Jersey Mike&#x27;s Subs

Let me just tell you how wonderfully amazing this tasted on a very hot day, which felt like it was…read moreover 100. I stopped by for a scoop of mint chip custard and it was creamy, rich, cool, and delicious. But - really is there no bad day for custard? No, there isn't! This place is busy all year round, and for good reason. For the custard, there is usually a flavor of the day, plus the usual favorites, vanilla and chocolate, plus a sundae and shake of the month. A sign outdoors advertises the flavor of the day and a monthly menu of each flavor of the day is available online, if you want to plan ahead for your visit. If you've not been to this Milwaukee icon, it's a must-stop; the custard is really, really good. The retail store is set up like a 50s type diner, and there are plenty of folks ready to take your order. There is no seating indoors, just a few tables for standing-only to munch and chat. However, there is outdoor seating like a mini amphitheater on cement steps, and when the weather is nice, it is not unusual to see large groups of customers sitting outside eating ice cream or other treats or burgers. The menu also includes burgers, chicken sandwiches, fries, shakes, malts, floats, and sundaes, too.

My third visit to Kopp's, and it continues to deliver. The food is consistently good, the frozen…read morecustard is excellent, and the prices are reasonable. This time I had the KRK Burger with fries and onion rings along with two scoops of Cookies & Cream custard in a waffle cone. Everything was delicious. The restaurant is clean, well lit, and runs efficiently. Even when it's busy, the staff keeps the line moving and is always friendly and helpful. I also love their rotating Flavor of the Day custard options, and they even post a three day forecast so you can plan ahead. Overall, Kopp's is a great spot for both food and dessert. Definitely recommended.

1.0 mi•Historic Third Ward

Cheeseburger

See all

Shake Shack Third Ward

3.4(267 reviews)

Ordered food for pickup. It was ready right away. Delicious as always!! It's convenient they have a…read moregood amount of loading zone parking so you can run in and grab your food quickly!

It was like any other Shake Shack but large, very clean, and not very busy. I ordered at the kiosk…read morebut the girl at the screen was very warm and welcoming. I ordered a regular double shack burger with cherry peppers (my favorite aspect of shake shack) and it came quickly, hot and delicious. I was going to take it back to my hotel but I didn't want it to get cold in the 15* walk, and it looked so good, I ate it there. Another successful Shake Shack experience!

1.8 mi•Riverside Park, East Side

Pick up counter

Pickup order, exposed to the air making the food not warm.

See all

Kiosk ordering, simple interface but the pick up process was really unclear.

Oakland Gyros

4.4(338 reviews)

I've ordered carry-out a few times from here, but I hadn't been in - so it was time to remedy that…read more The restaurant is located on a busy corner (Oakland and Locust) so allow a little extra time to find street parking. But that doesn't stop a crowd from eating in or for carry-out. You place your order at the front and then sit down, with plenty of seating in a casual cafe style atmosphere, and plenty of server staff. We had two chicken platters with rice and a moussakka with a side salad. The service was fast. I prefer a little more seasoning on my chicken, but I enjoyed the gravy on the rice to add in some more flavor. The tzatziki was mild - I like a little more seasoning. The moussakka was really rich and heavy. Generous portion sizes. The pita tasted pretty standard (tasted store-bought, not homemade). This is one of my go-tos for Greek food in the area.

Good Vibes, cool spot to stop for a snack or meal. Super clean & quick service. Lots of choices…read moreto pick from but personally I am always getting the gyro with fries & pineapple shake! Fries are fresh & fluffy inside. Gyro perfectly balanced with tzatziki, onions & lamb. I love gyros & normally I don't order dessert but... YOU HAVE TO ORDER A PINEAPPLE SHAKE!!!!! Yum

See all

Potbelly

3.6(84 reviews)

0.7 mi•Downtown, Westown

Yes, I know, Potbelly is a chain but this is in the downtown area just a few blocks from my hotel…read moreand I want a sammie... It was welcoming and friendly atmosphere... The day crew was spot on their game and the bread was fresh... I went with the Italian and added the potbelly peppers with the garlic aioli spread... Stupid delicious with some heat!! I would recommend easily!!

The worst!! I placed an online order and received a time for the order to be completed. Not only…read morewas the order not complete but I waited over 30 minutes for my order. What's the use of having the online pickup option if I could have Just walked in and placed my order. Do better!

See all

Dave's Hot Chicken

4.5(67 reviews)

0.0 mi•Lower East Side

Customer 100/100! I accidentally ordered not chicken ... they were kind enough to give me chicken…read more(I know the cauliflower is more expensive but still she was super nice!) ordering again now

This location is not as nice or well-kept as the Wauwatosa location, so I don't order from this…read moreoutlet as much as that one but was picking food up to go see a friend and this was a convenient option on the way to him. The food was still pretty good--it's no Raising Cane's, but then again, who is?--though the service was a bit rushed, and not all aspects of the order were exactly as we had requested (something with low spice was marked no spice, for example) using the website, but it was not anything that made the meal terrible. All in all, it was just an "OK" experience, and if I hadn't had better experiences at the other location, I probably would not have been so put off here; I know that they can do better!

