Kelly&#x27;s Ice Cream, LLC

The first time I came here in 2019, I loved it so much that I made it a staple on my Pocono trips…read more The place was cute, bright, lively, and the ice cream was TOP NOTCH!! The service was personal, intimate, and small town feel. I came back today, excited for what exotic flavors they had in store and to see how the store had improved since I know they've branched out a bit. The ice cream was still as I remembered. Delicious and flavorful with a feast variety from the usual suspects to Fig & Whiskey or Soursop. Stuff you can't get fresh anywhere! I chose the Cherimoya. FANTASTIC!!! When I first came, it was $3.50. Today, it was a little under $6 but a large scoop in a fresh waffle cone, I WON'T complain! It's worth it! Sadly though, the restaurant itself has gone downhill. Unkempt. Cramped. Dare I say, dingy. The brightness has dimmed. They used to have a HUGE room of tables for the customers but now, seating is mostly outside. It's too bad because because on a hot day, I hate for my ice cream to melt before I can eat it all.

Great ice cream . Good variety of flavors . Fond of pistachio and coconut. Quick service. Seating…read moreinside or outside. Plenty of parking, Fair prices. Cones or cups .

July 2019 Llama's

See all

Lavender and soursop ice cream

Zoe's Cafe & Ice Cream Emporium

4.7(32 reviews)

3.7 mi

Such a cute vintage place worth visiting. Kim was so nice and attentive and time flew by chatting…read morewith her. This is such a cool space with many stores if you like trinkets and old timey stuff you will love this place

This is such a cute vintage ice cream shop in the Castle Inn. It isn't open many days/hours, but…read moreit's got a great vibe for hanging out and relaxing. The menu includes both sweets and lunch food if you want more of a meal. I saw "egg cream" on the menu and wanted to try it. The drink itself was old-fashioned and containing neither egg nor cream but was a fizzy chocolate drink. The woman behind the counter had to get another employee to make it. It must not be commonly ordered, but it was really unique to get outside of old timey NYC. The prices were reasonable, and they had a lot of ice cream options. It's a unique business based on the original shop, so it was more than the treat but a bit of an experience.

Egg cream in process

Peach pie a la mode

See all

Egg cream completed

Lewis's Drive-In

4.3(17 reviews)

7.2 mi

Such a great ice cream stand -- really timeless and has excellent treats!…read more I've been visiting since I was a little kid, and our recent visit brought back all of the great nostalgic feelings. The addition of the playground is also fantastic for kids.

Local place, great ice cream, even better prices. Don't skip this if you're in the area and you…read morewant ice cream. Service is quick but it was a little buggy outside but you Can't do anything about that. They have some picnic tables under an overhang and a little pirate ship playground for the kids. Don't skip it if you drive by.

7/2023 covered & exposed seating. Awesome Kids playground in background.

7/2023 Restaurant sign on 209. Old name, new owner.

See all

7/2023 Rear view + bathroom.

Humpty Juniors

4.5(108 reviews)

3.7 mi

Voted the best burger place in Warren County and it's really true. Busy place but service is fast…read moreand amazing. Huge portions of serving specially their basket menus. I had the mouth watering ribs basket with their special sweet potato fries and coleslaw. Price is competitive and affordable. Place is well kept clean and maintained even busy place. They have 50 different kinds of milkshakes plus their tempting soft and hard ice creams. Definitely will be back to try their other items.

Dropped in for a quick ice cream, and was surprised to find a full menu of deliciousness. I was…read moreimmediately drawn to the organic grass fed burger, but since it was 3 pm and obviously not peak serving time I was prepared to wait a while. Nevertheless our food was delivered in only a few minutes. The burger was delicious, perfectly prepared, and came with a generous heap of fries. The 1950s era setting was very welcoming. Clean restrooms around back past a pinball table. Overall excellent food, very pleasant experience with reasonable prices, and attentive service.

Ice cream menu

See all

Humpty Junior's entrance

Blairstown Dairy

4.2(26 reviews)

5.3 mi

best ice cream place in the area. i live in mount bethel and have tried places in bangor, nj, and…read moreanywhere near and this beats all of them. me and my boyfriend always go here and love it. (and he's picky). the service is amazing, they get your ice cream out in no longer than a minute always, it's cheap, and there's a lot of variety. the ice cream is also very very good. love this place i could not think of any cons!

