I fell in love with Kilwin's in southwest Florida. The ice cream is so rich and decadent. Their freshly made waffle bowls are sweet and crisp. My only disappointment with this location is that they did not have Rocky Road which was my favorite flavor of theirs. I would think that would be a basic staple flavor, but I will keep my fingers crossed that it makes an appearance on one of my future visits. It's the only thing keeping me from a 5-star rating. The staff is very helpful and will let you try sample of different flavors if you are unsure of what you want. They all seem to have a great sense of humor too. Be sure to ask for a punch card which allows you to earn a freebie after so many purchases. They also offer several varieties of fudge and chocolate dipped goodies such as Rice Crispy treats, pretzels, apples, marshmallows, and more. The items might seem a little pricey, but worth every penny where the quality of the product is concerned. Definitely recommended if you're strolling through town and find yourself in the mood for some really good ice cream. :-) read more

I live so close to Kilwins and for some reason have yet to step foot inside for some desert. I finally went in with my family after a nice day at the beach and I was happily surprised. Their ice cream flavors were to die for! I'd definitely go back and bring friends. read more

The first time I was in a Kilwin's was in North Carolina. When I was strolling out of Kotobuki in Babylon, I couldn't believe my eyes. Even though Kilwin's is a chain, it is superb! The ice cream is on the level of a stand alone mom & pop owned ice cream shop! No joke! The girlfriend and I happened to stroll in on a day where they were doing buy one get one free cones! $6 for 2 big ass cones w/ some premium ice cream. Perfect compliment to an awesome Kotobuki sushi dinner! read more

I love everything about this place !! The staff is very accommodating and even let my 3 year old try every flavor of ice cream !! Which is our favorite thing in the store .. The hot fudge and whipped cream was also amazing !! We will be back !! And the only reason I didn't give it a 5 star rating is because they use the same scooper for all the ice creams which creates a nut allergy contamination and I can't come with some family members :( read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - Superman vanilla - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Babylon, New York

Wonderful place to stop in for Ice Cream, the selections are great, yeah it's a little pricey but it's worth it. I haven't had a chance to try their candy, but their candy apples are wonderful! I wish they had outdoor seating, there is 1 bench right outside if you get lucky enough to get it. read more

Tiny little store front with paid parking only. However.... The sweets are absolutely delicious. The fudge is creamy, chocolatey and melts in your mouth. The datk chocolatr is delicious, the salted caramel chocolate is also incredible. They have a special, buy 2 slices get one free. It costs 8.99 per 1/2lb and each slice is 1/2 lb approximately. Worth the ride. Fattening but yummy. Next time I'll try some ice-cream!!! read more

Oh my goodness where do I begin? This is a bakeshop but I came here for ice cream and I was overwhelmed with the choices. Everything looked so decadent, rich and bursting with flavor. I honestly couldn't settle for one flavor so the kind girl attending me suggested I can get 1/2 scoops so I can experience more flavors at once. I picked a scoop of cake batter, 1/2 scoop of marshmallow s'more and 1/2 scoop of salted caramel. All in a waffle cone topped with rainbow sprinkles. All I can say is that I was not disappointed. It was everything I ever wished for. read more

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge - a hand holding an ice cream cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Babylon, New York

I am sooooooooo addicted to caramel apples & they sell some pretty cool ones. I actually went there specifically for the caramel apples for the first time back in October 2016. I was so excited because it was my first apple of the season. You walk into this store & the scent of chocolate goodness is everywhere. I am instantly transformed to being a kid again. I attempt to engage the teenager behind the counter, to no avail. When she decided to pay attention to my lighthearted jokes about loving how the place smells & looks, she stands there stone faced. I try more smiles & jokes but nothing worked. I finally just ordered my apples without asking about the other products I was interested in because I just wanted to get away from her. I paid & left. A couple of week later I went back & was pleased to see that same girl wasn't working. I had a better experience and was even told that they have a caramel apple club (so to speak) where you buy XXX amount and you get one free (or something like that). I immediately got excited & thanked the young lady behind the counter. A much better experience. read more

We usually go to Kilwins for the ice cream. The kids like superman ice cream, moose tracks and the sorbetto. And the toasted coconut is great. But the real star of the show is the salted caramel ice cream. It's my personal favorite ice cream of all time. The fudge is fantastic and so are the candies. read more