See all

Culver's

3.8(96 reviews)

2.8 mi

Our food was wonderful and so was the service. I am upset that at the Culvers in Oconomowoc, WI,…read morethey have employees standing outside taking orders for the drive thru in what feels like over 100° weather. I understand its to help customers get their food faster and for their drive thru times, but if that were my kids, I'd be really upset to know my kid's safety and well being are less important than drive tru times.

I had my second negative experience at the Cuilvers in Shorewood drive through last evening. They…read morewere swamped. The issue started with them sending the wrong order out to me, a roast beef sandwich instead of a cod filet sandwich. I do not eat beef or might have eaten it anyway. I recently had surgery so really didn't want to get out of my car. But I carried it in. I stood at the counter waiting for my reorder for so long that my soda ice was completely melted by the time I got back to my car to eat. Telling the kitchen it was a reorder makes it sound like I had some frivolous complaint and takes no responsibility for screwing up my order. I don't think the kitchen made it a priority after someone in the team screwed up a customer's order. I didn't time them, but it clearly went into the que at the end of their current orders. They lost a customer last night.

0.9 mi•Historic Third Ward

See all

Smoke Shack

3.8(1k reviews)

We stopped in for brunch/lunch while in town for a wedding…read more We were seated right away at a shareable table. A little while after we sat down, a group on college kids came in and were seated at the table with us. They were a blast! We started with the burnt ends as an app. Delicious. My husband ordered the pulled pork Benedict - it was great. One of my kids ordered the brisket sandwich and the other ordered a sandwich.... I think it was chicken. I had a side of green beans (I knew I would be taking a bite of everyone's food, so I went with something small and not too filling). They were yummy. Service was great, too!

Great service Ice cold beer…read moreBbq with all the sauce And unique as can be We love this place

Bar

Pecan Pie with Purple Door Whiskey Ice Cream

See all

Smoked chicken, Mac and cheese & Brussel sprouts

Fully Loaded

5.0(1 review)

0.5 mi•East Town

The best way to describe This food truck is to say that the meal is absolutely delicious. The truck…read moreproudly states that it is home to the "world famous loaded fries". No I do like french fries but I never been big on gourmet fries. But I decided to try this place and I fell in love with the cheddar and steak fries. These fries are created and served by kind, considerate and talented chef(s). These are not the kind of fries you can just pick up with your fingers, you definitely need a fork, and the portion sizes are totally satisfying. If you see this truck, just stop and order some fries. You can follow them on Instagram also at https://instagram.com/fullyloaded_mke?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=.

Steak and cheddar. Why are all the pix of this? Likely cuz it's so good!!

The actual food truck

See all

Close-up of the steak and cheese fries

Crave Cafe

4.6(242 reviews)

2.6 mi

Just wanted to make a note that as of April 2026, this place is still legit. Great, solid burgers…read more It is still more of a pick-up place rather than a sit down place. There are tables and chairs, but it's tight and when it got busy with people coming to pick up their lunch, would feel weird sitting down to eat. As it was, we just waited to pick up our food, like everyone else. Didn't see a single person actually eating inside, though we saw a LOT of people coming to pick up lunch. Previous review stands (3/25/2022) This is another happy review. I'm happy to report that the burgers have improved significantly since my last review 4 years ago. Korean BBQThey toned down on the shredded cabbage and the sauce in the korean bbq burger. Everything balanced out much better than what I remember, and I could actually taste the kimchi inside this time. The meat was cooked to a nice medium, and travelled well in our to-go order. Soft Shell CrabThey put two whole deep fried soft shell crabs in one burger. Topped off with a lot of arugula, bacon and tomatoes. It was good, but not quite as balanced out as the Korean BBQ burger. I'm not quite sure what it is... Lacking some sauce?Overall, the place had some great burgers and I would definitely go back more often that I have recently. But there's a little bit missing still to give it a whopping 5 star review. Plus the buns were really bready... a little less dough would have been nice. And on the downside... the fries weren't awesome. They were ok. But felt more like baked fries than deep fried. In any case, I love improvements and having great joints in my neighborhood. Thank you Crave Cafe!

Ate here lastnight 09/10/26. for the first time. Ordered the softshell crap BLT & katsu sandwich &…read moreranch fries. Would like to say, the food tasted great. The BLT was a bit soggy, not good quality of tomatoes. But, I would not recommend this place as we got food poisoning.

