I threw a birthday party there. They were easy to communicate with a very reasonable prices. We got salad, beef and broccoli, chicken franchaise, penne with vodka sauce (excellent) and seasoned rice. Everything was great although the beef and broccoli needed some kind of sauce like even a premade stir fry sauce. But the food was delicious and everyone was happy. It was well run and I got the beer/wine/soda included which was well worth it. I booked the two hour package but they let us stay for 3. I had a few no-shows so they even let me slide on the final price! Nice place and atmosphere and great help! read more

Nice local irish pub that features decent bar food and a nice hometown bar feel. Have been coming here for years and always have a good time. Atmosphere is perfect to watch football or any sporting event at, as they have a ton of tvs. Their also known to be open for special events like ufc or football in Europe. Food wise, it's bar food, but the wings, quasadillas, and burgers are always good. They have a large selection of tap and bottled beer and usually have bucket specials. There's also a dart board and outdoor area for those interested and is feet from the LIRR. Bartenders are always helpful, and servers are friendly. Cheers! read more

See all

My fave local place. Great food and drinks and very affordable. They have specials each day as well. The PRETZEL is the BEST. It gets busy, but get a drink and relax. Outside seating is available. Great place to grab a drink before the LIRR. read more

Johnny McGorey's - Vibes - Irish Pub Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

We brought a group of soccer playing teens and their parents here between tournament games. Though we didn't have a reservation, they had ample seating and televisions with games on (mostly American football). Everyone ordered and the food came out relatively fast. I had a burger and fries which wasn't at all greasy and my husband had a wrap. The server was a bit overwhelmed by all of the people she needed to serve but was courteous and got us what we needed. The bathroom was very clean and nice too. read more

Johnny McGorey's - Chicago burger and fries - Irish Pub Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

The bald bouncer reached in my pocket while i was having a drink with my friends and told me "see me before you leave."

I recently ate here, I thought the atmosphere was nice and casual, drinks were good and the menu was definitely what I look for in a pub. I would totally go back. read more

Live music Sunday, great crowd and good noshes. And despite the crowd no problem getting food and drinks. Super fun bar!

Great wings, beer fresh on tap, employees super friendly and efficient! Felt comfortable and at home. My wife and I will be back!

Went about 2 weeks ago for an early dinner with my wife... place is nicely redone and service was good. A big selection of burgers which is what my wife had and liked. I had the Chicken pesto sandwich that was very tasty but I thought it was a bit skimpy with only one thin chicken cutlet on the whole hero... if they want repeat customers they have to pump that up and give a better portion of chicken... my son in law ordered the buffalo chicken sandwich last week and said the same thing.... Good taste but skimpy on the chicken... it's an easy fix and hopefully they take care of it because I probably would've went back but am hesitant about the portion... let me know if that's taken care of read more

Nice old school saloon ! Plenty of tap beer and decent food. Live Music and plenty of parking.

We went to the Johnny McGorey's in Lynbrook, but Yelp didn't have a listing for that location. This was our second time at this location. The first time we sat at the bar. The draft beer was cold and delicious. I had the. Thai Chili Chicken Tacos -very good, and my husband had the chicken tidbits with side salad - also very good. Service with the bartender Jen was excellent. The second time we also sat at the bar. Nicole was the bartender and she was great. My husband had a draft beer again, nice and cold. I had a margarita- excellent! We ordered the sampler, the wings were too well done as were the potato skins. The cheese sticks and tenders were good. I ordered the beef stew. It was very good, but it was more a soup than a stew. My husband had the Philly cheesesteak and salad and he liked it. We'll go back and give this place another try! I didn't think to take a picture of my food, but I took a picture of my margarita! read more

Johnny McGorey's - Irish Pub Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Sitting at a table with Cockroaches running across the table. Repulsive. Sorry as we were enjoying the food.

Love the drinks, really get the job done, but the waiting service ended by the time we got there at 9 on a saturday, only a few bar items available. Staff is friendly and food is good, try the pretzel, wont be disappointed. Repeat customer :) read more

Johnny McGorey's - This pretzel is so good, and enough for 3 people! - Irish Pub Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Sports bar, nice inside, small room that can be for 15-20 person group. Lots of tv to see plenty of games. Wings were just ok, soft pretzel was good. Plenty of parking convent location. Will be back to try more on menu. Need better waitresses imo. read more

It's a neighborhood Irish Pub. The Guinness was fresh and poured properly. Done. Add to that friendly staff and a tasty burger, they nailed what they were supposed to. Friendly crowd of regulars are always at the bar, which adds to the experience. read more

Husband and I come in often. Bartenders Andrew and Phil are very good. This is a perfect local town bar. It does get a bit crowded when sports are on, though. May be difficult to find a bar seat. Otherwise, no complaints. read more

My friends and family have come every Monday for 10+ years for their Hot Wings! We have never found better! HUGE Tv's with Every Channel, Chill Atmosphere, Great Bartenders and Friendly Patrons! Phil (Monday's 7pm on) is one of the best bartenders in NY. He makes the best Long Island Iced Tea's in Long Island!!! Right Across from the Massapequa Train Station! read more