I cannot lie, we only been in Blairstown since the first of July. We been going to this place…read morealmost everyday. The customer service is great. Liam is great he gets to know the customers and makes the ice cream just as you like it. The ice cream is amazing, well it's ice cream and ice cream is always great. You can go inside to order and sit outside with your tasty treat, or roll through the drive through and get it to go. Blairstown Dairy is in a great location and the setup is perfect. You will not go wrong with stopping in and grabbing some ice cream. I prefer the blenders and my wife loves the chocolate peanut butter. He occasionally has specialties like his campfire which was great as well. You need to just check it out.

Fluorescent green pistachio ice cream? Blech!

See all

Sweet Creams Cafe

4.4(138 reviews)

5.6 mi

Amazing!! Walking in, I would have guessed this place was opened in the past two years. It has one…read moreof those modern retro vibes. I was shocked to learn it has been in business for over 30 years. My in-laws absolutely love this place and have been going there pretty much since it was open. First of all everything is squeaky clean. Not a crumb on the floor. The decor is extremely cool with a rock 'n' roll vibe and music playing over the speakers. Staff was super attentive and friendly. My wife has food, allergies, and they went overboard, accommodating her every request. I had the clam chowder which was a 10 followed by a roast beef sandwich, another 10, followed by strawberry ice cream, hot fudge with bananas and whipped cream. Absolutely wonderful. I can't recommend this place enough. What are the best food experiences I've had. Thank you so much!

we stopped into sweet creams cafe on a rainy afternoon, and it was a nice little spot. we chose…read moresandwiches from the short but creative menu, and they were fresh & tasty. we took the leftovers home as there was plenty. I asked for a sample of their homemade ice cream and the server gladly complied. it was very good! too bad I was full, definitely next time.

Ice cream & coffee counter

Waldorf Chicken Salad Croissant Cape Tuna Flatbread

See all

Such a cool vibe.

That Froyo Spot

5.0(3 reviews)

7.6 mi

Such a cute little spot with great service. It's soooo clean and friendly with such a huge…read moreselection of toppings. And JoJo is so knowledgeable to help with any questions. A Must Visit!!!!

Great place , so cute. Amazing froyo! The owners are the nicest people!!! This will be a regular…read morestop for us,

They even have dairy free vegan yogurt. Fresh fruit and boba.yum

See all

Trolley Shops Ice Cream

5.0(1 review)

5.4 mi

Quaint little place with a variety of Turkey Ice Cream. The toppings are numerous and delicious…read more They have a restaurant in another building that I wish I had tried as well. The ice cream sundaes that everyone had were delicious and plentiful. I would return.

Gabel's Ice Cream

4.0(66 reviews)

12.4 mi

We were recommended this ice cream spot by our dinner waitress. The place is very busy and…read morerightfully so, the ice cream was great and we wound up finishing our generous portions even though we were full from dinner. The price was fair and reasonable for the generous portions you receive. The property has a large outdoor seating area and a neat playground area for kids to play while we wait to order our ice cream. Very smart. We will be returning during our next trip to PA.

This is such a cute place that my friend recommended. Apparently it has been around forever…read more Wide range of ice cream, milkshakes and hot dogs / tenders on the menu. All at decent prices too. I got very excited and ordered a bunch but the maple walnut milkshake was the delicious thing ever! Wish we had this in NYC!!

Gabels

Hot Dog with chili

See all

My favorite place!

Fruit A Bowls

3.7(18 reviews)

5.8 mi

Exceptional service and wonderful food…read more I ordered the specialty chocolate bowl with peanut butter and granola (topped with strawberries and raspberries) and it was wonderful! I also ordered a frozen honeydew bubble tea (and tapioca pearls). The server was really wonderful and gave me the leftover honeydew bubble tea - which was the same size as a smaller order! I greatly appreciate their speed and kindness - and for not adding sugar or those horrific substitutes to their creations. To have bubble tea without extra sugar was fantastic! The establishment does have to work on its ambiance and how place orders and pay for them (right now, that's the same place). There's no bathroom, which I would expect from an NYC establishment but not East Stroudsburg.

I wanted a healthy snack, so I came here. When I arrived I parked nearby. I walked in and was…read moregreeted. The server was nice, and I ordered the chocolate banana smoothie bowl. When it came out, it looked good. The price was reasonable, and the bowl tasted good and healthy. I enjoyed it!