Exterior Crave Cafe

Burger and fries

See all

Japanese Katsu Burger

Crispy Kitchen

4.4(37 reviews)

7.4 mi•Brown Deer Park

Still love their chicken, especially their whole wings and leg/thighs. I miss the ginger flakes…read morethey used to have, but it is what it is. Lemon pepper salt works great. This last time, we got the 50 piece whole wings ($58.99) and 34 piece legs and thighs ($47.99). Enough to feed 20 people. With this order, we got 7 little packets of coleslaw. Hubby keeps picking up and forgetting to check, but we really needed more coleslaw. They also forgot bread. But a lot of hot sauce. One time, we got the 15 piece whole wings and 8 piece legs and thighs. It was plenty to feed two men and one gal with big appetites. Should be plenty for 4 people with big appetites, with leftovers. I generally get a lot so we can have leftovers. **On many occasions, they forget to pack coleslaw and bread. Check! 7/2024- Fried gizzard on this last pick up order. A+! Notes: - fried whole wings - deliciously golden, not too salty. They are whole wings, in 3 sections, which is nice if you like the wing tip area like I do. - potato wedges - these are more expensive than regular fries, but there's no Merrit in paying the extra. Regular fries are pretty good, and the wedges are subpar. - don't get lost. They are located right on the corner of Teutonia and Good Hope, inside the gas station. (and don't get gas here - it's cheaper just down the street)

Ohhhh No! I ordered a Greek salad for $12. This is what I received! Iceberg with barely any…read moretoppings! The feta was sliced in half (with less than 5 total and two olives! And the taste was terrible! Bad lettuce with brown juice on the bottom! Not balsamic... EXPIRED vegetable taste! Who SKIMPS on a basic salad and overprices it?! THIS PLACE! DOESNT accommodate meatless options. Not vegan/vegetarian friendly.

See all

Cole slaw for an order $100+

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Sammy S.

0

7

0

12 years ago

I didn't really care for the sub....(Very small, 6in or 12in subs.....The 12 in. is over 11$ & they only have 2 types of bread....Prices are high for what you get......I have went to Subway for the past 16 years & I will stay with them......:) read more

Emily G.

166

10

1

10 years ago

Employees were really friendly, really accommodating when they couldn't make one of the sandwiches we had ordered

Jersey Mike's Subs - hotdogs - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Jersey Mike's Subs also viewed

Jersey Mike's Subs

4.0

(8 reviews)

In the Jersey mikes vs Subway Vs Jimmy John's battle, Jersey mikes wins everytime. I order the same…read morething every time I go which is the original Italian sandwich. I get literally everything on it and ask for a couple sides of chipotle Mayo and Buffalo sauce on the side for no charge. Workers there are AWESOME and never forget anything. They even let me know that they didn't forget the side sauces when I pick up! Great place and thank you to those workers!! Y'all are the best!

Usually fast food chains in Milwaukee can result in opposite ends of the spectrum but this Jersey…read moreMike's location is really nice. Clean and nice staff, the worker Steve was very helpful to my boyfriend and I!

Chick-fil-A

3.8

(111 reviews)

Spicy Chicken Deluxe is the only way to go. The line for drive through is SO LONG its INSANE…read more BEWARE. I always order on the app ahead of time so I breeze past everyone in that line. This is the only fast food sandwich place where their chicken actually tastes good and like real meat. And their chocolate chip cookie is my favorite out of all fast food places

Absolutely disgusting. I opened my sandwich and what appeared to be a booger was in the bread and…read moreanother bloody thing on top of the bread. And when i touched the sandwich my fingers got this black stuff on it??

Cousins Subs

3.7

(20 reviews)

Simply the best Cousins sub I have ever had. The crew in this Cousins in the 7pm time killed it,…read moregood job!

Somehow, I've lived in Milwaukee for going on 8 years and I have never had a Cousins Sub. Not sure…read morehow that happened but here we are. Stopped by this location on a Sunday evening for a sub with a couple friends. We planned on eating in house before continuing on with our day. Our experience was rough. Whew. After what turned out to be a long and chaotic ordering process (from a service perspective), I ordered their tuna sub with provolone, mayo, and mustard added. My sub came without provolone. One of my dining companions ordered cheddar on his which was also missing. We both went to the counter to get it added and were met with annoyance (but, after checking our receipt, they did add the cheese). My dining companion was also missing tomato but after the attitude for adding the cheese, opted to not ask for it to be added. Our subs weren't well built at all and were incredibly difficult to eat. You had to kind of eat it like a bread taco for lack of a better way to explain it. The bread tasted like it had been sitting around a while but the toppings tasted fresh. The dining room was basic but clean enough. Overall the service was pretty rough and the sandwich was difficult and messy to eat (with napkins being hard to find). A swing and a miss for me.

