Off-season at The Curst Pizza is so weird. You just walk in and get a table. I am exaggerating…read moreslightly, but there were more helpers than customers. I ordered the 13-inch pizza with sausage and pepperoni. They have a meat-lovers pizza that I have wanted to try. Their pepperoni is slightly spicy, which I like. Not a big fan of tiny crumbles of sausage, wish the sausage were bigger. There is just something about seeing a picture of the Beatles hanging on the wall, eating pizza, that always brings a smile. Obviously fake, but nice seeing John, Paul, Ringo, and George.

Updating my review due to the recent price increases. The food is still great and I love the BBQ…read moreChicken pizza. But $30 for a 13" pizza and $18 for a house salad ... is just a bit too much for me. It was over $80 for my wife and I to have dinner. I didn't even have a drink -- just tap water. The price increases are excessive, IMHO.

If you're on the hunt for real New York-style pizza in Southwest Florida, look no further than…read moreAnthony's New York Pizza in Estero. We first heard about this place from one of the co-owners at the Bonita Springs flea market, who assured us it was the real deal--and let me tell you, she wasn't exaggerating. From the moment we sat down, we knew we were in for something special. We kicked things off with the meatballs and ricotta appetizer, and it was outstanding. The meatballs were unbelievably tender, with just the right amount of cheese mixed in, and the sauce was perfection--rich, flavorful, and just the right balance of tangy and sweet. For the main event, we went with a classic cheese with half pepperoni pizza, because if a place can nail that, you know everything else will be great. And wow--this was everything a New York-style pizza should be. The crust was super thin, crisp, and perfectly cooked, holding its shape beautifully when folded (because that's the only way to eat NY-style pizza). The sauce was spot-on, the cheese was high quality, and every bite was a perfect balance of flavors. Located just down the road from Coconut Point Mall, Anthony's New York Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza in the area. We'll absolutely be back, and if you love great pizza, you need to check this place out.

Great place. Great service inside is a typical pizza parlor Great during Covid. With curbside…read moreservice and delivery's

Great little authentic pizzeria, and Italian restaurant family owned. Pizza is thin crust and crisp…read moresauce is phenomenal and the mussels are some of the best I've ever had.

My brother-in-law has been dying to get us to Peppi's, and we finally made it! Being from NY, we're…read moretotal pizza connoisseurs, so our expectations were high. We were a party of eight and sat outside--absolutely gorgeous night for dining al fresco. There was only one waitress, but she was completely on point the entire time. We started with the mozzarella sticks and meatballs, both hot, fresh, and delicious. We were told we had to try the Cadillac pizza, and wow--definitely a must-try! I love a good white pizza, and this one was full of flavor. We also ordered a pepperoni pizza, a Margherita pizza, and the eggplant parm platter. The crust was nice and thin, and the sauces were super flavorful--honestly on par with NY pizza. If you're craving a taste of home, give Peppi's a try!

I've been back two times since my initial visit two weeks ago and continue to be impressed by the…read moreamazing flavors of all their slices. In my last two visits I tried the meat lovers, vodka grandma, supreme, and chicken bacon ranch. The quantity of food (loaded with toppings? is impressive and the vodka pizza was the best vodka pizza I've ever tried, no doubt about it. On top of the amazing flavor, texture, and quality of the pizza, the owner and other workers recognized us and treated us like family. Such an incredible place to relax and enjoy quickly served slices. Beyond friendly and humorous gentlemen working at this establishment who truly seem to love what they do. I'm sure I'll be back again soon!

We heard good things about this restaurant and wanted to stop by. This is a small restaurant, you…read morehave to look to see it between other buildings. Although the restaurant is small, the flavor is big! The menu has a good variety of pizza, calzone, salads and even a few subs. The pizza with the cauliflower crust was interesting and so was the Sicilian, but we decided on the usual pepperoni. This was a great choice, the flavors were balanced and the crust is true New York style, both crusty and chewy. It's one of the best pizza crusts I've found in Naples, IMO New York crusts make the best pizza. Service was fast and the staff is great, it's obvious they make a lot of pizzas here and know their stuff. If you like New York style pizza, this is a place to check out.