Seasonal Menu

See all

Menu

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Shea M.

3

5

0

9 years ago

Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaassssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss love it!!!!!!!! read more

Steve S.

12

163

14

13 years ago

This IS the standard we judge all other ice cream stands by. The home-made hard ice cream is fantastic!

Concetta Y.

0

4

0

13 years ago

High on flavor and low on atmosphere. Getting too price for this area.

Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC - icecream - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania Restaurants near Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC

BEST of Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania Coffee near Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC

BEST of Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania Things to Do near Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC

BEST of Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania Breakfast near Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC

BEST of Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania Pizza near Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC

BEST of Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania Dinner near Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC

BEST of Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania Sushi near Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC

BEST of Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania Winery near Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC

Best of Mount Bethel

Things to do in Mount Bethel

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Kelly's Ice Cream, LLC also viewed

Home Plate Dairy

3.9

(20 reviews)

Well let me start things off with this is honestly made ice cream for what I can tell I also see…read morethem making it in the back but beware this takes forever yes it is home made and tastes good but it should not be ten minutes to get two small ice cream's and a chocolate shake

Always good ice cream. There are a variety of unique flavors. Prices are reasonable. The staff is…read morefriendly too!

Owowcow Creamery

4.3

(82 reviews)

Very nice, clean, relaxing place with great AC on a humid, hot August day! One of their employees…read morehelped me with parking because it was my first time in the area. Mariah was awesome with samples! They have a lot of unique flavors, like corn and sticky rice and mango, even vegan choices. I was won over by the cashew caramel. It was so creamy! And you can walk to a little stream behind the place. Highly recommend this place!

Not all ice cream is created equal, at OWowCow they take the ordinary and elevate it with creative…read moreand locally sourced ice cream. Having trouble choosing a flavor, ask for a sample. Can't decide on what flavor you like the most? Order a flight. Besides the regular flavors look for the monthly specials- especially when local fruit comes in to season. Today I indulged on the strawberry shortcake, sweet cream ice cream, homemade shortcake and the freshest of strawberries.

Blairstown Dairy

4.2

(26 reviews)

best ice cream place in the area. i live in mount bethel and have tried places in bangor, nj, and…read moreanywhere near and this beats all of them. me and my boyfriend always go here and love it. (and he's picky). the service is amazing, they get your ice cream out in no longer than a minute always, it's cheap, and there's a lot of variety. the ice cream is also very very good. love this place i could not think of any cons!

I cannot lie, we only been in Blairstown since the first of July. We been going to this place…read morealmost everyday. The customer service is great. Liam is great he gets to know the customers and makes the ice cream just as you like it. The ice cream is amazing, well it's ice cream and ice cream is always great. You can go inside to order and sit outside with your tasty treat, or roll through the drive through and get it to go. Blairstown Dairy is in a great location and the setup is perfect. You will not go wrong with stopping in and grabbing some ice cream. I prefer the blenders and my wife loves the chocolate peanut butter. He occasionally has specialties like his campfire which was great as well. You need to just check it out.

Mary Annes Dairy Bar

3.8

(12 reviews)

Can't go pass this Ice Cream shop without tasting their delicious ice cream…read more Service is great. It's a little out of the way but cute.

This is a cute, slightly run down ice cream shop at the Pocono mountains. The service is great,…read morehowever the ice-cream is rather ok than spectacular. A variety of flavors but just what you'd get from grocery stores. The place itself would be so much better with some updating. And they do not accept cash which greatly limits the payment options.

Sundaes On Broadway

4.7

(14 reviews)

