My uncle, who owns a business, said to do whatever they thought was right as that is what he would do for his business. The owner spoke to my uncle and denied it as their fault as well. Two people denying an error in their kitchen and blaming the incident occurring during delivery is unfathomable. I can guarantee this moth did not fly in during delivery as it was in a box and it is clear this was not a moth that just died. It was under a piece of lettuce and was found because I saw a darker piece of lettuce (which I now know was the moth) and picked it up. Now I do feel bad for posting this as I know if I saw a review of this nature, it would immediately make me not want to go, however the reason for posting this incident is due to how it was handled. There is of course no excuse for this and there was never any apology for the inconvenience nor was there any accountability. The owner and manager both said it must have occurred during delivery, taking blame away from them. If something happens in the kitchen, accept it as a huge mistake but own it without blaming other people. After telling my cousin, he said he had a piece of plastic from bagged veggies in his food last week. There is a clear lack in attention to detail and cleanliness. I'm disappointed this happened as it is gross but also disappointed in how Mancini handled this situation. read more

Mancini Pizza - Moth in the Salad Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

I got takeout recently and I think it carried really well. I just wanted to update and confirm that since I ate there last time. Same opinion, really delicious! Would recommend! read more

Mancini Pizza - Burrata pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Best pizza- had artichoke, maria, and plain. All delicious. Service was friendly and efficient. Highly recommend.

About once a year I see a great review of Mancini and get sucked into driving there again. And every time it's terrible. We just left the place; ordered a large pepperoni which arrived underbaked and barely warm. Had huge blotches of cheese that hadn't even melted yet. One slice had a lot of sauce, the slice next to it almost none. I really think they took a whole pre-baked pie from under the counter that was destined for slices, just threw it in the oven to reheat it, and dumped it on us. Will never go back here. read more

Super popular and busy place... called ahead for a pick up was delayed by 10min. The delay was acknowledged, and it was really appreciated. The food was very flavorful. Would definitely go back! read more