The smell brought me in here as I waited for my group to arrive for dinner in Babylon. Oh my gosh, this place is heavenly! The staff were friendly and offered us a tasting of the fudge- yum! I ordered a Tonga (like a Girl Scout Samoa cookie, but with more short bread and less "stuff") and a dark chocolate peanut butter cup ($10 together), as well as a small ice cream ($6). The ice cream was AMAZING. I wish I skipped the Tonga and went right for more ice cream- the Tracks and Babylon ice creams were phenomenal. I haven't eaten the peanut butter cup yet but it was very large! My only complaint was that it was pricey. I spent $16 on a few small treats, which I certainly can't do all the time. It was yummy though! read more

Stopped in to Kilwins while in the area and we were not disappointed. My husband and I both had ice cream and it was delicious. My son loved watching the caramel apples being made. I grabbed a box of chocolate caramels with sea salt to bring home for a treat and they were delicious - wish I had picked up more as my sisters and husband ate a bunch as well :) read more

AMAZING CARAMEL APPLES!! On Tuesdays they have Buy one apple get one free! Cute little shop, great treats and excellent service. read more

Fresh sea salt caramel fudge. Oh Hell Yes!!!! So good.

If you are looking for a sweet treat in Babylon Village- forget every other shop. THIS is the place to go. The service was incredibly friendly and helpful. They let us try just about everything. The maple walnut and chocolate fudge was amazing, fresh and not too sweet. We also had the ice cream which was to die for! I experimented with their homemade salted carmel and it was incredible. They also had lots of candy which I plan to try next time! Wonderful addition to the village. read more

They sell top notch chocolates and treats here, which is reflected in the prices. It's a good place to get something special for that loved one. Everything I have tried has been delicious. They also sell ice cream, which I've yet to try but they have many tempting flavors, including their own version of moose tracks. read more

The ice cream was good super creamy. A lil on the heavy side...so one scoop is more than enough. Ppl said $6 was a lot but the scoop is not tiny and tastes homemade. No more expensive than coldstone...but its creamier. Tbe flavor coyld be slightly more pronouced but all in all it was tasty read more

One word the ice cream is heavenly ... Once you have it you are going to keep going back for more . It is On the pricy side for a cup however it's delicious and worth it. The Gourment chocolates are amazing as well. Clean friendly store too. read more

Ther ice cream selection is a bit limited though they do offer seasonal flavors. They have an assortment of fudge (yum) and chocolates, BUT I was most excited by their variety of chocolate and caramel covered apples! My favorite is their salted caramel covered apple complete with a layer of caramel, a layer or (milk or dark) chocolate, and a sprinkle of sea salt. AND you can ask them to slice the apple for you (I tend to think it tastes better that way letting you actually experience the combination of flavors all at once in appropriate doses rather than taking bites of the chocolate and caramel first, and having leftover apple with no topping). read more

I stopped in Kilwins for a caramel apple on Halloween and loved what I walked into! They give you sample of the fudge (so many options!), which are all good, and the selection of chocolates was great. I'll definitely be going back here whenever I am in the need for anything chocolate! read more

The chocolate ice cream is to die for! (And break your diet for). staff is incredibly sweet also. In general everything is sweet at Kilwins!

I've been holding this review off because I like their ice cream a lot. But it's gotten ridiculous. $6 for a single scoop of ice cream. Let me say that again, $6 for a SINGLE SCOOP OF VANILLA ICE CREAM. They are out of their minds. I was ok with the robbery for Father's Day a few weeks ago when I bought some chocolates for my dad, and paid about $40 a pound. I'm lost on how this stuff can be priced so high. It's literally insane. And sad to be honest. read more

Stop with you fabulousness! The peanut butter cups, organic dark chocolate bars and other confectionery delights will keep me from slimming down! Always a special treat when I visit on occasion to spoil myself just a tad... read more

Great selection of chocolates and the ice cream was as good as the staff said it would be. Friendly staff too!

I'm giving Kilwins 4 stars for their ice cream but if it were on chocolate alone, sadly id have to give less. I have given the chocolate several chances hoping maybe it was just the selection Id made and each time I'm disappointed. Last night was the validation when I took my friend and let him decide for himself without any opinion from me. There's some flavor in their chocolate that just doesn't belong there. Idk what it is but personally I don't like it. Maybe it's just a personal choice but I've never NOT liked chocolate. I grew up on Grandma's Kitchen in Wantagh as my go-to chocolate shop. That was my heaven and Kilwins I LOVE your ice cream but I'm hoping for you guys to step it up on the chocolate flavor! Tons of other chocolatiers are beating you out with the chocolate connoisseurs!! read more

I've been here multiple times and have never been disappointed. The staff are well mannered and efficient. Not only that but they have an AMAZING selection that's always fresh. While it is a bit pricy, it's still not bad to have every now and then. read more