Johnny McGorey's - Irish Pub Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Spent $80 here tonight and closed my tab, asked if I could get one more drink tonight without having to do the $20 minimum and they told me too bad I should haven't closed out my tab. Appalling that they couldn't give me a pass after already having spent that much. Will not be returning. read more

My first time here for a Fri afternoon . It was clean and well lit. We sat at the bar and I ordered a B & T with the Fish & Chips .My brew had the perfect head. The fish was fresh and had the perfect crunch when I took a bite. My friend knew the bartender, she was spot on when she recommended the Fish & Chips. I'll be back . My friend remembers this place as Solomon Grundy's.I remember this place when it was an Italian restaurant . I remember having this feeling I was going to get whacked lol. read more

Hey I've been going here for a while, mainly for the wings on nights where I wasn't quite yet of age to drink but at the time things were different. (Talking 20+ years ago.) Needless to say I didn't really care what I was getting at the time but today that is a very different story. All the food was like a mushy appetizer you'd get at Cosco and microwaved it instead of the proper suggested cooking method an oven or deep fryer. I wouldn't recommend, unless every other place is packed. The beer deals are ok but don't eat anything. Don't talk to anyone and don't breath. read more

Great little bar! Staff is very kind and accommodating. The staff members Richie, Andrew, and Philip are all amazing! 10/10 recommend for a good time no matter your age! read more

I've been to some good bars and some bad bars. This bar is probably the worst bar I've ever been to. First of all, I understand if someone breaks a glass. People are drunk --it happens. At McGorey's broken glass is the norm. Wherever you go, you'll be sure to find some broken glass. But, its a two for one offer. Not only will you find broken glass wherever you go, you'll also find the "kind of people" who like to prove themselves by breaking glasses, talking about how tough they are, and starting fights with people who glance at them in the wrong manner. Many of these people are stuck in their high school days. Now, lets talk about the beer. The tap is not changed often and really needs to be cleaned out. I'm not picky, but this is not hard to do and the staff at McGorey's fails at this. I will credit that the staff seems to be very hardworking --nonetheless the beer on tap is not remotely close to ideal. read more

Mcgoreys is a fine one step above a dive bar bar. In the weekends it's overcrowded with 21 year olds and sometimes the crowd is filled creepy old Men but the drinks are cheap enough and the food is regular bar food so if you're looking for a place to chill not on a Friday night, I would come by. read more

Only because zero stars is not an option. Avoid. The worst food and service today. The least attentive server. It's pints and bar food. That's all. The place had three tables of patrons. She was just not interested in the customers. Pints took 20 minutes. And we were overcharged. The soup took 30 minutes. For soup. A place setting had to be requested. And bread. Never mind plates for the appetiser that arrived after one of our group's entree. For what we hoped to be a quick bite, we were trapped over two hours. In an empty pub. With dreadful food and an uncaring server with no concern for the people she's hired to assist. Never again. read more

I've become a recent regular here and it's a great place minus the occasional Irish music. The staff is really nice and attentive especially Jackie Who is my favorite waitress. She definitely makes my dinning experience more fun. Food is great and the red wine is bad except the Pino noir which they tend to run out of. This is a great affordable place to go. P.S. The pesto salmon with pasta is really good! read more

My wife and I were looking for a new place to have an enjoyable happy hour and decided to check this place out. They had a live band, and great crowd and generous drinks. The staff at the bar was attentive and friendly. They have what appears to be a pretty nice menu as well - nothing too fancy - plenty of bar food type things - but plenty of things that make me want to go back again and check it out for a casual dinner. You will NOT be disappointed by this fine establishment. read more

Great local place to eat and drink. Great beer selection. I advise eating at the bar "better service ". Kid friendly. I've had many party's there. Always friendly staff. Wings suck avoid them.... but everything else is really good. Ask for joe Anne and carol. Tell them you read my review. All in all it's a good place I recommend read more

Yummy food and good beers on tap. Very reasonable prices and well made pub food. Typical Irish pub if you want to stop after work or on a Sunday for football. Their burgers are tasty and we enjoyed their hot pretzel as well. read more

We eat there on Wednesdays when it rains...why?.....great service Great food..n beer..a waitress is a bundle on talent n love Jackie is the name...the weekly specials re always great. Rain you say?.... we can't ride our motorcycles so we go locally! read more

Nice space however my friend and I had the most watered down drinks in existence we didn't even finish half before leaving .. poor first experience read more

Terrible service . Would definitely not go back. Waited and waited for a server.. We just left and went to good times.