Jersey Mike's Subs

4.8

(4 reviews)

I ordered the Italian sub and because it was for dinner I got the Mike's way vinegar and oil is…read moreseasoning on the side. For the next day, I was able to eat off this foot-long was delicious. Customer service was great. You can get it to go or Dine out in the ambience is a sandwich shop

We love Jersey Mikes and this location is always a pleasure to visit. Friendly staff, quick…read moreservice, and when we order for pick up our sandwiches are always made exactly right.

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.8

(17 reviews)

What's the purpose of calling in an order early and it's not even ready…read more Employees are pleasant but no there's no order to get people in and out during the lunch rush Food was alright

EXCELLENT SUB I'D GIVE THIS 10 STARS IF I COULD! I HAD A…read morePHILLY CHEESESTEAK SUB, AND I CAN HONESTLY SAY THAT IT IS THE BEST PHILLY CHEESESTEAK SUB I HAVE EVER EVER HAD IN MY LIFE I normally cannot finish 7 inch south but I did this time. It was too good to stop eating. The sub was nice and warm. The bread was also warm, moist and soft. I honestly can't think of anything bad about it. It's got all the other sub shops beat when it comes to this kind of sandwich. I ordered it through DoorDash and it's close by so I didn't get it very soon, but I'm sure people keep them warm. There are many locations as well. If you love, Philly cheeks steak sandwich, sandwiches, I highly recommend you try one at Jersey Mike's

Culver's

3.9

(16 reviews)

We went to a Memorial Day cookout early in the day - by the time we left and walked around Target,…read morewe were pretty hungry. My kids (adult kids) both ordered chicken strips and fries. My hubby ordered a burger and fries. I don't eat much so I ordered a kid's meal burger and fries. Service was fine - no problems at all. All of our food arrived at our table pretty quick and it was hot and pretty tasty. I actually cannot think of a time when our Culver's meal was anything less than hot and tasty. The restaurant looked a little messy - the garbage containers were overflowing and the drink area was .... bad... really messy and the parking lot was a real mess.

Brought my two kids and our friend along for a spontaneous dinner and was low key kind of impressed…read morewith Culver's. Haven't been in years and it was the first time to this (new'ish) location. It was clean as can be, and despite being fairly busy, the staff did great cranking out orders. My two littles split the kids cheese burger, which as a meal came with a side, drink, and ice cream scoop. All this for like 8 bucks is a heck of a deal in my opinion. Sizable portions too. I also added an extra side of broccoli (nice they offer that). I went with the grilled chicken sandwich and it was darn good! I'm not someone who regularly eats fast food, and quite honestly am normally turned off by it, but the quality here was good! We sat inside at a booth, and pulled up a kids highchair that came equip with a whole tray attachment. If you're a parent to a small kiddo, you know that's appreciated. They do have plenty of outdoor seating as well. Prefer to take food to go? They've got dual drive thru lines. Maybe we'll swing through there sometime soon since we did indeed enjoy our meals.

Wendy's

3.0

(29 reviews)

Very friendly staff! Ordering ahead is easy and there are always good deals in the app. Sometimes…read morecan be slow in drive through when busy, but honestly food quality has been high on all my orders so far.

Order 1 each of the 1.00 biscuit sandwich loved them and very filling.and they were made fresh due…read moreto the fact it was 10 am

The Original Suburpia

3.7

(146 reviews)

Suburpia subs taste different from most The oil dressing…read moreand tiny minced onions and the bread all stand out from other places

Always a treat to go here. Sandwiches are unmatched in flavor. I get the King Louie double meet no…read moreonions or tomatoes. Sometimes they put too much lettuce on, sometimes it's just fine. Service is quick and friendly. There's seats there but most people get their bag sandwhiches to go. Highly recommend.

Kraverz Frozen Custard

3.4

(72 reviews)

Well the fishy fry was good though quite greasy. Tartar sauce was good and fresh lemon is nice…read more Cole slaw didn't look rest so I brought it home to try it tomorrow. On the other hand, the kid's sliders were awful. Paper thin and the meat tasted really funky. I know when my kid won't eat even two bites of a cheeseburger that there's something wrong with it. He had liked every burger he's ever had but for these. I took a large bite and there's definitely something off. It tasted almost like it had been dissolved. Like it wasn't even meat? Just awful! Fries were also fairly limp and soggy. The few crispy ones were okay. Thankfully they weren't overly salted. Custard was good. Booths have lots of handprints of grease from kids reaching over the top or back behind their heads with their hands. We will try again but avoid the burgers.

So good I forgot to take a pic! Had the grilled chicken BLT with fries and I drink for $13! Huge…read moreportions! Service was fast and everyone was polite. Dined in, place was clean. Would eat here again! A great end to Halloween!

Shake Shack Third Ward

3.4

(267 reviews)