Unparalleled experience! This is the real deal. It's consistently out of this world. We came back…read moreto try the house special, Grandma's pizza this time and it's EXCELLENT. Thin crust, amazing flavors of garlic tomato and the perfect amount of cheese. You feel like family the moment you walk in the door. I can't believe how friendly they are- it's seriously remarkable. We will certainly be back- again and again!

Disappointed…read more Called ahead because I was 45 minutes away and asked them to time the pizza to be ready at that time. They guy who was on phine said it would be ready in about 45 minutes. When I arrived the man suspiciously announced "perfect timing right out of the oven!" I drove 15 minutes to my destination with the pizza that was "right out of the oven" to find totally overcooked pizza nearly burnt and the cheese had already solidified. Top of pizza totally dry. Crust was dry and overcooked. Two of the worse pizzas I have had in a long time. My family agreed and a sibling actually made fun of the leftover slices the next day. I suspect the pizza boxes were sitting on top of the stove for about 30 minutes and they immediately cooked the pizza as soon as I called. It was not busy this was 4pm and no other orders being cooked and underway. No phones ringing. Just me and my $40 waste of money.

My wife and I stopped in last week on a Tuesday. No wait at all. Only a couple of people in…read morerestaurant ( helps that it was 9 pm ). Just ordered a pizza and couple of drinks. Pizza was excellent with good flavor and crust not too thick or thin. Was also good as cold leftovers the next day. Definitely worth stopping by if in the area

Their pizza is flipping amazing. We had the deluxe and it was sooo good. The best pizza I think I…read morehave ever had. My husband loved it also. He put it in his top 3 pizzas ever.They have lots of options on their menu. The staff were super friendly and very attentive. The atmosphere was and of world Italian.

Ordered McGregor Pizza to go tonight for the first time and was blown away by the friendliness of…read morethe employees, cleanliness of the store, and freshness and flavor of the pizza. We ordered the pepperoni poppers and a McGregor Special with artichokes, Kalamata olives, ricotta, sausage, and tomato on thin crust. Our online order was ready quickly and tasted great. A moment of appreciation for the SAUCE -- the homemade marinara tasted like my mother's marinara sauce and was so great we will definitely be asking for extra next time. The pizza's crust was buttery and crunchy, and the pizza had a great crust-sauce-toppings-cheese ratio. To top it all off, McGregor had an extra "mistake pizza" that they offered us, which was the Red. White. Green white sauce pizza. We also loved the flavors and cheesiness of that one. Everything we tried tasted awesome, and I think McGregor's prices are very affordable. Their weekly specials are also a great deal. Will definitely be heading to McGregor the next time we're craving NY style pizza!

The pizza was alright. The margarita was just okay (not the best I've had, but solid), and the…read moreothers were okay. The crust was yummy too. We picked up to eat at home. Service seemed good. Small shop.

As someone born and raised in Naples, this has easily become my favorite spot to get pizza…read moreI get the garlic cheese pizza and it's ALWAY amazing!!!! I love the food the people everything 10/10!!!

A legit NY style pizzeria in the Tin City Waterfront Shops that opened on Independance Day last…read moreyear. Discussed pizza with the owner "Craig the Greek" and ordered a slice of cheese pizza with fresh grated Romano cheese sprinkled on top. While waiting for my slice, I browsed the Italian market that offered chips, sauces, meal additives and even an Italian cookbook and a retro wicker picnic basket. This room was extremely detailed and the customization was a nice addition to the small pizzeria. The slice was removed from the oven had a nice light charred crust and "no flop" whatsoever. The added Romano cheese gave it a Kapowy Bam!!! Would have liked a more garlicky sauce kick, but it was still tasty. The $6.00 price for the average sized slice was the highest I have EVER paid...Maybe all the ingredients are imported, not really sure, but either way, all the employees from the Tin City were raving about this eatery. Tin City Pizza offers a rewards program - buy 6 slices get the 7th free.