We went to Johnny McGorey's for dinner the staff was wonderful and they even took my hamburger off of the bill but the truth is that all of the food was over cooked. I ordered a burger medium and it was clearly well done. We also ordered the app sampler and the potato skins were burnt there was no potato I the potato skins ( burnt to a crisp). My daughter ordered fish and chips and the fish was burnt. We also ordered drinks during happy hour and we were charged full price. Needless to say we won't be going back. read more

I am a Johnny McGorey's fan! We gathered there on Sunday afternoon for some drinks, Irish music, and apps and were not disappointed. With all the options on Park Blvd. Johnny's treats its customers very well and is very fair with pricing, always offering specials, much appreciated. Always a relaxed and fun atmosphere! read more

Went last night for St. Patty's. They were serving us 12 oz. Warm bottles of Bud Light. We looked around and saw that people had 16 oz. aluminum bottles! For the same $5 price. I asked the bartender and he had the audacity to look me in the face and say they were the same size. I pointed to the 12 and the 16 on each bottle. I asked why we were being served those 12 while you had cold 16 oz. bottles. He walked away. We left after that. Sneaky. They lost 10 customers that night. read more

I use to go this place all the time years and years ago. It was, I thought, a great bar where me and a bunch of friends could get drunk, start fights and try to talk to chicks. In my mind, this was the greatest bar in the world. Unfortunately, I stopped in for the first time in years to watch my beloved Irish and my fond memories quickly evaporated. We walked in through the front and it did not look like they were seating people at the tables. And, of course, there was no one to ask. So we decided, reluctantly, to belly up to the bar. Or at least try to. The place was not packed but in order to get to the bartender we had to elbow our way through the collection of drunk grandpas who had surrounded the bar and were holding it hostage. We managed to get to the bar but not without pissing off the geriatrics. Unfortunately, the bar was staffed with only one bartender who didn't get to us for another 10 minutes. Inexcusable, especially since this place was empty, sans the old farts. We finally were able to order a drink and got very warm miller lites. Awesome. The whole afternoon was nothing but warm beer. Judging from the other reviews, it appears this place could upgrade their refrigeration units. After getting our warm beers, we retreated and quickly realized that the TVs over the bar were blocked by various decorations. Unless you were with the old-timers and were close to the bar, you weren't going to get an unobstructed view. I made due but it still sucked. Around halftime, some of the old guys decided they had enough and left. We seized this opportunity to grab a couple of chairs right at the bar. Got to watch the second half with no obstruction. Well, almost none. Turns out that the bar's drainage system must be right where we sat cause the smell was atrocious. It was like a combination of shit and urinal cakes waging war in my nose. The worst part was that the bar started to fill up and we couldn't move because we had ordered food, which under the smelly circumstances, was clearly the wrong move. I ordered a chicken sandwich with American cheese and a side of fries. The fries were fine but the sandwich sucked. The chicken was as thin as a slice of paper. Even the bartender commented that it was beaten within an inch of its life. My chick got the french onion soup and said it was different ("very liquidy - not thick at all."). McGorey's probably deserves a very poor rating but my youthful, fond memories do not allow me to do so. I am biased. At least I admit it. Probably will never order food from here again or sit where I did the other day, but I am sure I will be back even if that means warm beers. read more

Awesome local pub. Really Dig how everyone is Irish in the place. LOL I can barely understand them but its all good. Its really dead on the weekends and its poping on the wednesday. Wednesdays it is packed to the brim which is awesome good crowd. Seldom do I ever see fights break out or anything everyone just sits down and enjoys like 50 wings and many many pints. Ireland has a place is my heart and that place is called Johnny McGoreys. read more

So Johnny McGorey's is the quintessential Irish Pub. From the decor which is garnished with whimsical touches like old sports equipment and such to the bartenders and waitstaff who are mostly Irish ex-pats, this joint has a chameleon like ability. During the day the crowd is a mixture of all ages, at night it transforms into a much younger ( but legal ) group. Wednesday's are big night with great .10 cent wings ( not a typo ). I've seldom sen a Wednesday, Friday or Saturday when the place wasn't packed. During most days Carol does a great job of working the bar and most nights Nil, Joe, and Kevin keep the drinks flowing. Worth a visit. read more

As for the restaurant, the food was very good. I think it's under-rated. The traditional pub food is much better than the attempts at Italian offerings. Great appetizers. I agree that the service was lacking and the atmosphere was weird or forced, but if you're looking for the food I'd recommend. read more

Recently renovated. More beers on tap. It's a lot cleaner in there now. I've been going to goreys for over 10 years. The bartenders are top notch and will always hook you up with a buy back. The food is the best bar food you can get. Amazing wings. Try the Cajun Irish Nachos (waffle fries, bacon, cheddar and mozzarella, green onions). Also the sandwiches are excellent. My favorite is the Favorite Chicken Sandwich (chicken cutlet, prosciutto, mozzarella, and a pink light tomato sauce). The steak sandwiches are phenomenal too. Soft bread always toasted nicely. The only downside to goreys is it can get packed on the weekends. If it's too packed there are a few other bars in that area that are good too. There is also a nice new wine bar next door if that's what you're into. All Massapequa needs now is a Za! read more

Kind of a dive bar, some what hit or miss. Great spot to watch a game if your looking for an Irish pub, prices aren't great for what the place is. read more