Hunting for ice cream shops whenever we're away on a little trip has become a fun little part of…read moreour lives' treats and pleasures. The ice cream shop is located on the corner of a little block in Wind Gap. We stayed close by in Bangor, and didn't have a chance to check out the Wind Gap area too much. It's such a vintage, cute little shop; spacious with enough tables and even one booth in the back I believe. There were so many flavors to choose from! I was sold on a small (kids') cup - vanilla bean with peanut butter chunks. The ice cream was incredibly delicious and smooth. I could tell it was freshly made and it was such a good kittle treat for me. My husband followed suit with the size, differing in flavor - he originally wanted Death By Chocolate, but it was out of stock and the staff said they weren't close to making it in the back, unfortunately. He got a cherry flavored scoop and he said it was actually the best ice cream he had ever had. Bold claim, I'll say! I pondered upon the prices briefly afterwards. It was $6 and change for the 2 scoops. Though small, I think the price was very fair and it made me think that in and around NYC, it would probably cost close to double. This is a small critique and very trivial, but I didn't like either the cups or the spoons they use. The cups were styrofoam (no branding of any kind) and the plastic spoons were weirdly..... deep? (not sure if that makes sense, fully; for example, when they gave a sample, it was huge sample on one of those little spoons that are almost flat and very easy to scoop.) The staff were so incredibly nice and friendly, they even gave out Odin a free pup cup! He loved his just had much as we did ours. We'll definitely come back when in the Poconos again! 10/10 recommend!

Sundaes on Broadway is an excellent spot for ice cream in the small Pocono mountain town of Wind…read moreGap. It just opened up in 2024, but the great ratings are well deserved as they offer a plethora of ice cream and frozen treat options, sure to satisfy any craving. They also had multiple dairy free and sugar free options, including sorbet, and many flavors for both hard and soft serve ice cream. While I didn't get a chance to try them, the ice cream sandwiches looked amazing. Service from Jason (I believe he's the owner) was extremely friendly as he allowed us to try multiple samples of ice cream, including cookies & cream, orange pineapple, banana, and a couple others I'm forgetting. I went with the toasted coconut ice cream as he advised it was mixed in-house with a generous amount of toasted coconut. It was a great recommendation, as the ice cream was high quality and delicious with more than ample toasted coconut mixed throughout, and probably one of the best coconut ice creams I've had in years. Prices were fairly reasonable and the interiors were bright and welcoming with some pictures colored by kids in the wall, with plenty of indoor seating. I'd definitely be back, and would happily recommend Sundaes on Broadway to others visiting the Pocono Mountains.

Castle Gate Farms

3.5

(20 reviews)

Amazing stop! I've been meaning to stop here for the longest and I finally did. I'm so happy. Not…read moretoo many places have rum raisin ice cream so when I saw it was on the menu of course I ordered it! In addition to ice cream, they do have burgers and cheesesteaks and other items from the grill. I chose to order the cheesesteak and cheese fries. I must admit the cheesesteaks exceeded my expectations. It was tasty and flavored well and the bread was super soft. The staff was friendly and helped me decide whether I should get a couple or cone which I got both.. There isn't that much of an ambience. There are some tables and benches outside for you to eat or you can sit in your car miniature golf was next-door, but I think they closed down the course a few years ago. Everything looked overgrown. Overall, l give this place an 8/10, I most likely will return.

Best Ice cream in Phillipsburg.So much delicious flavors. If you're in the area you should…read moredefinitely try their ice cream.

Gabel's Ice Cream

4.0

(66 reviews)

We were recommended this ice cream spot by our dinner waitress. The place is very busy and…read morerightfully so, the ice cream was great and we wound up finishing our generous portions even though we were full from dinner. The price was fair and reasonable for the generous portions you receive. The property has a large outdoor seating area and a neat playground area for kids to play while we wait to order our ice cream. Very smart. We will be returning during our next trip to PA.

This is such a cute place that my friend recommended. Apparently it has been around forever…read more Wide range of ice cream, milkshakes and hot dogs / tenders on the menu. All at decent prices too. I got very excited and ordered a bunch but the maple walnut milkshake was the delicious thing ever! Wish we had this in NYC!!

Village Farmer and Bakery

3.8

(233 reviews)

A super cute local roadside stop that really makes you feel like you are out in the woods. This is…read morea combo farm store and cafe. So you can peruse the rows of goodies like local jams and jarred foods, pick up a pie to go, or order some breakfast and lunch to stay. We shared a BLT which came with a generous amount of bacon, thick and juicy farm fresh tomatoes, and perfectly fluffy bread. The fries were thin and crispy perfection, and the apple cider donuts were also tasty. They have picnic table style seating outside, and this was definitely much more fun than grabbing lunch at a rest stop.

We hit Delaware water gap and searched Yelp to see who was open on a Monday. The chicken club is…read moredelicious!! I had it on the homemade white bread. I followed that up with a cherry turnover that was probable the best I have ever had! I highly recommend!

Crazy Cones

4.8

(35 reviews)