This place sucks ass! The chocolate and ice cream Is expensive and I can't afford that shit! Your better of going to Ralph's down the road. The service sucks too. read more

Great place to go amazing chocolates and incredable ice cream, five stars all the way

Best mint ice cream I've ever had. Workers engaged in conversation and were super nice. Over all great experience. Would also recommend their fudge read more

There ice cream is amazing! The staff even at closing was wonder full. I recommend the classic turtle ice-cream on a sugar cone. The dark dark chocolate fudge is awesome by far my favorite but don't go by me as I LOVEEEE dark chocolate. The other fudge like the classic flavors are tasty as well just not my favs... read more

The absolute best! Every flavor is amazing. I really enjoy this place. It feels like I am on vacation every time we get ice cream here.

I love the Kilwins in Patchogue, that's why this place is getting 3 stars...but every time I have tried to go to this one in Babylon they are closed! An hour before closing time! It's disappointing when you have your heart set on the coconut ice cream and you see someone standing at the counter pretending they don't see you at the door. It was just a bit of a turn off. read more

I was only at this shop once and greatly controlled myself and only bought a few of these adorable ice cream cone shaped chocolate pops. I should have taken a picture before eating/giving them away because they were so cute and make great gifts/favors, especially for kids. I ate mine and it was delicious. I will have to get back here to try some other treats and pick up some more pops. read more

Had the double-berry pie ice cream in a waffle cone and it was amazing. Was too full to eat the other sweets there but they had amazing looking chocolates including a Twinkie dipped in fudge!!! read more

Delicious Chocolate thick shakes! so much homemade chocolates to chose from. A definite place to go to after dinner or lunch or as a nighttime treat! read more

Stopped here for Valentine's Day and purchased their chocolate covered jerky for my boyfriend. he absolutely loved it. their chocolate strawberries were also to die for . I recommend anyone pick up something sweet from Kilwins! read more

Omg, the best peanut brittle I have ever had!!! It's salty, sweet and smells amazing

Great place to get something to snack on and they really make you want to have more and want to get more when you come back it's a little expensive but for what your getting its worth it read more

I'm sorry but $8.59 for two scoops of ice cream is ridiculous! I have never been to an ice cream shop that charges such rip-off prices and don't give me some bull about the quality of your ingredients. You deserve to go out of business! read more

This place rocks! Cant tell which is better: their chocolate or their caramel. Their toffee bars rock too! And omg Matthew was super helpful! Ask for him, he knows what hes talking about :) 100 million stars read more

After stopping in at the Kilwins in Babylon a few times after I visited for the first time in September 2014, I am happy to report than I can upgrade my previous review from four stars to five stars, as the owner John M. responded to my previous review by addressing the lack of my favorite flavor, Banana Fudge Pie and explained about the portion sizes seeming smallish in my perspective. Thankfully, on my visits after September 2014 in June 2015, September 2015, and today, I found that this Kilwins was even better than I remembered! Not unlike other times I have been to this Kilwins, the smell of treats like chocolate dipped Oreos, caramel apples, and fudge being freshly made lured me in like a fish on a hook! As always, I found the store to be spotless and slightly old school, with a black and white checkered floor, the treats up front, and the ice cream counter in the back. I was greeted by Alex, who was a very enthusiastic, efficient, and helpful employee working when I came in.I also met John M. the owner, who has always been very friendly, welcoming, and accommodating whenever I came in. While I wanted to get Banana Fudge Pie Ice Cream, which is my all time favorite flavor at Kilwins thanks to its sweet and mild banana base along with sweet, rich, and robust pieces of fudge and it has been available here previously, it was not available today due to it not being rotated. Still, I appreciate that this Kilwins has had it, showing that they really do listen to their customers. Nevertheless, I was not deterred and after sampling various flavors, which were all fantastic, I went for Chocolate, which was creamy and had a sweet and bold flavor along with Mackinac Island Fudge, with a creamy and mild vanilla ice cream base along with velvety chunks of fudge. As always, the ice cream was fantastic and the small, which had two nicely sized scoops (just like in June 2015 and September 2015 too) came out to $5.50, which was very reasonable (and on par with other ice cream shops on Long Island) given the fantastic quality and larger portion size of ice cream than when I first came here, making the ice cream definitely worth the price! All in all, I will definitely return to Kilwins when I am in Babylon (and anywhere they are located) thanks to their fantastic ice cream and sweet treats, excellent service, and clean and pleasant surroundings. read more